Stephen Jay Gould Nonmoral Nature Essay

1126 words - 5 pages

Evil in Nature and a Benevolent God

     The idea of the existence of evil in nature many times creates arguments between creationists and scientists concerning not only the design of nature by a creator –God, but the actual benevolence of God. In Stephen Jay Gould’s essay “Nonmoral Nature” (1984), he explores this highly controversial issue by posing the question: “If God is good and if creation reveals his goodness, why are we surrounded with pain, suffering, and apparently senseless cruelty in the animal world?” He uses the life span of the parasitic ichneumon wasp to illustrate a scientific view that the concept of evil is limited to human beings and that the world of nature is unconcerned with it. To some degree Gould may be correct in his assumption that nature is unconcerned with evil, however, a Christian view and scriptural model does provide strong argument as to how the fall of man influenced evil in nature, and how nature points directly to the benevolence of God.
     The Christian believes that God created the universe and its basic life forms. According to scripture, when God originally made life, He considered it “good” and perfect (Genesis 1:25). However, the Bible also shows that the perfect state God established on earth did not last long. Scripture recognizes the existence of evil and suffering in nature, and points the finger at God Himself as being responsible. Genesis chapter 3 reveals several curses God placed on the serpent, on Eve, and on nature.
When Adam and Eve disobeyed their creator’s command not to eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil, they rejected God and demonstrated they were no longer capable of living in their perfect world. They needed a place for their fallen weakened characters, and in Genesis 3:17-18, God revealed the kind of earth they would live in
                                                  
from then on, “Cursed is the ground…in toil you shall eat of it all the days of your life…thorns and thistles it shall bring forth; and you shall eat the plants of the field.” After their fall, Adam and Eve lived in a world quite different from the one they had known until then. Not only would growing food be more difficult, but the perfect balance of nature God created in every organism in order to complete its strand in the intricate web of life began to break down (Wheeler,Gerald).
     Environmental conditions deteriorated as a reflection of man’s declining moral character and religious commitments. Chaos began to creep into their physical world. William Kirby (1835) wrote in one of the famous Bridgewater Treatises on natural theology that God created fleas, lice, and...

Find Another Essay On Stephen Jay Gould Nonmoral Nature

Stephen Gould: The Savior of the Scientific Essay

1195 words - 5 pages Stephen Jay Gould was born on September 10, 1941, in New York City. As a young boy at the age of five, Stephen went to the Museum of Natural History in New York City where he saw the Tyrannosaurus Rex along with other large dinosaur skeletons. He decided that he wanted to study the fossils and evolution; he began to read up on as much information as he possibly could. As Stephen grew older, he discovered that there was a specific field of study

The Validity of The Evolutionary Theory

1396 words - 6 pages causes evolution, to gain approval of his cynical audience for his evolution theory. He supports his claim with numerous examples of animals and plants that have developed traits beneficial for survival. A century later, Stephen Jay Gould, influenced by Darwin’s work, supports the evolution theory with a different method. In “Evolution as Fact and Theory,” Gould, in contrast to Darwin, criticizes his detractors, the creationists who believe that

Separate but Equal

1744 words - 7 pages “Rocks of Ages” is Stephen Jay Gould’s commentary on the conflict between secular scientists and religious believers who reject scientific theory when in it is disagreement with religious teachings about nature and origin of the natural world. Certain aspects of his argument hold true, but the application is impossible and still gives one magisteria a dominance over the other. While it is an accurate account of historical disagreements and

Steve Jay Gould

1016 words - 5 pages A five-year old boy and his father walk through the American Museum of Natural History in New York (“World Biography”). They explore the exhibits, but one in particular stands out to the child. In front of him stands a Tyrannosaurus rex. The five-year old boy was Stephen Jay Gould. He is quoted saying, “As we stood in front of the beast, a man sneezed; I gulped and prepared to utter my Sherman Yisrael. But the great animal stood immobile in all

The evolution of theory

727 words - 3 pages There is a monkey in your family tree. Whether that is fact or theory, and the difference, Stephen Jay Gould explains in, “Evolution as Fact and Theory”, which appeared in the May 1981 issue of Discover Magazine. Mr. Gould was described by the New York Times as, “one of the most influential evolutionary biologists of the 20th century” (Yoon). He wants to show how the creationist's have built their argument against evolution on sand, and the

On the Quantum Mechanics of the Human Intellect and the Stories It Creates

2908 words - 12 pages exist as a more general, continuous whole. The work of Stephen Jay Gould consistently capitalizes on the “meaningful joinings between the facts, methods, and concerns of science and the humanistic disciplines” (Landed 5). One of the most cogent examples of this “interconnectedness” is evident in his essay “No Science Without Fancy, No Art Without Facts.” In it, Gould describes the relationship between different disciplines of thought: The

The Burgess Story

3377 words - 14 pages . Since we are interested in searching for a definition of good science that is also applicable to fields such as paleontology (where laboratory experimentation is severely limited if not impossible), it seems reasonable to look at a concrete example from the discipline of paleontology itself In his book Wonderful Life, Stephen Jay Gould provides us with just such an example. He describes the story of the Burgess Shale in the Canadian Rockies, where

Religion in Chatharine Sedwick's Hope Leslie, Stephen Jay Gould's Dinosaur in a Haystack and Norman Mclean's A River Runs Through It

913 words - 4 pages Religion in Chatharine Sedwick's Hope Leslie, Stephen Jay Gould's Dinosaur in a Haystack and Norman Mclean's A River Runs Through It In Hope Leslie, by Catharine Sedwick; Dinosaur in a Haystack, by Stephen Jay Gould, and A River Runs Through it, by Norman Maclean; the authors use religion in order to give the reader an insight on the stories and ideas they present, as well as gaining respect in the reader’s minds. All people can relate to

Comparing Authority in Hope Leslie, Dinosaur in the Haystack, and A River Runs Through It

620 words - 2 pages describe their arguments. Stephen Jay Gould demands authority because of the extensive studying he performs and yearns for knowledge that he possesses. Each of the essays that he presents has scientific merit and has been extensively studied. By writing about natural science and specifically evolution, Gould displays his expertise and therefore his authority. Gould being a scholar and a Jew has extensive knowledge of the Old Testament. He

Science in Nathaniel Hawthorne's Rappaccini’s Daughter

1706 words - 7 pages most significant Parallel that can be made between the story and 18th century American Society is the use of science to explain the rank of creatures in nature. “The Mismeasure of Man” by Stephen Jay Gould is an important tool in critiquing the misuse of science to justify social inequalities such as racism and sexism. “In assessing the impact of science upon the 18th century views of race we must first recognize the cultural milieu of a society

Darwin vs. Gould

1151 words - 5 pages . Gould sees no conflict between evolution and religion, if only we compartmentalize." (Palevistz, 2000)Gould also asks why such cruelty exists in nature if God is so benevolent. He says there is not any answer. That it is not even an appropriate question to ask. "The natural world is neither made for us nor ruled by us it just is. Suffering caterpillars are not put here to "teach" us something metaphorically or theologically." (Gould, 1982) This is

Similar Essays

A Wonderfull Life By Stephen Jay Gould

2296 words - 9 pages This was a Book report. I kinda BS'd it. But I got an A. Very GoodName: Wonderful LifeDate: 1989Publisher: W. W. Norton and Company, Inc.Pages: 322 (Not including Bibliography and Index)This book written by Stephen Jay Gould is about the concepts of evolution based on the findings in the Burgess Shale that was found in Yoho National Park in British Columbia, Canada. The organisms that were found here at first by C.D. Walcott in the early 1908-09

The Pandas Thumb Stephen Jay Gould

704 words - 3 pages of the many exciting facts held within the pages of this publication. Gould is able to put what he writes about in words that are easy to understand without compromising the quality of the information. Many questions are raised in this book. Some questions that science just can’t answer at the moment. Time is a major theme in some of the essays in The Panda’s Thumb. I found these essays of utmost interest. Stephen Jay Gould writes as if you were

Certainty And Memory In Stephen Jay Gould´S Essay: Some Encounters Of A Mental Mind

1019 words - 5 pages In Stephen Jay Gould’s essay, “Some close encounters of a mental kind,” Gould discussed about how certainty can be both blessing and dangerous. According to Gould, certainty can be blessing because it can provide warmth, comfort and secure. However, it can also be a danger because it can trick our mind with false information of what we see and remember in our mind. Gould also talked about the three levels of possible error in direct visual

Compare And Contrast Of Stephen Jay Gould And Richard Dawkins´S Points Of View On Science And Religion

1254 words - 6 pages the study of evolution. It is possible for a scientist to be religious if he is not studying evolution, because science is very broad and it has various studies. In this essay, I will talk about the conflict between religion and science by comparing the arguments from Stephen Jay Gould and Richard Dawkins. I argue that science and religion do overlap but only in some area concerning evolution and the cosmic design. Furthermore, when these