Compare And Contrast Of Stephen Jay Gould And Richard Dawkins´S Points Of View On Science And Religion

1254 words - 6 pages

There are different viewpoints on the question “what is the universe made of?” I think that both science and religion offer their own explanation to this topic and they sometimes overlap, which creates contradictions. Therefore, I do not agree with Stephen Jay Gould’s non-overlapping magisterial, which claims that there is a fine line separating science from religion. That being said, I think the conflict between science and religion is only in the study of evolution. It is possible for a scientist to be religious if he is not studying evolution, because science is very broad and it has various studies. In this essay, I will talk about the conflict between religion and science by comparing the arguments from Stephen Jay Gould and Richard Dawkins. I argue that science and religion do overlap but only in some area concerning evolution and the cosmic design. Furthermore, when these overlaps are present it means that there are conflicts and one must choose between science and religion.
First, I will demonstrate Stephen Jay Gould’s argument against the overlapping between science and religion, which is as follows:
“The lack of conflict between science and religion arises from a lack of overlap between their respective domains of professional expertise—science in the empirical constitution of the universe, and religion in the search for proper ethical values and the spiritual meaning of our lives. The attainment of wisdom in a full life requires extensive attention to both domains—for a great book tells us that the truth can make us free and that we will live in optimal harmony with our fellows when we learn to do justly, love mercy, and walk humbly.”
Stephen Jay Gould demonstrates his claim that both religion and science can co-exist; he calls this the non-overlapping magisterial. He believes that together they can offer a greater knowledge because religion provides something that science lacks and vice versa. A person can look to science, which focuses on the facts, to understand more about the mechanism of the universe, at the same time, he or she can explore religious beliefs, which focus on moral values, to develop a true sense of right and wrong. Gould explains that these two aspects will result in a person, who is free from ignorance and is grounded by humility. In his argument, Gould seems to only concern with the overlapping between science and Christianity. He defends his non-overlapping magisterial with the claim that “creationism based on biblical literalism makes little sense in either Catholicism or Judaism for neither religion maintains any extensive tradition for reading the Bible as literal truth rather than illuminating literature, based partly on metaphor and allegory (essential components of all good writing) and demanding interpretation for proper understanding.” However, Gould’s non-overlapping magisterial would not hold with other religions that take the biblical stories literally. Hence, there is a conflict with the study of...

Find Another Essay On Compare and Contrast of Stephen Jay Gould and Richard Dawkins´s Points of View on Science and Religion

"Testimony before the U.S. Senate, 1883" and "The Political Economy of Seventy-three Million Dollars, 1882," to compare and contrast the two different view points

1759 words - 7 pages Gould v. LloydAre government regulations really needed in the late 1800's to stabilize industrialization or is "control by the government...contrary to our institution..?" To better describe the long time feud between ideas, we will be using two documents titled "Testimony before the U.S. Senate, 1883" and "The Political Economy of Seventy-three Million Dollars, 1882," to compare and contrast the two different view points of industrialization

compare and contrast between Nick Carraway and jay gatsby

2856 words - 12 pages out our arms still further… And one fine morning ---So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.” An additional disimilarity between the two types of hero is in what they acknowledge is real. Nick Carrawy and Jay Gatsby view two dissimlar realities . Gatsby ‘s reality is naturally of a hero of romance. The daily life is unreal for him; reality is what he has found as a result of his dreams. Whereas, the

A Wonderfull Life by Stephen Jay Gould

2296 words - 9 pages This was a Book report. I kinda BS'd it. But I got an A. Very GoodName: Wonderful LifeDate: 1989Publisher: W. W. Norton and Company, Inc.Pages: 322 (Not including Bibliography and Index)This book written by Stephen Jay Gould is about the concepts of evolution based on the findings in the Burgess Shale that was found in Yoho National Park in British Columbia, Canada. The organisms that were found here at first by C.D. Walcott in the early 1908-09

The Pandas Thumb -- Stephen Jay Gould

704 words - 3 pages of the many exciting facts held within the pages of this publication. Gould is able to put what he writes about in words that are easy to understand without compromising the quality of the information. Many questions are raised in this book. Some questions that science just can’t answer at the moment. Time is a major theme in some of the essays in The Panda’s Thumb. I found these essays of utmost interest. Stephen Jay Gould writes as if you were

Compare and Contrast Religion in Two Works

1933 words - 8 pages Religion is sold to the masses daily. In 1925 it was sold to the masses in the form of printed material by Bruce Barton. In 1960 it was sold to the masses by way of a film entitled Elmer Gantry. Bruce Barton sold a different idea of Jesus than most people were familiar with. In the film, Elmer Gantry sold religion with bravado and arrogance which was not the typical way of selling religion either. In each work, religion is being sold but

How does Galileo view the issue of religion and science? How does he resolve the tension between religion and science?

1127 words - 5 pages Kingdom with love. It does not answer questions related to scientific discoveries. We are supposed to use our own senses to interpret those observations and findings.Descartes's view of religion was similar to that of Galileo in the sense that there should not be a conflict between religion and science. The Humanistic Tradition says,"Descarte identified God with 'the mathematical order of nature'. The ideathat God did not interfere with the laws

Compare and contrast natural science and social science

2230 words - 9 pages approaches be chosen when conducing social science research and natural sciences? This is another baffling question. Now we will turn to the discussion of deduction and induction.Philosophically the approaches are focused on the consideration of induction and deduction, as well as the relationship between approaches and sciences. Deduction entails the development of a conceptual and theoretical structure prior to its testing through empirical

Compare and Contrast: Mr. Darcy of Austen´s Pride and Prejudice and Heathcliff of Bronte´s Wuthering Heights

793 words - 3 pages had rich fathers who died later in life. The difference is, Mr. Heathcliff was born a gypsy and was on the streets until Mr. Earnshaw took him in as a son. Mr. Darcy on the other hand was born as a rich boy who was never on the streets. Mr. Darcy and Mr. Heathcliff were in a wealthy family but Mr. Heathcliff was not wealthy for long until later on. Mr. Darcy no matter what was accepted into his family but as for Mr. Heathcliff he was not accepted

A Compare and Contrast of Thomas Moores Utopia and Machiavelli?s The Prince

1468 words - 6 pages then the Utopian society, although this society was more viable. They had what it took to last, to grow and to flourish.      Both societies have there good points and both societies have their flaws. More imagined a new society, even though it still carried some remnants of the one he knew. And the Utopian society looked great on paper; they were very just and honorable people. But when examined in depth it falls apart

Compare and contrast two social science views about the ordering of social life.

1611 words - 7 pages day. Both the theorists looked at the small scale of society, the people. But Foucault looked at the macro scale too, to again prove his point of knowledge and power playing a part in creating social order. Both Erving Goffman and Michel Foucault make very valid and very interesting points through their arguments, but because Goffman only focuses on the individual, he fails to see the bigger picture, giving him quite a narrow and small view of

Compare and contrast the view that ‘An Arrest’ is a tale of nature

1422 words - 6 pages Compare and contrast the view that An Arrest is a tale of nature rejecting a human villain with the view that it is concerned only with a vengeful superego ‘An Arrest’ is an ambiguous story. You can look at it in different ways. One way to see it is as a tale of nature rejecting a human villain. This view is put forward right from the beginning. When the narrator uses words such as “confined” and “fugitive” to describe the state of

Similar Essays

Certainty And Memory In Stephen Jay Gould´S Essay: Some Encounters Of A Mental Mind

1019 words - 5 pages In Stephen Jay Gould’s essay, “Some close encounters of a mental kind,” Gould discussed about how certainty can be both blessing and dangerous. According to Gould, certainty can be blessing because it can provide warmth, comfort and secure. However, it can also be a danger because it can trick our mind with false information of what we see and remember in our mind. Gould also talked about the three levels of possible error in direct visual

Freud And C.S Lewis: Opposite Points Of View On Religion

1252 words - 5 pages Two great men, two exact opposite points of view, when it comes to the question of a master creator. These two men would have a profound effect on the life that we live today. Freud who was born to an orthodox Jewish family in the mid 1800’s was born into a lower class family his father was in the wool trade. The collapse of the family business moved him and his family to a Vienna, Ghetto. Freud would later become the voice of science in a

Stephen Jay Gould Nonmoral Nature Essay

1126 words - 5 pages ;                                                 Works Cited Blackford, Russel. “Stephen Jay Gould on Science and Religion.” Quadrant Magazine 2000.     http://www.users.bigpond.com

A Compare And Contrast Of Ibsen And Strindberg And Their View On Women

843 words - 3 pages Ibsen and Strindberg are two playwrights of the same period, the Industrial Revolution. This is a time when the world is making a great change in how it runs. Not only is business changing, the way people think is changing too. People are beginning to question the ways of society. For an example, questions are arising on how women should really be treated. Such notions give way to very controversial theatre. Ibsen and Strindberg strongly