Criticism Of Moll Flanders Essay

1381 words - 6 pages

Criticism of Moll Flanders

      How should readers interpret the seeming contradictory character that Daniel Defoe presents in Moll Flanders?  Is her penitence a construction of irony?  While the question of irony was prominent in the earlier criticism of the 1950s and 1960s, most scholars have moved away from that question, acknowledging the existence of various types of irony and validating the true reformation of Moll.  Critics are now articulating other subtle and complex authorial strategies in Moll Flanders besides the use of irony, crediting Defoe with more of what it takes to be a "father of the novel."  Newer critical methodologies involving class and gender are also playing a role in establishing Defoe as advocate of social change. 

 

            Unfortunately, critics dealing with Moll Flanders lack as yet a truly definitive text from which to work.  The best one can do is to stay with texts founded on the first 1722 edition.  Texts taken from later editions, the second and third and later, may be abridged, and scholars have persuasively argued that such editions do not reflect Defoe's intentions or revisions.  Despite the short-comings in textual scholarship on the novel, recent years have seen no dearth of literary criticism.

 

            Defoe as innovative developer of narrative technique in the novel is a considerable topic of conversation in critical circles.  No longer are we hearing complaints about artificially connected, episodic writing and plot inconsistencies.  Ian Watt notes a "lack of co-ordination between the different aspects of [Defoe's] narrative purpose" (118) in "Moll Flanders•, as well as denying a conscious and consistent employment of irony, but he also praises Defoe for narrative successes in the creation of scenes and the development of the theme of individualism.  Others have followed Watt's laud for Defoe's technique, uncovering additional complexities in his contribution to the genre of novel.  David Blewett finds Defoe's work much more unified along several lines, addressing the incorporation of complex ironies that challenge stable society in such areas as family relations and marriage.  Overall, he attributes careful narrative planning to Defoe.        In the exploration of Defoe's narrative strategies, critics such as Maximillian E. Novak, Paula R. Backscheider, and Lincoln B. Faller are illuminating the dimensions of his language.  In his "Realism, Myth, and History in Defoe's Fiction•, Novak points out patterns of wordplay and double entendre that convey subtle meanings and notes manipulations of tense that enable curious blending of past and present.  Faller coins the term "trialogue" in recognizing a dialogue involving two characters and the audience present in "Moll Flanders• and "•rarely occurring in other literature of Defoe's contemporaries.  In the critical study, "Moll Flanders:  The Making of a Criminal Mind•,  Backscheider calls attention to elements of Defoe's prose...

Find Another Essay On Criticism of Moll Flanders

Discuss the role of place and setting in texts on your course. Shelley's "Frankenstein", Woolf's "Mrs. Dalloway", and Defoe's "Moll Flanders"

3209 words - 13 pages chosen to study the three following novels: Shelley's "Frankenstein", Woolf's "Mrs. Dalloway", and Defoe's "Moll Flanders".Places and setting play an important role in Shelley's "Frankenstein" as they are what give life to it; places and settings are the reasons of many of the happenings in this novel.One of the first important setting in Shelley's "Frankenstein is 'The Arctic Circle'. The story of Frankenstein is told at a great distance, both

Consider how Daniel Defoe's 'Moll Flanders' presents and discusses the social role of women

1682 words - 7 pages continually throughout his work. In his novel Defoe represents the reality of this patriarchal society through the life of Moll, achieving intense moments of naturalism that give the reader a clear sense of the daily anxieties attendant to the economic and social uncertainties experienced by a female of that era. Through this essay I am going to analyse how Defoe represents and examines the social role of women within the context of the era in which

Moll Flanders by Danile Defoe

1032 words - 4 pages Moll Flanders By: Daniel Defoe Book ReviewThe Fortunes and Misfortunes of the Famous Moll Flanders written by Daniel Defoe, is a very attention-grabbing novel, because Defoe presents his novel as a struggle to live in a society. The female protagonist in the novel, Moll Flanders, went through a number of events in her life. She leaves behind the importance of woman's social stability and financial security. Flanders is born in Newgate and during

Greed, vanity, and repentance in "Moll Flanders" by Daniel Defoe

1147 words - 5 pages Three recurring themes in Moll Flanders by Daniel Defoe are greed, vanity, and repentance. Theme is defined as an underlying or essential subject of artistic representation. These three themes play an important role in the development of the story of Moll Flanders.The first theme, greed, is shown in Moll's acts of prostitution. Moll turns to thievery in many instances to support herself. She also allows her morals to disintegrate; a result of

Moll Flanders

799 words - 4 pages A Portrait of a Criminal Daniel Defoe's Moll Flanders paints the perfect portrait of a criminal. The novel illustrates all the steps that Moll goes through on her way to becoming a master thief. Moll's future is determined the instant she is born. She is born with greed instilled upon her. Then she learns how to manipulate others. Later, in her teens, she develops vanity. After the loss of her first love, she develops a cold heart. Then when she

"Moll flanders" by Amber Romanowski

848 words - 3 pages their husbands died. Which is why Moll Flanders had to resort to a life of crime after she no longer looked good enough to make a living as a whore. This all, eventually, led to her imprisonment and trip to America to live happily with her husband.Moll Flanders chose her life as a prostitute. She states on page 138: "Well, let her life have been the way it would then, it was certain that my life was very uneasy to me; for I liv'd, as I have said, but

Moll Flanders and Colonel Jack

1035 words - 4 pages Jessica DoddProfessorMoll Flanders and Colonel JackDaniel Defoe presents in Moll Flanders and Colonel Jack insight that allows us to examine eighteenth century criminal behaviors. Moll Flanders provides the understanding of the classified life of the thieving industry from which Moll has mastered incessantly through her shortcomings and identification issues. Colonel Jack establishes a view into the creative mind of an eighteenth century young

Authenticity in Eighteenth- Century Crime Narratives

1084 words - 5 pages failure to attend church or certain lifestyles such as prostitution and stealing out of necessity could lead to a more extreme life of crime. When examining Daniel Defoe’s novel, Moll Flanders and “The Account of the Tryal, Condemnation and Execution of Mary Goodenough” we must consider the authenticity of the crimes, criminals, narrator and the reason of publication to get a true understanding of each narrative. Moll Flanders is a novel that

Moll flanders 2

744 words - 3 pages " Moll Flanders " Many questions arise when one talks about Moll Flanders. Who was born in Newgate, was a whore for twelve years, was a wife five times, was a thief for twelve years, eight years a transported felon in Virginia. Through hard and long discussions, many questions about Moll Flanders were answered but one of the toughest and hardest questions still remains. Is Moll Flanders penitent? Moll Flanders, who gets separated from her

Prison Realizations

1284 words - 6 pages , while other texts enable a realization of a society as a whole, but regardless some sort of realization is met. Some texts in particular that successfully do this are De Profundis, Moll Flanders, and “The Ballad of Reading Gaol”. First of all, in De Profundis by Oscar Wilde a self realization is met by the prisoner and author, Oscar Wilde. De Profundis was written in 1897 in prison over a course of three months. It is basically a letter from Wilde

Moll Flanders and Her World

1283 words - 5 pages that she might as well settle for a good man, than follow a man for love that will never treat her as anything more than a secret lover. From Robin she recieved a better life, financial security for the time being, the older brother offered her nothing but heartbreak.The many adventures of Ms. Moll Flanders had an ultimate affect on her personal changes and the choices she made. As time went on she became more and more cynical towards the idea of

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Moll Flanders

1418 words - 6 pages The novel is telling a real experience of Moll Flanders about her entire life in 18th century in London and in America. She spends her whole life to become a gentlewoman by getting wealthy and trying to achieve a high social status. On the path she was pursuing those; she has to give up so many things; including love, self-respect, religion, and peace of mind, and all the decisions that she had made were just in order to satisfied her vanity and

An Excerpt Of Moll Flanders, As Written By A Woman

934 words - 4 pages An Excerpt of Moll Flanders, As Written by a Woman In response to a comment made in class one day last week, I have taken it upon myself to rewrite a passage of Moll Flanders in the only way a woman can write. I have hereby turned a certain portion of the novel into an excerpt of a mushy love story, because I am a woman and it has been stated that I am only capable of writing in this form. When my lover, the one and only light of

Daniel Defoe's "Moll Flanders", Is Her Repentance At The End Of The Novel Genuine?

1055 words - 4 pages The repentance of Moll in 'Moll Flanders' by Daniel Defoe, and the subsequent question surrounding the sincerity thereof, is a complex and widely debated subject. In many ways the journey that Moll travels is highly similar to the misfortunes and life that Daniel Defoe himself lived. In writing Moll Flanders, he is in many ways trying to find his own version of repentance. However in trying to persuade us of the mitigating circumstances and

Crime In The Fortunes & Misfortunes Of The Famous Moll Flanders By Daniel Defoes

1219 words - 5 pages ​Crime has been something that has plagued us as a species since we started walking the Earth. Although it didn’t create a face for itself until the Eighteenth-Century when there became a split in economic identity, as well as a separation in gender. In Daniel Defoe’s “The Fortunes & Misfortunes of the Famous Moll Flanders,” the central female character, is driven by a lust to rise above what she has been born into, but through a series of