Are Prime Ministers Or Presidents Generally More Powerful?

1221 words - 5 pages

Within parliamentary systems, the government i.e. the legislature consist of the political party with the most popularly elected Members of Parliament (MPs) in the main legislative parliament e.g. the House of Commons in the United Kingdom. The Prime Minister is appointed by the party to lead as the executive decision-maker, and the legislature work to support and carry out their will (Fish, 2006). In presidential systems, the President is directly elected with the support of their political party, with the legislative being separately elected and, in the case of the United States, being made up of representatives from different states (BIIP, 2004). This essay will provide examples to suggest that Presidents are generally more powerful than Prime Ministers. As two of the oldest forms of parliamentary and presidential governments (Mainwaring and Shugart, 1997), the United Kingdom and the United States will be the main focus of this essay, but other parliamentary and presidential countries will be mentioned.

Power Separation
Separation of power is an important concept within presidential systems like the United States, with presidential power constricted by established levels of responsibility. According to Lijphart (1999: 125), the separation of power within presidential systems implies “not only the mutual independence of the executive and legislative branches but also the rule that the same person cannot simultaneously serve both”, which isn’t the case in parliamentary systems, where the Prime Minister does have control of both branches of government (SOURCES). This also applies to the powers of US state governments, with certain areas of policy i.e. educational standards and criminal justice (BIIP, 2004) controlled by states rather than by the President. The executions of Edgar Tamayo in Texas and Troy Davis in Georgia are recent example of the limitations of executive power in presidential systems – although the President was able to suggest a course of action (Valdes, Mears and Shoichet, 2014), state law took precedence in both cases, with the President legally unable to intervene (Benen, 2011; Cook, 2011).

Both executive posts have strengths and weaknesses in passing legislation - in parliamentary systems, a Prime Minister is strengthened by a majority government which is “unconstrained by other powerful domestic (or) international actors” (Krauss and Nyblade, 2005: 357). Not only can a strong Prime Minister dissolve a legislative, a power available in many British-based i.e. post-colonial parliamentary systems and unavailable in presidential systems (Lijphart, 1999), they are also able to control policy debates within elected parliament i.e. the length of debates and voting times (Szilagyi, 2009: 313).

Garnett and Lynch (2007: 120) used Blair as an example of a Prime Minister who enjoyed the advantages of “large parliamentary majorities, a strong position within the (Labour) party and a largely quiescent Cabinet”, which...

Find Another Essay On Are Prime Ministers or Presidents Generally More Powerful?

Are Humans Animals, Or Are They Something More?

1167 words - 5 pages Human beings should be more than animals, but are they really? In Republic, by Plato, Antigone, by Sophocles, The Aeneid of Virgil, by Virgil, and On Justice Power and Human Nature, by Thucydides, it seems as though human beings really are nothing more than animals.      Animals are thought of as not caring about anyone but himself or herself. It is survival of the fittest, if you are not strong enough, someone else

Are cell phones causing more or less damage

1040 words - 5 pages Are Phones Causing More Or Less Damage "People are spending an exceeding amount of time on their cell phones with an average of 130 minutes per day. "("Cyber Bullying Statistics."). About 87 percent of Americans can say that they own a cell phone. The new average age for a person to get a cell phone is now at the age of 13 . With this number decreasing and younger children getting phones this means more problems

Are diverse teams really more creative and effective or do they simply invite more conflict? Explain

648 words - 3 pages It is not simply to answer diverse teams which are more creative and effective or invite more conflict. Compare to homogeneous teams which is "team that includes members with common technical expertise, demographics, ethnicity, experiences or values" (McShane & Travaglione, 2003, p269) and individuals, diverse teams have advantages and disadvantages depend on different situations. Based on current workplace, Griggs and Louw (1995, p24

"The most powerful characters in The Odyssey are women." Argue for or against this proposition using examples from the text; please limit evidence to two or three episodes only

1179 words - 5 pages "The most powerful characters in The Odyssey are women." Argue for or against this proposition using examples from the text; please limit evidence to two or three episodes only.The word powerful can be looked at in several ways; it can be regarded as strength, knowledge, control, and beauty. All these forms of power are repeatedly illustrated within The Odyssey. A key observation with respect to power is that women are undoubtedly the most

Are technical skills or people skills more important to the team manager in a software development project?

731 words - 3 pages combination is generally a recipe for failure." Lacking project management or people skills and only possessing technical skills can result in a failed project.A team manager that lacks the technical skills to guide the software developers can be a hindrance to the software development lifecycle. Building a good team of developers will allow the team manager to defer technical aspects of the project to the developers, but lacking any knowledge of

Acceptance of Scociety, Describibe why some types of freakishness and/or disabilities are accepted by society more than others

786 words - 3 pages Acceptance of SocietyWhy is it that some forms of freakishness or disabilities are accepted by society more than others, making them more marketable? Disability is a word with many different definitions. Webster defines disability as, "The state of being disabled; deprivation or want of ability; absence of competent physical, intellectual, or moral power, means, fitness, and the like" (Webster 109). I see disabilities as an impairment that may


2167 words - 9 pages restricted and directed by more powerful ones because their economic influences on the metropolis. By writing “underdevelopment is not absence of development”, Rodney (1972) emphasizes that the development process would happen at both the center and periphery because everyone would have their own development way and enjoy the fruits of development in greater or lesser extents. Thus, “underdevelopment” only have meaning if it is used to compare the

"Compare how products and or people are represented in advertisements. Refer to two or more examples which you have studied. Use at least one past advertisement and one recent advertisement."

591 words - 2 pages low in fat, salt and sugar.The target audience does not seem to have changed in over 50 years. The more recent adverts are much more colourful, exciting and humorous. On the website some of the older television adverts can be seen; these adverts are all using classic children's stories like Black Beauty and Robin Hood. The timeline on the website helps promote the idea that Weetabix is a classic product which has stood the test of time. The two

Discuss the way one or more groups of Australians are represented in film and to what extent this representation reflects wider social attitudes. Refer to at least one feature film you have studied

1319 words - 5 pages a more assertive role over Hiromitsu who is very passive. Sandy's appearance, actions and dialogue also illustrate the representation that is being constructed by the filmmakers. Sandy regularly dresses in clothes such as pants, which are suited to hard work, even though she usually works in an office. She frequently smokes, this being another trait generally associated with males. Her dialogue consists of constant use of idiomatic language

An essay about whether the characters in the House of the Seven Gables (written by Nathaniel Hawthorne) are responsible for their own bad luck, or if it has to do more with fate

1428 words - 6 pages imagination to take control of their own logic, and by openly committing the seven deadly sins, whereas the more humble member of the family, Phoebe, leads an easier and happier life.Hepzibah and Clifford are predominately the two characters creating their own prison of fear in the house. Hepzibah constantly goes back and forth looking at the portrait on the wall and the photograph, reminding herself of the Colonel and of the curse itself. She is

British Prime Minister's Powers

1846 words - 7 pages powerful weapon to use in order to gain popularity but it can damage his or her image and give the party a negative image. In conclusion, the British prime ministers powers are constrained under the British system to some extent. As I have mentioned earlier on, the cabinet has a great influence in constraining the prime ministers power, as Brown had demonstrated his power in the cabinet through vetoing the entry into the European single currency

Similar Essays

"Words Are More Powerful And Treacherous Than We Think" J.P.Sartre

624 words - 2 pages "Word is a unit of language which has meaning and is used with others to form sentences, promises, comands and messages" (Oxford Dicxtionary). Words carries a specific emotional charge. Words are studied through the whole life, at school, during meetings or even watching TV. If we hear something it is saved in our brain at short notice. The avider readers we are, the more words are known, because books have been said to be the best tutor of

In What Ways And Why Are The Committees Of The Us Congress So Much More Powerful Than The Committees Of The House Of Commons?

1141 words - 5 pages are stopped at committee stage as different state members are seeking to protect their state's interests rather than protect national interests, this of course leads to indifference at committee stage which more or less guarentees the bill will be stopped at this stage.Also committees in the US congress are assigned roles with more power. For example, the House Appropriations Committee is incredibly powerful. its role is, after the president has

Themes In "Lord Of The Flies" : Good Vs. Evil Are People Generally Good Or Generally Evil?

1053 words - 4 pages There are various outlooks of a man in the novel ?Lord of the Flies.? Piggy and Ralph viewed man as being essentially good and that evil happens because something was wrong with people. Jack used power over others and believed that forces more powerful than him must be appeased through ceremony and sacrifice. Simon believed that both good and evil lay within each person. William Golding?s point of view is also represented by one of the

Are Men Or Women More Fortunate?

840 words - 3 pages Who is more Fortunate?      Are men or women more fortunate? Physically, men may be more fortunate; for men do not give birth, do not have to deal with periods and menopause, and do not spend a long time getting prepared each morning. But what is the answer if we just look at the temperament? In relationships, men are surely less fortunate than women: men often must take risks for the relationship; women can