Amitav Ghosh's In An Antique Land

1259 words - 5 pages

Book Review: Amitav Ghosh In an Antique Land
“The only people for whom we can even begin to imagine properly human, individual, existences are the literate and the consequential, the wazirs and the sultans, the chroniclers, and the priests—the people who had the power to inscribe themselves physically upon time” (Ghosh 17). History is written by the victorious, influential and powerful; however, history has forgotten the people whose voices were seized, those who were illiterate and ineloquent, and most importantly those who were oppressed by the institution of casted societies. Because history does not document those voices, it is the duty to the anthropologist, the historiographer, the philosopher as well as scholars in other fields of studies to dig for those lost people in the forgotten realm of time. In In An Antique Land, the footnotes of letters reveal critical information for the main character, which thematically expresses that under the surface of history is something more than the world can fathom.
Moreover, the main character of this arguably structural fictional novel, travelogue and biography, which encompasses both historical and biographical events, begins his journey through the truths of studying eleventh century Egypt. Amitav places himself in the story as a doctoral student who is given the opportunity to study social anthropology. As we learned and discussed throughout this course, there are a variety of methods in which to study religion. Social anthropology focuses on“the study of human beings and societies viewed primarily as both the creators and the creations of culture . . . sociology of religion . . . focuses its attention on social behavior and the way in which religion interacts with other dimensions of our social experience” (Livingston 21).
From the perspective of a social anthropologist, Amitav in bewilderment and does not know what to study relative to his academic responsibilities. However, hope is given when Amitav discovers letters written between Khalaf ibn Ishaq and his friend and business partner Abraham Ben Yiju in a Medieval Egyptian synagogue, in a chamber known as Geniz. Ben Yiju is a rather distinguished man; a poet, a calligrapher, and scholar, Abraham is a Tunisian Jewish merchant who he discovers had a slave named Bomma, in which he would have not known of ifit weren’t for him being mentioned in the letters. Prior to moving to India, Abraham lived in Egypt for many years an aspect that Amitav is intrigued by because of his Indian origins. He is able to infer various aspects of the life of Bomma such as where he was born, his religious affiliation and his journey through the Middle East. The main arguments of In an Antique Land questions what is academically considered historiographical study. It challenges the idea that evidence of society, specifically the lives of people in history need to be concrete in order to be relevant in academia.
In An Antique Land focuses on the Judeo-Christian...

Find Another Essay On Amitav Ghosh's In an Antique Land

Vision of Man-Woman Relationship in The Hungry Tide

3039 words - 12 pages choice etc. The contemporary Indian novelists in English like Anita Desai, Sashi Deshpande, Sashi Tharoor, Salman Rusdie, Shobha De, Manju Kapoor, Amitav Ghosh etc. deal with this theme minutely in Indian social milieu. Amitav Ghosh, an anthropologist-cum-novelist possesses a deep knowledge of human psyche regarding man-woman relationships. He is concerned with the inner world of his characters. He tries to look for the deep desires, emotions and

An Explication of Eavan Boland's "The Necessity for Irony

957 words - 4 pages Eavan Boland's poem "The Necessity for Irony" begins in narrative tone, when on a unremarkable Sunday Eavan, with her daughter, go browsing for antiques in town. However, by the end of the poem, Eavan's tone is lyrical, as she sends an apostrophe to the "spirit of irony," asking it to "reproach" her for focusing on antiques rather than what was truly beautiful, her child. Her dramatic shift in tone is slow and accomplished using various

Trans-nationalism and Border Crossing

1246 words - 5 pages draw cultural lines between themselves and the West. This can be seen in Amitav Ghosh’s The Shadow Lines in which the Grandma represents cultural nationalism which conflicts with Tridib’s representation of border crossing. This can also be seen in other texts such as Gandhi’s Autobiography and Natyantara Saghal’s Rich Like Us. Both texts examine the relationship between India, the West, and social class while attempting to simultaneously exist

The Message of Carpe Diem in Ozymandias

786 words - 3 pages beginning of this poem Shelley writes of a narrator telling about an encounter with a man from an antique land. "I met a traveller from an antique land" this already puts you in a frame of time. By starting with "I" as in present tense, but then takes a step backwards in time by introducing a traveller from the past. It is obvious that the traveller is an older person because of the word "antique" in his description. The whole first line of the

Usage of the extended metaphor in Emily Dickinson's poem #371

784 words - 3 pages reveal the theme. What especially underlines the extended metaphor and thus helps to reflect narrator's fascinating and exciting account is the use of allusion, diction, iambic pentameter in the poem, and also such elements as assonance and consonance. Basically, a reference to some of the great people in history is intended to be an aspect of the extended metaphor, which personifies The Antique Book, and is an allusion to the great philosophers

The Importance of Context in Understanding Literature

3857 words - 15 pages this, around fifteen million people were displaced from their homes. These novels also bring to focus a very famous novel, Animal Farm, which is an important political satire on the Stalin Government. To read it dissociating it from its context does not bring out the true meaning of the work. The contemporary generation of writers in India- Salman Rushdie, Amitav Ghosh, Shashi Tharoor, Upamanyu Chatterjee, Rohinton Mistry, Firdaus Kanga, Farrukh

Analyzing the Spectrum of Ozymandias

785 words - 3 pages antique in describing the traveller as being from an antique land, it demostrates an era of mystery. The question has to be asked; what is anitque land? Anitque seems to have the meaning of old and wise, but what land is not old and wise. Some lands are undiscovered but still they have a history and a past. Shelley leaves the traveller, stopping to tell the story, wise but no real home. This kind of writing keeps the reader aware of the poem and

Italian Cinema Paper

1256 words - 6 pages these assumptions when the viewer watches Thomas, a photographer by profession, shoot two photo shoots. Thomas hovers and yells at his model, controlling them as he pleases. When the women in the second photo shoot do not meet his expected standards, he abandons them for a visit at the park. On the corner of the street, next to the park, Thomas visits an antique shop. The narrow aisle surrounds Thomas with statues, busts furniture and unknown

"The House of the Seven Gables"

513 words - 2 pages In the novel, "The House of the Seven Gables", written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, distributes symbolism from a home that belonged to a family who prided themselves the best in the whole society. The House is built on land that is owned by Matthew Maule. Colonel Pyncheon built a massive house and took the land from Maule. The house of the seven gables was built with pride and cursed with death. These are symbols that destroy the Pyncheon family. The

Antique Shaving Mugs

1102 words - 4 pages , mug racks previously used in barber shops cost about $15-$20 per mug hole. It is more expensive than newer racks but it will really add to the character of your collection, which is antique. This is an interesting hobby, designed to make you proud when you put on display your final collection. Antique shaving mugs still hold a handsome tradition meant to be remembered up to this day. Works Cited Saving up green bean seeds for the next

Comparing and Contrasting Ozymandias and Saddam

948 words - 4 pages are the narrator's words, the rest are those of the traveler he meets. This creates the effect that an unimportant person, "the traveller", "who said" (which belittles him) there is a forgotten statue dying in a "antique" land. The pre-modifier "Antique" makes the statue seem old but precious at the same time. The traveller then goes on to describe the kings bleak and power deprived legacy, which is the opposite of what he expected. This is the

Similar Essays

An Essay About The Miserable Mother In "In The Land Of The Free" By Sui Sin Far

789 words - 3 pages In The Land of the FreeIn the story "In the Land of the Free", Sui Sin Far describes the sadness and melancholy of a young mother, Lea Choo, when she had to be separated from her son when they entered the U.S because her son did not have a necessary certificate entitling him to admission to this country. This story traced back to the time after 1870 when a huge number of immigrants from China arrived in the U.S. The U.S government, terrified by

Q5. 'when Not Available In Any 'real' Sense, Homeland Exists As An Absence That Acquires Surplus Meaning By The Fact Of Diaspora' (Vijay Mishra).

1024 words - 5 pages need to have 'real' territory to have cultural identity or can imaginative geography and history help intensify ones cultural identity and belongingness? In this essay, I will use Amitav Ghosh’s novel The Shadow Lines and Jhumpa Lahiri's The Namesake. I will examine through the characters of Tha'mma and Ila in Ghosh's novel and Ashima, Gogol and Moushami in Lahiri's novel and how their depictions of diasporic experience results in; vexed questions

Disquisition Of Women Characters In Amitav Ghosh’s The Glass Palace

757 words - 3 pages Amitav Ghosh has undoubtedly occupied an undefeatable position in the galaxy of Indian writers in English. He has contributed immensely to make Indian writings acclaimed worldwide. Most of his writings involve the themes of exile, cultural displacement, revolution, emigration, dislocation, loss of identity, uprooting that characterizes into historical novels. He recuperates the irony, disillusionment, dilemma and ambiguity of human condition of

The Idea Of Nation As Heterogeneous In The Writings Of Rushdie And Amitav Ghosh Es

1465 words - 6 pages , India. 6. Hawley,JohnC. 2005. Amitav Ghosh: An Introduction. Foundation Books, New Delhi. 7. Hazarika, Sanjoy. 2000. Rites of Passage: Border Crossings, Imagined Homelands, India’s East and Bangladesh. New Delhi: Penguin, 8. Kaul, Suvir. “Separation Anxiety: Growing Up Inter/National in The Shadow Lines.” In Ghosh, Amitav. The Shadow Lines. 1988. CULT Educational ed. Delhi: Oxford UP, 1998. 268–286. 9. Rushdie,Salman. 1995. Midnight’s Children. London: Vintage. 10. ———. 1991. Imaginary Homelands: Essays in Criticism 1981–1991. London: Penguin.