Is Hunting An Animal For Food Ehtical

1159 words - 5 pages

There was a time when hunting an animal for food was necessary for survival, but meat is now processed and packaged for our convenience. I have never hunted an animal, although I have gone fishing and in some respects, I could ask if fishing is as ethical as hunting an animal for food. I remember how it felt to cast my line out, reeling it in slowly hoping to get a bite. When I did get a bite, the fight between the fish and me was thrilling. In retrospect, the same feeling is similar, a hunter has after he stalked and killed a deer or elk. However, does the feeling of excitement when you have caught and killed animal right? Do we rationalize killing an animal for food to mask the excitement that comes from the kill? I would say yes to that, because I really did not need that fish for food even though I did eat it I still enjoyed the catching of it. Yet, there are those who do hunt for food, in remote areas it would be easier to hunt game than to drive 20 or 30 miles into the local town for hamburger. Perhaps for them there is a justification to hunt. As Peter Singer writes, “Eskimos living in an environment where they must kill animals for food or starve might be justified in claiming that their interest in surviving overrides that of the animals they kill.”(Singer) Nevertheless, that still does not answer the question is it still ethical to hunt and kill an animal for food?
However, there are many who would say that hunting an animal for food is justified because it helps to keep the herds by culling and protects them from over population that could lead to starvation, disease, or predation. Culling is a naturalistic fallacy based on a false premise that we are saving the animal from a terrible long drawn out death, which is not the case. Hunters kill a healthy, strong animal that would normally have many years of life while predators kill those that are weak or old. As for disease and starvation, you could argue that keeping the herds small would give them a better chance of survival owing to the fact they would be stronger due to not overgrazing and would be able to fight off diseases. This too, is a naturalistic fallacy because a small herd is just as likely to face starvation and disease as a larger herd.
A utilitarian would argue that by killing a deer or elk would bring harm to the animal, but the benefit to the hunter who wants food would outweigh the harm done to the animal. When you think of the utilitarian idea that each person has equal value and that harm is allowed if the benefit does the most good for the most people sounds like a way you can prove killing for food. For many that justification is not good enough because to them the animal has as many rights as a human and their desires or feelings to life are as important as ours are. As Tom Regan states “A universe in which you satisfy your desire for water, food and warmth is, other things being equal, better than a universe in which these desires are frustrated. Moreover,...

Find Another Essay On Is Hunting an Animal for Food Ehtical

For the Love of Food : Who is responsible for weight?

1427 words - 6 pages 259-288). Food at these [“fast food” restaurants] is generally high in energy density-the energy content per unit weight-and fat, while providing few nutritional benefits (Davis 259-288). The high energy density of the fast food thus “challenges our appetite control systems with conditions for which they were never designed.” A typical meal at a fast food restaurant may account for over eighty percent of the recommended daily allowance for fat

The Cove: an Analysis of Argumentation for Animal Rights

1076 words - 5 pages human entertainment at water parks and resorts worldwide. From the same utilitarian perspective it is hard to find the exact balance of those made happy versus the suffering of the dolphins related to be geographically transplanted into captivity. Animal rights utilitarian Peter Singer would argue that animals as fellow living sentient beings must be treated equally, and would therefore find captivity to be an unethical. I, on the other hand, do

Concerns for the Safety of Human and Animal Food During Transportation

3100 words - 13 pages of proper equipment for the loading of food products before they are transported to other area on the country and the lack of security. In order for these problems to the fixed and restore a proper and healthy means of transporting human and animal foods, there issues needs to be dealt with, which is why ideal regulations of Sanitary Transportation of Human and Animal Foods was put in place whereby the transportation of foods will be executed

Technology IS running our food! - an argument style essay

650 words - 3 pages irradiation is a processing method where the foods are exposed to ionising radiation (gamma rays from radioactive cobalt or an electron beam are commonly used). Irradiation changes the atoms, producing ions so it doesn't make the food radioactive like microwaves but the high-frequency radiation penetrates the food. It kills bacteria, moulds & insects, delays fruits from ripening and prevent vegetables from sprouting.Scientists argue over whether

This essay is an investigative report on "Fast Food Nation"

727 words - 3 pages that show how an increase in minimum wage would cause a very slight spike in the price of fast food. The article researched minimum wage increases in past years and the affect they had on the price of food. In 1992, minimum wage was increased fifty cents and the price of fast food was only raised approximately one cent.The article supports Schlosser's argument that for every dollar increase to minimum wage the price of fast food would rise a mere

Do People Really Know What is Sacrificed for Animal Testing?

941 words - 4 pages every day, right this very second. People do not like to think about these horrible things because they would have to realize that these horrific things are really going on. Hundreds of animals across the world die each day and for what? Drug, food, cosmetic, and medical tests? Some argue that animal testing is needed to advance in medicine. Scientists say that millions of lives have been saved thanks to animal testing. On the other hand, people

In Animal Farm, how is language important for gaining power.

1197 words - 5 pages Language is a very powerful tool that can be manipulated to become an instrument of control. Put differently, it can become a resource for accumulating great amounts of power, but if abused, can eventually lead to huge adversities. A quintessential example of this is the novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell. In this novel, a pig, which is the leader of animals on a farm, sets out his Utopian ideals of what might become of the future of Animal

This is an essay with a comparison of Animal Farm to 1984

1301 words - 5 pages and the only enemy against them is "man". They believed that they were better off without the humans and that they would live even better lives than the humans."The animals were happy as they had never conceived it possible to be. Every mouthful of food was an acute positive pleasure, now that it was truly their own food, produced by themselves and for themselves, not doled out to them by a grudging master" (pg. 24)The animals are isolated from

Respect for All Natural Living Beings: An argument to Acknowledge All animal Rights in Society

1860 words - 7 pages someone to stand up for their rights; rights that can no longer be disregarded by being overlooked. It is my belief that animals should be respected, and afforded ethical and human treatment by society instead of being looked at as a source of food. In a society where animals have no voice, it is everyone’s civic duty to participate in the animal rights movement and acknowledge animals as living beings, which share genetic relationships to the

This is an essay on animal experimentation, specializing in the Cosmetic section

810 words - 3 pages the food and drug administration.Now as a country, I think we would all agree that it is good to keep our money in the country, and there is no disagreement with that.There is no cosmetic testing in Australia, which means the entire animal testing for cosmetics come from overseas.So why would be buy products that get imported from major countries round the world, where the goods come in and the money comes out?Why do we buy from a company made in

This is an essay i wrote on animal testing and why it should be stopped

633 words - 3 pages this oven cleaner. Believe it or not, this testing goes on everyday and is a common form of testing for several products. Other products such as eye shadow and soap are tested on rabbits, guinea pigs, rats, dogs, and many other animals, despite the fact that the test results do not help prevent or treat human illness or injury. Animal testing is morally and humanely wrong because of the lives they take, the form of testing, and they ways testing

Similar Essays

Animal Farm Is An Animal Satire

1156 words - 5 pages Animal Farm is an animal satire through which Orwell indirectly criticizes the Russian Communism, Stalinism by using animals to portray the different classes of people. The aim of satire is to criticize the object of attack, teaching a moral indirectly with a humorous tone, in the animal satire, the author uses animals instead of human beings and places his animals in human situations. Thus Orwell is able to attack on the political ideas and

'having A High Intelligence Is Not Necessarily An Advantage.' To What Extent Is This Shown To Be True In Flowers For Algernon And Good Will Hunting?

800 words - 3 pages To a lot of people, intelligence is everything, but is it? In the novel, Flowers for Algernon, intelligence is the main desire for the main character Charlie. But in the film, Good Will Hunting, the main character has intelligence, but has no goal, and when given several options to take, Will refuses one after another.Most intelligent people have never had any problems with the law. They know right from wrong, which places to go and which places

Animal Rights Is A Cause For Vegetarianism

743 words - 3 pages Animal Rights - Cause for Vegetarianism The choice of eating meat or not has been a debated issue for a continued number of years. There have long since been two sides: the proponents and opponents of meat consumption. More and more debates of its value and effect on the world have risen. Many claim it is wrong, while others think of it as a needed pleasure. Today, a greater percentage of the population eats meat. Only a few individuals seek

Privately Owning And Properly Caring For An Exotic Animal

2503 words - 11 pages Privately Owning and Properly Caring for an Exotic Animal Owning an exotic pet risks the owners life and the animal’s life when the animal is not under the correct care. This has been an issue in recent history when pets escape and maul citizens or the animal is harmed by not being fully cared for, or if it has to be killed due to the danger it has caused. However, these accidents and tragedies are advertised globally and cover up the great