Leadership And Women Essay

1145 words - 5 pages

Leadership theories and women
Bass, 1990, explains that the word ‘‘leadership’’ was initially used to explain political influence and control of the British Parliament in the 1800s. He further elaborates that leadership was based on heritage and appointment and used to take place often in Anglo-Saxon countries (Bass, 1990, p. 11). Katz and Kahn, 1966, p.334 expands that leadership is to acknowledge the skill to influence others on organisational relevance. Michener et al. (1990) described leadership ‘‘as a process that takes place in groups in which one member influences and controls the behaviour of the other members towards some common goal’’ (cited in Denmark, 1993, p. 343), signifying that the control of employees was a required aspect of effective leadership. The assumption therefore is that if someone is to lead, he should extend beyond influence. This comprises motivation and helping others to accomplish the goals of the organisation.

The Great Man theory of leadership assumed that personal attributes of a great man determined the course of history (Denmark, 1993). The great man was thought to have distinctive and exceptional features and traits that distinguished him from his followers (Bass, 1990). Only very few people were thought to have such abilities, which were believed to be inherent, in other words, leaders were born with these qualities (Denmark, 1993).
During this time, women were not taken into account as possible leaders. The name given to sum up this theory illustrates that women were not professed as leaders in any capacity, and even research on leadership during this period related exclusively to males. It is therefore proposed that the Great Man theory has not ascribed something towards raising the profile of women in management.

Trait theories were essentially linking traits in manly terms, and these characteristics were considered vital for successful leadership. Women in the 1900s, worked mostly in helping roles in organisations such as secretaries or assistants. By 1940, only 4% of leaders were women (Parker and Fagenson, 1994). The normal work for women then were those of carers, assistants, nurses and teachers but not leading (Koziara et al., 1987). The caring and nurturing characteristics attributed to females were not seen as suitable in the role of leadership. The value bestowed on male characteristics or traits in leadership was inveterate in influential research which described the ‘‘think manager-think male’’ trend (Schein, 1973). It is also assumed that the trait theories did not support the effect of raising the profile of women in leadership. Thus, it is sensible to assume that there was no support drawn from the trait theories which would have had the effect of raising the profile of women in management.

McGregor, 1976, explained that researchers in the 1940s projected that traits only were not sufficient to explicate effective leadership. Interaction of leaders and followers, and situational factors,...

Find Another Essay On Leadership and women

Historical roles of men and women in leadership

1198 words - 5 pages in leadership and the roles of men and women seem to forget the thousands of years of history and the more recent, evolution of gender equality, which has taken place to get to where we are at present day. The key word is evolution; we are slowly but steadily evolving into a better and more efficient society through gender equality. The meaning better society is one that will optimally utilize its best resources, including people. The past and

women in leadership positions Essay

2062 words - 9 pages Information failure exists when some or all of the participants do not have complete information about the situation at hand or when one participant knows more than another; there is an asymmetry of information among different parties. This is the core of the problem that exists in the labor market for top leadership positions and that leads to major barriers for women leaders. There is a lack of women in top leadership positions to provide

The Most Undervalued Leadership Traits of Women, by Glen Llopis

1026 words - 4 pages In a Forbes article written by Glen Llopis, The Most Undervalued Leadership Traits of Women, Llopis, highlights his theories and opinions on each undervalued trait. Llopis provides specific details that make women effective leaders. The author predicates his assessment on women and leadership from his personal and professional experiences. Within the article, Llopis identifies six leadership traits that women naturally possess, which

How Women are Transforming the Practice of Leadership

762 words - 4 pages leadership skills from a very young age is somewhat vague in its own form. Though, there is the existence of instinct. The way humans think and the way the physical, mental and emotional attributes humans develop through time affects the way they act upon others; which eventually affects their instinct. When it comes to developing leadership instinct, Helen Fisher intends to show how women have a naturally-based personal development that leads

Perspective on Women Leadership: The Female Advantage, by Sally Helgensen

990 words - 4 pages can be visible, clothing or skin color as examples, others, however, are not as visible such as upbringing or family situation. Each of these factors could play a role in the leadership style of a leader. One trait that the author of the book uses to distinguish leaders is gender. As much as men and women must be treated the fairly and equally, it cannot be denied that outside of the biological aspect, men and women are slightly different. Each

The Perceived Challenges of Women in Leadership Positions That Prevents Them from Climbing the Corporate Ladder

2430 words - 10 pages The Perceived Challenges of Women in Leadership Positions That Prevents Them from Climbing the Corporate Ladder Introduction For years, women have encountered gender bias in the corporate environment. Men have dominated the workplace making it difficult for women to advance in power and leadership. Gender bias has become problematic for the career oriented women creating barriers such as stereotyping, job advancement, power imbalance, and

Male vs Female Nursing Leadership

2263 words - 9 pages leadership is automatically assigned with gender sensitivity mostly in favor of the male counterpart, even when the female may be as qualified or even more skillful than the man. Despite the fact that in some societies women's status has improved remarkably in the 20th century, however, in many societies women continue to lack access to power and leadership compared with men (Carli & Hagely, 2001).The ability of a leader to manage human and

Leading Ladies

1689 words - 7 pages elements: the leader, the followers, and the surrounding situation or context. An effective leader must know something about each and how they interact.” (Wren, p. 125). In the section “The Leaders”, Wren compiles readings which focus on the leader, bringing to the forefront issues about traits, behaviours, gender and minorities and how they influence leadership. In this essay, I will examine the issue of gender, specifically whether women lead

Woman Leadership in Islam

1157 words - 5 pages In New York, on the 18th of March 2005, a professor of Islamic studies at Virginia Commonwealth University, Amina Wadud, led 150 men and women, in a Friday prayer. This incident is the first of its kind, as it is the first time for a woman to take the religious leadership role in Islam. Of Course, This incident caused a huge debate within the Islamic cultures. Some sheikhs declared there was nothing wrong with women leading prayers, but the big

Leadership Styles and Traits

565 words - 3 pages quarterly’ was about investigations to prove the differences between men and women in leadership. After the investigation, the results had showed that women displayed more transformational behaviors and fewer laissez-faire behaviors than men (Vincenburg, Engen, Eagly, Schimdt, 2011, pp.10). The second study investigated stereotypes about the importance of leadership styles for the promotion of women and men to different levels in organizations

African American Female Leadership

1074 words - 4 pages African American women and leadership are two terms that are rarely found juxtaposed in American history. For centuries, the United States has been governed and controlled by white males. From the days of slavery, to current day, white American males have head many offices, presided over entire nations, and even asked whether or not a customer wanted fries with their meals. White males have been running all aspects of society since the day

Similar Essays

Women And Men In Leadership Essay

1618 words - 6 pages the context. In direct communication the sender is responsible for clear and effective communication. Male leaders tend to transmit a message through words rather than nonverbal actions, as they see communication as a way of exchanging information and ideas. Now, we will look at the leadership styles of women and compare them to those of men. Contrary to men, women have been known to have a transformational leadership style. Transformational

Men And Women In Leadership Styles

888 words - 4 pages female scholar. Consequently, women began taking aim for positions as physicians, attorneys, engineers, and practitioner (p. 10). The women’s movement quickly spread through multiple groups and professional organizations pushing to enforce laws prohibiting discrimination against women in the work force. However, the trend of women in leadership positions remain repressed. In the 1990’s, business and organizational leaders witnessed an impressive

Leadership Prejudices Of Men And Women In The Workplace

1840 words - 7 pages This research paper will take a symbolic interactionist perspective to contrast the different leadership prejudices of men and women in the workplace. The age-old debate of inequality for women in executive position will now be examined through online periodicals that show gender stereotypes in the workforce, different strategies men and women use to break the glass ceiling of the workplace, a focus on the interactions and reactions of a male

Preparing Women For Public Leadership: Programs And Strategies

2935 words - 12 pages Preparing Women for Public Leadership: Programs and Strategies While we know that women are underrepresented in all facets of public leadership – from political to corporate and local to global – we have a particularly compelling reason to explore this issue in our immediate regional context. Pennsylvania ranks 44th out of the 50 states (CAWP, 2003) in women’s political participation and serves as an excellent local example of the need to