Female Genital Mutilation: Why Legislation Is Not Enough.

4368 words - 17 pages

In the context of the current Western Australian debate on criminalising female genital mutilation, I argue that specific legislation prohibiting the procedure will in itself be insufficient in eradicating the process. To effectively combat FGM it is important to understand the underlying gender assumptions and cultural representations that inform the practice. Instead of using legislative reform, education leading to social and cultural reform will be more effective. Although various education schemes are currently in place, these have not achieved the desired result either. A shift in focus from viewing female genital mutilation as purely a women's medical issue to dealing with it within its cultural context as an issue that is influenced by men as well, is likely to be more successful.I begin by exploring what Female Genital mutilation actually is by looking at the types of FGM which occur and the terminology used to most appropriately describe it. I go on to interrogate the reasons cited for the continuation of the practice of FGM to reveal the underlying gender assumptions and power imbalances beneath the practice. I follow by looking at the desirability of the use of specific legislation in Western Australia to combat the practice and conclude that legislation alone is problematic and specific legislation is undesirable. I then examine the current education schemes in place and identify their limitations, I conclude by suggesting changes to the current education scheme which allow a more culturally sensitive approach and will therefore lead to more effective results.WHAT IS FGM?The World Health Organisation (WHO) defines female genital mutilation as `all procedures involving partial or total removal of the female external genitalia or other injury to the female genital organs whether for cultural or other non-therapeutic reasons. It is estimated worldwide 130 million girls and women are already circumcised and at leat 2 million a year are at risk.TYPESTogether with the definition, WHO has also produced a standardised classification system of four different kinds of FGM. The first involves removal of the prepuce (clitoral hood), sometimes together with part or the entire clitoris; in the second, the clitoris and prepuce are removed, together with part or all of the labia minora. These two are the most common forms of FGM, making up around 80% of instances. The third type, commonly referred to as infibulation, is the most extreme and comprises about 15% of instances. It involves removal of part or all of the external genitalia and stitching/narrowing of the vaginal opening.TERMINOLOGYIn light of the variations that exist within the practice itself, it is important to assess the appropriateness of the term Female Genital Mutilation. The term FGM was first used by feminists, human rights activists and women's groups. It was formally adopted by the International African Committee on Traditional and Harmful Practices meeting in Addis Ababa 1987...

Find Another Essay On Female Genital Mutilation: Why Legislation is not Enough.

Female Genital Mutilation Essay

1912 words - 8 pages States and other industrialized countries in North America and Europe. Female genital mutilation (FGM) is an umbrella term for three subtypes of crimes committed against women as a part of various coming of age rituals for young girls in certain patriarchal communities in Africa, spreading through migration of a populace through Northeastern and Western Africa and some spread into the Middle Eastern countries. These communities integrated this

Female Genital Mutilation Essay

1364 words - 5 pages A quite different type of surgery required by some cultures is known variously as female circumcision, female genital surgery, or female genital mutilation (FGM). The custom involves removal of some or all of a woman's external genitalia. The practice has existed for thousands of years and approximately 85 to 114 million women in the world have been circumcised. The practice is prevalent in Africa and the Middle East, but has also been

Female Genital Mutilation

4779 words - 19 pages female genitalia or other injury to the female genital organs whether for cultural or other non-therapeutic reasons. Female circumcision is another term for the procedure as well. Part I: History & Types of Female Genital Mutilation Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) has been an ongoing worldwide debate. Awareness as well as legislative activity have had an incredible amount of benefiting effect. However, it's been around for so long that

Female Genital Mutilation

1710 words - 7 pages story of FGM and the consequences it has brought to her life. b. At age five, she underwent the procedure that would affect her for the rest of her life. II. FGM, female genital mutilation has been practiced for thousands of years in African and Middle Eastern Nations. a. There are three types of FGM. The most common is the total excision of all external genitalia and stitching of the vaginal opening. b. This causes severe physical and

Female Genital Mutilation

1835 words - 7 pages - about one every 15 seconds. (1) Although Female Genital Mutilation predates Islam and is not practiced by the majority of Muslims, it has acquired this religious dimension. However, FGM is a cross-cultural and cross-religious ritual. In Africa and the Middle East it is performed by Muslims, Coptic Christians, members of various indigenous groups, Protestants, and Catholics; to name a few. The type of mutilation practiced, the age at which it

Female Genital Mutilation

896 words - 4 pages mental scars for the rest of their lives. Female genital mutilation (FGM) is the partial or complete removal of the external female genitals for cultural rather than medical reasons. Other names for FGM include female circumcision or ritual female surgery. It is performed in some African, South American, Asian and Middle Eastern countries. Mutilation is a cultural rather than a religious practice, and its origins are unknown. Usually, it is

FGM, Female Genital Mutilation

517 words - 2 pages Female genital mutilation has been practiced in country's around the world for thousands of years, and will continue to be practiced, until those that practice it decide to stop.Many people who live in country's that are more industrialized, like the U.S.A., tend to think that no ones believes on right and wrong is correct, except their own. That is what comes up in conversation about FGM. Personally, I am not pro-FGM when it comes to its

female genital mutilation controversies

1574 words - 6 pages references to clitoridectomy reveal the dominant position men assume by considering women as sexual beings and the second one is that references allow the Westerners to overlook their own deficiencies by condemning "them", the female genital mutilation (FGM) advocates, for what they do to their women. In my opinion, Tamir's best argument to support her stance is that the objections to FGM arise as a result of patronizing attitudes toward women (Tamir 1

Social Injustice: Female Genital Mutilation

1616 words - 6 pages society.Identifying an aspect of society that fits this definition of a social injustice should be a simple task considering there are many around you and possibly directly affecting you. I have found an aspect that affects me somewhat indirectly. This aspect is female genital mutilation (FGM), also known as female circumcision (FC) or female genital cutting (FGC).Why is female genital mutilation a social injustice? First you must understand what female genital

Research Outline: Female Genital Mutilation

2617 words - 10 pages western feminists is to provide resources necessary to open discourse within the understanding of FGM, as experienced by our participants. Whether women decide to partake in FGM or not, it is a personal decision. Women should have the ability to freely choose and properly consent to what happens to their bodies; with that we suggest that there are steps that need to be taken in order to make sure female genital mutilation is being done to only

Gender Reassignment & Female Genital Mutilation

2096 words - 9 pages According to Milton Diamond, children with genital impairments at birth are being reassigned to surgery to be transformed physically into women (1997, p.1). But where has the psychological part of these individuals left behind? Is this newly made up female capable to embody society’s expectations about women? Will these individuals be able to conduct themselves as women in an intimate relationship? Female gender mutilation and gender

Similar Essays

Female Genital Mutilation Is Not Wrong!!

836 words - 3 pages Female Genital Mutilation--Why the Practice is not Morally WrongAlmost everyone who has heard of the practice of Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) is without some form of opinion of the custom, which affects 100 million women in 26 African countries, and elsewhere in the world. It has been declared a gross violation of the human rights of woman and female children. However, at the same time some argue that the procedures are part of time-honored

Female Genital Mutilation Essay 1289 Words

1289 words - 6 pages on women suffering and living with FGM. Most of these stories are of women living with complications stemming from infibulation. Despite the stories, grandmothers and mothers are the ones who setup and perform the procedure. Female genital mutilation causes many health complications and has no health benefits. Cosmetic procedures such as labiaplasty or sex reassignment surgery procedures are not considered a form of female circumcision. FGM is a violation of human rights. It still continues today and in Africa about 3 million girls are at risk for female genital cutting every year.

Female Genital Mutilation Essay

1678 words - 7 pages Female Genital Mutilation Female Genital Mutilation is believed to have started in Egypt 2,000 years ago and spread from there. Only a few years ago, FGM was considered a cultural tradition, but now the United Nations has labeled it as a violation of human rights. Canada, Denmark, the Netherlands, and the United States has declared Female Genital Mutilation grounds for seeking asylum and is a punishable offense (1).      Many of us never

Female Genital Mutilation Essay 927 Words

927 words - 4 pages mutilation.Female Genital Mutilation is necessary in order for a girl to be considered a complete woman. Many men in these societies consider woman who have not undergone circumcision manly. They believe that if the clitoris is not removed, it will eventually dangle between the legs like the genitals of a man. An Egyptian woman states "we are circumcised and insist on circumcising our daughters so that there is no mixing between male and female...An