Sentencing Guidelines In The Criminal Justice System

3816 words - 16 pages

The criminal justice system has been in place the United States for centuries. The system has endured many changes throughout the ages. The need for a checks and balances system has been a priority for just as long. Federal sentencing guidelines were created to help create equal punishments among offenders. Judges are given the power of sentencing and they are not immune to opinions, bias, and feelings. These guidelines are set in place to allow the judge to keep their power but keep them within a control group of equality. Although there are a lot of pros to sentencing guidelines there are also a lot of cons. Research has shown that sentencing guidelines have allowed the power to shift from judges to prosecutors and led to sentencing disparity based on sex, race, and social class.
There are differences between state and federal sentencing guidelines. The federal guidelines are very vast and complicated (Leonard-Kempf and Sample 2001 p.113). These guidelines have been amended many times over the course of the past 25 years. According to Gazal-Ayal, Turjeman and Fishman (2013 p. 131) judges have historically had the weight and responsibility to sentence criminals in the way that they see fit. Some judges have abused this responsibility leading to the creation of sentencing guidelines. The Sentencing Reform Act was passed in 1984 in order to place strict guidelines on the judge’s discretion during sentencing (Rehavi and Starr 2013 p. 11). The United States Sentencing Committee wanted to keep the judge’s personal opinions and beliefs separate from the courtroom in order to create fair sentences. The creation of sentencing guidelines keeps people involved in the sentencing process in check.
These guidelines have the best of intentions but they have their downfall. When the guidelines were created they allowed the power to shift from the judges’ hands to the prosecutors’ hands (Gazal-Ayal, Tureman and Fishman 2013 p.132). The guidelines that were set, could be looked up by anyone; the prosecutors now had an advantage because most offenses carry a minimum and a maximum sentence. The prosecutors choose which offense to charge a criminal with. Once they chose which crime they were punishing them with they had a rough estimate of how much prison or jail time a defendant could be facing (Gazal-Ayal, Turemand and Fishman 2013 p. 132). This idea has led many people to believe that prosecutors now have the power to sentence offenders.
Prosecutors have an enormous amount of control in the sentencing process. More than 95% of sentences come from guilty pleas, because of the plea deals that defendants are offered (Rehavi and Starr 2013 p. 10). These guidelines have created a playbook for prosecutors to follow when they make plea bargains. The guidelines have an equation that calculates a range of time that a defendant could be sentenced to incarceration (Leonard –Kempf and Sample 2011 p. 114). The level of an offense is based on the...

Find Another Essay On Sentencing Guidelines in the Criminal Justice System

The Criminal Justice System in USA

1687 words - 7 pages Decisions in Law Enforcement. Heather Mac Donald (14 May 2010). Distorting the Truth about Crime and Race. The New York Times is at it again. Mastrorilli, Mary Ellen, (2012). Week 2: Racial Discrimination in the Criminal Justice System, Boston University. The Challenge of Prisons. Mike’s Blog. (2009, November 8). Mike’s Blog. School of Government, UNC-Chapel Hill. Retrieved May 18, 2012, from http://mrs.sog.unc.edu/?p=962 Tushar Kansal (January 2005). Racial disparity in sentencing: A review of the literature

Intersectionality in the Criminal Justice System

2262 words - 9 pages The criminal justice system is dynamic and has changed rapidly since the works of Cesare Beccaria and Cesare Lombroso during Enlightenment Period and this reflects in the issue of intersectionality with the changing approaches taken towards concepts of gender, race and class. Sexual assault will be a predominate study used throughout the essay to examine the different approaches and issues between traditional and non-traditional justices. This

Racism in the Criminal Justice System

1255 words - 5 pages Is the Criminal Justice system racist? This question has been asked many times by people of many colors. According to Mac Donald (2008), the criminal justice system is not at all racist. The article depicts arrest rates of both whites and blacks and compares statistics on these arrests. It looks at the number of whites and the number of blacks in jails and prisons. In this critique, we will be looking into this article to see these points in

Psychiatric Disorders in the Criminal Justice System

1960 words - 8 pages * Stephenson, P. (2004) Mentally ill offenders are ebing wrongly held in prisons. British Medical Journal. May 08 2004 Reports: * Federal Bureau of Prisons Central Office, National Criminal Justice Reference Service, US Department of Justice. Mental Illness and the Criminal Justice System. * Sentencing Project. Mentally Ill Offenders in the Criminal Justice System: An Analysis and

Racial bias in the criminal justice system

660 words - 3 pages Numerous study have found widespread racial bias in US criminal justice system. A new report issued by a coalition of civil rights organizations calls the "massively and pervasively biased" treatment on blacks and Hispanics by the US police and courts the major civil rights problem of the twenty-first century entitled "Justice on Trial : Racial Disparities in the American Criminal Justice System." The study finds that minorities in the US face

Technology in the Criminal Justice System

1348 words - 5 pages Recent advancements in technology have had a huge impact on the current criminal justice system. These new developments have made it easier for those in the field to track down criminals and help provide better evidence to support their cases. Things such as fingerprint databases, DNA testing, GPS tracking, and many other things have made it easier for prosecutors or defendants to prove their cases in court. This is very beneficial because with

Racism in the Criminal Justice System

6805 words - 27 pages have resulted in worse treatment for minorities in the criminal justice system. The tougher punishment for the use of crack cocaine, which is prevalent in minority neighborhoods, and the harsh new sentencing laws are a result of a new, stringent brand of law enforcement in which officers are trying to arrest as many people as possible. Unfortunately, as a result of this new brand of law enforcement, minorities, who are disproportionately thought

Toxicology in the Criminal Justice System

3178 words - 13 pages Forensic science has been a significant aspect of the criminal justice system for centuries. With the flourishing determination to develop forensic science throughout the years, advancements have led to the development of many significant sciences, including toxicology. Understanding and studying the adverse effects of chemicals on biological systems has proven to be a necessary force in the criminal justice system. By exploring new theories in

Lance Lowry in the Criminal Justice System

1027 words - 5 pages extremely stressful occupation with poor pay and bad workplace conditions. Correctional Officers have very high rates of stress-related illnesses, divorce, substance abuse, suicide and even PTSD.” I asked Lance if he felt prison have any rehabilitative potential. Lance considers it a very punitive system that he has been working to improve. In 2007, a group of criminal justice experts got together and agreed reform was needed, and the legislature

Personal Interest in the Criminal Justice System

674 words - 3 pages We are all faced with articles and news reports detailing crime occurring all over the world, crime that affects all types of communities, crime relating to religious, gender and age differences to name but a few. I have always paid close attention to the punishments handed out to criminals, in which I always seem to find myself debating on whether these punishments have been fair or are un just. I am particularly interested in the Criminal

Females in the Criminal Justice System

1094 words - 5 pages For the course of weeks spent in social issues I have decided to choose my topic on Portraits of Girls in the Criminal Justice System. I believe it’s important to acknowledge that the variety of murders and crimes committed is not only done by men but woman as well commit these crimes. As generations have passed by it has been seen that gender roles have changed woman are now more involved with crimes. Throughout the years it has recorded that

Similar Essays

The Criminal Justice System Essay

2417 words - 10 pages The criminal justice system views any crime as a crime committed against the state and places much emphasis on retribution and paying back to the community, through time, fines or community work. Historically punishment has been a very public affair, which was once a key aspect of the punishment process, through the use of the stocks, dunking chair, pillory, and hangman’s noose, although in today’s society punishment has become a lot more

The Criminal Justice System Essay

1487 words - 6 pages The Criminal Justice System After speaking with several different individuals, I think the reason I chose to use the responses and thoughts of Alissa C. in my paper is because she had straight yes and no answers with thoughtful explanations, and she had very few "I don't know" or "maybe" type answers. Alissa C. seemed genuinely concerned about the state of the criminal justice system and, obviously, had given it a great deal of thought

The Criminal Justice System Essay

901 words - 4 pages The Criminal Justice System The Criminal Justice System is one of the most important tools available to society for the control of anti-social behavior. The criminal justice system needs to prove a balance between punishing the guilty and protecting the innocent being found guilty; however it is not as easy to convict those who are guilty of committing crimes. There have been many miscarriages to justice where innocent

The Criminal Justice System Essay

3698 words - 15 pages into the community in an acceptable way. Changes in lifestyle, though difficult to measure, including an increase in education or the ability to hold a quality job, would also indicate that a program is achieving its goals. Programs that claim to fulfill these measures include, shock incarnation, prison boot camps and the extended use of the parole system. (University of Cincinnati, Division of Criminal Justice) Both shock incarcerations (SI’s