Article Critique On Csi Plagiarism Essay

686 words - 3 pages

In CSI Plagiarism, M. Garret Bauman (2009) writes on his and his colleagues’ personal experiences as a professor and their students’ plagiarism. After a couple stories, which appeal more as a catharsis behavior, Bauman finally proposed a different approach on the way students should be addressed. He presented a suggestion on an effective way to address the issue of plagiarism in an educational setting with a goal of causing less harm to the educational leaders. This essay will review and criticize Bauman’s new approach on dealing with fraudulent students, as well as evaluate the weakness or the strengths of the article.
Right at the beginning of the article, Bauman leaves the perception of ...view middle of the document...

And by that, he means to shame, mock or embarrass the students into fearful obedience. Bauman ends the article by presenting an example of a conversation between the students and himself where he applies his new way of fighting back.
The strength of the article is found on the narrative of the stories that the author and his colleagues had experienced with students who committed plagiarism. By telling the stories, it brought to light the difficulties, frustration and intense work professors have to put into identifying all aspects of plagiarism and how they fight for a prudential educational world.
Although the article has strengths, the topic was not explored in great depth, mainly because there is a lack of resources cited to support his thoughts and thesis. Bauman’s main points, include his new approach which is the belief that professors should be dealing with students in fraud by playing the same game and the current posture of conformism with the culture. I do not agree with the new approach that he presents. Being a Christian counselor and professional we should have...

Find Another Essay On Article Critique on CSI Plagiarism

Qualitative Article Critique on Palliative Care

1156 words - 5 pages used? A grounded theory approach was used in this qualitative research design to better understand the views of palliative care nurses on euthanasia (Wester, 1987; Kuyper & Wester, 1998). In this article, face-to-face interviews were used involving an interview guide. The data was grouped into concepts according to significant passages, then the concepts were grouped into categories for continuous comparison, then the data was ordered

Critique of Article Titled "An American Attack on Iraq is not Justified"

822 words - 3 pages because it makes it easier for the reader to trust that he knows what he is talking about since sociologists study these types of situations and their effects on society. Since Farley participates actively in protests against the war, he is part of the movement and knows about the situation. Furthermore, the organization of Farley's article helps his argument. He separates the article into different sections with subtitles for all the different

Critique Essay on the NY Times Article 'Far-Flung Artworks, Side by Side Online'

760 words - 3 pages Write a summary essay on any article that deals with modern day art. State your feelings on the article and if there is any other information the writer should have added.SOURCE: New York TimesDATE:May 22, 2003Far-Flung Artworks, Side by Side OnlineBy Matthew MirapeaulWhile researching for many of the topics in this class, I came across invaluable online resources. Many websites claimed to have museum quality reproductions of artwork, but I

The Potential Impacts of Upcoming High-Stakes Testing on the Teaching of Science in Elementary Classrooms-Research Article Critique

1165 words - 5 pages appreciate the research. Information was analyzed, evaluated and used to support the collected data in the conclusion portion of the paper. The variables addressed included the impact of the independent variable, impending high-stakes science testing, and its effect on the teaching of science, which was the dependent variable. This data was focused on teacher concerns and perspectives of the issues. They were not operationally defined in the

Explains plagiarism

1006 words - 4 pages 1. INTRODUCTIONThe act of plagiarism has been perpetrated by many students, journalists and writers over the past years. This essay aims to discuss plagiarism, starting with a definition and giving possible reasons as to why one may decide to plagiarise. It will then go on describe different types of plagiarism, making use of descriptions as provided by Professor Irving Hexham of the University of Calgary, and conclude my suggesting means by

Crime Scene Investigation

1773 words - 7 pages Maricopa County study showed that almost ninety percent of prosecutors “explain to juries why police might not collect the kind of evidence depicted in television shows. Seventy-five percent try to have fingerprint or other expert witnesses available to counter the effects on juror perceptions created by forensic crime television shows” (CSI, 2005). This phenomenon affects defense attorneys alike, in a recent article in USA Today, some defense lawyers

Faculty Perceptions of Self-Plagiarism: An Exploratory Multi-University Study

731 words - 3 pages Faculty Perceptions of Self-Plagiarism: An Exploratory Multi-University Study Rachel Foxx Liberty University Article Review and Analysis Two: Faculty Perceptions On Self-Plagiarism: An Exploratory Multi-University Study The article that will be reviewed in this paper is Faculty Perceptions On Self-Plagiarism: An Exploatory Multi-University Study written by Colleen Halupa and Doris U. Bolliger. This paper will

The Silent Harm of Plagiarism

1107 words - 4 pages itself. On the other hand, others argue that the new “lax” attitude adopted by many young people contributes to the social acceptance of plagiarism in the academic setting. In the data collected by Hard, a drastic 60.6 percent of students had copied sentences, phrases, paragraphs, tables, figures, or data directly or in slight modification of a book, article, or other academic sources without giving proper acknowledgment to the author (Hard 1069

A Matter of Honor Case Study

3022 words - 12 pages article that was written, Sheila’s parents indicated their belief that their daughter did not knowingly commit plagiarism. They placed the burden on the school, commenting that the school should have done a better job of educating students about what this meant. With the scrutiny of the press as an added pressure, the superintendent asked the principal to make a quick determination that would avert the looming crisis. The Problem In the case study

the verdict is in

2368 words - 10 pages during the commission of a crime. Forensic science and crime based shows on television today seemingly portray our criminal system, but viewers don’t seem to connect that these shows are still a works of fiction and that sometimes their methods used to solve crimes are far from accurate (Mancini). CSI, Bones, NCIS and other crime dramas have created an explosion in people’s interest in forensic science. While these shows are very entertaining

Plagiarism Must Stop

896 words - 4 pages rather spend their time doing more enjoyable things such as going to basketball or football games and parties. However, this behavior must stop and more needs to be done to educate students about copying. Solutions to stop plagiarism include educating students at a young age, learning and understanding the consequences, and focus on originality rather than plagiarism and the negativity. If a student in college does not understand plagiarism, it

Similar Essays

Article Critique On Gmo Essay

694 words - 3 pages Article Critique on GMOPOL 1113Prof. Marija NaumoskiFall 2014By Sachet KhanalEverybody enjoys eating ice cream on a hot summer day, and having pan cakes for breakfast, but most of us don't bother thinking about what is in our food or how it was made. A lot of food available for sale are genetically modified, but as these foods do not have to be labeled, we will not know whether the food we buy is genetically modified or not. In an article titled

Research Article Critique: A Critique On Bitchener

1217 words - 5 pages , group 3, and group 4, meaning that the result obtained by group 2 (Direct CF + W) was not significantly different from the control group. Critique of the method There are several points worth discussing in this article. The first and the most important one is the integration of the ‘mini lesson’ in the treatment given to group 1. As the researcher had explained, this mini lesson comprised of explaining “the rules and examples that the students

Critique On The Nursing Article Critical Care Patients’ Experience Of The Helmet Continuous Positive Airway Pressure

2784 words - 11 pages (2005) suggested that such measures should not be taken in isolation to justify credibility of research papers. This article by Dimech is published in a peer-reviewed journal (JNCC). Which means it is being reviewed by experts in the field. Palatnik (2012) stated that Nursing in Critical Care is a peer review journal that presents the latest practical clinical and professional information in a clear, concise, hands-on approach, which critical

Critique Of Article On Adlerian Theory

636 words - 3 pages and is less likely to perform criminal behavior, so said Alder. I find it hard to understand why some people are empathetic towards other humans and why some just are not. So what really makes someone more empathic than the next? The article that I chose investigates this very topic. The study, "Predictors of Social Interest in Young Adults", looks into three influential factors on the effects of developing social interest, these are