Social Media Public Sphere Essay

1248 words - 5 pages

Through the emergence of the Internet, the last 20 years have seen a transformation in the way the society communicates with one another. There is no doubt that the Internet has changed the way the world interacts with one another on a democratic scale. Can it be said that with the emergence of the Internet, a new public sphere has been created? If so, is this new public sphere capable of embodying the theory that Habermas constructed? Petros Iosifidis article “The Public Sphere, Social Networks and Public Service Media” (2011) examines reasons that hinder social networks from becoming a seamless public sphere, and why Public Service Broadcasting should change over to Public Service Media.

Social Networks
Summary
Iosifidis starts the article by discussing in detail his first topic- social networks as a new public sphere. His main argument is that while social media spaces create new public spheres of both “democratizing and empowering functions” (2011), the Internet is also capable of both informing individuals and manipulating them. He argues that the public sphere is still a strong analytical instrument in today’s societies, as it “helps us help us make sense of the relationship between the media and democracy (civic engagement)” (2011). Iosifidis brings up several interesting and debatable reasons why social media is mostly overstated and represents hopefulness in the ability to be a public sphere. His six reasons are: open participation of social media may turn chaotic; the Internet lacks all-inclusiveness; the Internet content is prejudiced in favour of particular causes; some countries use censorship; it has become stage for corporations to take possession of; and there is often an inability to have extensive dialogue and critical discussion. With those reasons, he concludes that social networks allows individuals to feel involved, though they do not turn that participation into civic life.

Analysis and Evaluation
These six reasons are valid arguments and all contribute to existing theories and understanding of the issue of social networks as a public sphere. Firstly, Iosifidis states that the open participation of the Internet can lead to chaos, because there are no guidelines that allow for structured conversations. This reasoning coincides with Dean’s (2003) idea that there are too many voices and opinions on the Internet for it to be a proper public sphere. The Internet allows people with opposing theories about a variety of topics to see themselves as united, though they generally do not share an agreeance (Dean, 2003). She states that there are no filters that regulate the authority of structure on the Internet, calling it a ‘nightmare of inclusion’. There is no baseline which guidelines are developed, leading to chaos.
Secondly, Iosifidis argues that not everyone has access to the Internet or cannot afford it, therefore lacking all-inclusiveness. His argument can be seen in correspondence with Papacharissi’s argument that...

Find Another Essay On social media public sphere

Assess the Impact of Social Media on Public Relations

2412 words - 10 pages Assess the Impact of Social MediaonPublic RelationsName: SHUAI WANGStudent ID: Z34740271. IntroductionThis article is to assess the impact of social media on public relations by a case study on the "PPA event" of TSKF. If the television has long been a cold medium, and social media can turn the television into a hot medium by a newer and more close means to make audiences interact with television shows and celebrities.(Mayer & Vicki 2011, p

Social Media and its Enhancement of Public Speaking

742 words - 3 pages the world. It has revolutionized the idea of public speaking, it has changed the status quo, and it has expanded the power to interact with anyone at anytime. Since the rise of social media, public speaker have enhanced and revolutionized thinking among society. When Patrick Stewart preached about domestic violence or when Martin Luther King Jr. discussed separate but equal they capturing their audience with their poetic vernacular as the words

The Study of Public Sphere in Modern China

3595 words - 15 pages than “those economic and political privileges of the bourgeoisie”. Additionally, Habermas also pointed out that mass media is becoming an important part of public sphere during time passing. Herbams argued that: “By “the public sphere” we mean first of all a realm of our social life in which something approaching public opinion can be formed. Access is guaranteed to all citizens. A portion of the public sphere comes into being in every

What did habermas mean by the "public sphere"?

1457 words - 6 pages how quick exchanges of discussion and production of information are able to take place unchecked. Since the Internet de-emphasizes the body as a characteristic for social evaluation, users are able to interact on an equal level. The mass media or the "new public sphere" manages to generate a political space that respects the rights of the individual and in turn strengthens communities and our democracy as it stands.All adults are now recognised as

Jürgen Habermas’ The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere

2229 words - 9 pages which Habermas couldn’t possibly have predicted, the world wide web. Could this possibly be the new public sphere? Constant discussions taking place online, having the ability to reach everywhere & anywhere, all for free using platforms like social media, blogging or twitter. Many people now will openly admit to checking twitter instead of checking the news, which essentially is just a massive stream of people’s opinions. We have documentaries

Marketing Usage of Social Media for Customer Engagement: A Wells Fargo Case Study

2237 words - 9 pages . The impacts to the public sphere and society at large will play into the discourse of the social media topic and finally, the underlying theories will be discussed as they pertain to Wells Fargo and social media. Current State Wells Fargo has developed an advanced social media strategy that is handled by the Social Media group within the Marketing Department of Wells Fargo (Wells Fargo Bank, 2014). As of 2014 this team is handling eight blogs

Twitter: The New Information Platform for Public Sphere

779 words - 4 pages problem of twitter in public sphere construction. The last part is the assumption that how to use the information source and the main transmission mode of twitter to explore new news platform. Twitter construct a new public sphere. The concept of public sphere first time presented by Hannah Arendt in her book ‘The human condition’. In this book, Arendt calls the public sphere as ‘the rise of the social’(Benhabid, 1996). After that, Jurgen

The Spheres of Influence

645 words - 3 pages places not only include our own lounge rooms and work places but also the greater public sphere of the media. The media can provide a forum for discussion in many outlets such as editorials and letters to the editor, to the relatively new concept of Internet chat rooms, and web logs. Another popular and easily accessible outlet is talkback radio.Habermas believes that the public sphere is being infiltrated by Public Relations and the spin that is

content analysis

997 words - 4 pages London Times website, they also alow people to be able to share their article and their opinions over social media as a way of almost eradicating the need for journalists in the future because people’s opinions are becoming the news themselves. A study conducted by Jürgen Gerhards and Mike S. Schäfer called ‘Is the internet a better public sphere? Comparing old and new media in the US and Germany’, it showed that old media outlets such as radio

Public Service Broadcasting

1156 words - 5 pages support. Scannell thinks, talking about the specific programmes, reading off them work in different ways or studying broadcasting systematically could recognize that Hall is misunderstand and misrecognized objection of B. Contrast to Paddy’s view, Habermas, to some extent, agrees with Hall. Habermas pointed out that public sphere had been threatened by the social developments, industrialization, urbanization and other related factors. This means, to

Mass Media as Potential Obstacle to Foreign Investors in Post Conflict Countries

1323 words - 6 pages considerations, especially when it comes to political communication, as a key formula for the free flow of information and trust them see the autonomy of media in relation to the environment and support of civil society. ˮMedium of political communication in the public sphere can facilitate deliberative process legitimating in complex societies only if self-regulated media system to preserve the independence of their social environment and if

Similar Essays

Jürgen Habermas: Public Sphere And Media Sphere

1297 words - 5 pages how to apply his theory to social media. Internet changed citizen’s relationship with the media and created a new way of doing what the author thought of as a principle of democracy: rational-critical debate. How relevant is the public sphere concept in today societies? We will expose Habermas’ concept and critic it, and then see how we talk about public sphere in a hyper connected world. In feudal world, debate was a private affair for

Title: Analysis Of The Role Of Media In Society Considering The Idea Of The Public Sphere

2266 words - 9 pages Analysis of the Role of Media in Society Considering the Idea of the Public SphereIn 1960s, German philosopher Jurgen Habermas posed "the public sphere" theory. "'The public sphere' means a realm of our social life in which something approaching public opinion can be formed. Access is guaranteed to all citizens"(Habermas, 1964: p.49). The public sphere theory helps understand the role of mass media in contemporary society."The public sphere as a

Politics, Media Systems And Governance: The Battle For The Public Opinion Sphere In Latin America

1864 words - 8 pages understand the dynamics of the relationship between politics and communication as well as its effect on governance and the public opinion sphere. In this context, my interest is focused on how the media relate to politics in Latin America and how this relationship interacts with democratic governance. Since the beginning of the century, we have witnessed a struggle between politics and the media for building the public agenda in order to guide the

Public Social Media Essay

1053 words - 5 pages I will start this off by saying that I personally do not use public social media services like Facebook or Twitter (and the companies they own including Vine, Instagram, Voxer, etc.). I am one of the youngest students at this school; and have only barely made the age to have a Facebook account. I choose not to use them because I see no use in them currently. There are no people I know well enough to connect to through such a primitive method as