Freedom Of Expression? R V. Zundel In Depth Case Analysis.

1881 words - 8 pages

Thesis Statement:The Dictionary of Canadian Law defines the term "freedom of expression" as "Permitting free expression to the end of promoting truth, political or social participation, and self-fulfilment. That purpose extends to the protection of minority beliefs which the majority regard as wrong or false." R. v. Zundel.It was fair? Unlawful?Profile of the Law:Criminal Code of CanadaSpreading False NewsSection 181Every one who wilfully publishes a statement, tale, or news that he knows is false and that causes or is likely to cause injury or mischief to a public interest is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years.Annotations: This section violates the guarantee to freedom of expression under s. 2(b) of the Charter and is of no force and effect.Canadian Charter of Rights and FreedomsGuarantee of Rights and Freedoms1. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the rights and freedoms set out in it subject only to such reasonable limits prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.Fundamental Freedoms2. Everyone has the following fundamental freedoms:b) freedom of thought, belief, opinion and expression, including freedom of the press and other media of communication;"Section 2(b): Freedom of expression / Interpretation - Section 2(b) protects all forms of expression, whether oral, written, pictorial, sculpture, music, dance or film. The freedom of expression referred to, moveover, extends to those engaged in expression for profit and those who wish to express the ideas of others, and to the recipients as well as to the originators of communications."General Summary.The Dictionary of Canadian Law defines the term "freedom of expression" as "Permitting free expression to the end of promoting truth, political or social participation, and self-fulfilment. That purpose extends to the protection of minority beliefs which the majority regard as wrong or false. It is one of the fundamental concepts that has formed the basis for historical development of the political, social and educational institutions of western society." Ernst Zundel has been charged under Section 181 for having knowingly published false news that was likely to be injurious to the public.The charge arose out of the accused's publication of a pamphlet entitled Did Six Million Really Die? The accused had added a preface and afterword to an original document, which had previously been published by others in the United States and England. The pamphlet, part of a genre of literature known as "revisionist history", suggests, inter alia, that it has not been established that six million Jews were killed before and during World War II and that the Holocaust was a myth perpetrated by a worldwide Jewish conspiracy. The accused was convicted after a lengthy trial.The charge arises out of the publication by the appellant of a 32-page booklet seemingly entitled "Did Six Million Really Die?",...

Find Another Essay On Freedom of Expression? R v. Zundel - In Depth Case Analysis.

Mill's Freedom of Expression Essay

1305 words - 6 pages pleasure such as drinking and gambling, which will bring lower utility. He is concern on individual freedom of expression, thinking that such libertarian ideal in a person that had brought to the Enlightenment of Europe is disappearing within society in the 19th century England and the Western world. This paper will convey Mill’s arguments for freedom of expression and its acceptance. Freedom of expression according to Mill is the essence of

Freedom of Expression Essay

691 words - 3 pages Freedom of Expression Freedom of expression, and open access to media, are as fundamental to the survival of Progress as the sun and rain are to the survival of planet Earth. Yet censorship remains a traditional response of any group that finds itself offended at another's message or creative indulgence. The argument that because they serve the "public interest," media should willingly accept a moral arbiter to decide what will and what

Promoting or hindering, CNN IReport, a case study on the role of Internet intermediates in Internet freedom of expression

1237 words - 5 pages ). Through this process, expression of freedom may be promoted by the user, who shifts the role of tradition gatekeeper and changing its practice. But expression of freedom may also be hindered by the tradition gatekeeper, who restrains stories to fall in the line of news organizations and tradition news values (Karlsson, 2011). Therefore, this study tends to analysis how and in what degree specific Internet intermediary like CNN IReport propel and

Freedom of expression in Hong Kong since 1997

3061 words - 12 pages public order (ordre public), or of public health or morals. Also, the restrictive measures must be necessary and proportionate to the aims sought to be achieved.Ng Kung Siu caseThe limitation for the protection of public order has been the centre of controversy since the resumption of sovereignty. In HKSAR v Ng Kung Siu and another , a flag desecration case, the CFA confirmed that freedom of expression is not absolute and is subject to

Freedom of Speech and Expression

1257 words - 6 pages notion of autonomy (Rawls 1980, 554). Therefore restrictions on our freedom of expression correlate to restrictions on our autonomy. The doctrine of freedom of expression was written to single out the protected acts in which hold us to be immune from restrictions despite the existing facts that have consequences or harms us to be sufficient to the justifications and impositions of legal sanctions. Oliver Wendell Holmes believed that

Uniforms and Freedom of Expression

1256 words - 5 pages Does wearing a school uniform really make a difference in the learningprocess? Ever wonder what is the purpose of wearing a school uniform in thefirst place? If all of the students are dressed alike, it seems like it would bepretty tough to express your freedom of expression through attire. Manystudents, parents, and administrators have different opinions on the strictenforcement of a wearing school uniform. Some religious students might notbe

Litigation of R. v. Buhay

1519 words - 6 pages The litigation of R. v. Buhay is a case where the Charter of rights and freedoms was violated by the policing parties but maintained and performed by the Supreme Court of Canada. This litigation began after two individuals; of which one was Mervyn Buhay, rented a locker at the Winnipeg bus depot. Buhay began to distract the security guards while his friend placed a duffel bag in the locker they had rented. After they left, the security guards

in-depth analysis of a cluster

830 words - 4 pages market players have influence on the market. At the same time, since this industry are the most powerful within Russian economy, the oil and gas producing and transportating companies are interdependent with Russian government structure. So political factors have a great impact on the industry. Since this work is aimed at researching the transportation of oil and gas in Russia as well as its export, a historical data of this cluster, analysis by

Freedom of Speech and Expression - Little Freedom in a Complex World

1185 words - 5 pages Christmas, New Year's Eve, and his sixteenth birthday in jail. Finally there is the case of the former mayor of Mukingo in Ruhengeri Prefecture, Juvenal Kejelijeli, who is desperately fighting deportation to face charges for his "freedom of expression," which helped ignite genocide in Rwanda. Free speech and freedom of expression must be protected, but the speakers and writers must also take responsibility for their actions. During the twelfth

Argumentation of the case involving Tinker and the Des Moines School District over freedom of expression

1274 words - 5 pages , Tinker vs. Des Moines, brought the Freedom of Speech amendment all the way to the Supreme Court. The Petitioners in this case were John Tinker, Christopher Eckhardt, and Mary Beth Tinker. At the time of the original trial, all three petitioners were students in the Des Moines School District and their ages were 15, 16, and 13 respectively.The three students were suspended from school for wearing black armbands to protest the governments

The War of Freedom of Expression

1935 words - 8 pages 'Taking on anti-Semites and Holocaust deniers in the sanctified courtroom environment is like responding to someone who calls your mother a prostitute. The right to freedom of expression can be described as a war. It is a war that has lasted for centuries and may last for centuries more. It is a war between freedom of expression and social intolerance. In this war there are many battles. The battle on which this brief essay centers itself is the

Similar Essays

The Right To Freedom Of Expression: R. V. Keegstra

3315 words - 13 pages of R. v. Keegstra to argue that the rights of individuals and groups to be afforded the right to respect and dignity outweigh any claim to freedom of expression. R v. Keegstra: s. 2 (b) of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms versus s. 319 (2) of the Criminal Code The case, R. v. Keegstra, constructs a framework concerning whether the freedom of expression should be upheld in a democratic society, even when it is used to perpetuate deliberate

Freedom Of Religion And Freedom Of Expression: Tinker V. Des Moines

1865 words - 7 pages ? The first amendment states some of the freedoms we have. These are freedom of religion and freedom of expression. These include the right to free speech, press, assembly, and to petition the government. The reason for wanting to wear the black armbands was to show their anti-war belief in the Vietnam War. Rebelling against the authority figures’ ruling, three students wore the armbands and got suspended. The students’ names are John F. Tinker, who

Analysis: R V. Harrison Case

2231 words - 9 pages Durango, thereby increasing the constable’s impression of deviant activity occurring (R. v. Harrison, 2009). As a result, the Supreme Court of Canada exercised its authority as it is not constrained by the reasoning of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice and Ontario Court of Appeal in relation to section 24(2) and the rest of the Constitution. In the final analysis of the case R. v. Harrison, consideration is given to Charter breaches, relevant

Freedom Of Expression Essay

2612 words - 10 pages we are protecting the wrong people in this case. The minority is given precedence at the sacrifice of the majority.The book, American Voices, is a collection of essays on the freedom of speech and censorship. I chose to put this collection of essays into my book because they represent the strong central theme of freedom of expression as the cornerstone of American government, culture and life.11 Each essay strongly defends a case for free