Rationalization Of Mass Killing Essay

3253 words - 14 pages

According to former Secretary of State Lawrence Eagleburger, “there is no rationality at all about ethnic conflict. It is gut, it is hatred”(Z). Despite this claim however, many political scientists assert that mass killing is rational, and serves a purpose to those who instigate it: two such theorists, Barry Posen and Benjamin Valentino, present two differing philosophies. Posen presents a theory for mass killings that focuses on the realist school of thought, and therefore mainly on the concept of security dilemma and anarchy. Unlike Posen whom presents his theory based on the state level of analysis, Valentino presents a theory that encompasses the individual level of analysis, and as such can be considered to follow the constructivist school of thought. His theory attempts to explain mass killing as a strategy that leaders use in order to fulfill their long-term goals. Posner’s realist explanation describes a limited range of mass killings: It can merely describe and predict the mass killings and ethnic conflict that can occur after the deterioration of a large central authority into small ethnic subgroups, such as what happened to Yugoslavia. Conversely, Valentino’s theory not only offers rationalizations for all types of ethnic conflict and genocide, but also presents an accurate model that can be used to predict the manifestation of such events in the future. Thus, due to Valentino’s ability to present explanations for most occurrences of mass killings in history and the facility to predict such events occurring in the future, his theory for mass killings is superior to Posner’s limited explanation and even more constrained ability to calculate the chances of future manifestations of mass killing that is offered in his rationalization.
Barry Posen, a political science professor at MIT presents his explanation for mass killing and ethnic conflict in his article “The Security Dilemma and Ethnic Conflict”. The article presents a vindication for mass killing through the lenses of a realist explanation for international relations. Thus, his argument heavily focuses on the concept of security dilemma, a model that realists utilize to describe why states go to war. Realists assume that because there is continual anarchy throughout the international political system, the main concern of independent states is security. Thus, a state will build up its defenses in an attempt to provide itself security in the state of anarchy in which it resides. This, in essence, is the crux of the security dilemma: actions that seem “sufficient to one state’s defence will seem, and often be, offensive to its neighbours” (X). Thus, what a state does to augment its own security in the face of anarchy will compel other states to increase their security as well, and will produce uncertainty and fear in the political environment. The security dilemma becomes especially severe under certain conditions, such as when one cannot distinguish between the offensive and...

Find Another Essay On rationalization of mass killing

Clorox Case Study - Council of Logistics

1486 words - 6 pages internal alignment issues between the different departments.SKU RationalizationBecause Clorox is in a downward spiral, it needs to develop solutions that will give the company a competitive edge and will make their products profitable again. One strategy Clorox should consider is SKU rationalization.SKU rationalization is defined as an analytical process used to determine the merits of adding, retaining, or deleting items from a retailer's

Critical Thinking and Perception Essay

786 words - 3 pages that we do not need to use muchexplicit logic because we have already built the logic into our language. For example, killing is 'bad' unless justifiedby war or self-dense. I know that with decisions I followed what was recommended and what my friendswere doing and then rationalized it with the following rationalization: Everyone does this and the stock rises for awhile and when the market eventually gets a severe correction I rationalize that as

Saddam Hussein Theories of Force

593 words - 2 pages In March of 2003 the United States army, backed by the British forces, led the "invasion of Iraq", under the pretence that the nation of Iraq was developing a "weapons of mass destruction" program. Iraq, led by its egoistic dictator Saddam Hussein, did not comply with the United States and did not surrender to the American forces, despite its overwhelming presence in the Iraqi border. After trying to lead the Iraqi military against the American

Comparing Cuban and Sierra Leone Youth

2675 words - 11 pages In a world that is being assimilated by a digital revolution of mass media and better means of travel, most of the Earth’s population would like to have cultural traits that maintain their unique identity in a peaceful state of co-existence. Assimilation requires an understanding of cultural differences in order to bridge them. If assimilation begins with the newest generation, one must understand any difficulties that lie in

The Role of Education in Society as Discussed by Emile Durkheim, Pierre Bourdieu, and John W. Meyer

571 words - 2 pages testing for cultural norms of the ruling class, and achieving individual’s aspirations is unrealistic based on the focus of education geared towards the elite class. Moving forward, John W. Meyer’s contemporary worldview theory discusses the functionalism of a world culture where nation states mirror each other in social, political, and educational norms. Meyer points out ‘conventional legitimization for mass schooling insists that formal

The mass hysteria between today?s society and the Salem witch hunt

560 words - 2 pages The mass hysteria between today’s society and the Salem witch hunt can be compared through Freedom , Religion ,and the killing of innocent victims. Mass hysteria has caused a lot of destruction in society throughout the years. It has brought about a lot of chaos in both Salem as well as the present society. Mass hysteria has brought out a lot of fear in people in both Salem and present society.      Freedom in today’s

John Wayne Gacy, Jr. "The Killer Clown"

1447 words - 6 pages ; lack of remorse or guilt for wrongdoings, as indicated by indifference to or rationalization of having hurt, mistreated, or stolen from another; and deceitfulness, as reflected in frequent lying, use of aliases, or conning others for personal profit or pleasure” – other behavioral patterns are listed, but the three I stated justly expose John Gacy’s criminal wrongdoings (Bartol & Bartol, 2014, p. 216 – 217). Avowing that influential factors

Future Trends in Marketing Paper: "Internet Marketing"

564 words - 2 pages For anyone who cares to think about it, there is no surprise in the fact that the web is becoming increasingly mainstream in its behavior. A few years back it was the equivalent of the wild-west, a place where only the brave would venture. Some of the brave made a fortune in so doing, a larger number lost their shirts in the dot com rationalization of the year 2000. Yet the feeling persists that if you are smart enough, you can make a killing on

Tang dynasty; Confucian to a fault?

1631 words - 7 pages view of the familial unit (Hansen, p. 71). Furthermore, in the section subtitled "Establishing relatives", Taizong speaks at length about issues inherent with detaching ones self from relatives. He says "With no relatives to rely on, the (Qin) dynasty fell after two generations. Isn't this all because of the fact that if a tree has a mass of branches and leaves, it is difficult to root up, but if the limbs are disabled, the trunk has nothing to

Paranoia: Digging your Slot

842 words - 4 pages , never to be rescued again, as their self control and mental health was ruined. The term and process of “rationalization” that Freud mentions to describe Schreber’s paranoia and megalomania is something akin to what the characters in the tragic characters do as well (148). While Schreber fills the slot of his missing father and rationalizes his persecution and homosexual tendencies as stemming from God and something bigger than life

europe

986 words - 4 pages changes for both France and the European continent: individual rights, secularization, the spread of the Enlightenment ideology and of the idea of nationalism. This results not only in a rationalization, bureaucratisation and centralization of the state, but furthermore, in an international revolutionary example for Europe. The Industrial Revolution was the next major event that shaped both the British society and the European continent through

Similar Essays

Rationalization & Suspense In Poe’s “The Raven” & “The Tell Tale Heart”

1149 words - 5 pages : not only is there failed rationalization occurring, but the rationalization is provided by the very ominous figure that will realize the old man’s assumed fear. The narrator, who has been considering killing the man, foreshadows his own act of murder through imagining what the old man is thinking. In a sense, the narrator of “The Tell-Tale Heart” assumes the same role as the ominous bird in “The Raven”: both man and bird are watching a second

Hamlet's Revenge Essay

551 words - 2 pages Hamlet, a play of rationalization, vicious deceit, and stinging vengeance develops Hamlet as a main character. These specific traits are carried out in the play by the character Hamlet himself. Procrastination is one of Hamlet's undesirable characteristics. Hamlet seeks revenge when Claudius kills Hamlet's own father, the king. Hamlet's reasons for the delay in seeking revenge for his father are his moral reasons and his need to be a rational

Killing Squads Essay

675 words - 3 pages How did the Nazis kill so many people ? This question is important because somehow the Nazis managed to kill over 6 million Jews during the Holocaust. During the Holocaust, the S.S deployed Killing Squads which were characterized by their tactics, important dates,and their impact on the Final Solution. Killing Squads managed to find a fast killing tactic. This is a crucial part of the topic because figuring out how Killing Squads kill could

Slavery In The United States Essay

895 words - 4 pages slaves. During this time Nationalism begins to waste away and Sectionalism begins to set in. In the 1840's the South's population consisted of a majority of poor whites and of course slaves. In this Paternalistic society a very small amount of the population, maybe 5%, where wealthy plantation owners. Those who where in power treated everyone below them as children, there was a mass delusion that the slave life was a good life for African