Observing The Similarities And Differences Between Handmaid's Tale And Gattaca

1181 words - 5 pages

Dystopian fiction has dominated human imagination for centuries and themes of

futuristic societies oppressed by bureaucratic and technological control have become consistent

throughout various novels, films and television shows. The absence and mistreatment of

humanity due to factors such as war, famine and poverty criticize current global issues while also

foreshadowing the consequences of those issues if left unresolved. Both Margaret Atwood’s The

Handmaid’s Tale, and the movie Gattaca reflect dystopian societies in their approach to human

reproduction and social class. The illusion of utopia and dehumanization of individuals are

present through both societies’ dependence on an elite group of males.

Handmaid’s Tale and Gattaca, while sharing similarities between dystopian themes,

challenge reproduction from two greatly opposing perspectives: science and religion. In Gattaca,

natural conception is highly unrecommended whereas in Handmaid’s Tale it is firmly encouraged

and supported. Handmaid’s Tale concentrates on biblical teachings and gender roles reflect those

of old world normalities. Citizens are divided into different social classes and are to conform to

the expectations of their class. Gattaca on the other hand is based on gender equality, and social

class is divided between two categories-genetically engineered and naturally conceived. The

presence of an elite group of males, extreme scientific and religious influences, and abuse of

differing hierarchical systems determine both Handmaid’s Tale and Gattaca as two societies that

have become ineffective in their failed attempt for perfection.

Handmaid’s Tale takes place in the republic of Gilead, a distressed state in the midst of

civil war. In Gilead, conception depends on commanders-higher ranked generals that assume

authority over their respective households-and the monthly ‘ceremonies’ that are held in effort to

conceive offspring. During these ceremonies, the commanders have sexual intercourse with their

designated handmaids whose only purposes are to carry and give birth to children. If a handmaid

does not become pregnant within a few ceremonies, she is classified as ‘un-woman’ and

immediately transported to the colonies to perform hard physical labour. Commanders possess

full power over their handmaids as they are the leaders of the household, and failure to obey

them-depending on severity-is punishable by death.

In contrast to Handmaid’s Tale, Gattaca takes place in a futuristic society rich with

technological advancements. Natural conception is avoided and discouraged, as it increases the

chances of conceiving a child with physical mutations and syndromes. In Gattaca, reproduction

lies in the hands of geneticists-doctors fertilize the egg outside of the female body and

genetically engineer it to ensure that offspring are as close to perfection as possible. In other

words, chromosomes are...

Find Another Essay On Observing The Similarities and Differences Between Handmaid's Tale and Gattaca

The Similarities and Differences between Theravada and Vajrayana

690 words - 3 pages The Similarities and Differences between Theravada and Vajrayana Before we compare and contrast these two different sects of the same religion, we probably need to define the why first. There appears to quite a few different splinters of Buddhism, however they seem to all have the same goal, just a different way of achieving that goal. Why? I believe it all comes down to interpretation. Since Guatama Buddha did not have any written

Discuss the similarities and differences between prokaryote and eukaryote cells

756 words - 3 pages a bacterium (See Figure 1). The other class is the Eukaryotes which are the cells of plants and animals, and example is a palisade cell (See Figure 2). Both have similarities and differences in their functions and structures.Both Prokaryote and Eukaryote cells consist of Cell wall, (however this is not present in animal cells) - this is made of Peptidoglycan (though the plant cell is made of cellulose microfibrils embedded in a layer of calcium

Differences and Similarities Between the Holocaust and Cambodian Genocide

1006 words - 5 pages person. Each yellow star had to be worn at all times on their upper arm at all times. The blue scarf was the yellow star (“Blue”). In Cambodia, Every man, woman, and child was to wear a blue and white checked scarf, a kroma, at all times (“Blue”). Just like in the holocaust, they had to wear the scarf at all times. The Holocaust and Cambodian Genocide also had similarities in discrimination. During the Holocaust, German Jews are forbidden to

SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES BETWEEN REALISM AND LIBERALISM

1578 words - 6 pages from each other but at some certain points they nearly have the same ideas and features. This essay will explain what the main similarities and differences between realism and liberalism are and to what extend they have these similar and different features. But first of all, some main points and basics of these two theories should be given to understand the issue better. According to many scholars, realism is the oldest and dominant theory of

Similarities and Differences Between Dennis and Dee

1052 words - 4 pages The very popular dark comedy, It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia, showcases the similarities, and some differences between the twin characters, Dee and Dennis Reynolds, in many of its’ funniest episodes. In the show, Dee ( often referred to as “Sweet” Dee ) and Dennis have a rather unconventional brother-sister relationship. In their group of friends who are also coworkers, Dennis is viewed as somewhat a leader and superior to the others

Similarities and Differences Between Dally and Johnny

1413 words - 6 pages How can a rough, mean and tough hood have anything in common with a sweet and thoughtful boy? In S.E. Hinton’s The Outsiders, Dally Winston, a tough greaser, and Johnny, an innocent, scared boy have many obvious differences, but despite the fact that they are so unalike Johnny and Dally have distinct similarities. Johnny and Dally have a few similarities. For example, both of the characters have neglectful parents. Dally Winston resents his

Differences and Similarities between Dally & Johnny

1070 words - 5 pages Opposites attract, right? That is a common theme in movies, books, or tv shows. There is always that odd pair that find friendship despite their differences. Johnny Cade and Dallas Winston fall under that category. Although Johnny and Dallas from S.E. Hinton’s The Outsiders, are foils of each other, they are close friends. Johnny and Dally have vast differences but significant similarities. Johnny and Dally are similar in many ways. For

Similarities And Differences Between Billy Elliot And Kes

1735 words - 7 pages Similarities And Differences Between Billy Elliot And Kes In this essay I am comparing the two films Kes, made in 1969 and set in the 1960's and Billy Elliot, made in 2000 and set in the 1970's. Both of which have the same location, Northern England and both have a strong relation to a working class environment where coal mining was the main source of employment. The films are similar in terms of community, family, and

Similarities and Differences between Reggio Emilia and High Scope

1950 words - 8 pages let’s the teacher see how the individual child has grown. Reggio Emilia prides themselves for not using formal assessments and instead using the documentations to share the child’s progress with the parents (Downey & Garzoli, 2007). Over all the High Scope and Reggio Emilia approaches have many similarities and differences. When it comes to the developmental domains doth curriculums value, but promote them indifferent ways. High Scope promotes

Similarities and Differences Between Polly and Jessie Wilson

981 words - 4 pages Polly and Jessie Wilson both have many similarities and differences in the book The Secret Lives of Sgt. John Wilson. First, both of these characters stay dedicated to John Wilson throughout the entire story, trusting he is always doing the right thing. Second, neither Polly nor Jessie suspect John is doing anything wrong. Third, Polly and Jessie are both married at a young age, which doesn’t give them time to experience life before dedicating

Differences and Similarities Between Risk Management and Patient Safety

918 words - 4 pages and similarities between risk management and patient safety.” (Youngberg, 2011). Offering a safe environment for patients is one of the main commitments of patient safety, whereas analyzing the consequences of an unsafe environment would be the concern of risk management. “One of fundamental differences between risk management and patient safety is the difference between fixing problems and driving change toward creating a safer environment

Similar Essays

The Differences And Similarities Between Plays

759 words - 4 pages The Differences and Similarities Between Plays Plays express different plots, yet authors use similar writing methods to convey a particular point. For example, one play discusses serious matters, while another play has a comedic tone. However, both plays use physical movement to represent a character’s mood. Death Knocks, Fly, and Our Town are three very different plays with different themes yet these plays use a lot of similar writing styles

Similarities And Differences Between Ballads Essay

686 words - 3 pages that chirped them over." As you can see so far, there are many differences in the way that these two songs, otherwise known as ballads, were written. That could be because of the big time gap in between, there was just a changed in the popular type of music. Or it could simply be that the authors had different tastes in their music.S. Foster repeated one line in the whole ballad, "Floating like a vapor on the soft summer air," that is what his

Differences And Similarities Between Never Let Me Go By Kazuo Ishiguro And The Handmaid’s Tale By Margaret Atwood

2393 words - 10 pages narrator who is identified by her name and age and that addresses the reader as a fellow “carer” from the very beginning: “My name is Kathy H. I'm thirty-one years old, and I've been a carer now for over eleven years.” (Ishiguro 5) This immediately involves the reader and creates intimacy between him and the narrator. On the other hand, The Handmaid’s Tale begins with a description of the setting told by a voice belonging to one of the healthy

The Differences And Similarities Between The Movies "Emma" And "Clueless"

675 words - 3 pages Emma vs. CluelessEmma and Clueless, are two movies that illustrate Jane Austen's novel entitled "Emma". The stories illustrate the importance of self-development and personal growth by using the theme of social status and moral worth. The protagonists, Emma and Cher, are bound to transform from callow young adults to mentally and emotionally mature women, given their similar situations.The major difference between Emma and Clueless is the way