Island Tree School District Vs. Pico Benjamin Waldman Civics/4 B 1/12/14

1157 words - 5 pages

“'Forget books,”'said Rosewater, throwing that particular book under his bed. 'The hell with 'em.' 'That sounded like an interesting one,' said Valencia.”
-Slaughter-House Five by Kurt Vonnegut
In 1975 the “interesting” books for students of the Island Tree School District were nearly thrown under the bed forever. The Island Tree School District was presented with a complaint from the group Parents of New York United that posed a concern regarding the content of library materials. This community was concerned that public school libraries in the district were exceedingly “permissive” with the books they provided for students. The list of books that the Parents of New York United were wary of were: “Slaughter-House Five,” by Kurt Vonnegut; “The Fixer,” by Bernard Malamud; “The Naked Ape,” by Desmond Morris; “Down These Mean Streets,” by Piri Thomas; “Best Short Stories of Negro Writers,” edited by Langston Hughes; “A Hero Ain't Nothin' but a Sandwich,” by Alice Childress; “Soul on Ice,” by Eldridge Cleaver; “A Reader for Writers,” edited by Jerome Archer, and “Go Ask Alice,” by an anonymous author(New York Times, 1982). The Island Tree School Board complied with the Parents of New York United's concern and took these books off school shelves in early 1976.
Five students, lead by Senior Steven Pico, gathered to object the school board's ruling and filed a lawsuit that made it to the Supreme Court in 1982. They stated that the Parents of New York United's concern was based solely in a complain about the books going against the group's subjective values, and not the objective value of providing quality education to the students of the Island Tree School District. The student's objection to the school board's ruling to remove the “anti-American, anti-Christian, anti-Semitic, and just plain filthy.” books garnered attention from free speech organizations and concerned libraries.
When the case made it to the Supreme Court the Justices that presided over the ruling were Justices Powell, Blackmun, Brennan, Stevens, Marshall, White, O'Connor, Rehnquist, and Chief Justice Burger. In a majority ruling of three out of four, Pico and his fellow students were rewarded for their fight for freedom of speech in their education. Though the Parents of New York United continued to raise their concerns about morality in the school system with the presence of these books, they were stunned silent when the Supreme Court set the precedent that the First Amendment of the United State's Constitution played a role in the material public schools could provide for their students.
A precedent was also set to appease the Parents of New York United. The books that had been removed in 1976 were required to have a parental advisory stamp printed on them so that parents could be made aware of the potentially immoral content that their children may have been exposed to. In this instance the Supreme Court Justices exercised an interpretation of the Constitution that has...

Find Another Essay On Island Tree School District vs. Pico Benjamin Waldman Civics/4B 1/12/14

Freedom of Speech

3056 words - 12 pages distributor of magazines and books, had been indicted in 1954 for using the mail to advertise anddistribute material with sexual content, notably Aubrey Beardsley's Venus and Tannhäuser. His conviction was upheld. (ACLU Website)In the year of 1969 a monumental case occurred. Tinker vs. Des Moines Independent School District. John and Mary Beth Tinker objected to the Vietnam war that had become the main focus of the country at the time. In

Closing The Gap Essay

1473 words - 6 pages and 57% free and reduced lunch. About 40% of the parents have an education beyond high school. The NFAY population averages around 14%, meaning that 14 out of every 100 students were not enrolled for a full academic year. These students either left the school district or entered the district or both during the school year. Participant selection. The students used in this study will be a convenience sample. This site was chosen because the

The Passamaquoddy Indians

2535 words - 10 pages inhabited the tribe's other reservation, Indian Township (Waldman 1). After Gellers' representation of the tribe ended, the tribe hired attorney Tom Turner, who was fresh out of law school. Turner believed that the 1794 treaty was null and void. He wanted to base the tribe's claim on the 1790 Trade and Intercourse Act of Congress. This stipulated that no sale of Indian land was valid without authority of the federal government. In 1975

Human Development: Basic Trust vs. Basic Mistrust (Birth to 18 Months)

2274 words - 9 pages continues to thrive and successfully moves forward to the next stage of life – industry vs. inferiority. Stage 4: Industry vs. Inferiority (6 to 12 Years) In the fourth stage of Erikson’s theory, children must address the crisis of industry vs. inferiority with school being the major focus of their lives (Zastrow & Kirst-Ashman, 2007). They are faced with the external demands to learn new social and academic skills to achieve - industry, or

Censorship in schools

1607 words - 7 pages . Pico, the Island Trees Union Free School District School Board removed 11 books from its library’s shelves (Emert). The books that were removed contained subject matter that was considered inappropriate for the students to read. These subjects include vulgar language, innuendos, and things that could be offensive to students (Emert). Some of the students’ parents found out about this and they filed a lawsuit against the school district. They

Ideals of Humanism

1531 words - 7 pages sonnets as well as his plays. In “Sonnet 18,” he compares his lover “to a summer’s day,” and claims that her “eternal summer shall not fade” (Shakespeare, “Sonnet 18” 1, 9). By comparing the subject of the poem to an eternal summer day, Shakespeare portrays her as immortal and divine, which exemplifies the perfectibility of humans which Pico della Mirandola describes in his Oration on the Dignity of Man. He describes his lover as a precious jewel

Supreme Court cases who's decisions have greatly impacted society. (Veronia vs. Acton (1995), Planned Parenthood vs. Casey (1992), Lee vs. Weisman (1991), and United States vs. Lopez (1995)

1011 words - 4 pages . The District Court held all the provisions unconstitutional, and permanently enjoined their enforcement. The Court affirmed in part and reversed in part, striking down the husband notification provision but upholding the others.The case of Lee vs. Weisman deals with the question of prayer in school. Nathan Bishop Middle School in Providence, Rhode Island, was in the habit of inviting clergy to offer prayers at graduation ceremonies. Deborah Weisman

observation of jonah

515 words - 3 pages Heaven. (vs. 9)The Lord God of Heaven made the sea and the dry land. (vs. 9)The men knew Jonah was fleeing from the presence of the Lord because he told them. (vs. 11)Jonah asked the sailors to pick him up and throw him in the sea to calm it. (vs. 12)Jonah took accountability of the storm coming up on the sailors. (vs. 12)The sailors prayed to the Lord that they wouldn't perish on account of Jonah. (vs. 14)The sailors picked Jonah up and threw

Tinker vs. Des Moines

746 words - 3 pages thing. Works Cited Kushner, Sherrill. "Dress Codes Vs. Free Speech." Cobblestone 19.1 (1998): 29. MasterFILE Complete. Web. 29 Oct. 2013. Remy, Richard C., Gary E. Clayton, and John J. Patrick. "Supreme Court Cases." Civics Today. Columbus, Ohio: Glencoe, 2008. 796. Print. "Tinker V. Des Moines Independent Community School District." Supreme Court Cases: The Dynamic Court (1930-1999)(1999): N.PAG. Points of View Reference Center. Web. 29 Oct. 2013.\

Benjamin Rush

2281 words - 9 pages . They settled in Byberry Township, a farming community made up of predominantly Quakers near Philadelphia. Five generations of Rushes went on to live in this community. [1: Alyn Brodsky, Benjamin Rush: Patriot and Physician (New York: Truman Talley Books, 2004), 17.][2: Carl Binger, Revolutionary Dotor: Benamin Rush, 1746-1813 (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., 1966), 19.]John's eldest son was named William Rush. William was Benjamin's

The History of Piracy: A Closer Look at Early Pirates

1472 words - 6 pages activity that the world has knowledge of is back in the seventh century BC (Matthews 1). By the mid 13th century BCE pirates had become the dominant seafaring people of the Mediterranean, committing acts of piracy (Waldman). The Golden Age of Piracy was when pirate activity increased greatly. The Golden Age of Piracy dated 1660 to 1730 (Matthews 2). The act of piracy was a crime on the seas. For over 2,500 years pirates lurked along trading routes

Similar Essays

Board Of Education V. Pico Essay

811 words - 4 pages Education, Island). Works Cited "Board of Education, Island Trees Union Free School District No. 26, ET AL. v. Pico, By His Next Friend Pico ET AL." N.p., n.d. Web. 12 May 2014. . "Board of Education v. Pico." Case Briefs. N.p., n.d. Web. 12 May 2014.

The Removal Of Books From Schools And Dress Codes

680 words - 3 pages taught children witch craft. A big court case in books is Board of Education v. Pico. In 1976 Island Trees Union Free School District removed 11 books from their high schools. The books consisted of The Fixer by Bernard Malamud, Laughing Boy by Oliver Lafarge, Black Boy by Richard Wright, Go Ask Alice by Anonymous, and A Hero Ain’t Nothing but a Sandwich by Alice Childress. The books were removed because of language, sex, and other materials. In

Argumentation Of The Case Involving Tinker And The Des Moines School District Over Freedom Of Expression

1274 words - 5 pages , Tinker vs. Des Moines, brought the Freedom of Speech amendment all the way to the Supreme Court. The Petitioners in this case were John Tinker, Christopher Eckhardt, and Mary Beth Tinker. At the time of the original trial, all three petitioners were students in the Des Moines School District and their ages were 15, 16, and 13 respectively.The three students were suspended from school for wearing black armbands to protest the governments

The Incredible Place That Is Cuba

1163 words - 5 pages . 2013. Web. Iyer, Pico. “Cuban Evolution.” Time Magazine 8 July 2013: 58-65. Student Research Center. Web. 10 May 2014. Sweig, Julia E., and Michael J. Buscamente. “Cuba after Communism.” Foreign Affairs July Aug. 2013: 101-14. Student Research Center. Web. 12 May 2014. Hahn, Laura M. “Famous Cuban Immigrants.” Cuban Americans (2003): 54-56 Student Research Center. Padgett Tim, Dolly Mascareñas, and Siobhan Morrissey. “Cuba’s Chance