Dr. Haviland’s A Silence That Kills And Florence King’s I’d Rather Smoke Than Kiss

1267 words - 5 pages

Do you smoke? Such a question has been asked to most people at one time or another. The topic of smoking certainly requires a thorough analysis, whether you smoke or not. It’s also an issue which seems to polarize people. In this reading we’ll compare contrasting viewpoints by two different individuals. As I present the arguments, I’ll dissect them to truly understand their inner-workings. Both Dr. Haviland and King touch on many subjects yet seem to ignore others. I think a balance must be struck when it comes to smoking, both through individual rights and a social responsibility.
“I’d Rather Smoke than Kiss.” is Florence King’s very astute retort to anti-smokers. In this writing she advocates for smoking as a simple enjoyable thing to do. To emphasize this she recalls her first smoking experience, which is for the most part very normal and unexciting. However, this inconsequential account is not indicative of the rest of the story. King quickly switches gears as she goes on the attack. In the first section she labels hatred of smokers as a form of misanthropy which she goes on to say is “the most popular form of closet misanthropy in America today” (King 32). This perspective is further augmented by the fact that she considers second-hand smoke an invention; a means for the “Passive Americans” (King 32), to justify prejudice towards smokers.
As she moves into the second section, she begins to document the hostility shown to smokers. Through her own personal interactions or through examples she views in newspaper articles. King really focuses on the subject of public perception, and while some of the examples validate her perspective, others do not. We see this in her response to a Washington Post article, in which she states that “the whole article has a die-damn-you undertow” (King 32). This perspective is perhaps a bit over the top and only serves to polarize her views, thereby alienating some readers.
This is compounded by the next section with the peculiar title of” Health Nazis.” In it she likens the public service ads against smoking to political propaganda. Nevertheless, she touches on some strong points in regards to public perception and the media’s control over it. As we move to the final section, she begins to draw interesting parallels. She compares the attack on smokers as a form of class warfare, and even goes so far as to allude to racism in the last paragraph. Indeed, she goes on to say that hatred against smokers is meant to “identify and punish the undesirables among us” (King 32). An attack by what she thinks of as the politically correct and self-righteous who happen to be going after black people, white working class people, 18-35 year old females, ethnic people, older people, middle aged women, or just about damn near everybody. Still, King’s essay draws up some very fundamental points which despite its radical views, must not be ignored. These are the individual right to do as you please to your...

Find Another Essay On Dr. Haviland’s A Silence That Kills and Florence King’s I’d Rather Smoke than Kiss

If You Read You Will Judge is a research paper that was composed on Kurt Cobain's musical talent and acheivements rather than his suicide

882 words - 4 pages protected than Lennon's or Hendrix's" (Wener, K4273) Many of Cobain's fans and critics rush bookstores to buy his journals in hopes to read between the lines and know what Cobain was really thinking.Even before his death fans spent countless hours trying to read between the lines of his lyrics. It was like trying to put one puzzle together that was in a stack of a thousand other puzzles. You just couldn't find pieces that both matched colors and fit

Assess the view that Leni Riefenstahl was documenting history rather than creating propaganda

2977 words - 12 pages promotion, however, it is evident that at this time she had not known the effects of the ideology presented in her films on German life. The view that Leni Riefenstahl was documenting history rather than creating propaganda is not one-sided. It cannot be said that she was doing one or the other because through her documenting history and recording what was in front of her, in what she saw was a groundbreaking artistic way, she created propaganda

Examine the contention that urban policy should focus on places rather than people

1571 words - 6 pages regeneration. She believed that rather than helping the people, you need to first help the economy and so, took an economic focus, and she concentrated on the place rather than the people. It wasn't until 1990 when John Major took over, that the policy changed again to a hybrid of the periods of urban policy. He introduced a socio-economic policy, concentrating not just on the economy or the social aspects but also on how the effect one another and how

This is a speech directed to the audience of the 2003 Academy Awards arguing that feature films are made for money, rather than entertainment

1058 words - 4 pages person out there who knows him or herself better than a four page glossy article printed in the latest trashy tabloid."Now tell me, truthfully, was that entertaining? Was it fun to sit there and be criticized? No, of course it wasn't. Whilst I myself do not believe a word of what I have just said, we all know there are many who do. I could have stood behind this podium tonight and showered you all with compliments and accolades. I could have

Explain Peter Singer’s argument that there is no morally significant difference between Bob, who decides to let a child die rather than sacrifice

859 words - 4 pages Singer aims to establish charitable giving as a moral obligation of those who posses more money than that which is needed to meet basic living costs. He concocts a thought experiment with an apparent conclusion that strongly favours altruistic behaviour, and uses this to affirm his belief that everyone should give away absolutely everything that they can afford to. He relates the choice of not giving to charity as being comparable in moral

Discuss the view that consolidation rather than expansion was the prime objective of Roman foreign policy between 69 and 211 A.D

1850 words - 7 pages Discuss the view that consolidation rather than expansion was the prime objective of Roman foreign policy between 69 and 211 A.DFrom studying Roman frontier policy, it seems clear that the image of the Roman army as great conquerors, sweeping through vast areas of the known ancient world, is a view which is probably more typical of the period of Augustus' reign rather then any subsequent long-term expansion policies of any of the later emperors

"The difference between medieval and early modern is one of degree rather than strict demarcation." Discuss this idea in the context of any two writers you have read.(Everyman and Dr Faustus)

2428 words - 10 pages Franciscan friar, as Faustus comments "That holy shape becomes a devil best," illustrating an air of contempt for the Catholic clergy. He further associates Catholicism with evil and devilry as he conjures Mephostophilis by chanting in Latin, the language of the Catholic Church. This mockery of Catholicism may be testament to contemporary social attitudes rather than the personal view of Marlowe himself. In the medieval era, it was highly uncommon for

"Anti-Vietnam Movement" I had a couple of fragment and run-on senteces, but other than that my professor, Dr. Durand (University of Maryland), said i did an outstanding job

2644 words - 11 pages failure and a complete mistake. I believe that the war was acted out for political will rather than military might and we should have never been involved with that war in any form. I believe over 58,000 men lost their lives for absolutely nothing and to have anti-Vietnam organizations with strong will and determination, as they showed us back in the 60's and 70's, gives this country a free democracy. The people coming together to put pressure on the

Catcher in the Rye Theme:Human beings are advised not to judge books by their covers, rather that they should look further than the obvious and try to apprehend the implied meaning

1892 words - 8 pages Catcher in the Rye's pallid cover, adorned only with seven multicolored bands in its upper-left corner, is not what one would call eye-catching. Its reverse side lacks criticisms or reviews of any sort; in fact, it is bare of anything except a copyright date. Human beings are advised not to judge books by their covers, rather that they should look further than the obvious and try to apprehend the implied meaning. The world has peered past

Explore the features of the language used in digital communications which suggest that they are closer to spoken rather than written language. Com

2120 words - 9 pages feeling anxious about what to say as they are discussing their own personal life; which can be hard. Another element of spoken language that has made its way into digital communication are pauses which is also an example of a non-fluency feature and is spontaneous so therefore suggests that online language is closer to spoken rather than written language. In post 2 of Text G, the person posting says, ‘I loved the special effects . . . and that kiss

Does the Rape Shield law support Nesson's View that verdicts are to instill confidence in the public rather than maximizing the truth

1297 words - 5 pages the prior rape law, the admission of evidence of a woman's sexual history was not limited to cases where the defendant himself knew his victim's reputation or history. If the defendant finds out that his victim was sexually experienced he could and would try to hide behind that fact at trial.The rape shield laws promote public confidence in verdicts since women are not judged on their sexual history but rather about the event that took place

Similar Essays

Why Do People Loathe Smokers? A Response To Florence King A Response To "I'd Rather Smoke Than Kiss"

1134 words - 5 pages Project. 16 Dec. 2000King, Florence. "I'D Rather Smoke Than Kiss." National Review (July 9, 1990):32, 34-36.Rpt. in The Allyn And Bacon Guide to Writing. John D. Ramage, John C. Bean, and June Johnson. 3rd ed. New York: Longman, 2003. 109-112."Smoking statistics: Who smokes how much." Factsheet no:1 2001 Ash. May. 1999

Consider The Arguments Both For And Against The Contention That Gender Is A Product Of Nurture Rather Than Nature

2014 words - 8 pages Consider the arguments both for and against the contention that gender is a product of nurture rather than natureSociologists use the term sex when referring to biological differences between male and female bodies whereas gender is used to explain the social construction of masculinity and femininity. The distinction between sex and gender is important as many differences between males and females are not just biological. The predominant

Evaluating The View That Poverty Is Caused By Economic Inequality Rather Than Cultural Attitudes And Lifestyles

2000 words - 8 pages . He argued that the welfare state has created an underclass of poor people who are lazy and prefer to live off the state rather than work. By Underclass, Murray means a significant and self reproducing group, who form a distinctive bottom element of the class structure in UK and US societies, he did accept that there are poor people who are poor through no fault of their own and his analysis of the USA differed from the

Essay On Machiavelli's, The Prince: How It Is Better To Be A Leader That Is Feared And Not Hated, Rather Than Loved

1851 words - 7 pages to a question that is in dispute: Is it better to be loved than feared, or vice versa?" (Machiavelli, 51) An effective ruler would be one that relies upon fear without hatred, rather than love, as described by Niccolo Machiavelli in his book The Prince.In a perfect world all people would be good-hearted, all would treat each other equally, and all would follow and respect the rules of society. Machiavelli points out that people tend to focus how