Analyzing: Al Jabarti’s And His Chronicle Of The French Occupation, 1798

981 words - 4 pages

The Chronicle of the French Occupation, 1798 – Napoleon in Egypt, was written by the Egyptian born scholar and jurist, Abd al-Rahman al-Jabarti (c. 1753-c.1825) between 1798 and 1801, framing the French occupation of Egypt. Both the Middle East and Europe, during the late 17th century were in a state of redefinition. Although the chronicle had covered only the brief period during first seven months of 36, it serves as a crucial accounting. Clearly illustrated is a paradigmatic shift between a modern culture and an antiquated system with a chronicle of events that swings between something that is merely observational to something written by an emotionally charged spectator. Although the work has been widely accepted, there is still some speculation as to degrees of censorship and possible omissions through various translations.
The French occupation is a confrontation between exported modernity and an old regime: the French revolutionaries and their dominance over the Ottoman social order that is markedly different in contrast; and, al-Jabarti reports on how it transfers cross-culturally. Levels of contestation, open and/or secretive acceptances give way to losses and gains driven by high emotion – even for this writer. He “describes very carefully every step in the negotiation of the organization of society, from administration to inheritance, from property to charity or from justice to deliberation.”
Al-Jabarti’s accounts were written with a criticism and tone that lacked very little neutrality. Clearly described is the questioning of Napoleon’s sincerity. They did not believe that a Christian could be a redeemer for Islam and distrusted him immensely. The disdain for Napoleon’s attempts to gain the trust and favor of the Islamic community, to demonstrate himself as a friend to the Ottoman Sultan and to present himself as a liberator, was abundantly evident. Strongly written are events showing the level of disrespect to holy vessels: “rejecting their beliefs, killing the priests, and destroying churches;” and, at one point refers to the French as “Satan’s gang” based on their atrocious. The swinging pendulum of al-Jabarti’s writing style was clear as it goes between him being a “careful chronicler, the recorder of events” to one who completely lacked any sense of objectivity. His inability to detach himself personally from the events is clear as he vehemently opposes Bonaparte’s attempt to use the religion to gain alliances; and, his demonstrations of false morality. Yet, at other times, he is sincerely noted to respect the French for various aspects such as some conduct in handling the Qur’an, their willingness to make a societal contribution to assimilate through religion and academics.
For all the accolades received for this and al-Jabarti’s other work, it would seem that he was, at times, not above writing events that can be misleading, whether deliberate or inadvertent. For example, in Livingston’s analysis of The Rise of Shaykh...

Find Another Essay On ANALYZING: AL-JABARTI’S AND HIS CHRONICLE OF THE FRENCH OCCUPATION, 1798

Maxilmilien Robespierre and his influence on the Reign of Terror during the French Revolution

1598 words - 6 pages Maxilmilien RobespierreLooking back at the history of the French Revolution, Maxilmilien Robespierre was definitely one of the most controversial figures. From one aspect, he was very virtuous and devoted to fighting for his people. However, judging from another point of view, Robespierre was a ruthless tyrant who took away the lives of thousands and thousands of people. So is Robespierre really a true dedicator to the Revolution or is he a

Race and the United States Occupation of Haiti

1415 words - 6 pages The United States foreign expansion after the Civil War was characterized by an intensified interest in establishing political and military control in the Caribbean and the Pacific. One of the most important nations in the Caribbean was the French colony of Saint-Dominigue which would later be named Haiti following a slave rebellion resulting in the Haitian Revolution. Saint-Dominigue became the single richest colony in the western hemisphere

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy and the Model of Human Occupation

3613 words - 14 pages improvement in the performance or habituation subsystems may help bring forth changes in volition by improving expectancy. It is necessary to consider occupational performance because engagement in occupation is meaningful to the individual and the means through which one pursues his/her goals. Occupational analysis, an evaluation technique, identifies where the disturbance in an occupation occurs. The steps include "observation of the environment

Gender and Race During the U.S. Occupation of Japan

1884 words - 8 pages The Fifteen-Year War was a time of great turmoil and uncertainty in Japan. Various facets of the country were tested and driven to their limits. During the occupation, race and gender began to evolve in ways that had not exactly be seen before. War had a tremendous impact on every part of the life of a Japanese citizen. Both men and women began to fill roles that were completely novel to them. Race became a part of the definition of who people

Legislation and the Teaching Occupation

2383 words - 10 pages Legislation and the Teaching Occupation Legislation affects all aspects of the educational environment. Legislation controls teaching credentials, funds allotted for teaching supplies, general public school operation, and curriculum. In turn, the educational environment affects the capabilities of a teacher. Senators and assembly members have made numerous amendments over time to the laws that they have created. Such changes greatly

The Nazi Occupation of Holland

921 words - 4 pages On May 14, 1940 Holland surrendered to German Forces, and Dr. Arthur Seyss-Inquart was appointed Reichkommissar, the highest governing authority. He watched over a German administration that included many Austrian-born Nazis. These Nazis, in turn supervised the Dutch civil- service. This configuration proved fateful for the Jews of the Netherlands. During 1940, the German occupation officials forbidJews from the civil-service and required

The Roman Occupation of Britian

2562 words - 10 pages It is known that if you treat people well and are fair and just towards them, then they will intern be loyal and respect you. If the Romans had been fair to the people of Britain during their occupation after their invasion in 43 a.d. then they would have gained the respect of the people in England, and intern prospered as coexisting civilizations. Instead they raped and pillaged England of it's pride and honor. They destroyed the Druid religion

The Roman Occupation Of Britian

2748 words - 11 pages It is known that if you treat people well and are fair and just towards them, then they will intern be loyal and respect you. If the Romans had been fair to the people of Britain during their occupation after their invasion in 43 a.d. then they would have gained the respect of the people in England, and intern prospered as coexisting civilizations. Instead they raped and pillaged England of it's pride and honor. They destroyed the Druid religion

The Occupation of a Carpenter

2792 words - 11 pages occupation is so large. However, there is still the chance of losing a job. This happens because many construction jobs do not last a long time and bad weather may halt other jobs. Carpenter jobs also depend on the part of the country they live. Construction jobs go where people and businesses move and where the local business is good. Therefore, the number of jobs in any year will be different from area to area. Construction jobs will

The Origins and Attacks of Al Qaeda

1403 words - 6 pages Soviet Union. One vital person came about through this, and his name as Osama Bin Laden. The "Osama" spelling is deprecated, because there is no letter "O" in Arabic He is the proclaim founder of the group Al Qaeda. Osama believing that the war with the Soviet Union was a holy battle between Islam and the infidel. “Osama Bin Laden's experiences as a logistical coordinator and financier for the Afghan and Arab resistance to the Soviet invasion of

Al capone and the business of crime

1239 words - 5 pages Al Capone was an Italian criminal working the streets ofAmerica. He started his life with petty crime in Brooklyn, NewYork. After escalating his way up in Brooklyn, Capone moved toChicago for bigger and better things. There Capone had prominencesupremacy as one of the giant bootlegging forerunners. Hiscollected and composed ways, made crime into a business that wesee in today's mafia. Capone changed crime into a profession,which in turn made it

Similar Essays

Alien And Sedition Acts Of 1798 And The National Defense Authorization Act Of 2014

952 words - 4 pages The Alien and Sedition Acts were passed by Congress on July 14th, 1798. At this time in American history, John Adams was President and the Federalist had complete control over the federal government. On the surface, the Federalist and the Adam’s Administration appeared to be supporting these laws with the concern of national security and the safety of our borders. However, it became evident that the Federalist had political motives to destroy

How The World Wars Created An Independent Asia: The Failure Of The British And French Methods Of Imperialism And How Japanese Occupation During W

1573 words - 7 pages nation in Asia. Before the outbreak of World War II, Japan had made a bid for its role at the head of an Asian hegemony with the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere and had taken control of Korea, northern Manchuria and the coastal cities of China, Taiwan, Indonesia, and even the French Indochina. The Japanese Occupation in the Pacific War stowed the seeds for independence in many areas. The Anti-Japanese resistance groups in Malaysia, Vietnam

Shots Of The Occupation Essay

1143 words - 5 pages history and the occupation as a whole). In the final scene, there are close-ups of most of the major characters in the movie, including Suha, Said's mother, Jamal, Khaled, and Said. Said's is particularly important because it starts far away, showing Israeli citizens on a bus, and then zooms in until his eyes are the only things in the frame. Again, this shows how the characters are trapped by the oppression of the occupation, as Said is trapped by the camera frame.

Debate Over Alien And Sedition Acts Of 1798

746 words - 3 pages -Republicans. Perhaps the largest debate was over the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798. The Sedition and Alien Acts were put in place during the United States's conflicts with France in the late 1700s and John Jay's treaty that was signed with Great Britain. John Adams the president at the time and a majority of the government were Federalists. Most of the debate was over the Alien Act as this acts also changed the year required for citizenship from five