Analysis Of The Battle Of The Granicus River

867 words - 4 pages

The battle of the Granicus involved Alexander the Great’s Macedonian army and a Persian interdiction force. Two sources address the events at the battle of the Granicus; however, these sources do not complement each other. The two sources are the accounts provided by Diodorus, and Arrian. Multiple contradictions exist between the two sources, which is unacceptable because both accounts cannot be true. The author of Article ‘The Battle of the Granicus River’ in the Journal of Hellenic Studies attempts to identify which of the two sources is more credible.
The author begins the article by addressing the issues involved with the portrayal of the battle of the Granicus, and states, “Historians have found the battle of the Granicus River the most puzzling of Alexander's battles.” Three reasons are associated with the puzzling aspects of the battle, which are the inconsistencies with timeframes provided by the sources, inconsistencies with formation movements, and inconsistencies with the exact location of the battle. The article discuses each inconsistency in detail, and in the order they were presented by the author.
The article first addresses Diodorus’ description of the timeframe of the battle, which states Alexander’s army crossed during morning in a relatively brash manner. The author is quick to point out why Diodorus’ account of the timeframe and formation arrangements is illogical, and inconsistent with Alexander’s generalship. The author than identifies Diodorus’ description as being a mixture of fact and dramatization. Furthermore, the article identifies writers who do not recognize the inclusion of dramatization in Diodorus’ description. The identification of troubling issues which plague Diodorus’ account and its continued influence on writers is an important point, which was made early in the article.
The author criticizes the works of writers who not only portray the account of Diodorus’ as entirely accurate, but also fill gaps in the account with personal assumptions. This article informs readers of works of literature that lack credibility and supports these accusations with the identification of the grave assumptions made by the authors in question. This is important for historians because it puts an end to the pollution of history with literally works that are more assumption than fact.
The article then addresses inconsistencies with descriptions of formation movements provided by the sources. The author analyzes the translations of the Greek text in Arrian’s account of Alexander’s movement of formations. First, the author includes the actual Greek text of the sentences in the article for the reader’s immediate reference. Second, the typical translation of the Greek text is included. Finally, the author...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of The Battle of the Granicus River

An Analysis of the Battle of Trenton

937 words - 4 pages In the beginning phase of the American Revolution, the American people believed the war to be all but over. This negative mentality was impartially due to the uphill battle faced by General George Washington and his Continental force during the fall of 1776. During that time period the Americans were defeated at the hands of the British in multiple major battles. After suffering a number of “demoralizing defeats at Long Island, Manhattan and

Analysis of the Battle of Leuctra

1797 words - 8 pages The Battle of Leuctra, one of the most influential and significant battles in ancient Greek history, occurred during the summer of 371 BC. This battle not only influenced Greece for many years to come but also eastern European history in the fourth century BC. Prior to Leuctra, the city-state of Sparta was the most dominant and powerful force in the Peloponnese and the rest of Greece. However, as a result of the conflict, the course of history

Analysis of the Battle of Leuctra

1757 words - 8 pages The Battle of Leuctra, one of the most influential and significant battles in ancient Greek history, occurred during the summer of 371 BC. This battle not only influenced Greece for many years to come but also eastern European history in the fourth century BC. Prior to Leuctra, the city-state of Sparta was the most dominant and powerful force in the Peloponnese and the rest of Greece. However, as a result of the conflict, the course of history

Drunkard Of The River

536 words - 3 pages A.) The text is about a boy called Sona who lives with his mother and father. Every Saturday the father is down at the bar where he drinks until he faints. Because of the fathers drinking the family hardly has any money, so the mother is very skinny because that they don't have enough money to buy food for. The boy really hates his father and it tortures him to see his mother cry all the time and get skinnier and look older for every day

Analysis Of The "Personification Of The River Tigris"

590 words - 2 pages Analysis of the "Personification of the River Tigris" Art's existence began with our existence. The earliest artists used cave walls as their canvases. As we advanced so did our art. People began to use different resources to create art. A resource could be rocks or ash. The "Personification of the River Tigris" is a great example of artist ingenuity. This piece is from the late second to early third century. It is

Geographical Analysis of the Hawkesbury - Nepean River Catchment

1347 words - 5 pages Describe and explain the spatial and ecological dimensions of the river catchment you have chosen.The Hawkesbury river catchment is one of the largest river catchments in Eastern Australia. The river catchment is located roughly to the west of Sydney and is sourced from the Great Dividing range and flows out to sea at Broken Bay. Spanning from Goulbourn in the South to Broken Bay in the North, the whole catchment area approximately covers around

Literary Analysis of Kate Grenville's The Secret River

1049 words - 5 pages Kate Grenville is one of Australia’s best known authors, she was born in 1950 in Sidney, Australia. She has won many national and international awards for her writing about Australia’s past and the interactions that may have been taking place between the first settlers and the aborigines. The Secret River was one of these popular novels, which is exploring the past, although it is only historical fiction. The inspiration for writing these

Analysis of the Battle of Kamdesh in the Afghan War

1011 words - 4 pages hence totally ignored. This favored the Taliban fighters to stage a partly successful attack (Kelly, 2011). Further analysis of what led to the overrunning by the fighters showed that, the generals involved did not command and make required measures to countering such attacks. This led to them being reprimanded while the few platoon men who managed to regroup and retake the camp were awarded medals of Honor. The Battle of Kamdesh was

History of the Colorado River

1552 words - 6 pages INTRODUCTION According to tree ring scientists from the University of Arizona in Tuscon, the Colorado River went through a six decade long drought during the mid-1100s. This drought was longer than any other drought know to the region. The Colorado River is essential to the American Southwest, draining into about 242,000 square miles of land to include seven U.S. states: Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming

Mysteries of The Secret River

714 words - 3 pages What secrets of history dwell rooted in the emotional depths of the muddled Australian river? Kate Grenville, an Australian author delves into the conflicts, encounters and relations between the Indigenous Australians and the European settlers within her novel ‘The Secret River’. The Secret River is part of a trilogy, published in 2005 and is a piece of historical fiction set upon the colonisation of Australia. Grenville uncovers a perspective

Matriarchs of the River Ki

1156 words - 5 pages The three prominent relationships in The River Ki are all very different due to the different times and people, but all of them have one thing in common--Hana. She is the stronghold throughout the book, not just because she is the main character, but because of her inordinate strength and spirit. She got much of the spirit from her grandmother, Toyono, who raised her after the death of her mother, Mio.Toyono was a prominent figure in Hana's life

Similar Essays

The Battle Of The Allia River

548 words - 2 pages the Greek hoplite fashion. The Romans were outnumbered 2 to 1 and back then this was usually the primary decider of the battle. The Gauls, trying to avoid as many casualties as possible, attacked the Roman reserves first. This frightened the Romans, seeing their only backup slaughtered and tried to run through the opposing forces but they were surrounded. They were slaughtered on the spot. Others tried to cross the river to safety but all drowned

The Battle Of Okinawa Analysis

2327 words - 9 pages World War II consisted of many devastating battles in both the European and the Pacific Theater. The Battle of Okinawa was fought in the Pacific theater. In the beginning of the battle there was little opposition from the Japanese soldiers but as the American troops traveled more inland the more resistance they met. Eventually, the 10th Army came against the fierce challenge of the intricate defense lines the Japanese held up. Many caves and

Battle Analysis Of The Battle Of Little Bighorn

2629 words - 11 pages Battle Analysis of the Battle of Little Bighorn On June 25, 1876, The Battle of Little Bighorn took place near the Black Hills in Montana. This was one of the most controversial battles of the 20th century and the line between good guys and bad guys was grey at best. Gen. George Armstrong Custer (reduced to LTC after the civil war) had 366 men of the 7thU.S. Cavalry under his command that day. Sitting Bull (A Medicine Man) led 2000 braves of

Analysis Of The Battle Of Arracourt

3839 words - 15 pages on the battlefield and their swift momentum outran their supply lines (Fugate, 1999). Lack of logistics allowed the German forces to take advantage of Patton’s Army and initiate one of the largest tank battles of World War II, the Battle of Arracourt.   BATTLE ANALYSIS THE BATTLE OF ARRACOURT I. Define the Subject. a. Define the Battle to be analyzed. (1). The Battle of Arracourt took place in Arracourt, Lorraine Province