Animal Rights Essay

1139 words - 5 pages

For the past 20 years, there has a been an on going heated debate on whether experiments on animals for the benefit of medical and scientific research is ethical. Whether it is or isn't, most people believe that some form of cost-benefit test should be performed to determine if the action is right. The costs include: animal pain, distress and death where the benefits include the collection of new knowledge or the development of new medical therapies for humans. Looking into these different aspects of the experimentation, there is a large gap for argument between the different scientists' views. In the next few paragraphs, both sides of the argument will be expressed by the supporters.

A well known scientist named Neal D. Barnard said," The use of animals for research and testing is only one of many investigative techniques available. We believe that although animal experiments are sometimes intellectually seductive, they are poorly suited to addressing the urgent health problems of our era, such as heart disease, cancer, stroke, AIDS and birth defects." He goes on further to say that animal experiments can not only mislead researchers but even contribute to illnesses or deaths by failing to predict any toxic effect on drugs. The majority of animals in laboratories are used for genetic manipulation, surgical intervention or injection of foreign substances.

Researchers produce solutions from these animal "models" and are adapting them to human conditions. Unfortunately, these animal "models" can't always be connected with the human body thus creating problems. Many times, researchers induce strokes on animals in order to test certain methods for curing. The downfall of this procedure is that a healthy animal that experiences a sudden stroke does not undergo the slowly progressive arterial damage that usually plays a crucial role in human strokes. In another illustration of the inaccuracy of animal research, scientists in the 1960s deduced from many animal experiments that inhaled tobacco smoke did not cause lung cancer.

For many years afterward, the tobacco industry was able to use these studies to delay government warnings and to discourage physicians from intervening in their patients' smoking habits. We all know now that this is totally untrue and that smoking is a large contributor to cancer. It turns out that cancer research is especially sensitive to differences in physiology between humans and other animals. Many animals, particularly rats and mice, synthesize within their bodies approximately 100 times the recommended daily allowance for humans of vitamin C, which is believed to help the body ward off cancer. The stress of handling, confinement and isolation alters the animal's mental stability and introduces yet another experimental variable that makes any results from testing even less valuable to human helping. In many cases, drugs and other substances are given to the test animals but studies have...

Find Another Essay On Animal Rights

ANIMAL RIGHTS Essay

867 words - 3 pages humans and therefore, we don’t have the right to kill or harm them in any way. The premises are the following: animals are living things thus they are valuable sentient beings, animals have feeling just like humans, and animals feel pain therefore animal suffering is wrong. 2 sources I will be using for my research are “The Fight for Animal Rights” by Jamie Aronson, an article that presents an argument in favour of animal rights. It also discusses

Animal Rights Essay

771 words - 3 pages A pretty good essay No commentsChris MorraEn-105-03Animal RightsIn Brigid Brophy's essay, The Rights of Animals, there are some statements that I agree with and some that I don't. Unlike Brigid Brophy, I am not a vegetarian, nor would I ever become one, but I do believe that animals have certain rights.I feel that there is nothing wrong with killing an animal for food. Animals have been killing each other for food in order to survive since

Animal Rights

836 words - 4 pages According to Tom Regan’s Kantian Account, “There are no degrees of moral standing” (Waller, 2011). Animals and humans are equal. Just because a human is smarter than an animal does not give it any more rights than the animal. Utilitarianism casts a wide moral net: all who are capable of feeling pleasure or pain must be counted in our moral decision making (Waller, 2011). Animals should have rights such as humans do even though they may not be

Animal Rights

1192 words - 5 pages . Animals do not have the same moral judgement or cognitive ability that humans have because of this animals have been treated differently by almost every culture (Animal Research p.1).If animals were given the same rights as humans, they’re would be no more eating meat everyone would have to become vegetarians and hunting would be banned. Whether or not you’re testing on animals or humans the product, vaccine, whatever it maybe has to be tested in

Animal Rights

1220 words - 5 pages Animal Rights      Ever since The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in England in 1824 was formed there has been long running debates on the topic of animal rights. The first societies were formed to protect and maintain human treatment of work animals, such as cattle, horses and house hold pets. Towards the end of the 19th century more organizations were formed, this time to protest the use of animals

Animal Rights

1209 words - 5 pages Animal Rights      "Isn't man an amazing animal? He kills wildlife--birds, kangaroos, deer, all kinds of cats, coyotes, groundhogs, mice, foxes and dingoes--by the million in order to protect his domestic animals and their feed. Then he kills domestic animals by the billion and eats them. This in turn kills man by the million, because eating all those animals leads to degenerative--and fatal--health conditions

Animal Rights - 596 words

596 words - 2 pages Animal Rights The 20th century has had more medical breakthroughs than any other hundred years in history. But there is a price. No significant discovery in this time has occurred without the use of animals in biological research experiments. Heart surgery, polio, osteoporosis, diabetes, AIDS, and cancer have all had significant breakthroughs thanks to these experiments(McCarty 15). The use of animals in today’s world is highly

Animal Rights

991 words - 4 pages the process that an airport's customs goes through to protect innocent country folk from terrorism, drug trafficking, and infectious products, groups such as PETA are trying to protect the innocent animals who are merely trying to survive in a hectic and sometimes cruel world that human's seem to believe they run. Without help from these organized groups (custom or animal rights groups) the outcome of the acts performed by any individual could

Animal Rights - 1181 words

1181 words - 5 pages SUPERIORITY. Over 7 Billion animals die at thehands of humans, in the US, every year. Out of those 7Billion animals, about 95% of them are killed for uses asfood. Advocates for animal rights justify their research bypresenting the obvious differences that exist between humansand animals. These include size, status, strength, and ability.Sometimes, one who is against animal rights will take theattitude that "God gave them [animals] to us to use

Animal Rights - 845 words

845 words - 3 pages ; Animal rights are an emotional issue-second only, perhaps, to the bitter abortion debate." For decades the value of animal research has been grossly overrated. Although researchers have depended on animal test data to achieve medical advances, there should be other means of research because testing on animals is cruel and inhumane and often unnecessary.The American Medical Association believes that research involving animals is absolutely

Animal Rights - 1000 words

1000 words - 4 pages Animal RightsToday, after the evolution of human beings over several millenniums, in the twenty-first century, it is hard to deny animal rights. As most people know, animals have rights just like humans; however, they are unable to defend their own rights. As a result, some humans take advantage of this situation and violate animal rights by hunting, torturing, or abusing them. Given the above situation, a simple question comes to the mind of

Similar Essays

Animal Rights Essay 1285 Words

1285 words - 5 pages Justifying Animal Rights In this society, it is under law for all people have the basic rights under the universal declaration of human rights. As stated, this only benefits humans, where humans rule the world. So where does the rights of animals come from? Many people do not understand animal rights and how we should treat them equally and why. Through animal research and experimentations, humans are getting benefit and gains in the

Animal Rights Essay 843 Words

843 words - 4 pages tries to stop the vivisection of animals as they believe it is not our right to experiment on animals as they feel the pain and terror just as any human does. It started in the 80’s and nearly succeeded in passing several legislations but medical science always made a breakthrough just in time. The Animal Rights Movement has often gone hand in hand with racial protests trying to insinuate that treating animals differently as racist and

Animal Rights Essay 1261 Words

1261 words - 6 pages Animal rights, also referred to as animal liberation, is the idea that the most basic interests of non-human animals should be afforded the same consideration as the similar interests of human beings.[3] Advocates approach the issue from different philosophical positions, but agree that animals should be viewed as non-human persons and members of the moral community, and should not be used as food, clothing, research subjects, or entertainment

Animal Rights Essay 575 Words

575 words - 2 pages As Doctor Zola-Morgan stated in a speech to animal right activists, "I've seen the impact of the animal rights movement. I believe this is an attack on science of the worst kind. If we allow it to prevail it will take us back to the dark ages." Too much of the public has come to think of medical researchers as "tormenters rather than healers." The good is overlooked and the bad is exploited. Although many people think that animal research is