Shock Incarceration Essay

1713 words - 7 pages

     Miranda Warnings

     You have the right to remain silent, anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to speak to an attorney, and to have an attorney present during police questioning, if you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed to you by the state. These words have preceded every arrest since Miranda v. Arizona 1966, informing every detained person of his rights before any type of formal police questioning begins. This issue has been a hot topic for decades causing arguments over whether or not the Miranda Warnings should or should not continue to be part of police practices, and judicial procedures. In this paper, the author intends to explore many aspects of the Miranda Warnings including; definition, history, importance to society, constitutional issues, and pro’s and con’s of having the Miranda Warnings incorporated into standard police procedures.
     The Miranda Warning, is the requirement set forth by the United States Supreme Court in Miranda v. Arizona June 13, 1966 that prior to the time of arrest and any interrogation of a person suspected of a crime, he/she must be told that he/she has: the right to remain silent, the right to be told that anything he/she said while in custody can and will be used against him/her in a court of law, and that he/she has the right to legal counsel. The Miranda Warnings inform the arrested of constitutional rights and are intended to prevent self-incrimination in violation of the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution (Neubauer 2002).
     The Fifth Amendment to the Constitution states “No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the militia, when in actual service in time of war or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation” (Murphy1996). By neglecting to inform a suspect of his Constitutional rights the due course of legal proceedings according to the rules and forms established for the protection of rights has been violated. In other words, the suspect has been denied his right to protection from being unjustly deprived of life and liberty for failure to abide by due process of law (Ivers 2002).
      The Constitution reserves several rights for suspects of a crime. One of the fears of the authors of the U.S. Constitution was that the government could act however it wanted to by saying that an individual was a suspected criminal. Just by a person being suspected of committing...

Find Another Essay On SHOCK INCARCERATION

Reaction Paper # 2: An Analysis of Broken On All Sides

947 words - 4 pages Sides has its title. My initial reaction to the film was one of shock. Though this entire semester I have been studying and taking notes on the assigned readings, being able to see the effects of mass incarceration visually was even more disconcerting. In the beginning of the film, it was announced that the public is not blind to race, but rather to racial caste, in which whites have special privileges that many people of color, particularly

The Need For Extreme Criminal Justice Reform In California

2537 words - 10 pages ) B. But while this approach is to be applauded, its spreading prevents the fulfillment of its true potential. C. "By retaining those non-violent offenders that are currently in state prison and continuing to pursue defensive punishment at the local level in the form of short term "shock incarceration" and bootcamps, the costly and ineffective methods of criminal behavior correction remain intact." (Charles Calderon-US News) D

Criminal Justice Reform / Speech Paper with Outline and all Supplements. The need for extreme criminal justice reform in California

2714 words - 11 pages Official)B. But while this approach is to be applauded, its spreading prevents the fulfillment of its true potential.C. 'By retaining those non-violent offenders that are currently in state prison and continuing to pursue defensive punishment at the local level in the form of short term 'shock incarceration' and bootcamps, the costly and ineffective methods of criminal behavior correction remain intact.' (Charles Calderon-US News)D. By immediately

death penalty

1757 words - 8 pages cannot bring back the victim, but it may improve the quality of life of some of the co-victims" (Keane 47). With the killing of the criminal, it feels like justice is rightfully served. It helps the co-victims because they like the revenge and believe in the eye for an eye mentality. Co-victims have the thought if you killed a love one of mine you deserve to die also. Another pro of the death penalty is that it is costs less than incarceration. To

Home Confinement: An Alternative to Incarceration

978 words - 4 pages Home Confinement: An Alternative to Incarceration      West Virginia state prisons have a maximum capacity of 2,154 inmates; currently they house 2,363 inmates, and more remain in City and County lockups to manage the overflow (West Virginia Blue Book). Home Confinement solves this problem. Reduction of the prison population should be reason enough to institute home confinement, but other reasons do exist. Would you like lower taxes? Home

Alternatives to Prison

1665 words - 7 pages . (Allen 204) The approximate cost of this program is $4,000 per year for each offender. (Jacobs et al. 87) This is substantially less than the cost of keeping a person imprisoned. One third of all New Jersey non-violent offenders choose ISP’s over prison. (Jacobs et al. 87) The recidivism rate is 31%; or 69% effectiveness. ("Successful Alternative" 18) Shock incarceration, also known as boot camp, is a controversial, military-type program

Incarceration as a Form of Punishment

1756 words - 7 pages Incarceration is thought of as a positive form of punishment, and negative form of punishment. The opinion varies with the type of person, and their experience from jail if they have gone. Most inmates while in prison will tell you it is a horrible place that should be gone. That would allow criminals to be free and that would let them cause harm to others or other illegal activities. Incarceration was not designed to be a paradise, it is a

Overcrowded Prisons

999 words - 4 pages drugs in our society are a big problem the is no reason why someone who sold pot in their life once and got caught should take up cell space instead of a molester.Of course, there are alternatives to incarceration altogether. One of these programs is Shock treatment. Shock was designed for young people who were first time drug offenders. It is now open to any health, first time offender of a misdemeanor, that is no older than thirty eight years old

Probation and Parole: A Comparative View

1635 words - 7 pages in Champion, 2005, p. 131). Parole is defined as "the conditional release of a prisoner from (either prison or jail) under supervision after a portion of the sentence has been served (McKean and Raphael, 2002 cited in Champion, 2005, p. 286). The obvious difference is that probationers have the opportunity to avoid incarceration where as parolees are incarcerated first and then have the opportunity for early release from prison after serving a

Juvenile Boot Camps Do Not Reduce Juvenile Delinquency

3174 words - 13 pages complaints and obvious signs of distress. In another case, an incontinent boy died of an undiagnosed infection (Ravenell, 2002). Other concerns included the high rate of mental health issues and sexual assaults experienced by boot camp participants (Tyler et al., 2001). Analysts also attacked boot camps for being nothing but “shock incarceration” facilities. Because boot camps left aftercare to already burdened probation authorities, they

Juvenile Justice

676 words - 3 pages , although this has been shown to help. Rehabilitation doesn’t always work (Lieb, 1994). Just like adults rehabilitation works the best with high-risk offenders, which target delinquency factors and use modes of learning compatible with the needs of the offender. Also, behavioral approaches in rehabilitation showed decreases in recidivism. Some rehab motifs such as shock incarceration can actually have negative effects on recidivism. A

Similar Essays

Alternative Incarceration:Are Boot Camps An Effective Form Of Incarceration? Introduction & Overview Of The Problem

4890 words - 20 pages notwithstanding, simply shifting the older youth offender population into the adult justice system does not appear to be a viable strategy. The adult prison system faces even bigger problems of overcrowding and under-funding than the juvenile system (Simon, 1995; Schwartz & Barton, 1994). During the past 15 years, prison boot camps, also known as "shock incarceration programs" have emerged as a potential alternative to prison aimed at dealing

Alternatives To Incarceration Essay

901 words - 4 pages when jail crowding occurs, or when a violation of probation occurs. On of the newest and most publicized sanction program is shock incarceration, or boot camps. These programs vary in size, duration, location, control of entry (judiciary or department of corrections), the level of post-program supervision and in the level of training, education, or treatment programming provided. All of these programs are relatively brief, usually three to

Alternative Sentencing: Money Well Spent Essay

1394 words - 6 pages transition from a supervised alternative-sentencing environment to an unsupervised life in mainstream society are marginal. The individual has often established permanent employment and obtained affordable housing prior to graduation, resulting in less culture shock and reliance on social services. While the effects of an incarceration in the traditional judicial system have far-reaching ramifications, offenders enrolled in an alternative-sentencing

Alternatives To Incarceration.This Paper Is About Options Available For Offenders That Do Not Require Jail Or Prison Terms.Raises The Question Of Cost Effectiveness

868 words - 3 pages occurs.On of the newest and most publicized sanction program is shock incarceration, or boot camps. These programs vary in size, duration, location, control of entry (judiciary or department of corrections), the level of post-program supervision and in the level of training, education, or treatment programming provided. All of these programs are relatively brief, usually three to four months, and are designed for offenders who have not yet served time