Rutherford B. Hayes Essay

1126 words - 5 pages


	 Rutherford B. Hayes was considered by many to be a simple, uncontroversial, and honest man to run for the presidency. That is why many people are perplexed that such an astute person should have one of the most controversial elections and presidencies ever. Considering Hayes’ honorable principles, it came as a surprise to see how he could unknowingly make a decision about reconstruction where its effects were so blatantly derogatory to the cause he was trying to help.

	The controversy began when he was merely running for office. Hayes was running against Democrat Samuel J. Tilden. When the ballots were tallied in 1876, Hayes clearly lost the popular vote, and had lost the electoral vote 184 to 165 . However, twenty votes in Oregon, South Carolina, Florida, and Louisiana were disputed due to the protest that blacks were not given the equal chance to go to the polls and vote. Congress created and electoral commission, which carefully decided that Hayes would receive all twenty votes. Facing the possibility that the country would be left without a president, both parties were considering taking the office by force. In spite of all the conflict, a deal was finally struck. Republicans made a secret deal with Democrats in congress, who agreed not to dispute the Hayes victory in exchange for a promise to withdraw federal troops from the south and end reconstruction . Hayes made good on the deal. He swiftly ended Reconstruction and pulled federal troops out of the last two occupied states, South Carolina and Louisiana . During the brief period of radical reconstruction the negro enjoyed both civil and political rights.

	This political bargain contained three generally recognized parts: 1) The north would keep hands off the ‘negro problem’. 2) The rules governing race relations in the South would be written by whites. 3) These rules would concede the negro limited civil rights, but neither social nor political equality (page 787) . It is clear, however, that by 1876-77, a majority of white Americans were weary of continuing to battle southern retaliation to the reconstruction, especially when there appeared some possibility that the South was ready to give more than lip service to the rights promised by the Civil War Amendments. This bargain quickly caused an uproar by its opponents. Democrat William Clay said, "Instead of withdrawing, he should have sent more troops in there". Hayes was convinced that this policy was best for everyone. He thought that the country and most white southerners would welcome a policy of moderation and react by assuring rights previously granted only sparingly . Consequently, he thought that by releasing troops from the last two remaining states would, "get from those states by their governors, legislatures, press, and people pledges that the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and fifteenth Amendments shall be faithfully observed; that the colored people shall have equal rights to labor,...

Find Another Essay On Rutherford B. Hayes

The Election of 1876 Essay

774 words - 3 pages had only 184. On Monday, March 5, 1877, Rutherford B. Hayes was sworn in publicly as president of the United States. As promised, within two months President Hayes removed the last troops in the South, Democratic state administrations gained power, and the era of Reconstruction formally ended. A Democratic senator was named to a cabinet position. Hayes' promised protection for freedmen and poor whites proved to be empty, and the conditions of life

Politics in the 1870s Essay

898 words - 4 pages was known as the “most controversial election” of its time. Samuel J. Tilden was nominated by the Democratic Party. He received his fame from the prosecution of “Boss” Tweed in 1871. Rutherford B. Hayes was the republican candidate (“The Election of the President Throughout History”). The controversy dealt with the vote count. Tilden won by popular vote with 4.2 million to Hayes 4 million. Tilden received 184 electoral votes and Hayes 165. The

The Presidency of Hayes, Garfield, Arthur, Cleveland, and Harrison

1131 words - 5 pages President Rutherford B. Hayes former governor of Ohio was the 1876 presidential nominated for the Republican Party and he was chosen over the more dynamic Speaker of the House of Representative, James G. Blaine. Corruption in politics was widespread. Hayes was elected by a narrow margin of 185 electoral votes to 184 in a disputed election over the Democratic nominee Samuel Tilden, even though Tilden won the popular vote. The election was so

The Great Railroad Strike of 1877

1121 words - 4 pages cut was returned to employees. The governor of the West Virginia sent the states militia to Martinburgs to get the train stations and train service back up and running. The states militia understood the strikers and the soldiers refused to take part, so the governor of west Virginia asked President Rutherford B. Hayes for further help and the president decided to call for federal troops to come in and restore train service.The great Railroad

Shadow And Custodial President

1830 words - 7 pages the term is fitting.      After his Presidency Grant became involved with a financial firm that later went bankrupt. Soon following he was diagnosed with cancer of the throat and died in 1885, shortly after completing his memoirs. Rutherford B. Hayes 1876-1880      At the center of the most debated presidential election ever, is Rutherford Hayes. A man who spoke well, presented himself properly

Reasons why the South Won Reconstruction

961 words - 4 pages he did everything they told him to do. Johnson agreed. With Johnson out of the way, the Radical Republicans could pass whichever laws they wanted to. This soon ended when the presidential election of 1876 occurred. In the presidential election, Samuel J. Tilden had more popular and electoral votes than Rutherford B. Hayes. However, there were still four states in dispute. Since there was no possible way to determine who should win the electoral

The failure of the Reconstruction, following the civil war

875 words - 4 pages slavery. However, Johnson's plan, like Lincoln's, also failed to address the rights of the blacks in the areas of voting rights, property holding, and protection under the law. He gave permission to the southern states to do as they wished with the African-American voting rights, which, once again, angered the Republicans. After Johnson's term was over, Rutherford B. Hayes, a Radical Republican who opposed Johnson's conciliatory views, came to power

Racial Discrimination in America: Brief History

1022 words - 5 pages power structure succeeded in completely suppressing blacks. African Americans were excluded from voting. Southern states wrote Jim Crow laws that segregated blacks from white society. Blacks lived under constant threat of violence" ("An"). This was a cause of the Election of 1876 which was between Rutherford B. Hayes, a Republican, and Samuel J. Tilden who was a Democrat. Tilden won the popular votes, but was one vote short of winning the majority

War Of 1812

1080 words - 4 pages - politically potent fraternal organization of several hundred thousand Union veterans of the Civil War; gave ballots to Republicans.Conklingites vs. Half-Breeds (Roscoe Conkling vs. James G. Blaine) The Hayes-Tilden Standoff, 1876 Republicans turned to compromise candidate, Rutherford B. Hayes Democratic nominee, Samuel J. Tilden Contested southern states: Louisiana, South Carolina, and Florida.Question: The President of the Senate opens the electoral

A Short Biography of William McKinley

1228 words - 5 pages Osborne enlisted in the Twenty-third Ohio Volunteer Infantry. McKinley survived his four years without getting a wound or falling ill. He participated in the single most bloodiest day in the Civil War: The Battle of Antietam Creek. His bravery under fire in the battle served him as he was promoted to second lieutenant and appointed to the staff of Colonel Rutherford B. Hayes. By the end of the war he was awarded brevet (or honorary) major

Reconstruction

1608 words - 7 pages Reconstruction era slowed to a halt with the presidential election of 1876. The Democratic candidate was Samuel J. Tilden and the Republican candidate was Rutherford B. Hayes. The election results were disputed because of misleading ballots in South Carolina, Florida and Louisiana. Normally, disputed votes would be recounted by the president of the Senate in front of Congress, but because of conflicting political views neither the president of the Senate

Similar Essays

Rutherford B. Hayes Essay

749 words - 3 pages Rutherford B. Hayes was a great American president. He was the 19th president of the United States. His life was very interesting and busy and he was respected for everything he did. Throughout his early childhood years, and all the years that led up to his success as a lawyer and a congressman helped him in his future career in the presidential office. These were just some obstacles Hayes had to deal with throughout his lifetime.October 4, 1822

Rutherford B. Hayes Essay

701 words - 3 pages Rutherford B. Hayes was the 19th president of the United States of America. He was born on October 4, 1893 in Delaware Ohio and died on January 17, 1893. He attended Kenyon College, where he was top of his class. He then attended Harvard where he studied law. After college, Hayes moved to Sandusky, Ohio and married Lucy Webb (Hoogenboom). Hayes enlisted in the Civil War and worked his way up to Brigadier General. While Hayes battled in war he

Post Civil War: The Gilded Age

1340 words - 6 pages rulers. Chester Arthur, Grover Cleveland, and Benjamin Harrison deserve their historic reputation as they failed to maintain control of the country, and lacked authority when making decisions. However Rutherford B. Hayes and James Garfield do not deserve the historic reputation of a weak president as they succeeded in financially improving the country and continually making the right decision for the people and the nation. The first president

John Adams And Zachary Taylor Essay

624 words - 2 pages Adams, ignored his cabinet members. Taylor represented pro slavery because he too own slaves. He wanted new states, even if they had slavery. Towards the end of his presidency Zachary tried to find compromise between the north and south but got sick from lying in the sun and eating bad foods and soon died. The north and south joined in sorrow for Taylor. His last words were "I regret nothing".Rutherford B. Hayes was a man with no nickname because