Rhetorical Criticism Of Cross Essay

1435 words - 6 pages

William Jennings BryanCross of Gold Speech Let's begin by analyzing and explaining the theory of metaphoric criticism. A metaphor, as defined by Aristotle, is the transference of a name from the object to which it has a natural application. A metaphor is decoration, ornamentation, and figurative language to a rhetor. They are not needed but create unordinary speech. Metaphors serve as heuristic tools for suggesting new hypothesis, new areas of research, and new research strategies. They also function as rhetorical devices for communicating ideas. Let's consider uses of metaphor as tools for thought and communication. The tool function of metaphor is to extend the capacity of active memory using the medium speech; while the function of metaphor as a tool for thought…is to extend our capacities for perceiving relationships in the perceptual domain to the conceiving of relationships in the conceptual domain. A criticism is an analysis or finding a fault of something. Together, the two definitions compose a metaphoric criticism. There are four steps to using metaphors as a unit of analysis; Formulating a research question and selecting an artifact, selecting a unit of analysis, analyzing the artifact, and writing the critical essay.In applying the theories of metaphoric criticism, I will focus on two metaphors used throughout the "Cross of Gold" speech. The first use of metaphors is to convey violent acts to show the wrongfulness in changing the gold standard. Bryan refers back to fighting, contest, and war to show that the people are not going to go along with the government. Bryan speaks of "brother against brother, father against son" to show that part of the government is on the same level as the citizens and another part is above the rest. But when the citizens "clad in armor," they will be stronger and overcome the wrath of the government. WJB refers to the office as "the plank which declares against life tenure." What is shown here is the opposition of what is being built up by the plank in Washington. The life tenure being built is opposed, and "excludes from participation in official benefits the humbler members of society." Why would the battle of Waterloo and St. Helena be mentioned in this rhetoric? It is to show of things gone bad, as is Mr. McKinley's reputation when he rebuts against his nation. When he is "in favor of fastening the gold standard upon this country, or who is willing to surrender the right of self-government," the battle, wars, contest, fighting, and challenges are made. He talks about enemies in battle and who shall win to refer to the government against the people and vice versa. The battle is between the citizens of the country and the government and there shall be a winner. Who the enemy is determined by the audience. But WJB is referring to the government and how their actions are not in favor of the people. His appeal, furthermore, is to labor and to the farmer, in a day when feeling is creeping through the...

Find Another Essay On Rhetorical Criticism of Cross

Response to Bitzer's Rhetorical Situation Essay

2378 words - 10 pages In The Rhetorical Situation, Lloyd F. Bitzer argues that what makes a situation rhetorical is similar to that which constitutes a moral action as he writes that, “an act is moral because it is an act performed in a situation of a certain kind; similarly, a work is rhetorical because it is a response to a situation of a certain kind”.(3) By defining the rhetorical situation in this way, Bitzer further contends that rhetoric is a means to

A Close Textual Analysis of Corporate Layoff Memos

1396 words - 6 pages multitude of rhetorical features that will be useful to academics and practitioners alike. In this article, I discuss and apply close textual analysis (CTA) to the three corporate layoff memos, focusing particularly on the use of euphemism to mask bad news messages. Close textual analysis: A brief overview Close textual analysis as a method of rhetorical criticism, advocated by scholars such as Michael Leff (1986, 1988) and Stephen E. Lucas

Final Reflection: Grasping the Writing Process

1130 words - 5 pages introduction, but instead of directly saying I contradicted myself in the sentence after, she kind of hinted it when we were sitting down. As we progressed on in the class, we became more comfortable with each other so the criticism was more visible which was good because I knew what needed to be revised. Peer Review was a great aspect in my college writing class, and a positive influence on my essays. I was already nervous at first about this

Symbolic Convergence in Gossip Girl: The Fantasy of the “In Crowd”

1707 words - 7 pages about the basic components of symbolic convergence and have a general understanding of the show’s premise and plot line. Symbolic Convergence The theory of symbolic convergence was developed by University of Minnesota professor, Ernest Bormann. Originally called fantasy theme analysis, Bormann set out to develop a method of rhetorical criticism, which uses a dramatistic approach (Griffin, 2009, p. 27). While completing his research, he noticed

Self-Reflective Essay

1850 words - 7 pages argument. Even though I did not use all the feedback given (either because I didn't know how or I didn't know what to change) I believe these types of revisions and constructive criticism were extremely beneficial towards meeting course goals. Throughout the quarter, we wrote many different types of papers and for many different situations. We wrote “Little Red Riding Hood” from memory and used a Cornell box to perform rhetorical analysis. “The

"A Southern Mode of the Imagination" and Thomas Wolfe

2273 words - 9 pages assessment that it is “as good criticism as any I know, of Thomas Wolfe.” Although the dialectical mode Tate would expect of a new Southern writer can be discerned within Wolfe’s short stories, it is clear that Tate viewed Wolfe as rhetorical, stuck in a one-way conversation without regard for his audience. One might allow, then, that Wolfe is perhaps not the example Tate would use to support his own theory. Tate could hardly object, however

Aristotle and the Techne of Rhetoric

1433 words - 6 pages modern discourse analysis and rhetorical criticism. (In fact, I am using the book in two of my rhetoric classes today, a true indication of the lasting effects he had on the discipline.) Within that notable work, Aristotle defined rhetoric as, “the energy inherent in emotion and thought, transmitted through a system of signs, including language, to other to influence their decision or actions” (Aristotle 7). In On Rhetoric, Aristotle also went on

The Evolution of Frankenstein

2086 words - 8 pages . While the various mimetic, expressive, rhetorical and formal theories apply, in part or in whole to any criticism of a work, modern theory has expanded, either because these basic principles had already been covered in years past, or because it was felt by some that more could be read into a text if it was analyzed in a new light. While denounced by many as gruesome or bizarre in its day, the basic themes of the novel were not, as Prof. Colleen

Reflective Argument

2338 words - 10 pages The four distinct learning objectives are as follows: First, students are required to be able to adopt a rhetorical perspective in order to identify, analyze, and describe the various aspects within one’s own discourse community. How I will show this objective is by citing earlier identifications of genre, conventions, and occasions for writing made in my assignment two. Second, students must produce writing that draws considerably on concepts

Possible museums

744 words - 3 pages contexts is welcomed if this can be used economically; moreover, the interest in global developments and the acceptance of criticism prove the ability for self-critical reflection. Seen against this background, even the most serious criticism can very quickly become a rhetorical gesture or the décor of a system that it originally defied. Specific elements of the criticism are taken up, in fact just as many as are needed for social legitimation and

A Rhetorical Analysis of Superman

929 words - 4 pages can come to a new land and prevail” (Look Up in the Sky! The Amazing Story of Superman) Superman, although fiction, was apart of the Great Depression, WWII, The Women’s Movement, and more historical events in The United States as he will continue to be throughout history. Works Cited Burgchardt, Carl. Readings in Rhetorical Criticism. 3rd ed. State College: Strata Publishing, 2005. Print. Look Up in the Sky! The Amazing Story of Superman. Dir. Kevin Burns. Warner Home Video, Inc. 2006. DVD.

Similar Essays

A Rhetorical Criticism Of Tiger Woods

931 words - 4 pages actions challenged the core of American morals and raised feelings of contempt among the public. These next 14 minutes of speaking in defense would be Tiger’s only chance to set things straight, his only chance to rebuild his life. Over the course of his speech, Tiger utilized the four rhetorical techniques for self-defense as cited by Ware and Linkugel in the article, “They Spoke In Defense Of Themselves: On The Generic Criticism Of Apologia

Peer Review

877 words - 4 pages Peer review is one of important elements for academic sources. According to Lunsford (2013), peer review helps the writer see what he or she wrote from other viewpoints and what strong and weak point the paper has. In order to do that, this paper will review the partner’s paragraph which the partner composed in paragraph assignment. The rhetorical situation of the paragraph is she will have a presentation for a small class of HSC History

Rhetorical Analysis Of An Advertisement About Obesity

1892 words - 8 pages 3[Type text] [Type text] [Type text]1Horn Paige HornEnglish 5Razo21 October 2014Rhetorical Analysis AssignmentWhat is a rhetorical analysis? A rhetorical analysis is a type of criticism in which you look at the factors that affect a rhetorical situation such as: the purpose the author is writing, who the intended audience is, the stance or persona the writer is taking, the genre or text that the information is presented in, and the context or

Rhetorical Analysis

1892 words - 8 pages 3[Type text] [Type text] [Type text]1Horn Paige HornEnglish 5Razo21 October 2014Rhetorical Analysis AssignmentWhat is a rhetorical analysis? A rhetorical analysis is a type of criticism in which you look at the factors that affect a rhetorical situation such as: the purpose the author is writing, who the intended audience is, the stance or persona the writer is taking, the genre or text that the information is presented in, and the context or