Is Gender Inequality And More Pressing Issue Than Freedom

1583 words - 7 pages

I Introduction – an unfair comparison?
This paper responds to the question “do laws against sex discrimination inappropriately prioritise the goal of gender equality over the promotion of other human rights like freedom?” The scope of this paper examines gender equality vis-à-vis other human rights/fundamental freedoms in the Australian context and with reference to the international phenomena. In this paper, I: (II) explore any authoritative basis for preferential status amongst human rights; (III) analyse the purpose and merits of gender equality; (IV) assess the criticisms of imbalance from a social justice perspective; and (IV) given that the law is dynamic, conclude whether comparisons ...view middle of the document...

The above viewpoints do not help us determine whether certain rights should take precedence. What we can examine is: ‘what’ and ‘how’ differences in human rights are expressed in the law – through Constitutions, Bills of Rights, Conventions and domestic law.
The Australian ethos is built upon the foundation of ‘a fair-go’ for all. Much of what Australians take for granted as human rights does not appear in binding legislation and those that are specifically included are subject to criticisms of incompleteness or ineffectiveness. The Australian Constitution was framed to deal with separation, division, limits of executive power, and provides little in the way of human rights. Australia was an early leader in many human rights, such as women’s voting rights, old age pensions and the minimum wage. Australia has implemented a raft of anti-discrimination legislation since 1975 and given effect to a number of conventions, such as the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women, which was implemented as domestic law in the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth). However, there are notable exceptions to Australia’s implementations such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) of 1976 which covers the right to life, freedom of speech and rights to due process amongst many others. However, this situation is not a denial or denigration of those rights, they are respected. The reasons are partly political and partly a reflection of social development in Australia. When the United Nations adopts conventions, it sets up the process for each nation state to give effect to the conventions under their own terms and circumstances. There is no precedent for a particular right to have more ‘right’.
III Gender equality – a “right” of passage
Discrimination and equality are human rights issues that are enshrined under Article 7 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Equality between men and women was not a concept recognised in Australian legislation or at common law, and therefore equality could not be guaranteed.
In 1986, the establishment of the Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) was ushered in on the back of a raft of anti-discrimination legislation based on race, age, disability and sex - which includes gender equalities, sexual harassment and marital status discrimination under the Sex Discrimination Act. The Workplace Gender Equality Act 2012 (Cth) gave rise to an agency charged with specifically promoting gender equality in the workplace. The function of both these pieces of legislation serve (along with legislation supplemented at the State levels) is to ‘eliminate’ discriminations (which usually only affects women), in order to achieve egalitarianism and social equality.
To some, the gender agenda may appear less significant compared to other rights, especially those that guard against evils. However, the instances and problems of gender inequality are very...

Find Another Essay On Is Gender Inequality and More Pressing Issue Than Freedom

Gender Differences and Inequality Essay

748 words - 3 pages Tanaka’s paper aimed at discussing the issue of gender difference and possible inequality in the context of Japanese language under formal setting (Tanaka 2009). The objective of this essay is to find out whether Japanese language had changed over time on the aspect of different language strategies and methods adopted by different genders. Firstly, statistics of allocation of talks and times of interruptions were gathered from ten formal

Gender Inequality and Family Structure Essay

863 words - 4 pages Gender Inequality and Family Structure Gender is the oldest form of categorization among society. The problem is not that gender is a differentiating category, but that the female gender is exploited through both benevolent and hostile sexism that creates unequal conditions. Given the biology of males and females, physically and neurologically, it is not farfetched to assume that it is natural for men and women to have tendencies associated

Sex Stereotypes and Gender Inequality

2414 words - 10 pages first sentence and a man for the second. Why does these professions paint a picture of a particular gender in your mind? Stereotypes. Most of the population is indoctrinated by the agenda of gender stereotyping. In this essay, I will give a whirlwind overview of this social construct and its evolution from the obvious to more covert in the western world.Whose story is it anyway?Is our genetic makeup such that we are trying to achieve something

Evaluating the View that Poverty is Caused by Economic Inequality Rather than Cultural Attitudes and Lifestyles

2000 words - 8 pages of labour, it divides the working class (therefore there is no united working class which could threaten to overthrow the bourgeois and it drives down benefit levels and thus increases the motivation to work. He argued that only the abolition of capitalism would lead to the abolition of inequality. However, Jack Kincaid's work was criticised in many ways, it did not explain how some groups were more prone to poverty than

War is nothing more than organized crime

992 words - 4 pages Organised crime is not relative. It is universally condemned, because most right-thinking individuals realise that such activity is detrimental to the human race as a whole. War on the other hand refuses to be evaluated objectively, because it is an act of violence sanctioned by the state, an amorphous entity claiming to represent the views, beliefs and morality of its citizenry, and that is why war is far more insidious than organised crime

Social Justice Is More Than A Definition

1449 words - 6 pages of life. Some of the issues are poverty, immigration, racism, and government, as well as women, gay, and minority groups’ rights, amongst many others. The aim of those who advocate for social justice is to reach equality throughout. For example, it raises the issue of why is there poverty in the world? Why is there such a big gap between the wealthy and the poor? What can we do about it? Why are some races given more privileges than others

"Beauty Is More Than Skin Deep"

1288 words - 5 pages Simran MalekPersuasive Speech:"Beauty is more than skin deep" It's everywhere. You can't escape it. It's sprawled across flashy billboards with alluring models. It's plastered throughout all kinds of magazines and books. Celebrities ooze with it. And's it's all too friendly with teens; it overpowers their very being like too much axe in the gym change room. It's the pressure of beauty. Good morning/afternoon students, teachers, judges and fellow

Money is more Important than Education

774 words - 3 pages greater the benefits in terms of salary and other compensations such as health and fringe benefits that have high monetary values. In closing and before I take your question I leave you with this : If you were to check the list of Fortune 500 company bosses, you would find that more than half of them never attended university. In fact, many of them never even finished High School. Even the richest of the rich Bill Gates is a Harvard drop out

How Nurture is More Dominant than Nature

1349 words - 6 pages Nurture plays a more dominant role in human development than nature Undoubtedly, humans are unique and intricate creatures and their development is a complex process. It is this process that leads people to question, is a child’s development influenced by genetics or their environment? This long debate has been at the forefront of psychology for countless decades now and is better known as “Nature versus Nurture”. The continuous controversy over

Why EQ is More Important than IQ

1514 words - 6 pages Why EQ is More Important than IQ For decades, a lot emphasis has been put on certain aspect of intelligence. This intelligence is called IQ ( Intelligence Quotient ). IQ includes aspects of Mathematics, spatial learning, Verbal, logical reasoning, and memory. This intelligence could predict to a significant degree of performances and some degree of personal and professional success. However, some people with fabulous IQ scores are doing

Critical Thinking Is More than Common Sense

1291 words - 5 pages , thinking and application of the material take priority over the simple memorization of facts. As the Center for Critical Thinking’s Director of Research Richard Paul puts it, “It is thinking about thinking while thinking in order to make thinking better: more clear, more accurate, more relevant, more deep, more broad, and more effective.” In short, critical thinking yields a better education, and that is something an educational institution should

Similar Essays

Freedom Is More Valued Than Security

1812 words - 7 pages country will not allow its government to achieve either, as both will affect the country significantly in a negative spotlight. However, balancing freedom and security doesn’t take away all the problems, as having same amount of freedom and security is impossible in reality and will soon tip into either side, and having more security than freedom will make citizens protest outside and inside of the area of influence by the government, and the

Education As A Freedom: Talking About Gender And Race Inequality

804 words - 4 pages discussing and creating dialogue over race and gender inequality. To venture into becoming active agents of educational freedom is to actively become conscious of the systematic workings for marginalized students. For instance, when discussing race and gender inequality, it is easy for individuals to view them as separate problems while also putting one as a primary issue and the other as a secondary. Yet, by disconnecting the two issues, individuals

"All Genders Are Equal, But One Gender Is More Equal Than The Other." A Researched Journalistic Column On Feminism

1151 words - 5 pages All genders are equal, but one gender is more equal than the other.Since the beginning of the feminism movement in the 1960s, feminist ideologies and propaganda has littered the floors of society with 'equal rights' objectives and taboo subtexts. __ investigates if the continuing and widespread gender equality movement is in all reality, progress towards a truly utopian society.The roots of feminism can be directly traced back to Marxist

Gender Roles Are Nothing More Than Social Constructs, Discuss

2055 words - 8 pages , sensitive side. The traditional male is a dominant bully who feels the need to show his authority to women, he thinks that women are just an inferior copy of himself, the new man (the one in touch with his feminine side) has seen the error of his ways and strives to be more like women. A man is not born a 'man' as such but he is created by the culture he grows up in. The postmodernist view of gender differences is that all knowledge is