Beowulf And Poor Catechesis Essay

2011 words - 8 pages

Beowulf and Poor Catechesis

 
        Beowulf is a good example of bad catechesis in the Scriptures and in church doctrine and practice. Christianity is presented by  scops/minstrels/poets who had general notions about Christianity but were lacking in the detailed knowledge.

 

In Beowulf the Christian elements are about equally distributed between narrative and speeches. While the poet’s reflections and characters’ statements are mostly Christian, the customs and ceremonies, on the other hand, are almost entirely heathen/pagan: At the beginning of the poem, there is the account of the pagan funeral rites of Scyld Scefing, and at the close of the poem we see the heathen rites of burial for Beowulf himself, including cremation, deposition of treasures and armor, etc. with the corpse in the burial mound overlooking the sea. That enables the poet to “communicate his Christian vision of pagan heroic life.”(Bloom 2). Additonally, earlier in the poem, the Danes, when under extreme pressure from Grendel, reverted to Satan-worship:

 

At times they prepared              sacrifice in temples,

war-idol offerings,                                 said the old words aloud,

that the great soul-slayer                       might bring some comfort

in their country’s disaster.                      Such was their custom,

the hope of the heathen;                        they remembered Hell

in their deepest thoughts.                       They knew not the Lord,

the Judge of our deeds,             were ignorant of God,

knew not how to worship                      our Protector above,

the King of Glory (175ff)

 

This fact of heathen rites and customs seems to point to the conclusion that Beowulf  is originally a heathen work which has undergone revision by Christian minstrels. The Cambridge History of English and American Literature states that the Christian element was the work of later revision (v1,ch3, s3, n18). So when we talk about “poor catechesis” in the title, we are referring to the poor instruction in the faith given to these early Christian minstrels who slowly revised an originally pagan epic into a somewhat Christian one.

 

The minstrels’ catechesis seems poor because their allusions to the church and to the Bible are quite indistinct, vague, indefinete, thus reflecting a vague knowledge of Christianity on their part. In the whole poem there is possibly one half-hearted paraphrase of a Scriptural passage in lines 1743ff:

 

                                                Too sound is that sleep,

bound up in cares;                    the killer very near

who shoots his bow                  with treacherous aim.

Then he is hit in the heart,          struck under helmet

with the bitter arrow,                 the dark commands

of the wicked demon,               and he knows no defense.

 

The Biblical passage to which this may...

Find Another Essay On Beowulf and Poor Catechesis

Epic of Beowulf Essay - Beowulf as Epic Hero

871 words - 3 pages ) Heard how Grendel filled nights with horror And quickly commanded a boat fitted out, Proclaiming that he'd go to that famous king, Would sail across the sea to Hrothgar (l 134-137). Beowulf is going out of his way, "across the sea" to help a lord whom he is not obligated to.  He is doing so out of choice to show his respect for Hrothgar, and to help the poor people threatened by Grendel. Great personal valor is a necessity for

Two Grendels Essay

587 words - 2 pages about it the same way and thus repeating and not realizing the destruction they are doing to themselves. Before Grendel dies he says with a last breath to all the animals watching, “Poor Grendel’s had an accident, so may you all.”(Gardner 174) As result of him saying that it shows how he is happy about leaving such a world and to leave all his unknowing behind him. In the epic poem of Beowulf the character Grendel seems to be thought of as a

The Heroic Traits Of JFK And Beowulf

961 words - 4 pages A Hero is defined as, " A man admired for his achievements and noble qualities." (Marriam-Webster Dictionary, 1999) It's the best word to describe mythological character Beowulf, and 35th U.S. President John Fitzgerald Kennedy. Beowulf was a honorable man, who reigned as kind and the strongest warrior throughout land. J.F.K. charmed the U.S. with wit, kindness, and bravery. John F. Kennedy and Beowulf had similar heroic qualities.Beowulf

Essential Qualities of Protagonists

791 words - 4 pages through the characters of Hrothgar, Beowulf and Wiglaf. Hrothgar, the king of the Danes, undoubtedly yearns for what is best for his people. Having much experience with poor fortune and atrocity, Hrothgar is most necessary for assisting Beowulf in his development as a hero. His old age and familiarity with the pros and cons of leadership and power give him much wisdom, which he then passes on to Beowulf. Hrothgar is deeply affected by Grendel’s

Beowulf

696 words - 3 pages they have. A person can be rich, but thought of as a bad person, if they do not put at least part of their money to good use. A poor working man who volunteers at the homeless shelter is much more respected than the rich tycoon in his penthouse. In the Anglo-Saxon times, they still respected people who did great things. Beowulf was a hero because of his great strength and courage, and was probably respected more than many lords. But when the

Beowulf

1257 words - 5 pages Beowulf, Grendel still does not understand that what has come to him is a direct result of his actions, and thinks that the Danes are enjoying the slaughter of him simply for the sport of it. The beast is unable to understand that his destruction of so many people is what has led these people to desire his death: "They watch on, evil, incredibly stupid, enjoying my destruction. 'Poor Grendel's had an accident,' I whisper. 'So may you all

themebeo Epic of Beowulf Essay - Style, Structure and Theme

4780 words - 19 pages Style, Structure and Theme of Beowulf                    A consideration of the stylistic features in the classic poem Beowulf involves a study of the poetic verse, the vocabulary, alliteration, litotes, simile, kennings, variation and double-meaning or ambiguity. A consideration of the structure and the theme of the poem involve a wide diversity of opinion on the subject.   First, let us talk about style. The poetic conventions

An Analysis of the Epic Poem, Beowulf - The Style of Beowulf

1888 words - 8 pages The Style of Beowulf           A consideration of the stylistic features in the classic poem Beowulf involves a study of the poetic verse, the vocabulary, alliteration, litotes, simile, kennings, variation and double-meaning or ambiguity.   The poetic conventions used by this poet include two half-lines in each verse, separated by a caesura or pause. The half-lines are joined by the oral stressing of alliterative words in the

The Pessimism of Beowulf in the Epic Poem, Beowulf

2922 words - 12 pages     Anticipation of catastrophe, doom, gloom are present in Beowulf rom beginning to end, even in the better half of the poem, Part I. Perhaps this is part of what makes it an elegy – the repeated injection of sorrow and lamentation into every episode. In his essay, “The Pessimism of Many Germanic Stories,” A. Kent Hieatt says of the poem Beowulf: The ethical life of the poem, then, depends upon the propositions that evil. . . that is

An essay about the Apocalyptic visions in Beowulf

1915 words - 8 pages In folktales, legends, mythology, and even the Bible, people are told stories about Hero's and their unimaginable strength, wisdom, and power. Beowulf is a great example of this, the poor young eponymous hero is left alone in the woods to survive on his own and then he overcomes all of these to kill three mythological beasts, save two entire countries and live as king of a country for over fifty years of peace and prosperity. Now that in its own

Comparison: Beowulf, Grendel, and Robin Hood

1150 words - 5 pages see many examples of this in the following texts. The people from the stories demonstrate the differences and unique qualities/traits, from the brave to the evil and those with less drastic characteristics. We see an excellent example of generous helpfulness in the story Beowulf. Beowulf generously volunteers himself to attempt to kill the cruel monster Grendel who has been murdering and terrorizing the Danes. When he arrives, he loudly proclaims

Similar Essays

Analysis Of The Epic Poem, Beowulf Beowulf And Caedmon’s Hymn

2319 words - 9 pages pagan heroic life.”(Bloom 2).   The minstrels’ catechesis seems poor because their allusions to the church and to the Bible are quite indistinct, vague, indefinete. In the whole poem there is possibly one half-hearted paraphrase of a Scriptural passage, in lines 1743ff:                                       Too sound is that sleep, bound up in cares;              the killer very near who shoots his bow            with

Beowulf Essay

1243 words - 5 pages gone, Beowulf ruled in Geatland." (Beowulf; lines 2201-2206) # After a long and uneventful rule and no longer in the graces of the gods, he is driven from his kingdom where he mysteriously dies. Beowulf's rule was long, but not uneventful and poor. "Beowulf ruled in Geatland, Took the throne he'd refused, once, And held it long and well." (Beowulf; lines 2201-2203) Beowulf may not have been in good graces with the gods, however

Epic Of Beowulf Contradictory Christian Elements In Beowulf

2046 words - 8 pages (175ff)   The minstrels’ catechesis seems poor because their allusions to the church and to the Bible are quite indistinct, vague, indefinete, thus reflecting a vague knowledge of Christianity on their part. In the whole poem there is possibly one half-hearted paraphrase of a Scriptural passage, in lines 1743ff:                                                   Too sound is that sleep, bound up in cares;                    the

Beowulf And The Dragon Essay

1162 words - 5 pages to the power it holds in enrapturing the mind and the lessons that the legend contains. Critics of all sorts have reviewed Beowulf, but one in particular believes that modern heroism fall into the admiration of the traits wisdom and fortitude. However, the theory is only half correct when applying it to Beowulf, he shows poor wisdom, yet at the same time shows impeccable fortitude. To begin with, wisdom is a trait often sought after by leaders