Case: Ny V Bernhard Goetz (Assault And Murder)

966 words - 4 pages

In the case of NY v Bernhard Goetz, on December 22, 1984, a Saturday afternoon, Troy Canty, Darryl Cabey, Barry Allen, and James Ramseur boarded an IRT express subway train in the Bronx heading south toward lower Manhattan. The four young men rode together in the back section of seventh car of the train. The defendant Bernhard Goetz boarded the same subway train at 14th street in Manhattan and sat on a bench near the back section of the same car of the train as the four youths. Goetz carried an unlicensed .38 caliber pistol in his possession which was loaded with five rounds of ammunition in a waistband holster (Lender). Leaving 14th street station, the train headed towards Chambers Street. Allegedly the defendant was approached by two of the youths, presumably Canty and Allen. One of the two youths that approached Goetz, Canty, demanded, “Give me five dollars”. Goetz responded by getting up and pulling out his .38 unlicensed caliber pistol. He fired four shots striking each of the four youths and shot one of the youths, Cabey, again. The bullet severed Cabey’s spinal cord leaving him paralyzed. The rest of the youths that were struck with a bullet fully recovered from the attack.
According to the defendant he was aware that the youths did not possess any firearms or guns but was afraid based on his experience of being “maimed”. The conductor of the train , after hearing shots fired , instructed the motorman to call for emergency assistance. When the conductor went into the seventh car of the train, where the shooting took place, he saw the Goetz sitting on one of the benches while the four youths were injured lying on the floor or slumped against a seat. The defendant claimed to the conductor that the four youths were trying to rob him. Goetz fled from the scene while the conductor attended to the victims. Shortly after, the police and ambulance arrived to the scene. All the youths later recovered fully but Cabey was left paralyzed with some degree of brain damage.
Goetz surrendered himself on December 31, 1984 to police in Concord , New Hampshire. He later identified himself as the gunman responsible for the subway shootings in New York more than a week earlier. Later after surrendering himself to police and receiving the Miranda warnings, he made two statements to police. With his permission both were tape recorded. In the statements he made to police he admitted he was carrying an illegal handgun for the past 3 years in New York City. He also stated after he was injured from being mugged in the past he purchased the handgun in 1981. He admitted that he successfully, in between the past three years of possessing the weapon, protected himself against assailants just by displaying the pistol. Goetz also in his statement to police meticulously explained how he shot...

Find Another Essay On Case: NY v Bernhard Goetz (assault and murder)

UK Employment Law Case study of fighting in the workplace, citing the cases of Meyer Dunmore Ltd v Rogers (1978) and Post Office v Fennell (1981) Johnson v Marney Superstores PLC

2202 words - 9 pages dismissal without previous warning" and if this is the case this is good grounds for dismissal on the basis of conduct.The case must also have been conducted in a procedurally fair manner. In the case of British Labour Pump v Byrne (1979) the Employment Tribunal formulated the "no difference principal" and using this example even if an employer had failed to follow their own disciplinary procedures but could show that on the balance of

Ethical and legal analysis of the Ann Hopkins v. Price Waterhouse discrimination law suit. Focuses on case law and ethics

3145 words - 13 pages APPLY IN THIS CASE?-Title VII of The Civil Rights Act of 1964-Case of HISHON V. KING AND SPALDING (437 U.S. 69)-Texas Dept. of Community Affairs v. Burdine (450 U.S. 248)4. LIST OF OBSERVATIONSThe case HISHON V. KING AND SPALDING (437 U.S. 69) was a very important case with regards to this one. Specifically within the ruling the courts stated "Even if respondent is correct in its assertion that a partnership invitation is not itself an offer of

Marketing Law Case: French Perfume Manufacturer v Green Valley Cosmetics with regards to breach of Trade marks Act, passing off and business secret

1468 words - 6 pages the case of French Perfume Manufacturer v Green Valley Cosmetics, the French company must first provide that the existing goodwill or reputation associated with the label of the product is sufficient enough.a. Assumption 1: The French Company perfume has a good reputation only in the European market and very few in Australia actually know the brand.With this assumption, under the principle of Con Agra Inc v McCain Foods (Aust) Pty Ltd

In an essay response discuss how The Case of Lady Sannox, the Cask of Amontillado, Murder on the Orient Express and Playback contribute to your understanding of the crime fiction genre

1151 words - 5 pages changed to reflect the social values at the time.Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's writing is a reflection of the social attitudes and vales of time he lived. It is a product of an English environment in the Industrial Revolution and his work often had a capacity to focus on Science and technology. The case of the Lady Sannox was published in 1894, in England. The story is about a famed surgeon Douglas Stone who is having an affair with Lady Sannox. One

Brown v. the Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas was a landmark case about a little girl named Linda Carol Brown and the hardships she took on togo to a different school

1328 words - 5 pages must become desegregated. The case had been reargued several times before reaching this final conclusion from the Supreme Court which concluded that separate but equal was unacceptable ("Brown v. the Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas", and internet article). This was a unanimous ruling, racially segregating schools was intrinsically unequal. That was the best decision possible for everybody involved and everyone that it affected (Goetz, "Brown v

Autonomy v paternalism in mental health treatment, outline and review of the nys case on Jacob Gordon

2617 words - 10 pages directed to leave his home to receive medication that was given to him crushed, in an attemptto insure it's ingestion. 'Even peoples liberties in a highly controlled board and care home may bescarcely greater than in a hospital ward (Rubenstien, 1994, p.54).' In Mr. Gordon's case evenwithin the sanctity of his own home, his liberties were scarcely greater than in a hospital ward.Other than his autonomy the second issue for Mr. Gordon appears to

The Power Of Context: Heroes

1456 words - 6 pages the limits of our aspirations. A hero stands up for what is right no matter the consequences are. A hero is needed most when everyone is desperate to make a change but is afraid to. In the case of Bernhard Goetz, although some people viewed him as a criminal; many viewed him as a hero. Goetz might have unrightfully taken the law into his own hands, but he was the change that everyone was yarning for. When crime was rising and everyone had had

Duty to Retreat

1374 words - 5 pages right to stand one’s ground in the twentieth century. In 1984, Bernhard H. Goetz shot and killed four black youths which was labeled as vigilantism. Brown asserts that this was merely a case of standing one’s ground. According to the author, Goetz was justified as he had perceived a danger to himself and his belongings. Because of this American doctrine, Goetz was found not guilty of attempted murder and only charged with possession of an illegal

Minorities Say, “DUMP KOCH”: Mayor Koch and His Troubled Relationship with Minorities

893 words - 4 pages . In other instances, however, his political approach made him appear far less considerate and more apathetic towards issues involving race. In the 1985, Koch changed his stance to endorse the grand jury’s decision to decline Bernhard Goetz’s homicide charges. Goetz had shot and injured four African American men on the subway when he said they threatened him. In another instance, Koch had opposed making Martin Luther King Day a city holiday

Factors that Contribute to the Perception of Exploitability in a Relationship

1786 words - 8 pages . Goetz, C. D., Easton, J. A., & Buss, D. M. (2013). Women’s perceptions of sexual exploitability cues and their link to sexual attractiveness. Archives of Sexual Behavior. Goetz, C. D., Easton, J. A., Lewis, D. M. G., & Buss, D. M. (2012). Sexual exploitability: Observable cues and their link to sexual attraction. Evolution and Human Behavior, 33, 417-426. Haselton, M. G., Buss, D. M., Oubaid, V., & Angleitner, A. (2005). Sex, lies, and

Vigilantes: Cleaning Out The Wound

2077 words - 8 pages officials knew that Al Capone was committing horrible accounts of injustice such as bribing, extortion, embezzlement, assault, murder, bootlegging under prohibition of alcohol, racketeering, and other crimes, yet, they could not do a single thing to bring him to justice that was legal other than eventually bringing him in for tax evasion. A vigilante on the other hand, could have taken Capone down and stopped his killings and other illegal

Similar Essays

The Supreme Court And Its Effects On The Balance Of Power Between Federal And State. (Mc Cullogh V Maryland, Lochner V Ny, Nebbia V Ny) The Role Of Supreme Court In Relation To Federalism

2020 words - 8 pages . In this case, the justices took a loose reading of the Constitution and decided that the necessary and proper clause implied an expansion of power. The court decided that a state cannot tax a federal entity. Maryland has the right to tax its people, but not the entire nation. Another case was Lochner v New York, which took place in 1905 and right around the time of the Industrial Revolution. Lochner was convicted under a New York law

Stevenson's Depiction Of The Murder Of Sir Danvers Carew In The Strange Case Of Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde

1726 words - 7 pages Stevenson's Depiction of the Murder of Sir Danvers Carew in The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde Robert Louis Stevenson wrote the novel "The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde." The novel is set in the society of Victorian London and was written in 1886. The story tells of a middle-class respectable man, who's profession as a scientist one day leads him to experiment with a potion in his laboratory. He does this due

Summary And Key Notes On The Case Of Regents Of The University Of California V. Bakke

845 words - 3 pages petitioner could not take race into account in making admissions decisions, the program was held to violate the Federal and State Constitutions and Title VI. Respondent's admission was not ordered, however, for lack of proof that he would have been admitted but for the special program. A related case is DeFunis v. Odegaard (1974), in which Marco DeFunis, Jr., applied for admission as a first-year student at the University of Washington Law School

Case Note: Blackpool And Fylde Aero Club V Blackpool Borough Council

2964 words - 12 pages CONTENTS PAGE:Facts of the case.............................................................3Procedural history...........................................................4Legal issues in dispute......................................................4The decision..................................................................3Analytical Discussion of the implications for the principles of lawregarding offer and acceptance