Conscientious Objections To Same Sex Marriage Essay

1616 words - 7 pages

Research Topic: Conscientious Objections to Same-Sex Marriage: A Comparative Research Study of Scotland in United Kingdom and State of New York City in United States of America
Part A: Methods of Research:
The research on conscientious objection to same-sex marriage was carried out using mostly primary sources such as Scotland and State of New York Laws, this include constitution and laws enacted by the New York State Assembly and Scottish Parliament. Also past cases and accompanying judicial opinions issued by courts such as McClintock v. Department of Constitutional Affairs were also used to reach conclusions. From most of the court ruling, I got exposed to arguments and authoritative facts about the research topic.
The research also made use of secondary sources such as Legal encyclopaedias, Treatises Legal periodicals; Practice materials and domestic relations lecture notes. These materials were helpful and constituted a good source of citations.
Through random internet searches, I was also able to access links such as the New York State Assembly Marriage Equality Act A8354-2011, from where I deducted most of the data that informed the position of my research findings.

Part B: Comparison between Scots law and the law of New York City
This research is set to undertake a comparative study of rule (statutory or common law) setting out whether a person authorised to conduct marriages may refuse to do so (without breaching equality legislation) in the case of marriages between same-sex couples – in Scots law and New York City In the United States of America.
Scotland
The Scottish Parliament on 20th of November passed stage one reading of the Bill that seeks to allow same sex couples to marry. While the full passage of the bill is still in progress, it is worth to recall that existing Scottish law under the Civil Partnership Act 2004 designate marriage under religious believe as exclusive rights of opposite sex couples and recognises same sex relationship only under Civil Partnership . The distinctive difference between the aforesaid two relationships is that while the opposite-sex couples can choose to have a religious or civil marriage, the same sex couples are restricted only to civil partnership consummated under civil procedure with no religious celebrant (only district registrars).

Under the Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act 2004, it is an offence to refuse to record civil partnership proceedings . The Act vividly entrench that a civil partnership registrar commits an offence if he refuses or fails to comply with the provisions of the Chapter or any other regulations made under section 36 of the Act . The Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act further stipulate that a civil partnership registrar if found guilty or indicted of an offence under subsection (1) of the 2004 Civil Partnership Act will be liable to a jail term not exceeding two years, a fine, or in most cases both punishment will apply and that such a person on conviction...

Find Another Essay On Conscientious Objections to Same-Sex Marriage

same sex marriage Essay

615 words - 3 pages Same sex marriage Same sex marriage has become one of the most controversial debates in today’s world. The debate cut across to all members of the society from human right activists, religion, political leaders, to common citizens. Various reasons have been used as the foundations of same sex debate. Some of which are religious beliefs and cultural practices. Different people argue differently with some arguing for while others against

Legalizing Same Sex Marriage Essay

1560 words - 7 pages In 1996, then Senate hopeful Barack Obama wrote “I favor legalizing same-sex marriages, and would fight efforts to prohibit such marriages” (Weinger). The timing of the statement could be directly related to then President Bill Clinton signing into law DOMA, or the Defense Against Marriage Act, initiated by Congress in a bold move that “prevented the federal government from recognizing any marriages between gay or lesbian couples for the purpose

Same Sex Marriage

1023 words - 5 pages Should same sex marriage be legal over the United States? Well yes, why you ask because people have the right to marry whomever they want regardless of same sex marriage or opposite sex marriage, which if two people love each other they spend their life with each other, or marry each other. Although same sex marriage is considered as a disgrace throughout the United States. Same sex marriage can be a benefit towards society, which can boost self

Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage

1293 words - 5 pages Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage All couples in a committed loving relationship should be legally allowed to marry. United States marriage concepts have been changing in conjunction with society’s evolving culture. Traditional concepts assigning marital duties based on gender no longer apply, strengthening the effectiveness of the marriage in today’s world. Society is actively moving towards becoming a culture of contributing individuals who have

Same Sex Marriage

949 words - 4 pages Marriage should be about the love two individuals share, not what gender they are. Most people believe marriage should be between a man and a woman; however society has changed over the years. For a variety of reasons, same sex marriage should be legal in the United States, because every individual should be treated equally and be able to share a life together with the rights and responsibilities of a married couple. “Opponents of same-sex

Same-Sex Marriage

543 words - 2 pages Same-Sex Marriage Should be AllowedA few weeks ago, the famous singer Elton John got married to a man he was dating for twelve years. Many famous people anticipated his wedding ceremony, and it was broadcaste over a worldwide hookup. Nowadays, same-sex marriage was allowed in some countries and many people understand homosexual. However, the issue of same-sex marriage is still a controversial one. Same-sex marriage rights groups insist that it

Same Sex Marriage

1246 words - 5 pages is individual freedom’s ‘decisive blow’ because it destroys the last communal restraint: traditional marriage” (Devine). Even with people’s disapproval to gay marriage, there are others who are strongly for it. Same sex marriages are able to benefit the society in many ways such as political, economical and even socially. Society’s overall viewpoint of same-sex marriage has evolved throughout time socially from negative reasons to positive

Legalizing Same Sex Marriage

1253 words - 6 pages particularly unfair form is sexual discrimination which a same sex couple is not able to be married like a heterosexual couple. Slowly, this form of discrimination is becoming illegal which has caused much dispute. Even though there is debate about it, same sex marriage should become legalized because it deserves the same rights as heterosexual marriages. The idea of same sex marriage began when a court case in the early 1970s in Wyoming was tried

same sex marriage

3364 words - 13 pages AbstractSame-sex marriage has been around since the reign of Egypt, found in historical Egyptian artifacts. Over time, the practice began to become frowned upon, mainly due to the cause of Christianity. Stereotypes began to form, and hindered the social reputation of LGBTs. As individuals formed enormous feelings towards each other, but were of the same sex, laws were created to prevent them from the ability to marry. The United States, was

Same Sex Marriage Debate

913 words - 4 pages The gay marriage debate is complex, to say the least. Bitter, emotional, and controversial are just a few words that can be used to describe it. In 2004, Massachusetts became the first state to legalize same sex marriage; since then twelve states have approved gay marriage (Shapiro). Even though some states have decided to legalize same sex marriage others are standing firm on constitutional amendments that ban it. Deciding whether or not gay

Same-sex Marriage

1738 words - 7 pages “I'm not for gay marriage, but I'm not for discriminating against people” (Eskridge 1425). During the late twentieth century, activities involving homosexual relations increased. Lately, it is common to encounter a person who is attracted to a person of the same gender. The marriage between couples of the opposite sex became one of the most controversial conflicts that the United States, and the entire world, has to deal with. There are cases

Similar Essays

Expanding Marriage To Same Sex Couples Essay

2751 words - 11 pages marriage is erroneous and how the government cannot endorse recognition of plural marriage as it adversely effects civil society. Next, I will show why the expansion of marriage to same sex couples is the best public policy decision and finally address the objections to same sex marriage and how it does not hurt the institution of marriage but rather enhances it. The expansion of marriage to include same sex couples seems to be an essential

The Right To Same Sex Marriage

1524 words - 7 pages Gay Rights Gay people are criticized in many ways by many people depending on where there live and where they come from. “But same sex marriage is a reality; it’s here to stay and it will eventually become the law of the land”, said Sue Hyde (Hyde). We have come a long way since the first state legalized same-sex marriage; however; we still have a long ways to go (SV; conj. adv. SV). The Gay Rights Movement has been growing a lot lately, but

Say Yes To Same Sex Marriage Essay

840 words - 4 pages it really because they are not seen as normal human beings, that they are freaks of nature? This is surely not the case. Homosexuals are regular people, just like you and me. Even Michelangelo, one of the most admired and honored artists of all time, was gay (“Michelangelo”). Knowing this, same-sex marriage should be legalized nationwide. For many homosexual couples, the main reason that fuels their desire to be officially recognized as a

Same Sex Marriage Essay

600 words - 2 pages causing problems in their society growing up.Legal endorsement of same-sex marriage would be confusing to the institution ofmarriage. Marriage is a social institution of a long term relationship between man and woman.Marriage is fundamentally about children, love between man and woman, and the civilization ofsociety. Marriage is an institution that much of the culture revolves around in the environment,The history of our nation has demonstrated