Identity Study Essay

1484 words - 6 pages

Primordial school
Primordial school and modernist school are two very important main streams in identity study. Especially, in the national identity study, both of them have involved the study of nationalism and have a very unlike view of it. And they are often highly debated of the origins of nations and their identity.
The root of primordial school is originally based on the German romanticism and it mainly argues how those fixed factors influence in identity shape process. Those factors are constantly stable throughout the history and hardly changed. The factors have been passed on to generations and constructing the identity of people who lives in nowadays. For example, language is one ...view middle of the document...

This could be evidently showed in the dynastic community, the kings and royal family members in Europe sharing a close kinship which made the power flow inside the small ruling class. It is more generally to see are the tribes identifying themselves from each other by this kinship, not only remained in a small family membership but also much more extensive and broad level. Therefore, identity can be shaped and constructed through a fixed or pre-existed biological and genetic connection. And this is one of the primary ideas of primordial school for identity study.
The primordial school is also emphasizing the importance of the culture roots as one of the impacts on identity. For primordial school, culture has its origin and it is more likely to look at the past. In other words, cultural impacts are always tending to trace back to the history. Culture is also a very strong reference to resemble a specific identity. When people living in a community which has a past that can be traced back and if this historical past has regained its meaning at the present, people whoever in that community or recognize that will certainly share a common identity. Simply to say, cultural effects such as custom, manner, religion and so on will help to form an identity. And these effects also can be passed on and inherited from the history and affect our identity in nowadays.
Modernist school
Modernist school is different from primordial school. It basically argues that identity is imagined by us. People are imagining the situation that they have a shared common identity with others. This imagining can be both the imagination of factors or constitutive elements of people’s identity, or the illusion of other people that have the shared and same ideals as they perceived or treasured by themselves. This is what identity comes from. So primarily, I think modernist school disapproves large parts of the identity shaping factors by manifesting that most of these factors are capable of being invented or envisioned in human mind. And this imagination and invention can be either intentionally or accidentally.
For example the culture roots of identity initially go back to the religious community. In this particular community, the beginning of its shared common identity is the sacred language spoken by those religion believers. This language differentiation makes them aware of their similarity and uniqueness from other people. And it starts from those people who using the sacred language recording ideas and thoughts. They have formed a community sharing those ideas. And later, by the gradually spreading of the religion, this community has extended its boundary and not only people who spoke the sacred language, but also people whoever believes in their ideas and thoughts. I think this could show that people united by the common language, and they believe that other languages speaker are the same people as they are because this language has its special using for the religious...

Find Another Essay On Identity Study

Identity Theft Essay

1309 words - 5 pages numbers are now collected and could be used illegally by these individuals without anyone’s knowledge.      The purpose of this study is to investigate what is being done to help control this growing crime in North Carolina. This includes the evaluation of the identity theft policies that the banks in North Carolina have in place. The study attempted to determine which bank had better and tougher policies as well as whether

Ethnic Identity Essay

1412 words - 6 pages diversity and negative encounters with other ethnic groups. When students encounter these situations they begin to become more curious about their own ethnicity and so they start to explore and learn more about it. This exploration process in turn gives them a better sense of understanding and ultimately an affirmation of their ethnic identity. (French, Seidman, Aleen &Aber, 2006) A study that examined over the course of three years the

Identity Crises

2035 words - 9 pages The Study of “Things They Carried” by Tim O’Brien George Carlin, during the early 80’s, had a routine that was a witticism on the importance of having "personal effects". These “personal effects” or items that a person accumulates through life symbolize their identity. The impractical things carried in pockets, purses, bags and suitcases that make people feel "as themselves" while in strange surroundings. These things are so essential to

Ethnic Identity

1525 words - 7 pages question. The results of this study showed that many different factors motivate these students some factors being; racial identity, parental value on achievement, approval from others, incentives and the cost of doing well. (Rodgers, 2008) It was evident that the students all maintained high levels of self-concept but those students that favored social acceptance over academic achievement did a disservice to themselves by not allowing

Ethnic Identity

1753 words - 7 pages Teachers and administrators that strive to increase motivation and academic success in their students have to become of aware that their student body is becoming more diverse and so many aspects of the school’s culture must be changed. Many schools have alienated their students that come from different ethnic backgrounds by failing to make that connection between self-identity and school identity. There are many different strategies that can be

Identity Crises

1528 words - 7 pages The Study of “Things They Carried” by Tim O’Brien George Carlin, during the early 80’s, had a routine that was a witticism on the importance of having "stuff". This stuff or items that is accumulated in life are items that are symbols of identity. The impractical things that are carried in pockets, purses, bags and suitcases that make people feel "as themselves" while in strange surroundings. These things are so essential to identify the person

Party Identity

2339 words - 10 pages . Participants that were students of UNL provided the perspective of primarily younger , more educated individuals. Employees at Panera Bread gave me an insight to varying ages of individuals who range from no college, some college, or have a college degree. College professors focused on individuals with higher education and have had the chance to experience the world of politics. Results For social identity theory, the previous study I looked

Gay Identity versus Jewish Identity

1475 words - 6 pages their homosexual identity is for them to completely abandon their homosexual identity. This is virtuous since he would be choosing the happiness of many while negating the happiness of just one person, himself. In the end this seems an honorable choice to favor the happiness of others to negate his own sexual appetites. Works Cited Bavier, Richard (1972). The Study of Judaism; Bibliographical Essays. Coyle, A. D. (2000). Jewish gay men’s

National Identity

2123 words - 9 pages studies have been investigated in this essay to study the influence of nationalism and international factors on the pace and outcome of decolonisation. While some common threads can easily be found, the relative importance of these factors might vary significantly. A sense of national identity is a necessary condition, helping to mobilise forces against imperial rule, but it has also been shown that national identity is equally a source and a

Masculine Identity

2383 words - 10 pages Masculinity, similarly to other aspects of one’s identity, is being intensively discussed in contemporary society. It has undergone significant development in the last few decades which has been reflected in and accelerated by the media. This essay explores the reasons for this - it refers to historical development where appropriate and discusses the consequences of the fragmentation of male identitities. The essay starts with a brief

Jesus' Identity

2299 words - 9 pages Jesus' Identity To discover the essence of Jesus' identity we have to study the different titles and look into the relevance of each one. Jesus' titles show many aspects to his character and hold a lot of significance. I feel that to understand the identity of Jesus I have to discuss and understand his titles. His main titles are: 1. Son of God- This title is used no more than eight times in Mark's gospel

Similar Essays

Druids And Druidism: A Study Of Their Real Identity

1753 words - 7 pages When interpreting history it is almost akin to separating the wheat from the chaff in farming. Close attention has to be paid to every historical detail that is given. In many cases when studying a historical description the reader can find a particular bias that the author has written with. The writings of Julius Caesar and Pliny are not exempt from being written with a bias when they describe the druids. Both authors are considered to be valid

Identity Essay

986 words - 4 pages social identity constructed by Tajfel and psychosocial theory of identity created by Erik Erikson are two of theories which give answer to this question. Tajfel and Erikson(ref) defined identity as two dimensional, containing personal and social part. Both believed that to evolve identity people need to understand how they differ from others and how they are similar. Tajfel foccused on social part and Erikson on personal part. Tajfel’s (ref

Ethnic Identity Essay 2529 Words

2529 words - 11 pages . One factor that may play a major role in effecting one’s self-esteem is a component of identity known as ethnic identity. Unfortunately, the current literature has only begun to explore this relationship and has focused primarily inclusive groups (e.g. White, Black, Hispanic, etc) and has ignored the complex subgroups within these “main” categories of ethnicity. Ethnic Identity and Self-Esteem In a study conducted by Y. R. Chen, L.C. Masses, J.S

Self Identity Essay

1457 words - 6 pages enables them to create their own identity abroad that helps them acquire conceptualization of self. Initially, then they interact and apply their own cultural values in their daily activities. It therefore becomes interesting to find out what happens when an international student fail to find other learners from his or her culture. Brown & Brown (2013) study focused on the acculturation and welfare of international students and revealed