Should Racist Speech Enjoy Protection Under The First Amendment?

1517 words - 6 pages

Persuasive Speech -

Should Racist Speech Enjoy Protection under the First Amendment?

Prejudice and racial stereotyping are two of this country's greatest problems today. Many people in our society have tried to find ways to eliminate or at least limit these types of behavior, but have met with very limited, if any, success. Because of the complex nature of racism and racist acts, coupled with the fact the first amendment prohibits the government from limiting the publics' right to free expression and speech, the Federal government has been ineffective in eliminating racist actions that pervade our society. State governments and institutions have attempted to set up their own laws condemning such actions, but have been wholly unsuccessful.

Some of those waging a war on racism have established anti-discrimination policies, and have had these policies challenged as a result. Central Michigan University, for example, had instituted a discriminatory harassment policy, only to have it shot down by the Supreme Court in 1995 on grounds that the policy "necessarily requires [the] university to assess racial or ethnic content of speech." Since Central Michigan University is a State school, the First Amendment prohibits it from enacting regulations that would limit an individual's right to free speech unless the regulations, according to a 1986 ruling by the Supreme Court, are "narrowly and precisely designed."

As you can imagine, precisely tailoring any statute in order to prohibit racist speech is nearly impossible - and as many other speakers have already said, banning the current racial slurs will only create new ones. Additionally, an outright ban on racist speech and ideas could likely lead to a higher level of violence in our society.

A number of other supreme court rulings have come out in favor of protecting all speech, including racist speech, such as:

A 1941 ruling on the case of Sullens v State, stating that the "Freedom of speech includes freedom to speak unwisdom or even heresy."
A 1949 ruling on the case of Terminillo v Chicago, stating that "Attacks on racial and religious groups are protected by right of free speech in absence of showing of serious substantive evil that rises far above public inconvenience, annoyance, or unrest…"
A 1952 ruling on the case of Joseph Burstyn, Inc. v Wilson, stating that: "[The] First Amendment prohibits [the] state from banning communication of ideas deemed by some to be blasphemous or sacrilegious."
A 1965 ruling on the case of Cox v Louisiana, stating that "Freedom of speech is of paramount importance and may not be denied merely because it may create dispute."
Thus with these rulings, and with the only notable exception being in the case of the utterance of "fighting words," which are defined as "words which by their very utterance inflict injury or tend to incite immediate breach of peace," racist speech is...

Find Another Essay On Should Racist Speech Enjoy Protection under the First Amendment?

The First Amendment Essay

2209 words - 9 pages of a button, but that's just my opinion.Now I am going to talk about freedom of press. Is slander and libel suits protected under the first amendment? I think it is but it should be limited to a certain extent. The press and the media has a job and that is to gather out as much information as possible to keep the public informed on what is happening in the world today. I have mixed feeling on this particular issued. Although they are protected

The First Amendment Essay

1422 words - 6 pages under the First Amendment. Schools profess they are protecting the rights of the majority, but in actuality, they are violating the rights of the individual through the denial of their First Amendment rights. Legally, the question is to what extent does the First Amendment apply to students? The First Amendment states, "Congress shall make no law... abridging the freedom of speech...". In 1988, the Supreme Court ruled on a case, Hazelwood School

The First Amendment

1009 words - 4 pages Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people to assemble peacefully, and to petition the Government for e redress of grievances.      The first and inargueably the most significant of the amendments to our Constitution is the First Amendment. The amendment that established our

The First Amendment

1087 words - 4 pages The First Amendment is the first section of the Bill of Rights and is often considered the most important part of the U.S Constitution because it guarantees the citizens of United States the essential personal freedoms of religion, speech, press, peaceful assembly and the freedom to petition the Government. Thanks to the rights granted by the First Amendment, Americans are able to live in a country where they can freely express themselves

The First Amendment

555 words - 2 pages Dictatorships rule, there is little if any freedom to speak of. Citizens of these countries are persecuted or even killed if they attempt to exercise any of the basic freedoms. In these countries there is no free speech, no right to choose government, no right to express religion, no right to own property. This is why I believe the first amendment in the Bill of Rights under the Constitution is the most important amendment. The First Amendment

The First Amendment/censorship

2013 words - 8 pages will not allow you to intimidate or harass others or break the law. For example, religious sacrifice is not allowed in the U.S., and threatening phone calls are not protected under the First Amendment. A newspaper can be sued for libel if it knowingly prints information that is false.The young U.S. chose to be a forerunner in freedom of speech, something now associated with democracy. American colonists remembered that in 1500's England, speaking

The First Amendment - 1163 words

1163 words - 5 pages seemingly evil actually uses The First Amendment every time they meet. Some hate the KKK but it is their right to organize and say what they feel. No one can stop them from saying what they think of a certain religion. Some feel that there should be limitation on freedom of speech but then would our country truly be free? Often, children need to have the material they watch censored, because they themselves cannot distinguish how raw the material

The First Amendment - 750 words

750 words - 3 pages The First Amendment The Supreme Court decides on cases in the best interest of the national public. They will sometimes decide differently on very similar cases, because of current happenings around the world. For example, during wartime, the Supreme Court will change the Freedom of Speech laws. If you go against the war effort then the Freedom of Speech laws won?t protect you. There are many instances where the Supreme Court has to rule in the

The first amendment

746 words - 3 pages The First Amendment, which guarantees Americans the freedom of speech, has been debated for years. An example of the First Amendment in debate is in the case of Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier. In this case the people (Respondents) First Amendment rights were violated by the principal of their school. Their rights were violated because the principal deleted two articles from the school newspaper which dealt with student pregnancy and the

The First Amendment - 656 words

656 words - 3 pages what is contained in the First Amendment.To me the First Amendment is much more then a bunch of words on a piece of paper. The First Amendment is the basis of life. I feel that life is not worth living if you are denied such basic rights. The First Amendment, freedom of expression to me means that I can walk out the house with my hijab on and go to the mosque without being jailed. It means that I can enjoy my life and support for something that I believe is right and at the same time denounce what I feel is wrong. Over the years it has grown to become apart of me. I sometimes feel that I take these rights for granted and that I realize how lucky I am.

The First Amendment - 592 words

592 words - 3 pages “Richard Hongisto was an enigma: a maverick cop who became a politician, a jailer who became a First Amendment hero, a police chief who became a First Amendment villain.”(Turner 99) Hongisto, A police officer for the SFPD, was a crucial expert witness in Houchins V KQED. Houchins, the sheriff of Alameda County at the time, oversaw daily happenings and had control over who was able to have access to the County Jail. KQED, a country television

Similar Essays

Freedom Of Speech: The First Amendment

2097 words - 8 pages many more. The first amendment to the Bill of Rights is the right to freedom of speech and press which “protects individual expression by guaranteeing the freedom of speech. The Supreme Court has broadly interpreted “speech” to include Internet communication, art, music, clothing, and even “symbolic speech,” such as flag burning. Freedom of the press generally allows for newspapers, radio, television, and now many online sources to publish

First Amendment And Free Speech

1976 words - 8 pages Court has to protect the freedoms without stripping Americans of their rights entirely but it also has to protect Americans from those who wish to do harm to others under the protection of freedom of speech or expression. Not only does the First Amendment provide for freedom of speech but also freedom of expression which is as equally controversial. By examining the First Amendment and the protections and exclusions it has provided over the

Jason’s Speech Is Protected By The First Amendment

3005 words - 13 pages and the profanity in the speech would reasonably be seen as offensive and vulgar. Though if applying this case to the Fraser test Jason’s speech would not be protected, in this case I decided to apply his speech to the test set forth in Tinker v. Des Moines. If we apply the existing Supreme Court Precedent set forth in the case of Tinker vs. Des Moines, Jason’s speech would not be protected under the First Amendment. As stated in Tinker vs

The Constitutionality Of Separation Of Church And State, Freedom Of Speech, And The First Amendment In Times Of War

1868 words - 7 pages of their rights is unconstitutional during peace time, as well as war time (Davis 167). The First Amendment stopped Congress from making laws against free speech (Holmes, Freedom, 75). Schroeder believed the government made a mistake by thinking there was an intangible power of self-enforcement (Schroeder 70). However, almost all of my sources took the stand that free speech should be restricted if the advocacy presents a clear and present danger