Inspired Leadership Versus Commanding Leadership Essay

963 words - 4 pages

A leader who motivates and inspires passion in a team while streamlining the operations of their department is truly an effective leader. The opposite of this would be a leader who instills anxiety and fear by commanding, while expecting high performance from their direct reports. We all have a choice in the leader we want to be and from this class, have been provided the tools to build a positive path for this journey. As a new leader, my ultimate goal is to create more leaders to share this journey, not just to have more followers.
Five years ago, the director of my department retired. A new person was brought in who had the education, the experience and the highly ...view middle of the document...

In our department meetings, we were expected to sit quietly and only
speak up at the end of the meeting when she provided time for questions.
The problem was that Patty was brought in to improve the budget, period. There were rewards for winning and meeting her budget goal. Often times, prizes to be productive drive people to look better with little regard to doing what is morally right (Callahan, 2004). There are pressures to respond strategically to do what is best for the organization rather than what is best for the employee. A commanding leader, as Patty demonstrated herself to be, expects everyone to follow the rules with no questions asked. According to Dourado and Blackburn (2004) “command-and-control leadership will get people to show up in body but not, crucially, in spirit” (p. 7). The employees are at the mercy of those who lead them, which can leave them feeling vulnerable. At worst, this can lead the employee to experience coercion and manipulation (Johnson, 2007). This blind obedience can nurture tendencies of rebellion due to the nature of humans in wanting to make their own choices (Callahan, 2004). Blind obedience rarely involves praise but employs criticism when work is not done to the satisfaction of the leader. Criticism instead of praise inhibits innovation.
In reflecting on the style of leadership that was experienced while working for Patty, it has helped me understand what can be done differently to avoid the mistakes she made. Knowing and believing in the mission and values of your organization is critical to the success of any team who hopes to grow in that organization (Wilson & Dobson, 2008). Working with your employees to achieve the goals of the department in supporting these values will allow them to feel involved. A good leader needs to interact with their employees regularly and listen to...


Organizational Leadership versus Management Essay

595 words - 2 pages When in a leadership role I don’t like to consider myself as a boss, but a mentor. I don’t want my employees to see me as a boss but as a guide for further learning and success. Today’s managers are not leaders, they are people in charge and nothing more. They don’t necessarily have the skills to lead, don’t get me wrong they may be a very good manager. However, they are only managing and not setting an example as a leader for the employees of

Transformational versus Transactional Leadership Essay

740 words - 3 pages It is believed that for positive leadership in human life, there is a relation to the commitment in terms of the organizations (Aarons, 2006, p. 1163). When working in a mental health service organization, it is observed that organizational climate is mediated by the association between the workers and the working alliance between the management. It is evident that there is a connection between leadership, organizational and clinical process and

Leadership: Transactional versus Transformational

1026 words - 5 pages Weber (1920/1947, p. 358-359) described charisma, as a personality characteristic possessed by extraordinary, god-like exemplars. Robbins and Langton (2003, p. 395) asserted that the two most popular approaches to leadership are contingency models and the study of charisma. Burns (1978, p. 4) who built upon the work of Weber categorized two types of leaders, transactional and transformational. Kuhnert and Lewis (1987, p. 650) argued that

Male Versus Female: Leadership Stype

2225 words - 9 pages , employment is still not completely unbiased and equal between males and females and much of the inequality is due to subjective terms of leadership abilities. Research has shown that males and females have developed different leadership styles, and one may be more preferable than the other for high level corporate positions. According to authors Esther Chavez, Mark Green, and Diana Garza-Ortiz, leadership can be defined as “the process whereby

Leadership Versus Management: Exploring Leadership by Co-author, Barbara Kellerman

1091 words - 4 pages Several weeks ago, I stumbled on this quote “Greatness is not a function of circumstance; greatness is largely a matter of conscience, choice and discipline” by Jim Collins. Halfway into my Leadership One class, after a sober reflection; I realized that all the great leaders I had heard of and known personally exhibited traits of fascinating discipline, intense consciousness amongst other factors. Another interesting observation showed the

Situational Leadership

2234 words - 9 pages and as a mid-career officer, I feel that the model is particularly useful as I progress from unit-level leadership positions to more senior leadership positions involving more people and more complex missions.III. Leadership Theory OverviewAlmost all leadership theory is based on the relative importance assigned to the leader versus the follower in mission accomplishment. Those who believe that leaders are sufficiently enlightened, heroic, or

Management and Leadership

1163 words - 5 pages person who has commanding authority or influence" (2008). Leaders do not have subordinates, they have followers. Leadership inspires, motivates and sets the direction to achieve goals; leaders focus on people. Both people and organizations want leaders. People want leaders to assist them in accomplishing their goals. Organizations want leaders to not only motivate, but to provide organizational direction for employees to follow. According to Kouzes

Principles of Leadership Communication in Pearce's Leading Out Loud

550 words - 2 pages . Nonetheless the author conveys the differences between leadership of past generation versus this generation. As society loses confidence in leadership techniques of the past, it begins to look for management with a vision and the ability to communicate change. Interpretation can not be left up to chance or left up to the senior management, but everyone must engage. Most importantly, the leadership should know more than the people they are leading. In

Leadership in Small Groups

2217 words - 9 pages the group under control too.Moreover, there are multiple ways in which a leader can apply influence; it can be exercised by number of ways, such as "commanding, directing, requesting, demonstrating, cajoling, entreating, or bribing." Furthermore " by coaching, by building self-esteem and effective teams, and by delegating responsibility" (Elkin & Inkson, 2000, p205). Thus, leadership also involves power in its process, since power is:"The

Characteristics of a Leader and Two Types of Leadership

1001 words - 5 pages . 2014. . 4. "Transformational Leadership Vs. Transactional Leadership Definition." Small Business. Web. 13 Mar. 2014. . 5. "Transactional Versus Transformational Leaders." Boundless. Web. 13 Mar. 2014.

Effective Leaders

1661 words - 7 pages efficient leader will be able to inspire versus command the followers. In the Revelation of St. John (n.d./1999) God inspired John that the acceptance of God's way will live forever. Leaders need to possess confidence, intelligence, and courage. This is because leaders are role models for their followers. For example, in the Rule of St. Francis (1963/1999) the followers attempted to follow most directly the approach to life of the Saint (leader

Similar Essays

Management Versus Leadership Essay

2117 words - 8 pages The purpose of this paper is to discuss differences between management and leadership within a familiar organization. To understand the differences between a manager and a leader, one must probe their roles and responsibilities respectively and consider the origins of their similarities. No longer is it enough to understand these aspects of management within the American boarders, but it is imperative to gain an appreciation of these skills on

Leadership Versus Management Mgt 330 Essay

882 words - 4 pages Leadership Versus Management"Leadership is the art of accomplishing more than the science of management says is possible" (Gen. Colin Powell)In the text book Management: The New Competitive Landscape management is defined in the four functions: planning, organizing, controlling and leading. (Bateman/Snell, pg 15) A function of managing, therefore one could conclude, is leadership. Pieter Droog contradicts this statement. He says managing can be

Transactional Versus Servant Leadership Focusing On The Leadership Style And The Difference In Leadership Methods

3992 words - 16 pages charismatic leadership.The article "Transformational versus servant leadership: a difference in leader focus by (A.G.Stone; R.F.Russell; K.Patterson)" states that there are vast similarities between transformational and servant leadership but the main focus is towards the leader and his balance towards both leadership style. It is that very focus of the leader that determines the very difference in servant and transformational leadership. Also he states

Servant Leadership Versus Transformational Leadership Essay

1157 words - 5 pages Servant Leadership as it compares to Transformational Leadership Transformational and servant leadership are rooted in the study of charismatic leadership. An early conceptual model of "charismatic leadership" has been closely linked with the work of Max Weber, who described the leader as a charismatic person who exercised power through followers' identification with and belief in the leader's personality. Both transformational and servant