Haig And The Somme, Gcse Coursework Questions.

4894 words - 20 pages

Coursework: Haig and the Sommea). Study Sources A and B:How far does Source A prove that Haig did not care about the lives of his men?Source A concerns Haig's views on the high amount of casualties he believed were inevitable during the course of the war. The paragraph shows that Haig believed that the deaths of his men were in no way connected to the implications of his own actions, and does not appear concerned over the prospect of such appalling casualties that were evident in the Battle of the Somme during 1916. The extract shows that Haig did not take responsibility for the fate of his men, and seemed prepared to accept their deaths as a certainty rather than trying to rectify the situation. This clearly illustrates Haig's incompetence and incapability, and shows that he viewed his soldiers as little more than pawns in his grand scheme. Although he refers to the seemingly unavoidable high-casualty lists as 'sacrifices' on his men's behalf, this attempt to glorify death does not justify his display of negligence.The diary entries in Source B do little to promote Haig as a caring and cometant commander. Although he shows slight concern for the welfare of his soldiers, his optimism may be the result of the awareness that his diaries could potentially become sources of historic reference in judging his character, in future years. However, the fact that he believed that his plans would prove successful show that he did not intentionally send his men to be slaughtered. Nevertheless this fact may again be the result of his false optimism, or yet another account of Haig's incapability as a General. Indeed, the extent to which to which Haig is falsely informed about the progress made on the first day of the Somme shows that he was clearly ignorant of the feelings and circumstances concerning his men.Source A clearly shows that Haig showed little concern over the welfare of his men and although Source B is less condemning, overall it also supports the concept that Haig was an inept and uncaring commander.b). Study Sources B and C:Which one of these two sources do you trust more?Source B was written by Haig, who as commander-in-chief of the British army would have had access to information concerning the progress of the Battle of the Somme. As commander, his views would represent a wide perspective of the front line, and overall analysis of the fighting, since his role as General required information from every aspect of the battle. However, at such a demanding rank, Haig was widely regarded as a figurehead, and his optimism was essential to motivate his subordinates, which as a result could invalidate what is stated in Source B.On the first day of the Somme, on July 1st 1916, Haig was deliberately informed with misleading information on the progress of the battle by his intelligence officer, Charteris. Haig was often perceived as a volatile and unpredictable person, so it is likely that he was misinformed in order to maintain his high-spirits and...

Find Another Essay On Haig and the Somme, GCSE coursework questions.

Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig: War hero or butcher of the Somme?

1124 words - 4 pages Field Marshal Sir Douglas Haig: War hero or butcher of the Somme? Many historians see the Somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of the war. The devastating casualties and deaths of the war left thousands without their loved ones, a whole generation was lost at the Somme. After the devastation of the war, many soldiers blamed Haig. It was thought that Haig's leadership was to blame for the tremendous

Explain how the Schlieffen plan was meant to work: GCSE Coursework

2290 words - 9 pages History Coursework - The First World War.Explain how the Schlieffen plan was meant to work.The Schlieffen plan was the strategy Germany planned to adopt in the event of a war in 1914. It was intended to bring a fast, effective victory for Germany, and was devised by Count Alfred von Schlieffen who was the Chief of the General Staff of the German Army.If a war broke out, Germany would be faced with a war in the west against France, and a war on

The Somme: Heroism and Horror in the First World War

3115 words - 12 pages ahead to 1916 and uses entries from Sir Douglas Haig’s diary to illustrate the challenges Haig faced when proposing the need for an offensive on the Somme. He discusses how Haig needed to convince the War Committee that fighting on the Somme was essential for victory in the war and if successful it could mean an early end to the war. From this point on, Gilbert tells the story of the Somme through the accounts of General Haig, the soldiers who fought

GCSE Physics- Force, Mass and Acceleration Coursework

1213 words - 5 pages MethodIn this experiment I aim to find out how the force and mass affect acceleration. I shall do this by setting up an experiment involving a ticker tape timer and trolley, to keep the experiment as fair as possible I will only change one variable at a time. For the first part I will only vary the force (see fig. 1) in difference weights of 1N, 2N, 3N and 4N. In order to keep the friction acting on the trolley constant I will make the ramp

Questions and the Team

998 words - 4 pages to a better project experience overall. But what are the right types of questions to ask during a team project? Before even contemplating the type of questions, one needs to realize that any, or at least most questions relating to the project at hand can help the leader get acquainted with the individual learning and working styles of each member. Gaining individual understanding will obviously further enhance knowledge of the group dynamics

'Describe And Explain The Essential Features Of Infant And Believer's Baptism,' (A GCSE Coursework Question)

663 words - 3 pages Infant baptism is the baptism of practices that baptize infants as well as adults, whereas believers' baptism is the baptism of practices that only baptize from the age of 18 or 16.Both the different types of Baptism share the four symbols of baptism, water, oil, a candle and a white garment. However they are not all used in the same way. The Roman Catholics who practise infant baptism, sprinkle water on the infant's heads three times, whereas

GCSE english coursework: A comparison of three short stories from the victorian era. This essay compares the way the three stories use settings to add to the story's atmosphere

4508 words - 18 pages For this piece of coursework, I will be comparing the way that three short stories written before 1914 use setting and atmosphere to add to the story. The three stories are:-·The Red Room by H.G. Wells (1896)·The adventure of the Engineer's thumb by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (1892)·The signalman by Charles Dickens (1866)I will be analysing all three stories individually, and doing comparisons between them to show what I have

Business studies GCSE coursework 1 Types and styles of business's

707 words - 3 pages Payment'. Many high street name are Franchises: Benetton, Mc Donalds and Pizza Hut.AdvantagesA franchisee benefits from having an already well-established brand name, and bank's are more likely to lend money to franchisee's because of this. This position is much more reliable than being a sole trader.DisadvantagesA franchisee has very limited independence and is ruled by the franchisor. The business cannot be sold, and regular 'Royalty Payments

Christian Teachings and the Teachings of One Other Religion on Wealth and Poverty: Christianity and Judaism GCSE Coursework A*

551 words - 2 pages 'Christians believe that wealth is something which can be used for good or evil, and so, in itself, is not a bad thing. Christians can only gain money in lawful and moral ways and when they have wealth, it is a gift from God not theirs alone. Many biblical teachings show that if you have the wrong attitude to money, wealth can lead you away from God.' (Religion and Life, Victor W Watton, pg 99)When Christians say that money should not be gained

Hidden in the dark by Vanita Suthar GCSE coursework

1253 words - 5 pages Suddenly I felt a chill run down my spine. This was not due to the past, but caused by something real and in the present. My shoulders shivered inadvertently. The sudden feelings came over me I was no longer alone in the coppice. My eyes quickly searched about. This was absurd, for I saw no one, heard no sound. I was certain I was being watched.Feeling frightened and courageous at the same time, I managed the strength to call out "who is there

An essay comparing and contrasting the two poems: "Island Man" by Grace Nichols and "The Fringe of the Sea", by A.L. Hendriks. (UK English GCSE Coursework, KS 4)

1931 words - 8 pages Comparing and contrasting the two poems:"Island Man" and "The Fringe of the Sea".I recently read two poems, entitled "Island Man" and "The Fringe of the Sea". These two poems are similar in many ways, but also have conflicting ideas. They both have connections to the sea, through the content of the poems, but also through the authors. Grace Nichols is the author of "Island Man", and she was born in Ghana, and now living in Britain. A.L. Hendriks

Similar Essays

History Gcse Coursework Ww1. Answering Various Questions

2253 words - 9 pages The First World War(a) Explain how the Schlieffen Plan was meant to work (7)The Schlieffen plan was the strategy that was supposed to allow the German army a swift and deceive victory over France in a short space of time so that the German army could be rushed to the boarder to hold up the Russian 'Steamroller'Germany had one of the best transport systems in the world and they were going to use their network to move their troops around quickly

Gcse English Coursework: The Crucible Essay

1302 words - 5 pages GCSE English Coursework: The Crucible The Crucible. Arthur Miller, ‘The Crucible’ is a play based upon the events of Salem, Massachusetts in 1692. The story is about a religiously motivated town. The story is about a group of girls’ who are led by Abigail, who blamed witchcraft for their troubles. Being a strict Christian society the people of Salem believed in the girl’s stories. In conclusion this led into 20 people being falsely

Field Marshall Haig: The Butcher Of The Somme

3202 words - 13 pages Field Marshall Haig: the Butcher of the Somme In order to answer the main essay question on whether or not Field Marshall Haig was the Butcher of the Somme I will include points for and against and also quotes to sum up and give a complete answer on my opinion of Field Marshall Haig. When field Marshall Haig was appointed commander of the British forces, he was 54 years old. Before this time Haig had had a long and

Does General Haig Deserve To Be Remembered ‘The Butcher Of The Somme’?

1617 words - 7 pages Field Marshall Sir Douglas Haig (19 June 1861 – 29 January 1928) was a senior commander in the First World War (WWI), and perhaps one of the most notable figures in British Military history. Although he served as the commander of the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) from 1915 to the end of the war – which was one of the greatest victories in Britain’s military history – the involvement during the Battle of the Somme, lead him to become one of