Should Church And State Be Separate

1359 words - 5 pages

There has been much debate on whether or not the United States has been doing the right thing by keeping church and state as separate entities rather than keeping them entwined as had been the standard for centuries prior to the country’s founding. The list of influences this law could affect is substantial, ranging from the workplace to school functions. Even the way people decorate their offices and houses has come into question from time to time. However, remarkably, every person has a different style of argument and a different way of looking at the available facts. I intend to compare two very different argument styles on both sides of this issue, and how two capable writers use completely different methods of research, facts, and interpretations to propose their opinions.

Should Church and State be Separate?
Alan Wolfe (2002) speaks about many of the implied hypocrisies during the centuries-long debate over separation of church and state. While most people are brought up to question hypocrisy, Wolfe claims that some level of it is necessary to allow for compassion from the audience. “Surely we should want our anti-clericalists to have a touch of belief about them, especially when compared to the truly cynical.” Wolfe (¶ 14, 2002).
In his book, Separation of Church and State, Philip Hamburger called many of the politicians “…opportunistic” however; their type of behavior is often seen throughout our society today. In his article, “Church and State Should be Separate,” Wolfe (2002) uses lawyers as an example;
The history of American jurisprudence is filled with examples of lawyers seeking to build the strongest possible cases for their clients or causes, dropping one argument and employing another if it promises a greater chance of success, even if it seems to contradict the first. (¶ 13).

Throughout his argument, Wolfe also cites the court case, “Everson vs. Board of Education,” which placed separation of church and state into constitutional law in 1947. Prior to this case, the set of rules and ethics, God’s or Man’s, that should guide us, the citizens, had been debated but never determined.
On the other side of the spectrum stands Steve Bonta. Bonta contends that separation of church and state is a historical mistake waiting to happen. He uses examples from the French Revolution, in which they attempted the same ideal--giving the power to the people--and it failed them miserably. Bonta uses quotes from the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution to support his claim that we were each given “inalienable rights” from God, not from humanity, and therefore God should rule over the nation.
Alan Wolfe makes his opinion clear that church and state were separated in 1947 by ruling of the Supreme Court in the Everson trial, and it should remain that way to protect the rights of all citizens. His belief is that integrating the two powers would ultimately lead to further corruption of the government. He also states that keeping...

Find Another Essay On Should Church and State be Separate

Church and State Essay

917 words - 4 pages influence students towards beliefs of Christianity. To be fair to non-Christian groups, converting "Christmas" to "Holiday" concerts would maintain the "separation of church and state."In 1947, in the Everson vs. Board of Education case, the Supreme Court ruled that the 14th amendment prevented the States and the Federal government from setting up a church, passing laws that favor religion, or using tax money to suport any religion.Lynch vs. Donnelly

Separation of Church and State Essay

1320 words - 5 pages Separation of Church and State should not be judged based on ones religion, in fact it should not even matter what religion you are as long as it does not invade on other peoples rights. In the Yahoo! News article written by Lee-Anne Goodman, entitled Santorum says he doesn't believe in separation of Church and State, Republican Rick Santorum was interviewed for his response on John F. Kennedy’s speech on Separation of Church and State in 1960

Seperation of Church and State

2494 words - 10 pages intentional or an actual belief. Religion is definitely intertwined with politics and due to the research it is believable that it is done purposefully and done to pull at the heart strings of the voters. Today especially it is prevalent that religion is a hot topic in politics. Many Americans debate whether or not there should be a separation of church and state, but knowing that religion is important in ninety percent of American lives

Separation Of Church And State

1891 words - 8 pages , separate sources of funding, and distinctive methods, strategies, and identities. The church and the state are two separate bodies. Many attempts have are keep them apart, but there has not been an attempt, on its own, that has been successful.

Separation of Church and State

929 words - 4 pages The United States of America was founded on the basis of religious freedom. Judgment on the legality of the Separation of Church and State should not be based on one’s religion. The phrase “Separation of church and state” sometimes known as “wall of separation between church and state”, is a phrase used by Thomas Jefferson in understanding the two clauses of the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States: Establishment Clause and

Separation of Church and State

1194 words - 5 pages the years.Edwin S. Gaustad's book Church and State in America, he presents several court cases in which they argue or resolve issues concerning the separation of church and state and religions role in the classroom. In the U.S. public schools, where the vast majority of the nation's young people are educated, control of religion in class tends to be more local rather than federal (Gaustad 83). Also, in those schools the constitutionally correct

Separation of Church and State

2392 words - 10 pages has never been clear, favored that all Protestant denominations be sponsored by the state of Virginia (Beeman 306). One argument in Henry’s case was that Virginia was in a state of peril when it came to taking responsibility and that church and state should work hand in hand to promote public virtue to the people. It should also be noted that around the same time of Madison’s Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments, Patrick Henry

Separation of Church and State

608 words - 2 pages Separation of Church and State         “Separation of Church and State,” is a theory derived from different parts of the constitution; primarily the first and fourteenth amendment. The first amendment states “Congress shall make no law respecting and establishment or religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof....” The first amendment says that there can not be any laws against anyone’s individual religion. How far can we take

Separation of Church and State - 2725 words

2725 words - 11 pages United States is a spiritually and culturally different nation, may be the most religiously different state in the world. It seems hard for any of the people in the United States to see that persecuting church-driven state could ever raise its unpleasant head again. Earlier to the ratification of the bill of rights, various states, like Massachusetts were still pursuing those who had other faiths. Therefore, leading those who faced

Separation of Church and State - 726 words

726 words - 3 pages The separation of church and state is a fast growing issue of today. The beginning of the First Amendment says, "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof." Separation of church and state is a miss-representation of the First Amendment intended to deceive those that can be easily deceived.In the past there has been numerous court cases dealing with separation of church and state

separation of church and state

533 words - 2 pages reputation.Inequalities between religious, democratic ideals and religious divisions are the outcome of a theocratic government. The first amendment states that "Congress shall make not law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. (Source2)" The United States clearly violates their first amendment. Obviously they haven't made a law, but they integrate God into the society we live in today. We should not keep quiet and be satisfied with America forcing us into believing in God, it's a democratic nation that withholds it's free beliefs.SourcesSource 1: ( 2: (

Similar Essays

Church And Science Should Separate Essay

1730 words - 7 pages book is written in. By this statement, Galileo says that if you want to learn about outer space then you have to be able to understand mathematics to do so. Therefore, in my opinion, religious groups should never have the right to limit what are taught unless it is their own private school. This is my interpretation of why church and science should be separate from one another. Also that the religious authorities should not have the authority

Religion Has No Place In Politics, Therefore, Church And State Must Remain Separate If We Are To Preserve Our Individual Freedoms

756 words - 4 pages In order to explore religion and politics in America, we must first begin with our country's roots in 17th century Europe. There was heavy conflict, over religion, involving the Catholics and the Protestants of England, and across Europe. They were two different religions who shared the principle that there should be one religion, everyone should be forced to follow it, and that government should enforce it. Therein lay the problem, how can

Religion: Church And State Essay

1270 words - 6 pages Church”, p. 25) He is simply stating that if there is not reform within the church that the state of the empire will no longer be. John Calvin defended the notion that church and state are not separate and should not be separate (Calvin, On the Necessity of Reforming the Church”, p. 24). He expressed that it was the Emperors duty to reform the church and fix the corruptness within religion. Both Calvin and Luther along with Machiavelli are very

State And Church Essay

1259 words - 5 pages ;   Pg. 3 different then the rest. To make the voyage even more valuable, Columbus credited the church and state for his new findings, “ No one had ever entered it or gone in search of it until now when your highnesses commanded me to explore and discover these seas and lands”(pg. 127). The real finding he suggested he found was later in the voyage that would probably be very crucial to the church. Because of this importance it seems as