Should Hate Groups Be Allowed Free Speech?

927 words - 4 pages

From the century-old Ku Klux Klan to the widely publicized Westboro Baptist Church, hate groups have always been prevalent in America. They have been around since humans have had the ability to share and act upon common hatred towards others. Why do they still exist today even after all the progress our society has made fighting against racism and intolerance? The answer lies in the First Amendment right to free speech. Our democratic society allows all citizens the freedom to express any and all opinions, no matter how offensive and hurtful. This leads many to question whether these hate groups should be allowed the right to free speech. I believe that hate groups should be allowed free speech because all Americans have the right of free speech, it is not discriminatory unless it incites violence, and hate can be prevented through education rather than criminalization.
Hate groups are known to protest against otherwise agreeable opinions through rallies and speeches. The Westboro Baptist Church is known for picketing funerals, however they have never physically assaulted the people they hate, even when argued with by opposing bystanders. What they do may seem immoral, but it is not a crime to express an opinion. Their opinions and those of other hate groups are protected by the First Amendment which “should protect such expressions when they…do not present danger of an immediate breach of peace” (Attias). This was established in Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969) in which the Brandenburg test was developed to measure the intent, imminence, and likelihood of hate speech to instigate violence. Another issue is the difference between prejudice and discrimination. Prejudice is an intolerant opinion while discrimination is treating someone differently because of superficial characteristics, such as gender or race. For example, thinking poorly of minorities like Mexicans is prejudice, but denying a Mexican candidate of a position in a workplace based on their race is discrimination. While the former is seen as wrong, only the latter is unlawful because it denies the person of an equal opportunity. Prejudice and discrimination are “two different things—unless the words explicitly incite unlawful discrimination” (Tatchell). That is, prejudice can be discriminatory if it instigates violence. These words then encourage listeners to participate in activities that endanger others, such as physical assault or even murder. Only then should hate groups be criminalized. However, criminalization “is a means not of tackling bigotry but of rebranding certain…ideas or arguments as immoral” (Malik). In this way, hate groups may become criminals, but such a sentence will not change their hateful opinions. Instead, education can be given to spread awareness of tolerance. For example, the Week of Respect and education about bullying “seek to prevent hatred in the first place, whereas...

Find Another Essay On Should Hate Groups Be Allowed Free Speech?

Should Schools Be Allowed to Limit Students’ Online Speech?

910 words - 4 pages their students are safe and happy at school and off -grounds.They want to limit online speech so they can protect students and teachers who get cyber bullied online. Restate the question, using other words for “limit” and “online speech”: Should schools be able to restrict and regulate what students say on the internet ? Thesis and Road Map (Give three reasons why you think that schools should/should not be allowed to limit students

Limits of free speech and expulsion of a student from Brown University. Discussion on why it happend and should he be expelled?

811 words - 3 pages committee. Free speech and expressing ideas on any subject freely takes the students to an advanced level of education. Hann was experimenting it in a wrong manner but that is part of free speech. Sometimes we are right with what say and sometimes we are not right. That is why, Brown University was wrong to expel Hann, and He should be accepted back to Brown.Free speech should always remain at colleges. As Gregorian said, "The university's most

Should Abortion Be Allowed?

1577 words - 7 pages should remain legal and the Supreme Court made the right decision. It is the choice of the mother if she wants to have a child and if she chooses the option of abortion she deserves the right to have the safest and highly trained physicians at her disposal. You should not have to feel insecure with your decision or feel like you are going to be judged, you should feel free and happy with the decision you are making. With many modern advances in medicine the abortion process is painless and more people should be educated in it so it can remain legal and funded so women across the world can always have that option.  

Euthanasia Should Be Allowed

954 words - 4 pages to euthanasia? Or, is it just a proof that euthanasia is still hard to be done in Korea? Through this essay, I will explain the reason why euthanasia should be allowed in Korea for three reasons; human's right to die in dignity, burden to patients' families and themselves, and unrelatedness with social atmosphere that neglects life. First of all, every human has a right to take a charge and die in dignity. As an example of this point, there

Abortions Should Be Allowed

1732 words - 7 pages , I believe that although abortion can perceptively be viewed as immoral, it is desperately required in some cases and should thus not be outlawed. So let’s begin by establishing what an abortion really is. As I have previously mentioned, many of us are ignorant when it comes to what the process actually entails as well as the procedural and psychological sides of the operation. Abortion, as Wikipedia has declared it, is the termination of a

Should Euthanasia be Allowed?

1861 words - 7 pages cure illnesses will conjure. Besides, “A growing minority of Americans believes that doctors should do anything possible to save a life, no matter what, instead of saying there are some situations in which patients should be allowed to pass away” (Reyes). Reyes’s data reinforces what a doctor’s task (oath) needs to consist of, and by allowing patients to just end their lives, a doctor’s job deems incomplete. In fact, a doctor needs to somehow aid a

Should LBTG Adoption Be Allowed?

1070 words - 5 pages Hello there, my project is on adoption. Should it be allowed or should it not be allowed that is the question. I think that adoption should be allowed because it gives orphans a chance to feel what it is like to be in a loving family, it gives parents that are either sterile or barren to have children of their own, and it gives many people a great chance to be in the type of family that many people are so happily in. Maybe someone that you know

Teenage Marriages should be allowed

1146 words - 5 pages Many debates have taken place on whether teenage marriages should be legal or illegal. It all got down to a law that states that if a couple under 18 years of age wants to get married they need to have parental permission. Teenage marriages should be allowed for various reasons; they can work well together and grow together, they can enjoy their life better because they are young, they can enjoy their child more and the child becomes a new

Should reproductive cloning be allowed?

710 words - 3 pages don’t need it. Further, this argument appropriates the phrase "genetically related" to embrace a condition that has never before occurred in human history, one which according to International Chiropractic Pediatric Association abolishes the genetic variations that have always existed between parent and child. The institution of Family will be mostly affected if genetic cloning is allowed. The psychological and social

College Should be Free

901 words - 4 pages Should the cost of earning a college degree be free? Some students,parents, and educators say that it is morally wrong for a child to spend their entire life going to public school for free and having them to just turn around and pay for college. The students, parents, and educators all would agree that the cost of obtaining a college degree should indeed be free. Those who are against this issue believe that the students themselves or their

Prayer Should Be Allowed in Public Schools

1832 words - 7 pages should be allowed in the public school system because prayer is an important part of America’s rich spiritual heritage, and the First Amendment (Freedom of Speech Amendment). Prayer should allowed in the public school system because prayer is an important part of America’s rich spiritual heritage. All throughout the history of America there have been many important documents written of our country that have references to “Almighty God,” “Thy

Similar Essays

Offensive Speech Should Be Allowed

2716 words - 11 pages incapable of fighting back and believe that it's unreasonable to expect them to do so (Lawrence 159). Because victims of hate speech are recipients of verbal attacks, proponents feel these victims are "temporarily disabled' (Lawrence 159). Again, they focus on the relative lack of power experienced by these groups, which silences their responses. In addition, proponents argue that minorities should not be burdened with the responsibility of educating the

Should Hate Speech Be Regulated?

1840 words - 8 pages regulated or if it should be regulated. It is hate speech. What exactly is hate speech? Hate speech is when a person uses words intentionally to hurt someone else; they can use hateful words based on race, religion, gender, or sexual orientation (dictionary.com). Yet the origin of hate-speech laws has been largely forgotten. The divergence between the United States and European countries is of comparatively recent origin. In fact, the United

Should Hate Speech Be Regulated On Campus?

1229 words - 5 pages speech, the first being "purism".The use of speech codes is an example of purism, because they want to stamp out racism. According to Rauch, purists believe that all racist speech should not be allowed and eliminating prejudice is the ultimate goal. He thinks that there is no possible chance of this happening so, we as a society should make the best of it and tolerate and learn from prejudice. He also describes purists as totalists, who see racism

Free Speech Should Not Be Restricted

540 words - 2 pages Free Speech Should Not be Restricted I have an idea!  How about we let everyone freely speak their minds about issues and ideas.  Some will be better than others will of course, but the outcome will be a compilation of everyone’s best thoughts.  Everyone that is, except you.  We, meaning the country, decided that whatever it is that you have to say isn’t all that important and it is recommended that you keep all your thoughts to yourself as