In recent discussions of Michael Noer’s article “Don’t Marry Career Women” , a controversial issue has been whether or not Noer’s sources are credible. One contributing factor is that Noer does not include a reference paper. Although it does not necessarily discredit it, in no way does it help strengthen it. In his article, Noer states, “If they [career women] quit their jobs and stay home with the kids, they will be unhappy.” This statement is his own interpretation of the studies recorded in the “Journal of Marriage and Family”. A number of people have suggested that Noer is lying about what his sources say. From this perspective, the people will believe that his argument is invalid and should not be taken seriously. Others claim that his sources are credible and his theory should be taken into consideration. In sum, the major issue is whether or not Noers article is credible, and if it is, then how will it affect our lives.
The “Journal of Marriage and Family” covers a broad spectrum of the different aspects of marriage and family. In one part, “Satisfaction With Work and Family Life: No Evidence of Cultural Reversal”, it covers the work of professor Arlie Russel Hochschild. Hochschild observes that more people are starting to use their as their haven from the house, whereas it used to be the other way around. When conducting her studies, Hochschild surveys part of the nation. With this sample, Hochschild found many facts about labor force change and individual change. One fact she was able to discover with her sample was that employment of women had increased twenty-five percent over a 24-year span. With a deeper look into the studies, she found out that the employment of women rapidly increased with married women that have children. By 1990, seventy-five percent of married women with children had a job. Hochschild’s theory was that work was, and still is, a major source of satisfaction for women and that it is a safe-haven from the stresses that are associated with a housewife.
When Noer makes the claim, “If they [career women] quit their jobs and stay home with the kids, they will be unhappy,” he builds on his argument significantly. In the “Journal of Family and Marriage”, it does not specifically state that fact, but it does say, “Mean job satisfaction among american workers has been high and stable,” whereas, “satisfaction with family life has declined modestly,” (“Journal of Family and Marriage). When reading the research, it is easy to infer that when people are at home, they are unsatisfied, therefore unhappy. This means that Noer isn’t lying, but he is exaggerating what the text said by making that inference. Making an inference does not make Noer’s argument invalid. The truth is that many articles make inferences of their sources, and the only reason people are arguing this one is because it is a more controversial issue compared to the other articles that make inferences.
The research conducted...