Constitutional Questions Essay

813 words - 4 pages

Yes, the Constitutional Convention of 1787 was essential to preserve the Union, as the Articles of Confederation did a meager job establishing a stable America. Only a handful of people from the entire nation were pleased with the issues addressed in the Articles of Confederation. This document didn’t unite the nation, but created more differences among the people. The Articles of Confederation failed to properly allocate power between Congress and the states, giving the states supreme control, rather than Congress. This unbalance in society left each individual state on their own, besides the alliances they could form within each other (creating even more rifts within the country). The Congress didn’t hold the power to tax or create a national military, navy, and army, which didn’t allow America to strengthen as a nation. By vesting these powers in the state, the Articles of Confederation technically created thirteen small countries. After the Revolution, the United States became even more susceptible to foreign invaders and if a minute state militia was responsible for warding off these trespassers, the state would be easily attacked. This is just once consequence that could have occurred, if the Constitution of 1787 wasn’t accepted.
The Constitution bestowed essential powers to the nation, without which, America would crumble. Under this newly created document, three different branches of government were created: the judiciary, the legislative, and the executive. The legislative was composed of Congress, which now had the power to create a military, control interstate and international commerce, and create laws. The Judicial branch was the Supreme Court, which would review the decision of the President (in the executive branch). Through this system, one person making a decision that would tremendously impact the nation in a negative manner was prevented. The Constitution managed the power of people, states, and government well compared the Articles of Confederation. What came out of the Constitutional Convention, proved to be the nation’s greatest strength when coping with issues with slaves, different sized states, and Congress. If Constitutional Convention was not called, the Constitution would not be implemented within the country, increasing state power and divide. The fall of the Union would have been inevitable ude the Articles of Confederation.

d) Why was the question of representation such an important issue to the delegates at the Constitutional Convention of 1787 and what led to them to...

Find Another Essay On Constitutional Questions

Morality in the Judicial Process Essay

2221 words - 9 pages Justices must by necessity implicitly or explicitly consider questions of wisdom, justice, social harm and morality when deciding if a statute is unconstitutional. They should ensure that all these considerations are rooted in constitutional principles and constitutional questions. Society should not imagine these considerations are not present in judicial reasoning, nor should justices be ruled by them. The questions justices properly ask when

Canada and Quebec's Conflict Essay

2581 words - 10 pages referendum on the issue with 49% of the votes. With this narrow victory the federal government whipped into action and passed a bill through the house of commons that recognized Quebec as a distinct society and gave the province a type of constitutional veto to convince Quebec that Canada is a great place to live. The federal government also asked the Supreme Court of Canada to decide on three questions pertaining to the legal and constitutional

Describe the constitutional crisis of 1975, and the fall of the Witlam government

1036 words - 4 pages cause any disruption in the services of government; it saw the parties remaining committed to the political and constitutional process. Both parties campaigned for the election and accepted the result. Though it did lead to a constitutional change passed by referendum in 1977 to require that State Parliaments appoint a member of the same party to replace a retiring or a dead Senator1975 also raises questions about the governor-generals reserve

Abortion a Moral Choice or Leg

680 words - 3 pages Abortion a Moral Choice or Legislative Decision Should it be a woman's constitutional right to have an abortion? Who ought to decide if abortions should be legal-congress, state legislature, the woman, her husband, or some religious leader? (Milbauer3). The issue of abortion has been a constant struggle since ancient times. Abortion is not a contemporary issue. Historically both tribal and civilized societies have used a variety of

The Privilage by Journalists to Resist Criminal Process

1751 words - 8 pages 1261, 1266 (10th Cir. 2009). Whether the First Amendment or the federal common law recognizes a qualified privilege by journalists to resist criminal process is a pure question of law. The Tenth Circuit reviews purely legal questions de novo. See In re Grand Jury Subpoenas, 906 F.2d 1485, 1488 (10th Cir. 1990). A. The District Court Correctly Recognized a Qualified Reporter’s Privilege Arising under the First Amendment That Protects Against

Democracy, Liberalism, and Canadian Federalism

1656 words - 7 pages this, they believed that the best check on government power in a federal system would be the constitutional protection of the division of powers. They relate this to liberty through the argument that the more difficult it is to monopolize political power, the harder it would be to for an individual, or group to enforce their political upon the nation. More specialized, and independent branches of government would mean greater, divided

Seeking a Just Judiciary

1092 words - 5 pages history of its development would be in order. Almost two hundred years ago, in 1820, Thomas Jefferson became one of the first persons to mention the danger posed by judicial overreach. In a letter to William Jarvis, he said that “You seem…to consider the judges as the ultimate arbiters of all constitutional questions; a very dangerous doctrine indeed, and one which would place us under the despotism of an oligarchy. Our judges are as honest as other

A Critical Review of Peter H. Russell's Essay "Can the Canadians be a Sovereign People?"

1075 words - 4 pages problem with it though, is that "not all Canadians have consented to form a single people in which a majority or some special majority have a right to act and conclude the rest" It is difficult to create a nation state and have sovereignty when a defined nation is not present. Canadians differences on fundamental political questions and collective identity present a continuous problem for Canadian sovereignty.Russell argues that there was not a trace

The Prevelence of Assisted Suicide

662 words - 3 pages prolong life and all recognize the right of competent patients to refuse medical treatment. 7. 95% of cancer pain is controllable and the remaining 5% can be reduced to a tolerable level. 8. The states of California, Washington, Michigan and Maine rejected ballot referenda questions to legalize physician-assisted suicide in their respective states. The Supreme Court of Alaska in Alaska v. Sampson declared there is no state constitutional right to physician-assisted suicide, as did the Florida State Supreme Court in McIver v. Kirscher. The Hawaii State Senate voted down a bill to legalize physician-assisted suicide.

History - Federalist versus Anti-Federalist

688 words - 3 pages abandoned for want of energy. He also went on to inform the Federalist that if the ratification for a Constitution were passed the new government may protect, but it also may ruin the people. The Anti-Federalist raised many questions which were said to have a crucial affect on the Federalist writings since those writings provided answers to the allegations of the Anti-Federalists (Bollinger). The periodic and contemporary constitutional debates over

constitutional law

1066 words - 4 pages Constitutional Law Marbury v. Madison      Marbury v. Madison, one of the first Supreme Court cases asserting the power of judicial review, is an effective argument for this power; however, it lacks direct textual basis for the decision. Marshall managed to get away with this deficiency because of the silence on many issues and the vague wording of the Constitution. During the early testing period when few precedents

Similar Essays

Madison Vs. Jefferson: On The Issue Of Constitutional Conflict In The Federalist Papers

1398 words - 6 pages " (Madison, No. 49 312). That is, by trying to resolve constitutional questions by appealing to the people, the executive and judiciary branches of government, being relatively small and disconnected from the people, would be at a distinct disadvantage to the legislature.To substantiate the previous claim, Madison elaborates on his reasoning. He explains the legislature as being made-up of numerous members spread throughout country, each having

Constitutional Convention Essay

1457 words - 6 pages should be convened to revise the Article of Confederation (Constitutional Rights Foundation, 2009). Congress felt the Article of Confederation was not enough to effectively deal with the young nations issues. Congress knew it was time for the country to move forward, and to do that, there would be some big changes ahead, and that was the end of the Articles of Confederation, and the beginning of the created US Constitution. Reasons for the

Quebec Secession Essay

2565 words - 11 pages , and prevented a constitutional crisis that may have occurred in the political sphere without the reference case. In analyzing the use of reference questions from the perspective of federalism, I intend to argue that the reference mechanism, although far from perfect, has proven to be an instrumental deterent to political crisis. The court, acting as a mediator, is able to prodive guidance, hpw legitimate that guidance is, further expanded the

The Constitution's Accommodation Of Social Change

2337 words - 9 pages resources - despite a recorded decline in global poverty rates (Bhattacharyya: 2005). 2. Against this bleak landscape, it is unsurprising that realising sustainable development continues to date to be a key priority in policy making processes these cases. In Africa, like elsewhere across the global south for instance, economic drivers of development have shaped constitutional reform processes as policy makers increasingly see constitutions as a