Evaluating The Effectiveness Of Qualitative, Quantitative And Mixed Methods When Applied To Mental Health Counseling

5317 words - 21 pages

There are currently strong differences of opinion among counselor educators and practitioners about what aspects of counseling are included in the term mental health counseling. These differences, which seem to become more pronounced each year, may be the natural process of the evolution of counseling (we.e., the exact nature of the analysis is evolving and dynamic, so definitions change over time). Rather than working toward a consensual view, however, we see the counseling analysis dividing and building confusing and wasteful duplicate structures as counseling professionals cling to different definitions and terms that no longer represent the field accurately. Two examples of duplicate structures are In the areas of credentials and accreditation. We have two credentialing boards, the National Board of Certified Counselors and the National Academy of Certified Clinical Mental Health Counselors. Likewise the current accreditation standards of the Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related Educational Programs(CACREP, 2008) contain two different sets of standards for a program that prepares counselors to work in data gathering settings. The program can select to apply for accreditation in either community counseling or mental health counseling (see Spruill & Fong, 2000, for a more detailed discussion of this problem). Regardless of individual perspectives, however, when the term mental health counseling is used we have found counselor educators in general think of counseling that is provided in community (data gathering) agencies.As counseling seeks recognition among the helping counseling, it behooves us to understand and use the generally accepted definitions of mental health. The term mental health implies a dynamic continuum that is not only the absence of abnormality but also a state of well-being (Winett, King, & Altman, 2009). Summarizing definitions of mental health, Altrocchi (2000) stated that mental health is an ideal conception, the precise definition of which varies among mental health professionals. He noted that most definitions encompass the positive qualities of the development of identity, achievement of competence in work, and a striving for self-actualization as well as absence of abnormal behavior.Thus, the term mental health covers a broad continuum of states of the mind from well-being to distress. Therefore, when "mental health" is used to modify words such as professional or services, it denotes a professional scope or a continuum of services that is developmental, environmental, and ecological, as well as remedial. In contrast, the terms psychiatric, clinical, and mental disorder are used to connote services limited in scope to persons with maladaptive behaviors or mental illness.Illustrative of the contemporary scope of activities considered mental health services, Winett, King, and Altman (2009) described necessary mental health services in their integrative psychology textbook. They emphasized...

Find Another Essay On Evaluating the Effectiveness of Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods When Applied To Mental Health Counseling

Qualitative and Quantitative Research Methods Essay

1709 words - 7 pages In this paper, I will define quantitative and qualitative research methods and provide examples in the context of social issues which will hopefully provide insight into how this methods are properly applied. Social issues are very broad and diverse and are usually made up of factors or consequences which directly or indirectly affect a person or many members of a society and are considered to be problems, controversies or both and are

If you wanted to examine young people’s experiences of homelessness, would you use qualitative methods, or quantitative methods, or a mixed method

965 words - 4 pages is the most common definition used in Australia, as this is what the government use to identify the homeless (ABS 2006). When examining young people’s experiences of homelessness either a qualitative methods, quantitative methods or mixed methods approach must be taken. Qualitative methods approach is an alternative to the positivist paradigm is used as the basis for the study, words are considered the elements of data, a primarily inductive

If you wanted to examine young people's experiences of homelessness, would you use qualitative methods, or quantitative methods, or a mixed method

821 words - 4 pages population. The mixed methods approach employs both qualitative and quantitative methods in the same project (Sarantakos 2013, p. 50). Mixing these two approaches does not alter the structure of the two methodologies (Sarantakos 2013, p. 50). Mixed methods approaches are undertaken to research from any relevant perspective, and utilises any applicable previous research (Sarantakos 2013, p. 50). A mixed method approach provides a comprehensive and in

Differences in Qualitative and Quantitative Research methods for business

662 words - 3 pages There are two different methods for collecting data. There is Qualitative Research and Quantitative Research. Let's come up with some ideas on how to perform each method and brainstorm on different tools we can use. We will need to be aware of the pros and cons attached to each method as well. To get the conversation started here are my ideas and suggestions.First, I wanted to point out the differences in these methods. Qualitative research is

Mental Health Counseling

915 words - 4 pages appropriately within their practice. Established and new theories play an important and constant role in mental health counseling. Established theories in mental health counseling are based on “empirical or scientific foundations” (American Counseling Association, 2005). The best way to gain the most beneficial application of a theory is to establish its validity and purpose. If we look at any professional field, it will be obvious that each

Explaining the effectiveness of current treatments for mental health conditions using existing models and hypotheses

1359 words - 6 pages All treatments for mental health conditions are based on hypotheses that seek to explain their aetiology. These tend to be reductionist models approaching the problem from one dimension of the biopsychosocial paradigm. Unsurprisingly this approach is far from effective. Four models and therapies will be described and evidence that offers support or otherwise will be discussed. It will then be concluded that to improve therapy success rates a

When Mental Health Helps Mental Health: The features of an Effective counselor

1042 words - 5 pages When Mental Health Helps Mental Health: The features of an Effective counselor Introduction It is known that Therapeutic counseling is an important tool for the treatment, prevention and promotion of mental health. The psychotherapeutic method contains variables that influence the progress of the emotional state of an individual. Although the techniques and methods are components of the treatment, yet there still not a robot or machine to

Nursing Care as Applied to a Client with a Mental Health Problem

4715 words - 19 pages An extended essay demonstrating the candidate’s ability to evaluate how the application of theoretical knowledge gained during the course influences and effects the provision of quality nursing care as applied to a client with a mental health problem. The aim of this assignment is to explore the application of theory to practice with regards to a client with a mental health problem. In order to effectively care for

The Meaning of Quantitative and Qualitative Research

1227 words - 5 pages are different than the normal results. Researchers don’t use them in quantitative research because they are too complicated to account for and then put them in the research. The data is based off of the results falling into the normal category. Qualitative research’s main focus is to grasp an individual’s lived experiences, through their emotions, mental processes and behavior (Guts, 2014). Qualitative research studies subjective human

When people who can't cope with mental health their academic performance goes down, therefore their marks suffer

989 words - 4 pages demonstrate the correlation between not coping with mental health, and few other things. Thus, students suffer academically because of it. The methods that Dr. Hartley used are called “hierarchal or sequential regression analysis.” These methods that were used to record if their was any correlation between mental health and the GPA of students. The conclusion that Dr. Hartley reached is that because of the significance of college academics their

Qualitative and Quantitative Research

1648 words - 7 pages Introduction This essay aims to cover two main focus points. The first section of this essay will take an in depth look at the major differences between two research methods – Qualitative and Quantitative. I will explore when and why they are used for specific types of research and how they apply to some types of work more effectively. The second area for this essay will be based around the research question- what factors contribute to you

Similar Essays

Quantitative, Qualitative, And Mixed Research Methods

2197 words - 9 pages Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Research Methods Introduction This paper will discuss the approaches that can be used to conduct quantitative, qualitative and mixed method research that is based on a problem statement and a purpose statement that have been developed to study the adoption of sales force automation technology. This paper will also provide the advantages and disadvantages of quantitative, qualitative and mixed method

Quantitative And Qualitative Methods Essay

983 words - 4 pages   Contents 1.0 Introduction 2 2.0 Research methodology 2 Data types 2.1 3 Measuring Data 2.2 3 Graphical Data 2.3 3 Empirical research methods 2.4 3 Quantitative Methods 3.0 3 Qualitative Methods 3.1 3 Bibliography 4 1.0 Introduction I have been asked to produce a report which critically evaluates a wide variation of methodologies and how they can be applied to a given scenario. In this report I am going to be analyzing the usefulness of

Quantitative And Qualitative Methods Essay

1119 words - 4 pages (b) Data Collection Mixed methods research was conducted, where both qualitative and quantitative research were conducted. Such a method is beneficial as both methods can complement each other and fill the gaps that may be present if only one method had been used, thus allowing for a better grasp of the situation present. Despite its advantages, concerns have been raised about the possible dilution of research effort as resources have to be

Characteristics Of Qualitative And Quantitative Methods

937 words - 4 pages Qualitative and quantitative researcher’s exhibited conflicting ways of approaching a research. Some researchers prefer qualitative over quantitative and vice-versa. Also, it is common for qualitative and quantitative to be used together in a research. But, both methods when carried out correctly provide good research. Plus, both methods have their own unique differences and characteristics. In this paper I will define three of these