Single Member Plurality Vs Proportian Representation

2148 words - 9 pages

Part B- Essay
Single Member Plurality versus Proportional Representation
The single member plurality system, more specifically the first past the post system (FPTP), is an electoral process most commonly used in Canadian for both federal and provincial elections. Throughout the years it has been the preferred method of national elections. However, there have been political debates as to whether Canada should undergo electoral reform. Many argue that the current SMP system does not accurately represent the interests of the citizens, and therefore should be reformed to an alternate voting method. There are both strengths and weaknesses associated with this particular system, however many believe that Canada is in great need of a electoral system that can accurately represent the concerns of all, supporting voter equality. In comparison, an alternate electoral system, known as proportional representation, will be analyzed. This system is very popular in a number of democratic nations, and is argued to be the preferable system to SMP in regards to Canadian elections. Thus, this paper will determine if the current electoral process is best for Canada by comparing and analyzing both single member plurality and proportional representation electoral systems. This following essay will discuss the benefits of the single member plurality in Canadian elections and also address its impacts on government, politics, and the national party system. Following the examination of the SMP system, a similar analysis of proportional representation (PR) and its effect in Canadian politics will also be provided to determine which electoral process is most advantageous for Canada. Thus, this paper will argue that proportional representation is potentially preferable to single member plurality.
To begin, a thorough description of both SMP and the proportional representation systems will be provided to gain a greater understanding of what each system entails. Canada is divided into a number of districts in which candidates from the various political parties run for election. Single member plurality is a voting method in which a running candidate in each riding needs more votes than their opposing candidates in order to win the election and represent the district (Pilon 2010, pg 35). This is often referred to as winner-takes-all, where the candidate with the majority of the votes wins the election. Canada is comprised of just over 300 districts, which directly reflects the number of seats in parliament. The winning candidate of each riding becomes a Member of Parliament (MP). The political party with the most MP’s elected eventually becomes the party in power and forms the government, in which the leader of the winning party becomes the Prime Minister. This type of electoral system represents the peoples interests based on geography and regionally concentrated groups. Therefore, the SMP system is beneficial to concentrated geographical voters rather than dispersed...

Find Another Essay On Single Member Plurality vs Proportian Representation

Electoral Systems Around teh World Essay

1361 words - 6 pages any disproportionality produced by the district seat result. German federal election uses two-ballot mixed electoral systems, which is a typical MMP system. It includes a single-member district tier, where only the candidate who garners a plurality of the candidate votes wins, and a PR tier. The PR tier offers even small party lists a chance to gain representation in the Bundestag if they get more than 5 % of all party votes nationally. Party

Should Britain reform the existing electoral system for general elections?

1099 words - 4 pages Vote system and the Second Ballot system. These systems do not incorporate proportional representation, and can lead to the overrepresentation of the major parties (even if a person's first choice is a minor party, their second is unlikely to be). Proportional systems work on the basis of multi-member constituencies. There are two main systems of PR: the List system and the Single Transferable Vote system. Critics of PR argue that small parties

Reforming the Canadian Electoral System

1479 words - 6 pages to ensure fair representation of groups and parties. This paper critically examines the nature of the Canadian electoral system, as well as the necessary reforms needed to improve its popular support and legitimacy. Canadian electoral system is largely based on the single member plurality (SMP) system which was inherited from its former British colonial masters. The system dates back to several years before the formation of the Canadian

Plurality Voting System in Canada

2551 words - 10 pages The current plurality voting system in Canada is regularly attacked for unfairly representing the popular vote and giving some parties a disproportionate amount of legislative power while leaving others with none. Opponents contend that other electoral systems would be far superior and provide a better democracy. Proportional representation (PR) is usually cited as the best alternative; the debate of proportional representation versus plurality

A Vote is a Vote: A Plea for Proportional Representation

2852 words - 11 pages the current electoral system of plurality and implementing proportional representation.The current political electoral system in place in Canada today is called the plurality system or first past the post. Under this system adopted from the British, the country is divided up into 301 single member districts. In each riding the party who wins the most votes, regardless if it's a majority or not, elects an MP to the House of Commons. A party may

Examining Case for Electoral Reform

1700 words - 7 pages available? And is the current method of voting in the UK fair to all political parties, or does it favour some more than others? This question asks us in part, to evaluate our current electoral system, First Past The Post, which is a majoritarian approach and proportional representation, an aim not an electoral system. First past the post, based on single member constituencies, requires the winning candidate to gain

Unit 12 Essay Exam

947 words - 4 pages . There are four types of this winner-takes-all system: instant runoff, At-large, two round runoff, and single member district plurality. The most known one is the single member district plurality. This is what is used most of the time when we American’s vote in officials. This involves a bunch of check boxes next to people’s names and you check the person who you want to vote for. This represents the winner-takes-all because the person with the

Proportional Representation Voting Should Be Enforced in Democratic States

696 words - 3 pages The concept of representation in a political state that embraces a democratic system is determined by its capability to include a plurality of views when creating legislation. Election systems in a democratic government should, thus, aid and enforce the proportional representation of most politically active members of the state. As depicted by the International Institute for Democracy and Election Assistance (IDEA), “The purpose of an

The Electoral Reforms in Patterns of Democracy by Arend Lijphart

991 words - 4 pages In his book ‘Patterns of Democracy’, Arend Lijphart mentions how electoral systems of majoritarian and consensus model of democracies differ. The electoral systems in majoritarian democracies quintessentially tend to be single-member district plurality system, while consensus democracies usually tend to use the method of proportional representation. Most electoral systems fit into the two categories of PR and plurality-majority. However, there

Northern California

1594 words - 7 pages represent the people and therefore if we use things such as single member districts and individual representation this accomplishes this goal of representing the electorate. The following is a set of questions that could accurately and fairly test whether the public would accept my recommendations. 1. Do you feel that your ideals will be better represented with a single member or do you feel multiple representatives are needed? Single/Multiple

The Marginalization of Minority Groups in The Electoral System

1387 words - 6 pages addition, the assertions of Linz, Cheibub, and Lijphart will substantiate my argument that a parliamentary system, unlike a presidential system, can allow greater proportional representation of all minorities. To ensure a more balance and equitable representation of the candidate pool, I will argue the necessity of employing a Single Transferable vote. While many may see the flexibility and lack of stability in parliamentary systems as a flaw, its

Similar Essays

Draft: Are Current Political Conditions Ripe In Canada To Mobilize For A Change From Single Member Plurality (Smp) Electoral System?

916 words - 4 pages POLI 2304 Paper Intro The research question I chose for my term paper was number 13, which asks “Are the current political conditions ripe in Canada to mobilize for a change from our single member plurality (SMP) electoral system? If so, what should be the nature of the change? If not, why not?” To address these questions, I created the thesis statement “Canada’s current electoral system unduly favours the pluralist approach to the detriment of

Should Canada Adopt Proportional Representation? Essay

947 words - 4 pages compositions between them. Canada, Great Britain, and the United States use single-member plurality, while continental European liberal democracies generally use proportional representation (PR). To ensure increased fairness and as a step in reducing western alienation, Canada should shift from the plurality system to PR.The single-member plurality system, sometimes called "first past the post (FPTP)," is the simplest of designs. A country is divided

Representative Democracy Essay

927 words - 4 pages been continuously underrepresented in most of the world’s democratic societies, and while there have been small improvements in some countries, for the most part minorities in general have yet to make any impressive gain towards more effective political representation. In the existing literature, the under-representation of minorities in countries across the world and the potential impact of the Single Member Plurality and “pure” Proportional

Canada's Electoral System Essay

2407 words - 10 pages and burn after twelve years in power because of the anger accumulated by Canadians over the sponsorship scandal recently. This is what Canadians voted for, is to have a change in government and a leader that stands up for Canada or is it? Do Canadians want to see a new electoral system used in the federal elections or to stick with the Single-Member Plurality that Canada is currently using? Which system is going to bring out the most voters and