Should Prisons Be Privatized? Essay

674 words - 3 pages

Clear and convincing evidence from the United States and elsewhere shows that privatizing criminal correctional facilities results in better public service at a lower cost than government operation. When the modern correctional privatization movement started, it was widely believed that any private role would be limited to small facilities housing low-security prisoners. Today, however, it is common to see contract awards for facilities with rated capacities of between 1,000 and 2,000 prisoners and for prisoners requiring medium or high security.A growing body of research finds that contracting out corrections reduces costs, improves service quality and yields other benefits as well. Critics who initially argued that contracting with private companies could not save money have been proved wrong.First, the fact that contracts exist implies that the contracting agencies are confident that cost savings are being realized. Many statutes even require tangible evidence of savings before contracts can be awarded. Second, private sector fringe benefits, especially retirement contributions, are less generous for private employees than for government employees. Third, the private sector does not have the costly bureaucratic requirements that government imposes on itself in employee hiring, firing, promotion and procurement of goods and services. Fourth, private prisons are designed to operate efficiently with fewer personnel in a way public prisons are not.Faced with evidence of cost savings, critics then argued that "you get what you pay for," alleging that services were substandard. Wrong again. Government agencies overwhelmingly renew contracts with the private operators. Since the mid-1980s, only one facility - in Zavala County, Texas - has been closed for inadequate performance. The best data fail to reveal a single contract awarded to any firm currently in the industry that has been terminated or not renewed for inadequate contract performance.Also, not a single private facility is operating under a consent decree or court order as a consequence of suits brought by prisoner plaintiffs. Yet about 75 percent of American jurisdictions now have major facilities or entire systems operating...

Find Another Essay On Should Prisons be Privatized?

Issues in Corrections Essay

1077 words - 5 pages the article ("Drugs inside prison walls - Washington Times", 2010), “Roughly 1,000 “drug incidents” seizures of marijuana, heroin and other drugs are reported annually at California prisons. Between 2006 and 2008, 44 inmates in the state died of drug overdoses.” This issue has raised a red flag of how our prisons are really being operated, the smuggling of illegal drugs and contrabands into the prisons should be almost impossible, this issue in my

aertqefaasda Essay

707 words - 3 pages health care needs and services can be too high and the quality of those services can be poor (Teplin, Abram & McClelland, 1997). Courts have ordered prisons to offer the same about health care and services to women prisons as they do for men prisons; however, they are still very poor quality. A study was done to look at the health care and services from women prisoners with mentally ill disorders. In the study women who did have a mental illness or

Intermediate Sanctions And Shock Probation

2202 words - 9 pages reduction activities leading to looking for corners and cheap shortcuts to complete the projects and would eventually result in poor or unsafe environments. However, it is evident that the prisoners and staff would be more comfortable in privatized prisons than public ones. (Pugh, 1968). Contracting however could be risky especially where a potential bidder uses irregular means to obtain the approval of the government. Later on when the government is

The Public-Private Prison Debate

2472 words - 10 pages brought to the forefront of public and jurisdictional view and just as quickly fade into the background as new issues present themselves. In 1984, after President Reagan proposed that prisons should be privatized, one hundred fifty-eight facilities opened in the next six years. In 2003, the number of private prisons was only one hundred fifty-four (Zito, 2003). But as prison expansion was scaling back, inmate numbers continued to increase. This

The Ethics of Prison Privatization

2357 words - 9 pages How true is Christie’s warning that an increasingly privatized penal service threatens the ethics and effectiveness of the criminal justice system? More aspects of the penal system are now privatized, and are set to increase. This includes the privatization of such services as prisons, electronic tags, catering companies, probation work or prison escort services. David Taylor-Smith, head of the world’s biggest security firm, G4S says he

Does the Modern Prison System Work?

834 words - 4 pages prevention as oppose to just punishment. Five out of seven pupils were indicating that good behavior should not decrease prison sentence. 42% of the recipients were disagreed and 29% were agreed, therefore 6 out of 7 students felt that prison should be a place to be punished rather than the place to be rehabilitated. We can also see from the result that most of the individuals were disagreeing that prison industry should not be privatized and

Private Prisons and Interest Groups

3145 words - 13 pages Private Prisons and Interest Groups Privately owned prisons began to emerge in the mid-1980s. These prisons emerged because of the ideological imperatives of the free market, the huge increase in the number of prisoners, and the substantial increase in imprisonment costs. (1) Proponents of privatized prisons put forward a simple case: The private sector can do it cheaper and more efficiently. Corporations such as Correction Corporation of

Private Prisons Negativly Impact State and Local Governments

3199 words - 13 pages >. Dolnick, Sam. "Escapees Stream Out, A Penal Business Thrives." The New York Times 17 June 2012: A1. Print. Dolnick, Sam. "Finances Plague Company Running Halfway Houses." The New York Times 17 July 2012: A! Print. Haughney, Kathleen, and Aaron Deslatte. "More-expensive Inmates Shifted from Prisons to Be Privatized." OrlandoSentinel.com. 23 Jan. 2012. Web. 16 Sept. 2013.

Home Confinement is the Solution to Prison Overcrowding

1406 words - 6 pages , each offender can be accommodated only briefly" ("Punishment"). Prison overcrowding causes a controversy of positive and negative views concerning the construction of more prisons. Supporters claim that building more prisons is the only solution, while opponents argue that alternative methods could be used to solve the problem of prison overcrowding. The question becomes whether or not the cities and states should spend scarce resources

Copromising Humans For Cash

987 words - 4 pages not offering you any programs, by giving you one blanket instead of two, by keeping the heat turned down, by not giving you any rehabilitation programs or helping you with your GED then I?m saving money and increasing the chances that when you get out, you?ll be back?. The severity of neglect is evident in the privatized facilities. In one case a prison inmate tried to use nail clippers to remove wires holding his jaw shut when he could not get

Supermax Prisons: Harmful or Necessary?

1187 words - 5 pages convoyed into a prison” (Stickrath). These kinds of offenders make up a small percentage of the prison population, and they disrupt the stability of the entire prison system. In California alone, there are 160,000 inmates. Yet nationwide, only around 20,000 inmates meet the requirements to be housed in supermax prisons (Beiser). Supporters feel that because there is only a small percentage, these kinds of criminals should be in a separate facility

Similar Essays

Should Social Security Be Privatized? Essay

1990 words - 8 pages Should Social Security Be Privatized?Many people don't understand how the Social Security system really works. There are no separate Social Security 'accounts' set up for each taxpayer to which he contributes his Social Security 'tax' each year. Many people believe these accounts exist, that the money they pay into their accounts grows each year until retirement, and when they retire they get back what they paid in with interest. This is not

Life In Prison Essay

2174 words - 9 pages services of privatized correctional institutions or are correctional institutions creating an atmosphere that benefits in enslaving American? Life in Prison Were prisons intended to reform felons, to discipline them, to remove them from society or to pad pockets with cheap labor? This question has been kicked around since the earliest modern prisons of the 1820’s. Penologists agree that prisoners should be able to learn a trade and/ or continue their

The United Kingdom Prison Service Essay

1743 words - 7 pages This paper has analysed the efficiency and effectiveness of the PFIs in relation to Alticourse. Alticourse represents one of the earliest prisons to be privatized in the UK, making it a better case for analysis. From the case analysis, the paper has established that PFPs are so far a major success in relation to PFI system. Private security companies provide efficient services compared to public prisons. Moreover, they outperform the public

Privatization Of American Prisons Essay

2043 words - 9 pages warrant another look at whether or not privatization of prisons in America should be abolished. Ethical issue: Along with the rise of privatized prisons comes the widely debated ethical issues that come with it. The first of these issues is the notion that these corporations are being paid to keep a prison full. They will go to great lengths to keep that being the case so their profit is maintained. Another issue that comes up involves the