Leaving The Study Of Religion To Religious People

1058 words - 4 pages

Leaving the Study of Religion to Religious People

Assuming that "religion" here has the same meaning as one of the definitions referred to in O U Block 4 Unit 14 (and in particular is an activity caught by Ninian Smart's The Nature of Religion, A5 Resource Book 3) we still need to know what is meant by "religious people" before we can properly answer the question posed for this essay. By "religious people", presumably the question is not referring to theologians but ordinary people who follow a particular religion. If that is the case then it is felt that the study of religion should be left to religious people. However, this is not without its problems.

One of the problems in leaving the study of religion to religious people is in determining whether they will be objective. Will a Christian when studying, say, Islamic Fundamentalism, be prejudiced in favour of his own faith or will he treat the Islamic religion impartially? Until the Enlightenment in the eighteenth century, Christians referred to, for instance, Judaism as being "false or devilish". It was only after the Enlightenment that Europeans gave names to religions other than those found on the continent and although these were European inventions they were not always right. For example, according to Bill Heilbronn (an authority on Hinduism) , Hinduism was wrongly named and should have correctly been referred to as the Vedic religion.

It could be argued that non religious scholars are better placed to study religion. They are usually analytical, dispassionate and, because they have no affinity to one particular, or indeed any religion, can study religion without fear of being accused of prejudice or bias. But what happens when they come up against so called "miracles" -- will they remain dispassionate? Take the case of the woman who became pregnant and gave birth after having received a liver transplant (apparently believed to be only the third woman in the world to have had a baby after such a transplant). Her obstetrician is reported as saying "… doctors are supposed to be cool and professional. But when we come into contact with miracles we find ourselves asking questions about the mystery of life." : see The Times, 11th June 1998, p 1.

Will non religious people have a "feel" for a religion? Whilst they will be able to study a specific religion's beliefs, ceremonies, artefacts, dogma etc. will they be aware of the nuances or idiosyncrasies of that religion -- or have sympathy with it? Take David R. Kinsley writing about Hinduism (or should one now say "the Vedic Religion"?!) in Introduction: Benares. Here, Kinsley can be said to be non religious in that clearly he is not a Hindu. His witting testimony is there for us to read: for instance his description of "the great number" of ascetics to be found in the city of Benares and of their activities. His unwitting testimony,...

Find Another Essay On Leaving the Study of Religion to Religious People

Lifestyles and leaving conditions of the black and white people in Alan Paton's 'Cry, the Beloved Country'

884 words - 4 pages 'Cry, the Beloved Country' is set in 1946 in South Africa, where huge social and political changes had taken place at that time. It was first published in 1948 when Nationalist Party came to power and soon after that apartheid was introduced, establishing the separation of races in every aspect of daily life. Black people were refused voting rights and their role in the Parliament weakened. Alan Paton, in his novel had depicted the differences

Study of Religious Experience Essay

1993 words - 8 pages Can experience be properly categorized in the academic study of religion? Can an experience’s significance be determinate and/or meaning derived? Fundamentally speaking, what is the definition of religious experience? These supporting cast members serve to support the overarching question: how does and/or can one properly study the concept of religious experience? This paper comprises conversations from two persons engaged in this fundamental

Leaving at the Peak of Glory

579 words - 2 pages                 Most believe dying young is one of the greatest tragedies life holds. However, in the poem “To An Athlete Dying Young”, author A.E. Housman contradicts those beliefs. Housman uses the character of an athlete dying in the earlier stages of life to demonstrate the pros of dying at the peak of one’s glory. He does so by presenting this through the eyes of a speaker with a pessimistic view of life. Although a sad reality

A Study of the Druid Religion

2314 words - 10 pages that there isn’t anything that says what they should or shouldn't believe in although they do have a lot of the same beliefs. Some people don’t even consider this practice one of a religion (druidry.org). To them it is simply a way to live (druidry.org). Druids themselves are very open. Because of the flexibility of their belief system, they are very accepting and tolerant of other people (druidry.org). “The Druids hold that the should of a

The True Image of Islam: Religion Isn't Violent, People Are

1649 words - 7 pages terrorism to groups such as the IRA, West Borough Baptist church or the gangs of America. Therefore, religion does not create the act of violence it is the people that create the act of violence in the image of the religion. The true image of Islam is the majority of the Muslims that practice the religion the correct way. The meaning of Islam is full submission to God. Modern Muslims are followers of the book, the Quran, which have interpreted verses

Study of religion assignment

1118 words - 5 pages was to the general public of those times who were interested and engaged with God and religious figures. The birth of Jesus- Background context The birth of Jesus is a highly significant part of not just religious life but also branches into cultural aspects of today’s values and ethics. The scripture describes the event as a very harmonious however stressful time for all involved. The scripture explains that Mary and Joseph rushing to find an

American Women Leaving the Home and Going to Work

2182 words - 9 pages achieve better working conditions and better wages. By 1900, many poor and working-class young women, mostly of Northern white extraction, were leaving the confines and moral structures of their families and elders and venturing forth to the large industrial cities such as New York (Lunbeck 781). There they became enthusiastic participants of the new pleasures that were offered to consumers in the brand-new century. Essentially, these young women

Religious Conviction in Emile Durkheim´s Elementary Forms Of The Religion Life

701 words - 3 pages Emile Durkheim As An Idealist In "Elementary Forms Of The Religion Life" Durkheim's most important rationale in The Elementary Forms was to explain and clarify the generally primordial religious conviction identified by man. However, his focus as a consequence irk a number of outside connection for historians as his fundamental rationale went distinctly ahead of the modernization of an old culture for its own accord; quite the opposite

Reflection Paper For Philosophy Of Religion: The Continous Conflict Between Religious Pluralism And Exclusivism

1707 words - 7 pages Religion has been as part of society as far as its beginnings. All ancient human civilization had some sort of belief in a God or the transcendent. Beliefs have always been an issue within any human society. The belief of the transcendent gives humans a chance or hope for eternal happiness for people who abide their beliefs.But through out history, different religions and beliefs emerged which gives rise to the inconsistency. There are numerous

The Importance of Religion to American Slaves

2131 words - 9 pages The Importance of Religion to American Slaves Whether one notices or not, each person has the right to make choices concerning his or her life. Being able to make these decisions is a God-given right that vibrates in the heart of every human being who claims possession and mastery over his or her own self. However, for slaves, this concept did not exist, and they became the property of someone else with no place to call

Functionality of Religion: Emil Durkheim’s Elementary Forms of Religious Life

1519 words - 6 pages regarded as a way of interpreting the world using a different language. In conclusion, Emil Durkheim in his Elementary Forms of Religious Life explains how religious beliefs and practices unite practitioners into a single moral community and how unification is necessary for society. Religion is indeed functional in terms of providing order and a sense of belonging and identity to individuals. Although religion has been used to manipulate people

Similar Essays

Approaches To The Study Of Religion

1469 words - 6 pages The sociological approach looks at religious belief and practice in relation to the society. Sociologists are interested in two themes, the centrality of religion in society and the diversity of forms it inhabits (Hamilton 1995/2001:1). It regards religion as a social fact subject to empirical observation, which produces empirical evidence (Dillon 2003:7). The sociology of religion is a product of the enlightenment, from which it inherited a

Religious Effects On People Of The World

682 words - 3 pages Two examples of religious effects on the people of the world, which are from opposite ends of the spectrum. One is a good use of people's time and resources - aid to our fellow human beings and the other is the Holy Wars, which took place in approximately 1080 AD.In the brutal era of wars that tore Europe apart in the closing days of the first millennium AD, no period was more confusing, or more tragic, than the nearly two hundred years Europe

Religion The Opiate Of The People

1390 words - 6 pages the Earth is 6000 years old in this Enlightened age must be wiped out fervently and forcefully, their churches must turned into houses of the people or museums of science, their Creation Science textbooks burned, their children turned into Atheists and their preachers committed to lunatic asylums. Their status as religion should be replaced with one of mental disorder, and those who believe in their backward and barbaric ideologies medicated

Domestic Violence: The Barriers To Leaving

1455 words - 6 pages not respond accordingly, and most often force many women to return to their abusers. A woman may become vulnerable as she goes through the stages of leaving her abuser. There are many reasons why a woman becomes vulnerable; guilt, denial, and fear may be among a few reasons, though no matter what the reason may be, abused women must realize the risks they face to injury and death. Women do not realize that the long series of quarrels they