Children And Family Relationship Bill 2013: Parental Uncertainty In Cases Of Guardianship, Custody And Access

3174 words - 13 pages

[1.1] Introduction
In certain scenarios, where the law in Ireland fails to explicitly outline the rights of the parent, the judicial adjudication in relation to guardianship, custody and access is fundamental to ensuring that the well-being of the child remains secure. Although there is some sense of legal certainty in respect of married parents and their children, this is not consistent with the situation that non-marital parents sometimes face due to the outdated legislation of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964(1964 Act) as amended. This uncertainty has been a catalyst for the drafting of the Children and Family Relationship Bill 2013 (2013 Bill). The 2013 Bill aims to establish a legal framework which can support the many divergent family dynamics which are present in twenty first century Ireland. It is hoped that such a framework will provide legal pellucidity in regards to the rights and duties of parents within a non-traditional family model.
This submission will outline the law in Ireland today, while simultaneous highlighting the flaws and issues that are present within our legal framework in relation to parental uncertainty in cases of guardianship, custody and access. The 2013 Bill and its implications will also be addressed, accompanied by a critique of the relevant sections.
[1.2] Analysis
Although the 1964 Act provides guidance and clarity in some circumstances, it fails to provide a definition of the precise nature or range of responsibilities that arise from being a guardian. However, the courts have accepted guardianship to mean the rights and duties of parents in relation to the raising of their child. More notably, this piece of legislation is also quite restrictive on who can achieve automatic guardianship of a child. Under s.6 a married mother and father of a child enjoy an automatic guardianship right, which illustrates the influence of the traditional marriage based family. This influence was also recognised by O Dalaigh CJ in the B v B case, where he stated that s.6 merely reaffirms the meaning of Article 42 of the Constitution. However, where a mother is granted automatic guardianship, regardless of her marital status, a father does not enjoy the same privilege. It could be argued that an unmarried father has similar rights to that of a non-parent as under s9 of the 1964 Act a relative of the child in question or an individual who has functioned as a loco parentis to that child can also apply for access, just as an unmarried father can. S.10 of the 1964 Act also outlines that an unmarried mother holds the position as custodian of her child. However, the father’s right to custody, like his right to access and guardianship is not automatic and can only be attained if an application is made to the courts. This was praised in State (Nicolaou) v An Bord Uchtala by Henchy J, as he regarded the mother’s right to automatic guardianship as in accordance with Article 40.3 of the Constitution.
Given the...

Find Another Essay On Children and Family Relationship Bill 2013: Parental Uncertainty in Cases of Guardianship, Custody and Access

Child Custody and Homosexuality. Ethics in Psychology/Counseling or dealing with children

2630 words - 11 pages Standards, Expertise, and Experts in the Resolution of Contested Child Custody Cases. Psychology, Public Policy and Law, 6, 843-879.Murphy, J.A., Rawlings, E.J., & Howe, S.R. (2001). A survey of clinical psychologists on treating lesbian, gay, and bisexual clients. Professional Pychology: Research and Practice, 33, 183-189.Patterson C.J., (1993) Lesbian and Gay Parenting: A Resource for Psychologists - summary of research findings. APA's Committee on Women in Psychology (CWP), Committee on Lesbian and Gay Concerns (CLGC), and Committee on Children, Youth, and Families (CYF) 4-8.

Relationship Between Parental Acceptance and Psychological Adjustment

1996 words - 8 pages without properly examining if fathers and their parenting style has any influence on it or not (as cited in Rohner & Veneziano, 2001). Suggestions for future study in PARTheory should look into considering the social, cultural and economic aspect in the relationship between paternal and maternal acceptance and children or adults development. For example, the family’s social economic status and size of family may affects the parent-child interaction

Validation of the Parental Knowledge and Attitude towards Antibiotic Usage and Resistance among Children in Tetovo, Republic of Macedonia

2179 words - 9 pages present study were expecting antibiotics to speed up the recovery of their children from common cold (77%). According to Bauchner et al. (1999) the need for a quick recovery in order to return to child care could further contribute to the parental misuse of antibiotics in communities that depend on institutional rather than family child care. In the study done by Romman (2013), more than half of respondents (52.5%) that are 5% more as compared to

Validation of the Parental Knowledge and Attitude Towards antibiotic Usage and Resistance among Children in Tetovo, Republic of Macedonia

2500 words - 10 pages tell them about the usage of antibiotics for their children. Works Cited Al-Azzam SI, Al-Husein BA, Alzoubi F, Masadeh MM, Al-Horani MA (2007) Self-medication with antibiotics in jordanian population. Int J Occup Med Environ Health 20(4):373–380. doi:10.2478/v10001-007-0038-9 Al-Dossari K (2013) Parental knowledge, attitude and practice on antibiotic use for upper respiratory tract infections in children. Majmaah J. Health Sciences 1(1

Criminal Investigations, In Custody and Miranda Warnings

853 words - 4 pages of the term in custody. If a person is in custody, under arrest, the police have to read them the Miranda Rights, especially if they want to question them and use it as evidence in their trial. If the person is not in custody, under arrest, the Miranda warning is not required and information the person gives will be used in a trial if the person is charged with the crime committed. In custody is usually at a point in which an officer doesn’t

Relationship: Mother and Children in Literature

2003 words - 9 pages Tohidul Alam Professor Whitaker English 130-40 May 21, 2014 Class Time: Monday & Wednesday 2:15 to 4:05 Pm Relationship: Mother and children In this world, there is a lot of relation exist, and relation basically depend on love, affection, care, respect, trust etc. Relation often lie between two or more people who have enough faith on each other; such as, relation between friend, relation between teacher, relation between classmates and such

Children, Family and Society

2436 words - 10 pages and sense of belonging to a culture. Whereas childhood play allows a child to explore without set boundaries there identity, also there identity in relation to peers, there family, wider community and society. Vygotsky who “saw pretend play as a zone of proximal development in which children advance their learning. By constructing make-believe scenarios children are grappling with internal ideas, coming to understand that thinking is separate

Gender and Child Custody

993 words - 4 pages created such movements as the 'father's right's movement' where they were determined to appeal to the masses by attempting to change the ideology of guardianship and the role of the mother. Nancy D. Polikoff, who wrote the article 'Gender and Child Custody Determinations: Exploding the Myths', attempts to clear some of the mis-conceptions about the guardianship of children in referring to the father's claim's.Polikoff's argument about gender and

Uncertainty in Heart of Darkness and The Stranger

1021 words - 4 pages uncertainty and tension in The Stranger when Meursault gains certainty and the tension that then flows from the book. While the correlation in show in Heart of Darkness when Marlow is uncertain and the tension around him heightens. In both The Stranger and Heart of Darkness, the authors choose a first person limited narrator to obscure the facts, but for different purposes. In The Stranger, Meursault makes assumptions to carry the plot but

What are parental rights and how do they apply in specific family law situations?

3015 words - 12 pages I.Introduction of topic: What are parental rights and how do they apply in specific family law situations?II.Definition of termsA.Pro PerB.Sole legal custodyC.Joint legal custodyD.Primary physical custodyE.VisitationF.Child custody proceedingIII.Options available for Family Court representationA. Retain an attorney1.Advantage: Attorney understands rights and rules of the court; Speaks on behalf of the parent in court2.Disadvantage: Costly legal

Relationship Between Child and Family

1762 words - 7 pages In the early stages of a child’s character development, the family is the first social group that the child has. The relationship that is fostered between the family and the child is important, because it is the role of the family that influences the child’s behavior. Although the child may be influenced by the father and siblings, these relationships are looked to second. The child realizes early that the family belongs to him. This leads to

Similar Essays

Adult Children And Their Fathers: Relationship Changes 20 Years After Parental Divorce

1792 words - 7 pages spouse. Even if the divorce decree is flexible and gives fathers the rights of custody, custodial mothers often define and control the terms of visitation. However, parents from a cooperative relationship are less likely to engage in power struggles over the children. It is also known that when the parental relationship is unsupportive and filled with conflict the nonresidential fathers often withdraw from their children as a way to avoid all conflict

Is There A Significan Relationship Between Access To Piped Water And Knowledge Of Personal Hygene Among Salvadoran Children

1800 words - 8 pages The purpose of this study was to determine if a statistically significant relationship existed among Salvadoran children’s access to piped water and knowledge of personal hygiene. This study utilized data collected from a mission trip to El Salvador in January 2014; therefore the study is cross sectional. Data was collected via VCOM surveys, some of which were adapted from Save the Children. Study population The population of interest was

Parental Responsibility Parents Are Guardians Of God’s Children And Are

840 words - 3 pages Parental Responsibility Parents are guardians of God's children and are to train, educate, and care for them ~ Quote, (1) "We are the guardians of our children; their training and education are committed to our care, and if we do not ourselves pursue a course which will save then from the influence of evil, when we are weighed in the balance we shall be found wanting. FOUND WANTING? ~ Start at the beginning. I THINK: it's scary and difficult to

Review Of The Findings Of The Joint Parliamentary Standing Committee On Family And Community Affairs In Their Inquiry Into Child Custody Issues Of Australia

1188 words - 5 pages for more than 30% of the time.After the completion of the six month investigation the committee recommended that Part 7 of the Family Law Act 1975 should be amended so as to create a clear presumption, that can be rebutted, in favour of equal and shared parental responsibility. They recommended amendment of Part 7 Family Law Act 1975 to create a clear presumption against shared parental responsibility with respect to cases where there is a history