Diversity In Education Essay

2350 words - 10 pages

White savior mentality” is the perception of some white pre-service teachers, that they are going to be able to come into a classroom and save the “helpless” students of color from dropping out of school. Several pre-service teachers believe that they can help a child of color succeed in school because they, as a white teacher, are helping that student learn. As we all know, all children learn in different ways and sometimes it takes some extra help from a tutor or a teacher for the student to reach their full potential or understanding of the concept or lesson, but the pre- service teachers that Sherry Marx interviewed seemed to think otherwise. They believed that because they were tutoring Latino students, the students needed to be saved.
Some pre-service teachers like the tutors Sherry Marx interviewed in her book, Revealing the Invisible, “have a strong desire to ‘help’ children who are less fortunate than themselves” (Marx, pg. 40). This sent a red flag to me; they seem to have the belief that children of color are not as smart as children who are white, meaning that the children of color need more help. No student should ever be treated differently because of their background. I am a strong believer in the idea that what is on the inside is what counts! As pre-service teachers we need to put our thought of helping the “helpless” to the side and focus on education our future generation. They are not “helpless”, everyone has the ability to achieve anything they want and their teachers need to help mold them into great learners so they can achieve those dreams and goals without worrying about being perceived differently because of the color of their skin.
These tutors believe that once they help these students, they will be seen as the saviors of these students. They are taking the student’s race and making it out to be that because the student is Black or Latino, they need help. With the tutors treating the students with a lower standard based on their race, the students feel like they do not matter to them because the tutors are not treating them with equity and equality like the white students. The tutors are treating the Latino students differently than they would treat white students, because the tutors are basing the Latino students’ abilities based off their race.
The second concept discussed was deficit thinking. Deficit thinking is the practice of holding lower expectations to those students whose backgrounds do not fit into the traditional context of the school. This means teachers who judge students’ intelligence by the color of their skin, their class, or even their cultural background.
Like previously mentioned, the tutors Sherry Marx interviewed, viewed themselves as “saviors” and “have a strong desire to ‘help’ children who are less fortunate than themselves” (Marx, pg. 40). This is deficit thinking on these tutors part, because they have the mindset that since these are Latino students, they automatically do not understand...

Find Another Essay On Diversity in Education

Diversity and Its Role in Society and Education

2873 words - 11 pages its citizens enrich the nation. The importance and occurrence of diversity in American society especially in the education system has changed dramatically over the past 50 years. During the 1950’s the definition of diversity was drawn strictly along racial lines. The implementation and existence of segregation policies not only embodied social attitudes, but it also ensured that the majority controlled all aspects of life. However, with the

A Small Consolation Battling against Diversity in Higher Education

1489 words - 6 pages historically rooted in our national life can be broken by diversity experiences in higher education." The courts are recognizing this also. According to the latest rulings, as long as the decision process did not employ strict racial quotas, colleges can choose to accept whomever they want. Condoleezza Rice, said on NBC's "Meet the Press" that "it is important to take race into consideration, if you must" to achieve diversity within a school.Racial

Explain why cultural diversity is important in a college education

767 words - 3 pages my children. Why?Because I would have played in the sandbox at kindergarten with someone not likeme, cheered on a squad where not all have the same ethnic roots, and exchangedmath notes with a fascinating foreign exchange student.Cultural diversity is not important in a college education, it is vital. No otherplace is more ideal than college ke of success, everyone would unlearn theprejudices taught to them, and learn of What we need here is not the arrogance ofpower, but the cooperation of everyone to learn and to be open-minded.

The Education of" Little Tree" by Forrest Carter. Discussing diversity issues in the book, The Education of Little Tree

1015 words - 4 pages , I will expound upon some of the diversity issues that Little Tree encountered.Title: Exploring Diversity Issues Encountered by Little Tree in his Quest for Knowledge.In the book, The Education of Little Tree, grandparents of a five-year-old, Native-American boy informally adopted their grandson after his parents passed away in 1930. They affectionately called him Little Tree. He was a very naïve and impressionable, little boy who treasured

Diversity of Education

1834 words - 7 pages Diversity of Education Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. once stated, “Most…think that education should equip them with the proper instruments of exploitation so that they can forever trample over the masses. Still others think that education should furnish them with noble ends rather than means to an end.” What Dr. King was getting at in The Purpose of Education is that education holds many different values for many different people. How can

Improving Education through Cultural Diversity

1068 words - 4 pages In today’s society, cultural diversity is important as it was many centuries ago. According to dictionary, cultural diversity is the coexistence of different culture, ethnic, race, gender in one specific unit. In order, for America to be successful, our world must be a multicultural world. This existence starts within our learning facilities where our students and children are educated. This thesis is “changing the way America, sees education

Early Childhood Education Diversity Case Study

1854 words - 7 pages diversity. I am deeply saddened that both Tom and his parents first encounter in a learning environment is tarnished by a negative experience. Issues Relating to Discriminatory Practices There are quite a few issues identified in the case study, the focus here emphasizes the importance of recognizing, addressing, and providing acceptable practice. The teacher reveals that the school is a faith school and Tom will have to cut his hair in order to be

The Meaning of Diversity Among the Professorate—A Literature Review

671 words - 3 pages The Meaning of Diversity Among the Professorate—A Literature Review Different aspects of diversity in higher education are an ongoing topic of debate. In order for us to address the issue of diversity, we need to understand what diversity means. This paper reviews a study used at the University of Florida to assess their faculty’s meaning of diversity. It also looked at the faculty’s openness to diversity and the effect diversity has had on

Debate Surrounding Affirmative Action

890 words - 4 pages of how a more diverse workforce contributes to the bottom line" (p. 96). Gilbert and Ivancevich go on to note that diversity training and education does little to improve diversity management in the organization. As such, a successful diversity management organization will embed the process of diversity as part of its strategic objectives for the organization. In short, without diversity the organization will be unable to succeed.In addition to

Value of Diversity in the Workplace

841 words - 3 pages The world's increasing globalization requires more interaction among people from diverse cultures, beliefs, and backgrounds than ever before (Green, Lopez, Wysocki, Kepner, 2009). Past businesses had a hard time with diversification in the workplace. Workplace diversity refers to the variety of differences between people in an organization (Greenberg, 2004). Diversity encounters race, education, ethnic groups and more. Capitalizing on diversity

Diversity in the Workplace

932 words - 4 pages Diversity in the workplace encompasses much more than the topic of race. There is also diversity in age, education and gender. The matter of race is what is most often thought of when diversity in the workplace is the topic. There are a number of companies that have been identified by Fortune as the “Best Companies for Minorities.” These companies have been deemed successful for a variety of reasons, including leadership, recruitment

Similar Essays

Diversity In Higher Education Essay

2460 words - 10 pages treated equally? Two recent Supreme Court cases involving non-minority students filing suit regarding being denied admission to two universities are the 2003 case of Grutter v. Bollinger (539 U.S. 306) and the 2012 case of Fisher v. University of Texas (570 U.S.). In both these cases the non-minority students were not admitted to the universities involved due to the Supreme Court finding that “…diversity in higher education is a compelling state

Diversity In Early Education Essay

1841 words - 7 pages opportunities. While completely integrating diversity into classrooms is a challenge due to differences in cultural behavior, and misconceived notions of diversity education, there are many studies which are benefiting multiculturalism and strategies created by these programs to create a truly globalized and united world. Stereotypes with Professionals When interacting with people from other cultures, there are many barriers that a teacher has to

Cultural Diversity In Education Essay

1793 words - 7 pages forum. Formal public schoolinstruction in cultural diversity was rare, and appreciation or celebration of minority or ethnicculture essentially was nonexistent in most schools. In the 1930's, the educators were in theprogressive education movement, called for programs of cultural diversity that encouragedethnic and minority students to study their heritage's. This movement became popular in manyschools until around 1950. Now, these days in education

Diversity And Multicultural Education In The Classroom

1698 words - 7 pages Introduction There are many factors that play a role in the learning process for every human being. Race, religion, language, socioeconomics, gender, family structure, and disabilities can all affect the ways in which we learn. Educators must take special measures in the delivery of classroom instruction to celebrate the learning and cultural differences of each of their students. As communities and schools continue to grow in diversity