Sociolinguistic Field: The Nerd Community Essay

1685 words - 7 pages

1.What problems might exist for sociolinguistic studies that group speakers into speech communities, and how does the Communities of Practice model address these issues?
One of the first speech communities` problems stated by Bucholtz is that it is a theory that can only be applied to a sociolinguistic field .It is not useful to any other related discipline as its focus limits to study language and ignores all other elements that are crucial in human and social interactions. Moreover, speech communities analyses sociolinguistic aspects in a macro level so it is not possible to study identity through it together with the problematic and struggle emerging during its performance.
This theory assumes that language is a set of norms shared among all members and that there cannot be any variation within the group. In this way, the language and the norms that success among the community are imposed by the powerful ones. Thus, according to scholars of language and gender, traditional studies tend to consider women`s language as deficient in comparison to men`s.
As the focus of this theory is to study what the members of a community share and the set of norms established within them, any member who differs from the rest of the group is automatically marginalized and excluded. In the few cases in which these members are included in the study, they just serve as an example of how a linguistic norm can fall of the average. Once again, women may be marginalized, especially in studies on vernacular forms of language, as they tend to use a more standard form of language. This strict set of norms and refusal of the diverging element within the speech community also reflects resistance to change and to outsider influence; a fact that is not very realistic as it does not consider important to the language of a community the social interaction with other communities that can bring linguistic changes.
Finally, as the norms that are applied in the speech community are a consensus among the powerful members, there is priority to the group over the individual and speech communities do not take into account that individuals perform conscious choices in order to react to the limitations imposed by the group. Thus, this theory displays identity as a static phenomenon not as changing and moving, as well as an element which results from each individual`s agency. In this way, the speech community fails in its approach by considering the source of identity from the very top, the community, and not from the very basis, the individuals.
On the other hand, the community of practice is created in order to study identity and which aim is to deal with problems about gender that could not be resolved through speech communities theories. In this way, its focus is not just language as a set of rules, but as a part of social practice among individuals and the way in which those practices are used to display identity. Besides, it gives social and linguistic information about the...

Find Another Essay On Sociolinguistic Field: The Nerd Community

Address term Essay

1138 words - 5 pages investigate the use of Kurdish/Persian kinship address term in Kurdish community. The motive behind looking at kinship terms is that the researcher as a native speaker of Sorani dialect has realized that use of kinship terms in my community is not satisfactory. To date, there has been limited sociolinguistic research conducted on the influence of non-linguistics factors on various using kinship terms in Sorani Kurdish dialect in Iranian society. So

Variation in Address Forms for Arab Married and Unmarried Woeman in the World

1640 words - 7 pages -cultural phenomenon based on the social values and norms of a particular community. Holmes (1995:285) reports that politeness is "culturally determined", meaning what might be considered as polite in one culture, might not be polite in another. She defines politeness as "taking account of the feelings of others". Brown and Levinson (1987:107) state that "terms of address can be used as a method of stressing common ground between speaker and hearer

What is Social Science?

1367 words - 5 pages and his legacy, has enabled the development of a sociolinguistic perspective reflecting the importance of values within social scientific practice. This essay will further address the issue of what social science is and why it is important through the examination of the emergence within social work of an “evidence-based practice” (Thyer & Myers, 2011) as well as the case study of “sociolinguistic observations on the impact of changing political

The Internet and the Future of Language

789 words - 4 pages is static and permanent, the internet writing can be revised and restructured if necessary. Nevertheless the fact that the Netspeak displays the graphic and visual aspects, it is safe to say that the Netspeak has both speech and writing properties (Crystal 47). In sociolinguistic aspect, the Internet has created so-called a virtual community. It is true that the Internet is wired worldwide and at glance computer-mediated communication (CMC

Lingustic Dynamics of French

1510 words - 7 pages development of overseas trading-posts and colonisation (Battye et al., 1992).4 Focusing on Northern Africa and North America, in particular French speaking Canada, this essay will aim to discuss through comparison the sociolinguistic situation of the French language by considering the linguistic dynamic in which French operates and historical, political, social and cultural questions. Firstly we must look at the linguistic dynamic in which

Sociolinguistics of Australian English

4283 words - 17 pages and its language. Areas of the field include, but are certainly not limited to, pidgins and creoles, gender relations, economic status, and age. Researchers examine both the effects of social factors on language, and the effects of language on society. The contemporary world is bringing many people of different cultural and linguistic backgrounds together, perhaps more than any other period of history. Thus, the study of fields such as

Big George

1303 words - 5 pages High school sucksJeff Thompson was scared. This threat was real, very real, but this wasn't the first time he'd been in danger. A proclaimed "nerd" all his life, he lived the nerd lifestyle and was treated like it; isolated, teased and bullied.Moberly Lake was a small town northwest of Chetwynd. Peace and quiet were the only attractions to the town and most turned their heads when it came to anything thrilling happened; everyone including the

Imaging: a theme paper over Jake Reinvented By: Monica Eli March 5, 2014

848 words - 4 pages help them keep an image up. Jake is a prefect example of self-imaging. He wants to fit in so bad that he goes and entirely changes the way he is and acts just to get a girl and fit in with her social group. He goes from being a nerd, someone who gets a lot of awards and takes honor classes to being a football player, throwing elaborate huge parties and hiding his past as best as he can. But in the end you can never truly hide whom you really

Conformity vs. Individualism

2744 words - 11 pages expert in the field of their interest and second because it usually means they are apart of a group of people who also consider themselves nerds in that field as well. It’s almost like a sense of community you get from being different. Now that our culture encourages being your own person, more and more people are willing to speak out about their interests and are in turn finding communities of people, whether online or in reality, that also have the

Heroes, Men´s Power of Conviction, and Women´s Beauty

1100 words - 4 pages has defeated her, and his people look up to him. Beowulf is also skilled with his weapons, “I would rather not use a weapon if I knew another way to grapple with the dragon and make good my boast as I did against Grendel is days gone by.” Beowulf knows he has an advantage with his weapons, but the dragon can use his poisonous venom and his ability to breathe fire. This made the battle on a fairly level playing field because Beowulf had to use his

Women In Computing

828 words - 3 pages of the anti-social male 'nerd' and entice women into the field. Pamphlets and brochures need to make an effort to include an equal number of women and men. Perhaps at conferences and school visits universities need to specifically send female representatives enrolled in the computer science course. Allowing students to interact with someone who defies the stereotype of an anti-social male 'nerd' will interest more women into considering computer

Similar Essays

Nerds And Geeks Essay

2305 words - 9 pages The titles of nerd and geek could in some ways be considered objective but, looking deep enough one should be able to find a subjective and definite definition. These can be found by looking into some dictionaries the article as the author does in, “Nerd, Geek, Dweeb, Twerp — In Computer Lingo, Which One Are You?” in Community College Week by Reid Goldsborough. He finds that many of these definitions do not agree and looks to see if there

Can The Nerd And The Nigga Coexist?

1706 words - 7 pages In Daniel Beaty’s conversational poem Duality Duel: The Nerd vs the Nigga, he explains the battle being fought between the nerd and the nigga by speaking as both the nerd and the nigga. The battle is being fought within many African Americans. Many believe that there is no place in the elite society for the nigga, so they abandon the nigga within themselves and embrace the nerd or the image that seems “proper” to the behavior and image of the

The Brief Wondrous Life Of Oscar Wao, By Juinot Diaz

2157 words - 9 pages , Twerp — In Computer Lingo, Which One Are You?” in Community College Week by Reid Goldsborough. He finds that many of these definitions do not agree and looks to see if there is a definite answer and makes an attempt to find a modernized answer. According to its first definition of the word, a nerd is a "foolish or contemptible person who lacks social skills or is boringly studious." That sounds about right. But Oxford's first definition of geek is

Nerd Culture Essay

1015 words - 4 pages conversations that take place are constrained to the technologically apt individual. Despite their exclusivity to the average person, around the world there are many that are included. The result is a community that easily generates 10,000 comments a day on a popular article. The pride associated of being part of completely public yet exclusive community leads visitors to be self-proclaimed nerds. Nerds embrace their nerd qualities in many ways in