Surrogate Mothers And Parenting Essay

1105 words - 4 pages

According to the National Health Statistics Reports published in 2013, 11% of women age 15-44 reported impaired fecundity while 12% of men aged 25-44 reported some form of infertility. Until new scientific intervention guarantees a cure for both male and female fertility troubles, couples will continue to rely on Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) and surrogates as viable avenues to establish families and bear biological children. Theoretically, an individual or a couple who solicit the services of a surrogate and the woman who consents to the arrangement of serving as the surrogate both benefit; the employing party is not barred from parenthood due to infertility and the surrogate will gain the opportunity to engage in an altruistic deed and gain some form of compensation in return for the service. Whether a couple independently contract or hire a surrogate from a commercial company, the necessary exchange of money between two parties engenders serious legal implications—implications in which current family and adoption laws cannot possibly and adequately solve.
Inconsistent, highly variable, nonexistent, or unenforced surrogate laws among states exacerbates the legal complexity of surrogacy contracts or agreements and hinders the ability of judicial bodies to make sound and informed decisions whenever legal issues arise. Because ART technology exists and is effective, no benefit comes from banning or outlawing in-vitro techniques and consequently, the surrogates who participate in the process. Technological and innovative advances cannot be undone, but as the practice becomes more viable and accessible, regulation and legislation must be enacted to protect all parties explicitly and implicitly involved: the intended parents, the surrogates, and the unborn children. Due to conflicting surrogacy laws at the state level, those who desire children may employ the services of a surrogate from a surrogacy-friendly state if their state of residence bans the practice. Because this financial transaction occurs across state lines, surrogacy becomes an issue of interstate commerce as well as family law. The federal government has traditionally shied away from drafting enforcing laws concerning surrogacy contracts and establishment of parentage, but when these matters intersect with interstate commerce, the federal government possesses the duty and responsibility to intervene where necessary.

Proposal
Since the inception of surrogate-mediated ART, a number of conflicts have arisen concerning parentage of the rights of each party involved in a surrogacy agreement. Due to the nonexistence of explicit laws defining the roles and rights of concerning parties, judicial bodies have by default shouldered the burden of making judgments and decisions. As cases increase in complexity and legal ambiguity, the need for uniform legislation at the federal level becomes more urgent. Basis for legislation can originate from previous court case rulings such as Johnson...

Find Another Essay On Surrogate Mothers and Parenting

Biological and Ethical Benefits and Drawbacks of undergoing Surrogacy

2286 words - 10 pages between the surrogate mother and child relationship due to the challenge of surrendering the child (Shapo et al. 2002). When the child is born with a natural birth, surrogate mothers implied more positive interaction (between the surrogate and child as surrogate fathers experienced lower stress levels of parenting (Golombok et al. 2011). However, some sources researched on the relationships between the surrogate and the intended parent(s) and

The Surrogate Mother - Womb For Rent

1629 words - 7 pages of biological parents or those of the surrogate mothers-should be protected.   Gestational surrogacy, especially when it involves commercial surrogates, challenges the status quo in the ethical theory of reproduction, because with this technology the process of producing a child can no longer remain a private matter. Now a public contract exists between two parties, the couple and the surrogate mother. Such a gestational surrogacy

The Negatives of Surrogate Mothering

2106 words - 8 pages their child’s birth giver can than face some monstrous legal issues. An attorney or special agency specifically dealing with surrogate parenting needs to be enforced and involved, because when left to deal with the stress and struggle of pregnancy, plus the added stresses of legal proceedings, parents and the mother may find themselves very hopeless. With that said, the importance of a more enforced legal aspect would altogether improve the situation

Should Surrogate Motherhood be Allowed?

906 words - 4 pages void and unenforceable in order to try to deter couples and surrogates from entering into agreements.(1-2) Surrogate arrangements are made usually through close friends or relatives of the childless couple. However, the practice of commercial surrogacy has increased greatly during the last decade. Many major cities have surrogate agencies that maintain lists of potential surrogate mothers and help match these with couples wanting to have a baby

The Cause and Effects of Surrogate Mother

1825 words - 7 pages The main causes of women choose to be surrogate mothers are poverty and kind human being, and its result in physical and mental effects to the surrogate mother. II. Surrogacy is often done or committed is because of poverty. A. Effects of poverty 1. Hunger 2. Sickness B. Surrogacy is becoming a growing business. 1. Earn more money in order to overcome their hardship III. Surrogacy is being done by people. A. Help relative that could

Should surrogate motherhood be permitted?

924 words - 4 pages detercouples and surrogates from entering into agreements.(1-2)Bradley 3Surrogate arrangements are made usually through closefriends or relatives of the childless couple. However, thepractice of commercial surrogacy has increased greatly duringthe last decade. Many major cities have surrogate agencies thatmaintain lists of potential surrogate mothers and help matchthese with couples wanting to have a baby. These agencies areoften run by doctors or

Surrogacy Should be Banned in All States

1027 words - 5 pages process. First off, surrogacy in America is very expensive and not everyone can afford it. It is a violation of inequality to give some couples opportunities that are not universal. Another issue that arises is picking a surrogate mother. People with more money can afford to hire prettier or smarter surrogates. Paying more for brains or beauty can be seen as selfish or bad parenting, because it is paying for a child to have advantages. This is

Surrogacy: What Would You Stop at for Your Family?

1752 words - 8 pages as the work of the devil. Through the amazing medical technology we have today and incredible generosity of surrogate mothers so many people every year are able to begin their families. Wether you believe in the laws restricting infertile families, think it’s morally or religiously wrong you should take the time to ask yourself what would you stop at to have a family?

Over-Doing Surrogate Mother

1552 words - 6 pages There are many women who are not able to carry children or birth them. The good thing about this that there are other women that can carry them babies for them until birth. This is a relationship in which one woman bears and gives birth to a child for a person or a couple who then adopts or takes legal custody of the children; also called mothering by proxy. In surrogate motherhood, one woman acts as a surrogate, or replacement, mother for

Laura Purdy

1690 words - 7 pages approaches to non-traditional reproduction. Surrogate mothers gain their autonomy by choosing on how mothers want to conceive a child, and how they want to help other mothers to conceive it for them. They decide outside the norm of child-bearing and finally vocalize their consideration about such matter and they are in control of their life and body. Lastly, Purdy questions whether the proposed separation of sex and reproduction is necessarily wrong

Surrogate Motherhood

2513 words - 10 pages likened to prostitution. It is similar to prostitution in the sense that the body is being hired out, however, in the case of surrogacy the womb of the woman is the one that is actually being hired out and she is obliged to come out with a healthy outcome, a healthy child. Furthermore, surrogate mothers may also be regarded as a project that is subject for bidding, wherein the surrogates are actually hired out by the highest bidders. Although there

Similar Essays

Surrogate Mothers Essay

1122 words - 4 pages are ready and able to take on the responsibility of parenthood. Surrogate mothers fills a fundamental human longing. Procreation is a primitive instinct, and to many people it is devastating not to be able to become parents Surrogate motherhood is a solution to this age-old problem. Even in the bible, Abraham and Sarah resorted to a "surrogate mother" that produced their son Ishmael. 2NEED – Surrogate motherhood fills a need for

Prevelant Issues In Surrogate Parenting Essay

1757 words - 7 pages very nature. Nevertheless, surrogate parenting is attracting wide spread attention as a viable alternative for infertile couples intent on having a child. Contract surrogacy is officially little more than ten years old, although surrogate mothering is a practice that has been known since biblical times. In 1986 alone 500 babies had been born to mothers who gave them up to sperm donor fathers for a fee, and the practice is growing rapidly.For

Surrogate Motherhood Essay

775 words - 3 pages to at least one of them. I believe that everyone should be given the chance to have a family, and if the surrogate mothers are willing to do it, I do not see a problem with it.       Bibliography Hanafin, Hillary. “An Overview of the Psychological      Evaluation and Counseling in Surrogacy Parenting.”      1996. The American Surrogacy Center, Inc. &lt

Surrogate Mother Essay

1448 words - 6 pages . Secondly, there are also women that have biological problems which affect their ability to reproduce. The reproductive system is complex and can cause various ailments which make pregnancy impossible. Thirdly, some women may turn to surrogate mothers because of severe health problems. While the woman may be healthy enough to be an effective mother, her body may be unable to survive pregnancy. For example, some women would choose to use a