Civility Vs Barbarity In Milton's Comus, And Shakespeare's Titus Andronicus

2022 words - 8 pages

The relationship between civilisation and barbarity is an eminent theme in the works of antiquity, whose civilisations concerned themselves with eschewing the improper mores of the barbarous. Whether it was the savant Greeks, cosmopolitan Romans, or ascetic early Christians, barbarous behaviour was considered odious, and their supposed superiority to brutes was a source of pride. But these themes, whilst contrastive, aren't categorical; rather, they're amorphous ideas, shaped by an author's use of them in the text. This essay will examine the variance in the relationships between civility and barbarity in Milton's "Comus", and Shakespeare's Titus Andronicus (abbreviated to Titus), thus establishing how these themes are malleable ones that the author can manipulate in the text. To begin, I'll establish the versions of civility and barbarity found in these texts, then I'll examine the texts apropos to several other topics, which shall further define and contrast their relationships between civility and barbarity.
In "Comus", Milton's encomium of John Egerton, barbarity is the manifestation of moral decay rather than a state of being conferred by instinct, or low birth. As one's fall into depravity is a volitional lapse, Comus must inveigle Lady into supping his potion, as he cannot foist the eldritch philtre upon her: "Be wise and taste."1 (p.65). St. Augustine propounds similar ideas regarding the voluntary aspect of corruption in City of God, which shall be addressed in relation to both texts at a later point. In a statement concatenating "Comus" and sacrilege, Achsah Guibbory writes: "Milton presents Comus' courtly revels as a false religion"2. Milton limns Comus akin to Satan in "Comus", as neither can impel the soul, and must deceive the mind and subdue the body to garner acolytes. However, if Lady and Comus represent a re-enactment of Satan's perversion of humanity, as "...'Comus' has temptation at the centre of it"3, Lady possesses boons which were absent during Eve's temptation. Christ's passion, symbolised by the "enchanted chair" (p.61), empowers Lady, and the heavenly gift of virtue vouchsafes her soul, affording her the poise to pose rejoinders which sap the Bacchanalian sorcerer's confidence (p.65).
Heaven is lauded as the acme of civilisation, and that which we should aspire to in "Comus" - even the Attendant Spirit, whose diaphanous abode lies "...where the bowed welkin slow doth bend"(p.71), and not the empyrean sphere. This insinuates that man's path to paradise requires spiritual virtue, which "...heaven itself would stoop to..."(p.71). This patent showing of human imperfection diverges from the tone of the masque, which traditionally extolled a monarch or nobleman through pomp and revelry. Milton subverts this classical form by condemning debauchery, and proffering an earnest commendation of virtue; even requesting an abeyance in festivities to do so (p.69).
Adumbrating Shakespeare's use of Roman imagery to influence the...

Find Another Essay On Civility vs Barbarity in Milton's Comus, and Shakespeare's Titus Andronicus

Titus Andronicus and Julie Taymor Essay

1344 words - 5 pages easily viewed as the audience shockingly feels a sense of amusement when Tamora is being fed a pie containing her two sons (Titus, 1999). Taymor is able to not only create a scene that is dark and eerie but is also able to encourage her audience to see the humour that lies within it. This aspect is not apparent in the original text. Although Shakespeare's play is a masterpiece, it was intended to be acted out and therefore if it is not acted and is

Theme Comparison in Titus Andronicus and Hamlet by Shakespeare

1041 words - 5 pages turned into a confident and a just avenger when he found the rational and moral reason behind his revenge of his father’s death. He was in deep love with his father unlike Titus who would kill his son and dishonor his daughter for the sake of proving himself a dedicated Roman. Just like Titus, he eventually felt that all women are untrustworthy and disgusting (Davies). Role of Children and family relationships in Titus Andronicus and Hamlet     In

Comparing the Use of Language in Titus Andronicus and Hamlet

2949 words - 12 pages Comparing the Use of Language in Titus Andronicus and Hamlet As characters of high birth and important political positions, Titus and Hamlet are necessarily observed closely by those around them for their reaction to the tragic events that have taken in place in their lives; and it is primarily the unique language with which they express their grief and anger that disconcerts both their enemies and their friends, and keeps them under an

Words and Spectacle in Shakespeare’s "Titus Andronicus" and Julie Taymore’s "Titus"

2481 words - 10 pages Shakespeare’s earliest tragedy is a play infamous for its gore and spectacular violence. Within the play there are multiple murders and lopped limbs aplenty, but the chief victim of the play – the primary spectacle – is Lavinia. Her ill fate is first conveyed to the reader through the ornate words of Marcus, and from this point on Lavinia is seen, but heard only through the words of the other characters. Indeed, in Titus Andronicus Lavinia is

Dynamic Violence The Creation and Undermining of Dichotomies in Titus Andronicus

6622 words - 26 pages Dynamic ViolenceThe Creation and Undermining of Dichotomies in Titus Andronicus1. IntroductionTitus Andronicus has, for a long time, been one of Shakespeare's most poorly regarded plays, notably for the violence and brutality with which it is filled. Indeed, the play belongs to the genre of revenge tragedies and features numerous murders, mutilations, decapitations and a rape (or two, depending on how you count). Once the cycle of revenge has

In what way might Titus Andronicus have been satisfying and pleasurable to an Elizabethan audience?

513 words - 2 pages plotting could be that Titus Andronicus was Shakespeare's first play of this genre: Revenge Tragedy. In J.A. Cuddon's 'A Dictionary of Literary Terms', the author gives this definition of revenge tragedy:"A form of tragic drama, in which someone (usually a hero or villain) rights a wrong."Titus takes the law into his own hands and tries to right a wrong. Unfortunately, he undergoes two acts of hamartia (Greek for 'error'); firstly, when he refuses

A Freudian Reading of Hamlet and Titus Andronicus

2506 words - 10 pages A Freudian Reading of Hamlet and Titus Andronicus      In 1900 the eminent Austrian psychologist Sigmund Freud produced a seminal work entitled The Interpretation of Dreams which contains the idea that dreams allow psychic exploration of the soul, that dreams contain psychological meanings which can be arrived at by interpretation. Freud states that “every dream will reveal itself as a psychological structure, full of significance, and one

Compare/contrast the ways Philip Sidney's Astrophil and Stella and Milton's Comus explore gender and sexuality

1185 words - 5 pages female sexualities. On the one hand, the authors explore male sexualities and a desire for a woman. Phillip Sidney's narrator is a lustful, musing about his chosen woman, her body and a sexual intercourse. Milton's character Comus resembles a similar character when attempting to seduce the Lady, and failing to do so because of her reason and virtue. On the other hand, the two works introduce new and progressive views on women, and their new role in

Milton's Elegy Vs. Gray's Elegy. Through The Use Of Imagery, and Pathetic Fallacy, Argues The Superiority Of Milton's Elegy

887 words - 4 pages Often, John Milton's Elegy and Thomas Gray's "Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard" have been compared. Many believe that Milton's Elegy influenced Gray's Elegy. While the two Elegies' have a lot in common, they are still very different. Using literary elements, such as imagery, tone, and the use of pathetic fallacy, this essay will show that Milton's Elegy is superior to Gray's.Imagery is very important in a poem, novel, or elegy. It allows

Civility and morality in civilization represented in The Jungle Book and showing how danger threatens society

2160 words - 9 pages at the same time using the Law of the Jungle and all of the animals to metaphorically show morality and civility in human civilization.The easiest way to see how this "civilization" is being threatened is to break it down and look at what each animal represents. As Angus Wilson put it;The chief glory of [Kipling's] art in the Mowgli stories lies in his extraordinary combination of the natural and animal world with the world of the humans. Baloo

The Characters Of Samson And Dalila in Milton's Samson Agonistes

2618 words - 10 pages The Characters Of Samson And Dalila in Milton's Samson Agonistes      The character of Dalila is first described by Samson, in his opening dialogue with the Chorus, as "that specious Monster, my accomplish'd snare." He also later describes her as "fallacious, unclean, unchaste". Thus when she finally appears in person, the reader is perhaps surprised to hear the Chorus uses a simile of a pulchritudinous ship to describe Dalila, "so

Similar Essays

Illustrate Shakespeare's Understanding Of Stagecraft In Titus Andronicus Act I

887 words - 4 pages acknowledge this. Tamora says that they should all be friends. This adds to the irony of the act to produce a feeling of pity or sorrow for Titus. Lavinia is invited to a feast with Tamora (this could mean another murder) and Saturninus invites Titus to go hunting (another murderous possibility). The act ends on an edge; this shows a good handling of stagecraft: leaving the audience in suspense.Overall, Shakespeare's handling of stagecraft is patchy; it is good, or even excellent, in some places and terrible in others. Titus Andronicus was Shakespeare's first Revenge Tragedy, so his stagecraft is as good as can be expected.

Shakespeare's Titus Andronicus A Powerful Tragedy

1686 words - 7 pages exchange and he comments to that effect in an aside, immediately followed by laughter (III. I. 201-02). The hand is delivered to the Emperor but is rebuked and returned with the heads of Quintus and Martius, Titus's sons. This very grisly display is only one of the numerous gruesome acts in the play. Titus Andronicus is by far the goriest of Shakespeare's plays. Although there are over a dozen lurid acts either implied or presented on the stage, it

Shakespeare's "Titus Andronicus." Black Comedy For A Dark Era

679 words - 3 pages The most successful of Shakespeare's plays during his time and, in modern day, the most dismissed and controversial, "Titus Andronicus" provides its audience with an intimate and powerfully shocking view of what was considered humorous in the Elizabethan age. Shakespeare use of humour in this play depicts how the people of this violent time dealt with the day-to-day tragedy of living.During the Elizabethan age, people were well accustomed to

Misogyny. This Essay Is About Misogyny In Shakespeare's Titus Andronicus. It Cites Quotes And Passages From The Play. It Also Includes A Bibliography

1287 words - 5 pages punished as if her crimes were of the worst nature, when in fact her only crime was being a woman. Her genetic makeup ultimately decided her most unfortunate destiny. The reason that Shakespeare mocked women so enthusiastically is because women were inferior in his own lifestyle, and that was the mindset of the viewers of his plays. In any case, his play Titus Andronicus holds strong views about retribution of women and especially those in