Content Versus Method Essay

1079 words - 5 pages

Content Versus Method
In “Conspiracy Theories 101” by Stanley Fish, he writes about the meaning of academic freedom and applies it to the topic of professor Kevin Barrett's lecture of a conspiracy theory, taken place at University of Wisconsin at Madison. Fish explains that Barrett should have the academic freedom to teach his lecture on conspiracy theories about 9/11 as long as the topic is brought up for “academic interrogation and analysis.” Fish also demonstrates a distinction of being academically responsible and irresponsible. Discussed is also the study of a subject such as astrology and how as long as a subjects “structure, history, influence, and so forth” is brought up in the ...view middle of the document...

Even a subject such as cocaine can be studied in an academic setting according to Fish's definition of academic freedom.
If a professor wanted to lecture or even teach a complete class on cocaine, he could following the structure of academic freedom that Fish discusses. The subject of cocaine's actual and factual history, chemical structure, effects, and even opinions of users and non-users can be brought to the class discussion. If these things are taught carefully with no push, or agenda to get the students to be advocates or against cocaine; then the teacher will have accurately taught about cocaine according to Fish's definition.
If Patrick Farrel or Barrett's critics were to apply academic freedom to the study of cocaine, the outcome of the class would be different. Barrett's critics would probably argue that cocaine should not even be an academic subject, lecture, topic, or class, because “academic freedom has limits.” Farrell, would most likely want to be reassured that more than just 1 view point are brought up in the content of the class. Both of these definition differ from Fish's take on academic freedom as he mentions the importance of analysis of the topic rather than points of view as he mentions in paragraph 13, “The true statement is that no matter how many (or few) views are presented to the students, they should be offered as objects of analysis rather than as candidates for allegiance.”
Fish's definition of academic freedom can also be applied to a subject such as astrology. Astrology is usually a topic thought of having to do more with your daily horoscope on facebook rather than being an academic subject, which would again most likely not be considered a real academic topic by some. But, when applying Fish's definition you could lecture this topic or teach a class on many famous opinions on the subject, such as mentioned in paragraph 8 about Nancy Regan or Shakespeare. As long the teacher of the class does not have a hidden agenda to convert the students into the belief of or complete abandonment of the idea, then the subject would be in line of Academic Freedom. Things like the...

Find Another Essay On Content Versus Method

Computer Security, Defines encryption and explain how it is used to protect transmission of information

886 words - 4 pages 1Encryption is method of scrambling data in some manner during transmission. In periods of war, the use of encryption becomes paramount so those messages are not intercepted by the opposing forces. There are a number of different ways to protect data during transmission, such as Substitution (character for character replacement) in which one unit (usually character) of cipher text (unintelligible text or signals produced through an encryption

Communication Essay

640 words - 3 pages identify what the client is actually saying. Low context communication is the opposite, whereas the client may place greater importance of meaning on exact content messages. To illustrate this point, Sue & Sue depicted twins who use high context communication, versus the opposite, two lawyers during trial (Sue & Sue, 2012). The counselor’s nonverbal cues of proxemics and kinesthetics in The Impact of Diversity, communicated several aversions


643 words - 3 pages . Pseudoscience versus Real Science Argument The purpose of the article was to highlight the human and environmental harms associated with UNICOR e-waste recycling programs and to call for restorative environmental justice. Wikipedia defines restorative justice as “a model of justice that directly targets retributive criminal (in) justice systems” (“Restorative Justice”, n.d.). The article seeks to shed light in the way UNICOR dissemble and


1755 words - 7 pages microbes can persist in the compost environment and even their spores, if spread, can promulgate inside the human body. The spores spread easily from the compost source and probable chances are their dispersion when the compost is mixed, transported, shifted or stored. Microbial content can be assessed by the ATP content, the enzymatic activity assays, viable count of microbial biota and is followed by identification through density gradient gel

Intercultural Communication Paper

870 words - 3 pages Class: COMB254-001 Student ID: S-B01996-1 Name: Lao Chi Kio (Jojo)Intercultural Communication PaperIn this paper, I will summarize and evaluate Hofstede's published research in 1996: Gender stereotypes and partner preferences of Asian women in masculine and feminine cultures.In his research, Hofstede (1996) demonstrated the high significance of Masculinity versus Femininity (Mas/Fem), as one of the five cultural dimensions. According to Fred E

Research Proposal

1221 words - 5 pages accounting for nursing staff. Tempting as this may seem, this method presents a massive dilemma to providing safe quality care. Less staff coupled with large patient workloads will lead to adverse patient outcomes such as increased hospital acquired infections (HAI) which cost hospitals between $35 to $45 billion dollars annually to treat. Evidence shows that it is more cost effective to maintain safe staffing levels and prevent HAI's versus the

Design and Evaluation of DSP Based Differential Relay of Power Transformer

2409 words - 10 pages inrush current and the internal fault is based on the theory of harmonic analysis. The behavior of the presented relay has been simulated versus various situations (inrush current, internal fault and external fault). The obtained results shows that the proposed algorithm provides a good discrimination and a fast action. Index Terms— Algorithm, Differential, DSP, Digital, power transformer, harmonic analysis. I. INTRODUCTION ONE of the most

The Internet and User Content

1131 words - 5 pages remedies in various drafts, so I join my colleagues in criticizing the bills.” The author never goes on to state what these draconian methods are. He assumes that the reader will accept his word that the legislation deals with this issue using the mentioned method. In a way, this can be considered a bandwagon fallacy, in that we're supposed to accept that because he and his colleagues think the bill uses draconion methods, it does in fact use them

The Christian Worldview

1456 words - 6 pages . Knowledge via rationalism involves logical reasoning. It is the combination of stating precise ideas (often in the form of syllogism), applying logical rules, and making logical conclusions based on the ideas. The problem is when the syllogism’s content or either premises is false. The knowledge is not based on the content, but on the logical manner it is presented. Knowledge via empiricism involves gaining knowledge through objective

Caledonia Products

1229 words - 5 pages company to keep capital that could be used for other debts or purchases (Brandenburg, 2008). References Brandenburg, Jeff, 2008. Equipment Lease versus Buy considerations. Retrieved March 8, 2008 from, online source:

New Criticism

1811 words - 7 pages Criticism was so influential that for many teachers in North America and Britain, it became not a method of criticism, but criticism itself and alternatives to its interpretive strategies have until recently been regarded with deep suspicion. The New Criticism asserts that every text is autonomous. History, biography, sociology, psychology, author's intention and reader's private experience are irrelevant. William Wimsatt and

Similar Essays

Acceptance And Commitment Therapy Versus Cognitive Therapy For The Treatment Of Comorbid Eating Pathology

579 words - 3 pages Acceptance and Commitment Therapy versus Cognitive Therapy for the Treatment of Comorbid Eating Pathology Critiquing a Scientific Article Introduction This article aims to prove that Acceptance and Commitment is the best method for treating eating disorders. Although Cognitive Behavior Therapy has shown some promising results. It supports this claim by stating that Cognitive Therapy is an effective treatment for bulimia and was given a grade A

The Effectiveness Of Inquiry Based Techniques In Place Of Explicit Instruction

2414 words - 10 pages . During the interviews, documentation will note any discussions that indicate the students’ application of inquiry skills, correctly answering content standards questions, and any misconceptions regarding the content. The results of the overall student understanding of the engineering concepts and their use of inquiry skills will determine which instructional method is most effective. Review of the Literature Science in elementary schools is

Marketing Research Tools Essay

931 words - 4 pages Marketing Research Tools This paper will help demonstrate the differences between different marketing research tools. Three means of data collection for market research are quantitative, qualitative, and pluralistic (Burns & Bush, 2006). Qualitative research allows probing questions on small groups, yet obtains more feedback (McDaniel & Gates, 2007). The moderator or interviewer generally has special skills to deliver the content using

Chemical Analysis On Winemaking

3720 words - 15 pages is proportional and related to alcohol production. The Extended Experimental Investigation also suggested other relationships which could be investigated. These include the relationship of specific gravity versus alcohol content and reducing sugar; and also suggesting that pH is related to oxidation. Further study can be carried out to hypothesize these suggested research questions outlined by the results.During the process of performing these