Free Indirect Speech With Quotation Marks In Austen's Works

1240 words - 5 pages

I will think about how typographic conventions for speech representations in the eighteenth century influenced on the development of Free Indirect Discourse [FID] of this period.
FID for both speech and thought presentations is generally regarded as a style which enables smooth shifts between the narrative and dialogues/thoughts in the third person narrative. The reader is guided by the author/narrator to read the passage presented in FIS smoothly, thanks to its lack of quotation marks as well as the verb of saying and the attribution of the subject (such as ‘Tom said/thought’), while it retaining the third person and the past tense in the same manner as in the narrative. Modernist writers employed FID in combination with other styles for ‘the stream of consciousness’ so that the reader can feel closely with the protagonist’s train of thoughts. Virginia Woolf is one of the most successful writers in the experiment of this narrative technique. M. B. Parkes, an authority in palaeography, states that ‘Woolf exercises greater control [than her precursors] over her readers’ responses by means of punctuation.’(1) In the passages presented in FID, the narrator does not intervene in the reader but silently encourages her to experience a character’s inner thoughts.
Although the standard of FID is thus characterized by the absence of quotation marks, passages presented in Free Indirect Discourse for speech presentations [FIS] in Jane Austen’s works are sometimes enclosed with quotation marks. FID passages have an ambiguous voice of the narrator and a character conflated with. However, when FID is used for an apparent speech of a character (chiefly within a dialogue with other characters), in order to help the reader to recognize the embedded speech, quotation marks are used to make the part more visibly distinct to the reader.
In the explanation about the influences on the application of punctuation, Parkes states that ‘[i]n nineteenth- and twentieth-century novels the writer sets out to exploit the possibilities of the written medium in order to create an illusion’.(2) He continues,

The illusion achieved in a novel is the product of literary and linguistic conventions, among which the simulation of spoken discourse figures prominently. The author appears to be less intrusive when he or she exploits a character as a chosen focus of consciousness. However, the written medium had become so independent of that of the spoken medium, having its own complex of conventions, that the expectation that one could represent spoken discourse in a work of fiction was itself an illusion. (3)

According to Parkes, authors of nineteenth century fictions and onwards have been aware of the limit of the novel as a written form, and expected readers to reconstruct discourse within their minds. Graphic devices and punctuation marks are used for the purpose of aiding readers’ comprehension. Parkes further gives an example from a...

Find Another Essay On Free Indirect Speech with quotation marks in Austen's works

Stanley Fish's View On Free Speech With A Personal Opinion

831 words - 4 pages In the essay in his recent book, "There's No Such Thing as Free Speech and it's aGood Thing Too," Fish argues that free speech "is not an independent value, but apolitical prize," and any differences, which the courts have drawn between, protected andunprotected expressions are "malleable." Like any other concept, the principle of freespeech is, for Fish, "inherently nothing," but one more noise in the "din and confusion ofpartisan struggle

Direct and Indirect Methods of Communication with the Gods in Ancient Greece

1061 words - 5 pages insight of events to come. In addition, sacrifice at the hearth or public bonfires were used as a means of direct communication with the gods in order to convey prayers to the heavens. In terms of indirect communication with the gods, one of the most famous methods was consulting an oracle. One of the most popular oracles of Ancient Greece was the Oracle of Delphi. People would journey for days to visit this oracle and hear the wisdom of the gods

The Restriction of Free Speech in McCullen v. Coakley

948 words - 4 pages also relates to how an attorney practices and how they interpret the law. In this specific case, the decision is not easy because it not only brings into question the First Amendment as it relates to freedom of speech, Fourteenth Amendment as it deals with abortion, and also a past case ruling that it was acceptable for individuals protesting, educating, or distributing literature to be eight feet away from the facility. Although eight feet

Propaganda in the Online Free Speech Campaign, Propaganda and Mass Communication

5227 words - 21 pages Internet to spread propaganda to further this common cause of online free speech and opposition to the CDA. Context in which the propaganda occurs Five years ago, most people had never heard of the Internet, but today the Internet is a term familiar to most people even if they are not exactly sure about what the Internet is. Along with the concept of the Internet, it is widely known that pornography and other adult related materials seem to be

Childhood Apraxia of Speech in Those with Autism Spectrum Disorder

666 words - 3 pages CAS is a very specific disorder with a very specific profile, and is thus different from “typical” speech sound disorders. The hypothesis of CAS in ASD (the CAS-ASD hypothesis) is that “CAS contributes to the inappropriate speech, prosody, and/or voice features reported in some children and adults with verbal ASD” (Shriberg et al., 2011, p. 405). For this to be true, the speech, prosody, and voice findings in children with ASD must not only be

An Analysis of Collin v Smith; Nazi's right to march in Jewish community is upheld as free speech

868 words - 3 pages refusal of certiorari, "...the issues [in the case of Collin v Smith] cut down to the very heart of the First Amendment." (125) It showed the nation that to believe in free speech, meant that one had to allow unpopular speech in with all of the rest. It was a landmark case in the defense of free speech and is often used today as a precedent in free speech cases. This quote, from Circuit Court Judge Pell, succinctly and accurately sums up the overall consensus of the Collin v Smith case. "...if these civil rights are to remain vital for all, they must protect not only those society deems acceptable, but also those whose ideas it quite justifiably rejects and despises." (124)

The Cost of Stability in Brave New World - Freedom (with works cited)

3950 words - 16 pages and religion completely conceals the past and eliminates the freedoms of thought and speech. People live in the present with no knowledge of history, and those who explore certain new, prohibited ideas are censored."Art is the most intense mode of individualism that the world has known", said Oscar Wilde. Individualism, however, is not permitted in the World State where "everyone works for everyone else" (Huxley, 81). Many pieces of literature

Human Interaction with Nature in the Works of Aldo Leopold and Elizabeth Bishop

1583 words - 6 pages Human Interaction with Nature in the Works of Aldo Leopold and Elizabeth Bishop The poet Elizabeth Bishop and the naturalist Aldo Leopold share a keen power of observation, a beautifully detailed manner of writing, a love for the beauty of nature, and an interest in how people interact with the natural world. Like Leopold, Bishop examines human interactions with nature on both the personal and the ecological level. On the individual level, a

Arthur Miller's Dissatisfaction with the American People Expressed in Three of His Major Works

2104 words - 9 pages Miller’s plays A View from the Bridge and Death of a Salesman it shows that he understands people and the tragedy they go through. Every individual creates their own problems and creates a solution to fix it. With the problems people face, the solution they create allows the person to feel accomplished. Miller conveys the idea that every and any man will do anything to secure his dignity. In the works created by Miller, two characters Eddie Carbone

In The Period Of 70 To 50 BC, How Important Was It For Cicero To Align Himself With Pompey? (30 Marks)

816 words - 4 pages In the period of 70 to 50 BC, how important was it for Cicero to align himself with Pompey? (30 Marks) Although Cicero was an incredibly notable orator and lawyer, he lacked the influence and power required to progress in his political career. In order to pursue his career he needed a driving force, such as Pompey.Through the trial against Verres, Cicero came into close contact with Pompey for the first time and his success allowed him to make a

Criminal Justice Reform / Speech Paper with Outline and all Supplements. The need for extreme criminal justice reform in California

2714 words - 11 pages restriction.But I submit that such a philosophical foundation is flawed. Revenge while understandable from an individual human perspective is not a proper basis for society's response to the misbehavior of its laws. This human urge to punish should be removed from the current system and replaced with methods of restrictions that utilize the offender's potential to benefit his victim and society at large.In other words, in a free society the end

Similar Essays

The Challenge Of Free Indirect Speech In Mrs. Dalloway

1350 words - 5 pages Speech in Mrs. Dalloway.” Translating Virginia Woolf. Ed. Oriana Palusci. Berlin: Peter Lang, 2012. 39-47. Gingerich, Jon. “The Benefits of Free Indirect Discourse.” Lit Reactor. LitReactor, LLC, 23 Aug. 2012. Web. 15 April 2014. Thacker, Andrew. "Traffic, Gender, Modernism." Sociological Review 54.(2006): 175-189. SocINDEX with Full Text. Web. 22 Apr. 2014. Woolf, Virginia. “Mrs. Dalloway.” The Longman Anthology of British Literature. Ed. David Damrosch and Kevin J. H. Dettmar. Boston: Longman, 2010. 2338-2437. Print.

Expressives In Indirect Speech Act

681 words - 3 pages    Although our group have had a presentation of indirect speech acts in the class, I still want to discuss one of indirect speech acts in detail: expressives. The frequency of expressives is high in all our three group’s presentations, so I want to give further analysis and discuss its implications in people’s daily conversations. In the following paragraphs, I will first show the definition of expressives and explain it with some examples

Free Speech In Cyberspace

3714 words - 15 pages that natural human right. However, because of their natural egoist mentality, they are forced to violate freedom of speech on the Internet. They can no more let political opponents roam freely on the Internet with the free flow of information than they can let a Constitution stand in their way of political supremacy. The government could have taken a utilitarian standpoint and justified their actions as such. They may feel that the advocates

Free Speech In The Military

904 words - 4 pages certainly had the understanding that he was a Marine. An employee can state their thoughts about their employers to anyone and in any forum. It is their right of speech to do so. Sadly, being a member of the armed forces limits that same freedom that so many of us have at their cost. Works Cited Opelka, Mike. "‘Treason’ Or ‘Free Speech?’." The Blaze. N.p., 02 Sept. 2013. Web. 04 Mar. 2014. Perry, Tony. "L.A. NOW." Marine Who Criticized Obama: Charges 'drummed up against Me' N.p., 22 Mar. 2012. Web. 04 Mar. 2014. Stein, Gary. "Military Freedom of Speech." RedState. N.p., 02 Mar. 2012. Web. 04 Mar. 2014.