Animal Dilemma Essay

989 words - 4 pages

Every year there are tens of millions of animals like rats, dogs, birds, and farm animals that are killed to discover new information on medical discoveries, product testing, and for educational purposes. Many believe animal testing is inhumane because just like humans, animals feel pain as well, but others believe we should not treat animals as moral equals. However, in the recent years there have been new products introduced to decrease the use of animal testing or even possibly completely stopping it.
Using animals for medical experimentation, product testing, and education is a controversial subject that often leads to a large argument. While the problems can go into detail, the suffering involved in animal experimentation is painfully clear. Every year there are tens of millions of animals that die in federally and privately funded experiments. A projected 90 percent of all animals used in research are rats and mice, and many other species including guinea pigs, dogs, cats, rabbits, nonhuman primates, and farm animals are killed every year to animal testing. (UGA) The experimentation of animals and testing has not stopped because it is not the most accurate or reliable means of research, but because of the tradition, peer pressure, and large amounts of funding from those with strong invested interests into the business. (UGA)
The people that support animal testing dispute that without testing many of the medications and procedures that we have today wouldn’t exist and research and growth in the medical field would be very restricted. For scientists and researchers to be able to work on animals, they have made some great discoveries. Surgery on animals has helped in development of organ transplants and open-heart surgery techniques. Animal testing has also helped in development of vaccines against diseases like rabies, polio, measles, mumps, and rubella. Development of antibiotics, HIV drugs, insulin and cancer treatments were all made possible by animal tests. (Animal Experimentation)These supporters argue that other testing techniques like Corrositex are not as realistic and correct as testing on live subjects. (Alternatives)
Furthermore, blood pressure, pacemakers, and heart and lung machines were used on animals before them being tried on humans. Medical procedures like measuring surgery techniques, like those to mend and eliminate bone diseases were worked out of experimentation on the animals. (Animal Experimentation) The people that support animal testing believe that humanity has a responsibility to take actions in ways that will reduce injury and take full advantage of benefits. Making the experimentation on animals illegal would not allow humanity to achieve these outcomes. It is understood that a scientist’s goal is to develop methods to reduce pain to every degree possible but for now we have to sacrifice the animal’s pain to achieve the outcomes. (Of Cures and Creatures Great and Small)
The people who agree with animal...

Find Another Essay On Animal Dilemma

Researching context and perspectives Essay

604 words - 2 pages effectiveness of the argument, due to the reactions induced in the readers on both a logical and emotional level.Both articles had their own views on this controversial issue, and appealed to the audience with logic, ethics and emotion. This was achieved through the use of emotive language, statistics, quotes and many other techniques. They are equally convincing texts, but whether animal cruelty is seen as a critical ethical dilemma or a crucial

say no to aminal testing Essay

1013 words - 5 pages - Mone, G. (2014). New Models in Cosmetics Replacing Animal Testing. Communications Of The ACM, 57(4), 20-21. doi:10.1145/2581925 An Ugly Dilemma for Beauty Companies - Lin, L. (2013). An Ugly Dilemma for Beauty Companies. Bloomberg Businessweek, (4348), 31-32. Fact Sheet: Cosmetic Testing http://www.humanesociety.org/issues/cosmetic_testing/qa/questions_answers.html#.U3QG4PldXQw http://thelawdictionary.org/cruelty-to-animals/ http://www.dosomething.org/facts/11-facts-about-animal-testing

What the Government Should do About Animal Testing

2125 words - 9 pages are the ‘moral dilemma’ and ‘on balance justification’ views. The ‘moral dilemma’ view expresses that animal experimentation is morally unacceptable but avoiding research also is. The last, ‘on balance justification’ view says that animal research is morally acceptable if the costs outweigh the benefits. This is a very utilitarian approach to animal research and is the one that I believe the state should adopt. Utilitarianism is that the right

Animal Testing- Is it Good?

2214 words - 9 pages living longer, healthier lives (University of Toronto, 2005, p. 2). The table at the end of this paper shows additional advancements due to animal research.Finally, even with all the medical advancements and the disappearing ethical dilemma, scientists continue to go through much hardship and ridicule from critics and animal rights activists for their use of animals for testing even though they should be credited for the great research or discoveries

Humane Treatment of Animals

1425 words - 6 pages suffering. However, as far as animal testing is concerned we are confronted with the ethical dilemma of a choice between the welfare of humans or the welfare of animals. Some supporters of animal testing argue that ethical rights and principles of justice apply only to human beings. Morality is considered as a social creation out of its eventual process in which we do not associate animals. As animals are not part of this moral community created

Animal Cloning Morally Wrong

1144 words - 5 pages been many different animals cloned by scientists all over the world. Before the scientists in Scotland cloned Dolly the Sheep, they probably did not consider the moral dilemma that they were about to create. We all need to ask whether or not we believe that the cloning of animals is morally wrong and consider the negative consequences of cloning animals. One of the obvious reasons why we might think that animal cloning is morally wrong is that it

Owners' Knowledge of Dogs

897 words - 4 pages are brought to the animal control center, there is only “1” veterinarian. This inadequacy on top of other factors such as reckless breeding makes taking full management of the issue challenging to tackle. Although funding problems contribute to the increasing dilemma of animal control; it is neverthless, owners who create the situation by not getting proper training for dogs that exhibit aggressive tendencies. For instance in Trevino and Shuit’s

Animal Cruelty and Youth Violence

2242 words - 9 pages There are over seventy million cats and fifty-five million dogs in the United States, yet the number of reported cases of neglect, or abuse is severely lacking (Davidson 1). Animal abuse is an ongoing dilemma in this country; recent studies have indicated child animal cruelty offenders often go on to pursue disturbing acts of criminal behavior. This nation simply does not have standardized legislation across the nation as a preventative

Animal-Assisted Therapy

811 words - 3 pages Animal-Assisted TherapyThe recent researches made by prominent scientists show that pet can be good for people's health and their well-being. Now you can see pets in some therapeutic regimens of nursery houses, rehabilitation centers, psychiatric institutions and some others. Pets are usually used to help the patient to inmate in correctional facilities and gain sympathy. For example, autistic children can swim with dolphins. There are some

Let's Put an End to Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation

2006 words - 8 pages come before the good of the few or the one. True, animal testing has brought the human race many advances in the area of medicine and technology, but the cost has been horrendous. The only solution to this moral dilemma of necessity versus morality is to have compassion and judgment in what is really important for survival. If every person showed compassion and respect for those animals which they must use, only essential testing would be carried

Flaws with Utilitarianism

636 words - 3 pages introduced through the ethical thought experiment The Dilemma of the Swine. Resultantly, human existence constitutes higher pleasure that does that of an animal and we are often better served by making such a distinction through intuitive analysis rather than applying “Hedonistic Calculus.” The fact that Utilitarianism can be forced into contradictions regardless of the stance they choose makes the inclusion of animals under their ethical umbrella a significant problem.

Similar Essays

Animal Testing: A True Ethical Dilemma

1704 words - 7 pages Imagine a life locked away in a cage with no form of control on your existence. It’s cold, dark, and you are scared. You don’t have a choice of what you eat, where you live, or how you are treated. You are unsure if it is day or night or what will happen to you next. You are locked away in a prison cell and you committed no crime. This is the life of a laboratory animal. Animal testing is the use of animals for scientific research purposes and

Animal Testing In The Research Field

1385 words - 6 pages aberrant because they are infected with “human diseases.” Scientists “force-feed chemicals to animals, conduct repeated surgeries on them, implant wires in their brains, crush their spines, and much more… usually without any painkillers” (“Life in a Laboratory”). This practice is called “Animal Research,” which has been a controversial issue, placing the public’s emotions into a dilemma. Have you ever wonder how some of your personal care products

Testing One Two Three Essay

772 words - 4 pages Since the beginning of time, man has had a connection with the animals around him whether it was for food or companionship. It is out of this relationship the controversial subject of animal testing arises. If most of society believes it is immoral to cause animals to suffer then experimenting on animals creates a serious ethical dilemma (BBC United Kingdom, 2008). While some people believe experimenting on animals is a necessary evil, others

Animal Testing Should Be Outlawed Essay

1198 words - 5 pages According to Biology Online, animal experimentation is defined as the use of animals in experiments and development projects usually to determine toxicity, dosing and efficacy of test drugs before proceeding to human clinical trials. Animal experimentation has been going on since ancient Greece when Aristotle and Hippocrates first made their model of the human body based on what they had observed through animal dissection. Then, Romans used