The Black Swan Essay

1943 words - 8 pages

Post-modernist critique points to the destabilization and fragmentation of the idea of the coherent, unique subjectivity that has led western culture, and subsequently its critique, through time. Cultural objects seem to correspond with the processes of naturalization of gender divisions and the female body. On a literal level, Black Swan gives the impression that it follows this tradition. In this paper I argue that the use of allegory in Black Swan is a conscious choice that emphasizes the discrepancies between the film and its original source Swan Lake, in order to contest the notion of a stabilized female subjectivity. I am also going to contrast stereotypical ways of looking at the female body in the film, exemplified by feminist film theory, and how pleasure derived from the act of looking at the female body is disrupted through specific visual elements. Finally, drawing from Butler’s theory of performativity I contest the idea of the essential female body, while bringing together the notions of performance and performative acts.
Allegory and Postmodern Subjectivity
In the first part of his essay “The Allegorical Impulse: Towards a Theory of Postmodernism” (1980) Owens discusses how allegorical elements are being employed in postmodern art, parting ways with the romantic and modernist obsession involving originality and the self-proclaimed “genius”. Postmodernism is not preoccupied with originality; in fact it creates art which recites its own eventuality, insufficiency, lack of originality. Since the allegorical work “is synthetic; it crosses aesthetic boundaries producing a ‘confusion of boundaries’”(Owens 75), it corresponds to postmodern needs, where the crossing of boundaries and the conflation of genres lead to the break of defined categories and add to our understanding of works of art as artificial. In the allegorical work, the first level is the literal. At first sight, Black Swan might appear as too obvious, too shallow, perpetuating stereotypes usually met in Hollywood films. According to Owens, this “possibility of perversion” is explained as “what is ‘merely appended’ to the work of art [can] be mistaken for its ‘essence’” (84). More specifically, the premeditated ‘confusion of boundaries’ can be viewed as an unbearable accumulation of clichés. This is why “extreme” critiques of the film as inherently misogynistic or as a ballet movie that “even straight guys might like” appear as adequate responses when the film is interpreted only on a literal level.
Black Swan is viewed or read through Swan Lake, the Tchaikovsky ballet. Aronofsky consciously draws connections between the ballet performance and the plot and execution of his film (one can easily see that in the ending credits, where each actor’s name is followed by their part in the film and in Swan Lake at the same time). By quoting Frye, Owens states that the allegorical work “prescribes its own commentary”(69); this is exactly the reason why allegory is being...

Find Another Essay On The Black Swan

Black swan: Madness of swan queen:

2701 words - 11 pages Thomas Leroy: What did you do? What did you do? Nina Sayers: [weakly] I felt it. Thomas Leroy: What? Nina Sayers: Perfect. I was perfect. The movie “black swan” ends up with the conversation between the Nina and Leroy. The story is a depiction of a professional and perfectionist New York ballet dancer Nina going astray and ultimately her madness leads her to self destruction. Her pursuit of the leading role in a classic theatre

Black Swan Events: Global Emergency Management

1155 words - 5 pages , future leaders should look to build on the works of the previous emergency management stalwarts, skewing the plans and strategies towards the occurrence of future catastrophic events. Similar to G7 summit that is held by countries to discuss global issues, there could be a similar forum involving all the countries of the world, to discuss and formulate joint strategies to plan and respond to ‘black swan’ events that could impact multiple countries

Form and Style of Black Swan, cinematography of Darren Aronofsky’s Black Swan

1600 words - 6 pages Com. Arts 250Nicole NaudiOctober 29 2013Form and Style of Black SwanDarren Aronofsky's 2010 drama, Black Swan, is a psychosexual thriller that beautifully exemplifies the wild and imaginative artistic direction usually present in his films. Black Swan follows the story of Nina (Natalie Portman), a professional ballerina struggling with portraying both the White Swan and the Black Swan in her dance company's modern twist on Tchaikovsky's ballet

The Mute Swan

1722 words - 7 pages the color of the bill itself- orange, with the tip and base colored black. The cygnets have dirty-gray feathers when they are first hatched. These are soon replaced with brown feathers, which eventually turn white over the next twelve months. The name Mute Swan was given to the bird only fairly recently. It was probably not the most proper name to choose due to the fact that they are certainly not silent. "The Mute Swan has a series of clearly

Living Like Swans

1445 words - 6 pages box’s worth, and then the webbed black feet that raised up to her upper side. She had two black eyes that I could barely see, any more than you see a dot. The swan was bewildered into tranquility as she was coming from beneath a fine body of tarnished water seven feet away. I was bewildered into tranquility sitting backwards on the wooden bench. Our eyes locked, and someone lost the key. Our look was as if two lost sisters, or best friends, finally

Duality in the Characters in Film

3755 words - 16 pages , although its definition does not vary too much from what the common definition is. In film, duality is the contrast of two people or entities. These two entities however, can be portrayed in several ways. The duality can be a conflict within one’s self, as seen in Darren Aronofsky’s Black Swan (2010) and David Fincher’s Fight Club (1999), a dual personality or change in character, as seen in the Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight Trilogy and George

The Ballet Physique as Molded by Media

2479 words - 10 pages perception of these idealistic views of the of the ballet image. A specific example of this is the Hollywood film “Black Swan”, where a ballerina is portrayed as having an eating disorder. Ultimately, through “Black Swan”, various magazine articles, and recent studies on the issue, media’s limited and restricted beliefs about body image in ballet are able to resonate through to the general public. Ballet dancers have always been expected to resemble a

Breaking Dawn

1006 words - 5 pages Spending eternity with your soul mate sounds like the ultimate dream come true, but what if eternity came with a price? Twilight: Breaking Dawn by Stephanie Meyer is a romantic novel based on the hardships of marriage and family for main characters, Bella Swan and Edward Cullen. Most of the story of Breaking Dawn takes place in Forks, Washington at the Cullen house and in Bella and Edward's new cottage in the woods. There's also a short jump to

Analysis of 6 poems on the topic, "Hidden messages". contains poems by hughes, mcauley, strand, dobson, yeats, williams

1204 words - 5 pages ", physically they are blurred because they are buried in the feathers of the swan, and emotionally, "vague" may perhaps indicate she does not know what to do or that she does not take any definite action.Zeus' magic and mystery are reflected by word use such as "dark webs" than "black feet" as the colour suggests something sinister and mysterious, and "strange heart" has suggestion of enchantment.The third stanza recalls the tragedies of the Trojan War in

Picnic At Hanging Rock

653 words - 3 pages outfit and would cluster the frame. Most scencs were shot with a short depth of field and would use rack focus. The use of the white dresses on the girls expressed the innocence that still remain in them while Mrs. Appleyard was shown wearing dark black outfits and shot from a low angles which dictated her power over the girls. Miranda on the other hand was shown alone and less constrained than the other girls. She often would be the only person

The History of Ballet

1697 words - 7 pages coming-of-age. The Queen offers him a crossbow, and reminds him that he must become the king and must find a bride. The prince meets Odette in the woods. Odette tells him about the curse and he promises to save her. The prince returns to the ball, and can’t stop thinking about Odette, he sees the sorcerer’s daughter who looks exactly like Odette and dressed as the black swan. The prince announces that he will marry her. He realizes that he

Similar Essays

Expressionism In The Black Swan Essay

1589 words - 6 pages The Black Swan is a psychological thriller that documents a prima ballerina’s descent into madness. Nina Sayers is a dancer at a New York City ballet company. Her mother is a very controlling, ex-ballerina whose career ended when she became pregnant with Nina. Having forced his current prima ballerina into retirement, Thomas Leroy, the company's director, is searching for someone worthy enough to play the Swan Queen in his next production

The Character Of A Black Swan

1024 words - 5 pages me. She said be who you think you are because in this world you don’t find yourself you create yourself. So i think about my past and where I am now, and I come to the conclusion that I am extraordinary, I am spectacular, I am a black swan. A black swan is described as an event characterized by rarity, extreme impact, and retrospective probability. I’ve had to stare adversity in face many times in my life and somehow i always seemed to find a

Review Of The Black Swan By Taleb, Nassim Nicholas

1044 words - 5 pages The Black Swan is a book about the importance of the unexpected. Taleb used the allegory of the Black Swan to explain how people often expect what is known and seem to forget that an unknown event can happen. The Black Swan metaphor was drawn from earlier beliefs that Black Swans don’t exist. Before the year 1697, no one has ever been reported to have seen a black swan. Consequently, people believed that all swans were white. However in 1697

A Critique Of Nassim Taleb's The Black Swan: The Impact Of The Highly Improbable

1360 words - 6 pages A Critique of Nassim Taleb’s The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable The economy is a constantly changing work of art. It depends on different factors from the consumer’s choice to the global market. From country to country the state of their economy can be seen through many walks of life. All countries have the elite and the poor. In America and other industrialized countries the middle class is shrinking and in underdeveloped