Major League Sports Labor Disputes Essay

1459 words - 6 pages

Eleanor Roosevelt once said: “Why cannot we sit down together with a board of arbitration, honestly state our difficulties and try to work out a sane method of procedure?” Mrs. Roosevelt is saying that they should have a third party to help work out the disputes in a professional manner. The relation from this quote to major league sports labor disputes is the league and players tend to go to court to try to settle their disputes. However, the leagues have gotten very use to going to court to settle their disputes that they do not try to settle the little disputes personally. Hence, the government intervention should be limited in the major league sports labor disputes.
First, the government’s intervention into major league sports causes problems because the judges do not always label the disputes correctly. Some of the federal laws, that determine what the labor disputes are labeled, are the National Labor Relations Act, the Sherman Antitrust Act, the Clayton Act, and the Norris LaGuardia Act. However within the article “Federal Jurisdiction in Sports Labor Disputes” by Michael LeRoy a professor in labor and employment relations, the sports labor disputes are often set under the antitrust act instead of the labor law. Therefore, the judges do not always read the cases right, and in return the judges mislabel the cases under the antitrust. When the court systems label the disputes under the antitrust act, the judges normally dismiss the cases. However, the Clayton Act organizes labor under antitrust laws in a bad manner, which causes more problems than it solves from LeRoy’s article “Federal Jurisdiction in Sports Labor Disputes". Therefore, the Clayton act was not well written because the act caused more problems than it solved. According to Nathaniel Grow, a professor in Legal Studies in his article “Decertifying Players Unions”; even the judges were arguing if the laws were being read correctly and if they were rightfully placing disputes under the right acts . Hence, with the judges not even knowing if they were labeling the cases correctly, one can only assume that the judges did not label those cases correctly. When it comes down to the laws and acts, the court system does not know how to interpret them correctly with all the labor disputes.
Following, the judges in major league sports have been mislabeling sports leagues as a single entity. However, Grow mentions in his article “There’s No ‘I’ in ‘League’ Professional Sports Leagues and the Single Entity Defense”, one reason the court labels the sports leagues as more than one entity is each team is owned by separate owners; continuing, that is not true because if all the teams were owned by one person, who would be able to tell if the games were not rigged. Therefore, the reasoning that sports leagues are a single entity is not always true because if the sports leagues were a single entity they would be more involved in rigging the games. In the mid-1980s, the MLB was classified as a...

Find Another Essay On Major League Sports Labor Disputes

The League Of Nations And Its Impact On World Peace

833 words - 3 pages World powers, the League had little chance of surviving. On November 11, 1918 an armistice was declared in Europe. Wilson saw the opportunity to form an international organization of peace to be formed. He acted quickly. On January 18, 1919 he released his fourteen points. The Fourteen Points consisted of many things, but the most important was the fourteenth-the establishment of a league of nations to settle international disputes and to

Negro baseball league Essay

962 words - 4 pages The Negro Baseball League The Negro Baseball League was a league comprised of professional, African American baseball players. The creation of this league comes from the black players who were not accepted into major or minor league baseball. Generally, The Negro Baseball league was a reflection of America during a time when society was segregated. The Negro Baseball League was influential to the 1920s because it changed the social development

The league of nations was a success

551 words - 2 pages wanted to avoid war happening again, they all agreed that an organisation which could sort every countries problems out would be a good idea. Countries looked to the league to bring stability.The first problem I am to discuss is the fact that the strongest country America wasn't in the league which is a shock considering it was the president of that country came up with the idea of the league! One major problem in America was that they didn't want

Assess the Significance of the League Nations

2139 words - 9 pages had to be reached between council members before a resolution could be passed therefore indecision also tormented a lot of the league's disputes. Decisive and efficient action was difficult. Major powers such as the USA who had not joined the league added to structural and economic problems. These problems back up the claim the league of nation's failings were significant in serving as an ideal blueprint of how not to run a subsequent global

Why College Athletes Should NOT be Paid

1997 words - 8 pages research however; I have come to many conclusions why the payment of athletes should not take place at the collegiate level.The payment of athletes is only for athletes at the professional level. They are experts at what they do whether it is Major League Baseball, Pro Basketball, Professional Football, or any other professional sport and they work for that franchise or company as an employee. The payment of NCAA college athletes will deteriorate the

Kansa City Monarchs: Bringing Strength to Major League Baseball

940 words - 4 pages developed some excellent players who were able to lead the way through racial integration of Major League Baseball. That contribution greatly strengthened – and forever changed – Major League Baseball in America.   Bibliography Libal, J. & Simons, R. (2003). Courage. Professional Athlete & Sports Official, 13. Retrieved April 30, 2014, from http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=ndh&AN=10439516&site=src-live Mills, P

The successes and failures of the League of Nations

1562 words - 6 pages In the 1920s, the League of Nations achieved some significant successes involving the international community. One of the main achievements was making agreements that were designed to solve international conflict and sustain global peace. The League managed to solve disputes over the Upper Silesia, Aaland Islands, Bulgaria, and other small nations. It also addressed the issues of health, transport, refugees, working conditions and other social

The League Of Nations

752 words - 4 pages did not really agree among themselves about the League.A system of colonial commands was also set up. Based in Geneva, the League proved useful in settling minor international disputes, but they had a hard time stopping aggression involving major powers such as, Japan's occupation of Manchuria in 1931, Italy's invasion of Ethiopia in 1935-36, and Germany's seizure of Austria in 1938. It collapsed early in World War II and ended in 1946.Its ending

Jackie Robinson in the Civil Rights Movement

962 words - 4 pages During the Civil Rights Movement, no black men were able to play baseball. However, in 1947, African American Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier and played baseball with white men. Jackie Robinson made a contribution to baseball when he played in the Negro League, played in the Minor League, and played in the Major League. Because he played baseball during the Civil Right Movement, he inspired many other black men after him to play the

Men Vs. Women in Professional Sports

1447 words - 6 pages ), the second largest MLB (Major League Baseball) and the largest the NFL (National Football League). All four of these leagues generate profits in the billions each year. Each has a multi-year contract with at least one major television network (NHL-ABC/ESPN, NBA-NBC/Turner Sports, MLB-Fox/ESPN, NFL-ABC/Fox/ESPN/CBS). The largest is the NFL’s contract; it brings in over three billion dollars to the league. The largest Television contract for a

An evaluation into the League of Nations' efforts in the 1920s

577 words - 2 pages The League of Nations was set up to stop war and to bring peace among countries. It believed in discussing the problems and solving them without the usage of the military. In the invasions of Corfu and Bulgaria by Greece and Bulgaria, the League of Nations settled the disputes before the out break of war. However, their actions affected their reputation in many ways.The incident in Corfu started because an Italian officer was killed because he

Similar Essays

Drug Policies Of The Four Major Sport Leagues

1076 words - 5 pages those policies the way they see fit. The rise of players using illegal substances in all sports has increased substantially and the drug testing programs have to improve in order to rid the game of cheaters. Although, Major League Baseball has the best drug program, all of the programs could and should be better. Constitutional law and labor law is the valid legal basis in drug testing professional players that receive monetary allowances for

Assessment Of The Success Of The League Of Nations

1185 words - 5 pages Assessment of the Success of the League of Nations In 1914 war broke out in Europe. The war ended in 1918 and Germany solely blamed. The end of the war was signed with the treaty of Versailles. From the war was born the League of Nations; who helped nations resolve disputes peacefully without going to war. When the League was formed, the defeated nations were not invited to join. The League originally had forty-two

Tanner W. Rough Draft As Of 12/10

797 words - 4 pages amount of money because of the bigger crowds. For major league baseball umpires a season they make 100,000 to 300,000. Most pro officials require a experience with proven ability to make it to this level. The annual earnings for all sports officials is ranged between 16,000 and 50,000 with the median of 23,000 a year. Working conditions for officials are inside if bad weather or outdoor if it is good sports weather. It is important for the officials

The Purpose And Intent Of The League Of Nations Essay

540 words - 2 pages intent was to maintain a good relationship between all nations, and maintain harmony through their imposing power.The League of Nations was undoubtedly designed for the purpose of preventing another major scale war, or 'world war'. It set to go about this by uniting many of the major powers of the world to form an international framework. The League would be in a sense the judge of the world's disputes and settle matters peacefully without the