Genetic Testing And Cloning: Is Technology Ahead Of The Law?

3794 words - 15 pages

Introduction.Between the ongoing decoding of the human genome, the cloning of Dolly the sheep, and the increasing promise of stem cell research (which is based upon the principles of genetic research), U.S. society has a plethora of new medical legal and ethical issues with which it must come to terms. For example, how can personhood be established when "persons" can be created at will in the laboratory? Furthermore, when personhood is established is especially relevant when considering issues of stem cell research. How can we balance the rights and needs of patients with diseases such as Alzheimer's with those of a society at large that worries about the extent to which science tends to go when given free reign? These are just some of the more obvious legal issues that have arisen with the latest trends in genetic technology. There are, of course, many others, some clearer than others. Moreover, this is such a new form of technology that not only will unforeseen issues emerge with time, but we also will have trouble keeping up with those about which we are already aware.Issues: Pros and Cons.Donald Elliott (61) notes that before entering into the ethical quagmire that seems to surround these issues, legal scholars must remember that science has always changed the law, and society has always struggled with how to incorporate new scientific discoveries into its overall cultural mores. Having said that, he presents several issues that are front and center in this debate. First, and perhaps most frightening to society in general, is the worry that the ultimate reach of genetic testing will be to "design" our offspring, thus gradually phasing certain people and characteristics out of existence based upon certain arbitrary standards (62). A second issue concerns the worry about "genetic profiling" in issues of employment (to either attract or dissuade potential employees from entering certain jobs). Finally, Elliott notes that how we understand genetics (in a metaphorical sense) will dictate how we legislate our application of the knowledge we acquire. By this, he means, for example, the questions concerning whether genes can ever be considered property (63).Elliott makes some excellent points. Our society is still frighteningly unable to truly appreciate differences in appearance, intellectual abilities, and other variations of humanity. There does indeed exist a tremendous potential for people to, at some point in the not-so-distant future, "design" their offspring using genetic technology, or for them to abort fetuses that do not live up to the genetic standards of the day. After all, such behaviors already exist when it comes to the sex of the baby. His point about genetic profiling also has merit. While it is theoretically true that all results of genetic tests can be held in the strictest of confidentiality, it is also true that there are numerous examples of such confidentiality being breached. How can we be absolutely sure the results of our...

Find Another Essay On Genetic Testing and Cloning: Is Technology Ahead of the Law?

Genetic Testing and The Diagnosis of Genetic Diseases

1389 words - 6 pages Genetic testing is used to determine the risk of a patient or patient’s offspring developing genetic diseases. This is done with DNA sequencing in adults and preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PDG) on embryos. These methods of genetic testing are effective means of determining the likelihood of developing diseases such as Huntington’s disease, a disease resulting from trinucleotide repeat on chromosome 4p16.3 that causes uncontrollable muscle

The Benefits of Genetic Testing Essay

1593 words - 6 pages Genetic testing is a voluntary type of medical test used to identify changes in chromosomes, genes, or proteins. This type of medical test checks for alterations in an individual's genes or changes in levels of gene products, proteins. Genetic testing could also be used to look for structure of certain proteins, and for levels of RNA that play a role in certain conditions. The purpose of the test is to indentify genetic problems or possible

The Ethics of Genetic Testing

3438 words - 14 pages The Ethics of Genetic Testing The Goal of the Human Genome Project is to obtain genetic mapping information and to determine the complete sequence of all human DNA by the year of 2005. The project started in 1990 and 180 million dollars are being spent on it annually. This adds up to a total of over 2 billion dollars for the 15 year budget. Of this 2 billion dollars budgeted, 5% is spent annually on the ethical, legal and social issues

This essay is about whether cloning and genetic engeneering is an extention of selective breeding. it compares selective breeding with cloning and genetic modification

759 words - 3 pages Agribusiness Perspectives - Paper 51 - 1, Genetic modification or GM is a term used to describe a group of techniques, which can modify the genetic material of a living organism (plant, animal or microbe) and thus alter its characteristics. While cloning can be define as the process in which a colony of genetically identical cells or organisms were grown in a laboratory to produce numbers of identical plants or animals.Some people assume that cloning

Cloning and the Decline in Genetic Diversity

1458 words - 6 pages Cloning and the Decline in Genetic Diversity *Missing Works Cited* One of the biggest problems with the use of cloning is the decline in genetic diversity, continued use of cloning would lead to inbreeding, wide scale, conformity. Humans would be taking nature into their own hands. Over the past billion years, life has grown into a fascinating structure. Of the 300,000 kinds of plants and more than a million kinds of animals that are

Cloning and Genetic Engineering

2216 words - 9 pages . This created an uproar over the result, which focused not particularly on Dolly, but on the possible application of cloning technology to other mammals, specifically humans. (Dudley, p.13)Soon after the announcement of the cloning of Dolly, the British scientific journal 'Nature' stated that "cloning humans from adults' tissues is likely to be possible any time from one to ten years from now." (Dudley, p.14) This, and other evidence of the

Genetic Engineering and Cloning

862 words - 4 pages Human’s wisdom has not yet caught up to their capability in science and technology. Genetics are being experimented which could alter human evolution. This technology, genetic alteration, is close to being used by the public. Cloning is a form of genetic alteration and experimentation. More legislation should be passed to further restrict genetic experimentation due to the possible misuses of the technology. There are many different forms of

Pros and Cons of Genetic Testing

1572 words - 7 pages In today’s world, people are learning a great deal in the rapidly growing and developing fields of science and technology. Almost each day, an individual can see or hear about new discoveries and advances in these fields of study. One science that is rapidly progressing is genetic testing; a valuable science that promotes prevention efforts for genetically susceptible people and provides new strategies for disease management. Unnaturally, and

Genetic Testing and the US Healthcare System

2442 words - 10 pages is Genetic Testing? According to the National Human Genome Research Institute, “Genetic testing is the analysis of human DNA, RNA, chromosomes, protein, and certain metabolites in order to detect heritable disease-related genotypes, mutations, phenotypes, or karyotypes for clinical purposes. Prenatal, newborn and carrier screening, as well as testing in high risk families, are included. Tests for metabolites are covered only when they are

The Controversial Topic of Genetic Testing

1218 words - 5 pages this growing technology to use. Some agree that it is a person’s right to know and understand his or her genetic makeup. However, others argue that, despite the benefits of genetic testing, caution should be used to carefully inspect the risks associated with this new technology. Relatively simple tests can be used to conduct genetic testing on adults and children; even fetuses can undergo testing, but at greater risk for complications. Currently

Biotechnology and Genetic Testing

1701 words - 7 pages ; however, direct-to-consumer tests (those that are available to the public) are not as regulated (GHR, 2014). Thus, it is difficult to determine the reliability of genetic testing. Genotyping technology, such as those utilized by companies like 23andme, only looks at different parts of the genes and makes predictions based on small segments (PBS, 2012). These results may not be conclusive. Since the technology is still being researched and is in no way

Similar Essays

The United States Law Banning Genetic Cloning Of Humans

1369 words - 5 pages , created after World War II and in response to Nazi genetic engineering experiments, were held to be stricter than the signed ban. Britain was the only country to refuse to sign the ban and declared itself "open" to the new cloning technology and research. By the 20th of January 1998, the Food and Drug Administration had made into federal law that without their authority, it is illegal to try somatic cell transfer, which happens to be the same

Social Media And Modern Technology & Genetic Testing

850 words - 4 pages Social Media and Modern Technology & Genetic Testing Everday we come into contact with social media and everyday it becomes more involved in our life. So much that it has an influence in our social, political and culture in major ways. Its almost unheard of now a days for some not to have a Facebook page or some type of online profile. Genetic testing is become more and more prevalent, and is allowing us to recognize genes that’s can cause

The Progression Of Genetic Engineering And Cloning

746 words - 3 pages Imagine having to explain to your child why they don’t look like you because of you’re selfishness. Imagine thinking your going to design your baby and turns out it has severe leukemia because scientists didn’t put together your baby right. Where Genetic Engineering and Cloning is headed this is possible. Not only is this effecting your child its affecting the whole world as well. Many people think they only do this in humans it happens in

The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Genetic Testing

861 words - 4 pages have these risk factors, nowadays, most parents are choosing to tryout genetic testing to know whether their child has any chances of getting something through genetics. This has led to several debates between people who support genetic testing and those who are against it. Now the question becomes, is genetic testing fully ethical? Well genetic testing is simply a way of gathering genetic information from a person to help protect them ahead of