The Relationship Between Art And Philosophical Ethics

1520 words - 6 pages

The relationship between art and philosophical ethics can be divided into a dichotomy of two, radical understandings: aestheticism and moralism. Aestheticism prioritizes, if not entirely isolates, the artistic and technical value of an artwork over its moral implications. The aesthetic tradition asserts that art ought to be composed solely “for art’s sake,” hinging this position upon the assumption that only the essential component of an artwork—the sense to which the artwork is intended to appeal—is relevant in its critique (Peek, “Ethical Criticism of Art”). Within classical aesthetics, this conception of artistic value is epitomized by Enlightenment-era rationalist Immanuel Kant’s Critique of Judgment, in which he argues that one’s judgment of art must be of inherent “disinterest,” unconstrained by concepts of utility and morality. Kant suggests that art ought to be judged only upon its formal properties, such as design and composition, instead of for its perceived practical or moral worth. In this way, Leonardo da Vinci’s Mona Lisa, for example, would not be judged based upon da Vinci’s perceived psychological neuroses nor for the paintings modern relevance and fame, but on its arrangement: the use of contrapposto, pyramidal perspective, curved and straight lines.
This perspective is rivaled by Moralism. The Moralist theory emphasizes that the aesthetic value of an artwork is determined, or at least influenced, by its ethical premise. This school of thought formed the foundation of the modern philosophical study of art, making the discipline of recurring interest and debate since Plato’s aesthetics. To reference his “Parable of the Cave,” Plato interprets the arts not as shining indications of the enlightened world beyond the cavern, but rather as shadows on its walls. In his Republic, Plato asserts that the role of the actor, for example, is one of pretense, as he believed theatre offers only a troubling parody of reality. This assertion, that art is inextricably linked with a moral component, was later re-visited by Russian writer Leo Tolstoy, though he had approached the subject with a more ambivalent mentality. Tolstoy understood art a method of communicating and forming ethical and emotional positions, holding that “without art, humans would be ignorant of others’ feelings, and we would be savages.”
Yet, we must ask, to what extent is Tolstoy’s position a defensible one? What role, if any, do the arts play in the development and expression of our collective ethical identity? These questions expand into much broader inquiries, concerning whether the possession of knowledge in and of itself is charged with ethical associations and responsibilities. Art is knowledge producing in that it provides us examples of, or exercise in, morally relevant activities. That is to say, particular and practical knowledge is to be gained from art, as not only does artwork prompt an immediate moral response from the spectator but it also grants imaginative...

Find Another Essay On The Relationship Between Art and Philosophical Ethics

The Relationship Between Humans and the Environment

1364 words - 5 pages The Relationship Between Humans and the Environment Nearly everything that a human does is in response to the environment. Our lives are defined by what is around us and what we find in front of us, whether this means accepting, dealing with or changing it. This has been the pattern since primates first stood up and became Homo erectus, and has continued until we considered ourselves doubly wise. The shape of the land affected where humans

The Relationship Between Personal Values and Success

972 words - 4 pages Personal values and ethics govern personal success and have an impact on career success. Everyone has their own set of values and ethics that have been taught throughout life. Personal values and ethics are learned behaviors, hence, some are easy to understand and apply, some can be acquired, and each compliments the other. Values and ethics can carry consequences. Therefore, if one applies the practices, they can succeed. If one ignores or

The relationship between rhetoric and science

755 words - 4 pages The lack of understanding by the general public as well as higher intellectuals on the relationship between rhetoric and science has lead to wasted potential - potential for sparking discussion, promoting action or furthering scientific understanding in the general public. There is place for rhetoric in science and science in rhetoric. In order to understand the relationship, one must understand each separately. Scientists are in pursuit of

The Relationship Between Emotions and Making Decisions

1090 words - 5 pages loss of emotions, which in effect leads to the inability to make simple everyday decisions. Through many of Damasio and his colleague’s work we determine that there is a relationship between emotion and feelings with a human’s ability to make decisions, both simple and difficult ones. Damasio’s hypothesis of the somatic marker has accurate procedures and helps illustrate what he was trying to prove with his idea that emotions are what influence the

The relationship between surrealist and schizophrenics

1111 words - 5 pages both lack the barrier in which separates the two allowing them to interpret the world in whatever way fits. Surrealists to me are schizophrenics who have managed to control their disorder in a way that suits them best. Nadja by Andre Breton is a surrealist work that focuses on a relationship between two characters. Nadja and Breton come across one another while wandering the streets of Paris and simultaneously become intrigued with one another

The Relationship Between Self and World

1978 words - 8 pages According to the Central Argument the relationship between consciousness and self bears the same structure as that between consciousness and world. The self and the world are thus linked together as “two objects for the absolute, impersonal consciousness” (Ibid, 57). As a philosophy of human experience7, this account of the relationship between self and world seems to leave out too many aspects of our actual experience to provide a satisfying

The Relationship Between Gender and Bicycling Behaviour

1299 words - 6 pages There is an abundant amount of existing literature that proposes that females are less likely than males to cycle for transport in countries with low bicycle transport mode share, such as The United States. I will investigate the relationship between gender and bicycling behaviour, and whether female commuter cyclists are more likely to use certain types of bicycle infrastructure over others. Relative to utilitarian bicycling, the study of

The Relationship Between Gregor and Samsa

1642 words - 7 pages illustrates his beliefs in the existential philosophy. Throughout The Metamorphosis, Kafka illustrates the relationship between Gregor and Mr. Samsa fully, to the extent that their almost identical relationships become overt through Kafka’s illustrations in his novella. Both Gregor and Franz despise their vocational bondage but are imprisoned by their sense of familial loyalty and devotion. Gregor despises his occupation as a traveling salesmen

The Relationship between Church and State

1573 words - 7 pages Question #2 Separation of the church and state is not a new concept. Within the past two thousand years of Christian history however the strategies and ideas of Christian leaders have changed several times. During the time that Christ walked the earth we can anecdotally perceive a very adversarial relationship between Jesus’ ministry and the local Jewish and Roman governments. This type of relationship continued for the first three centuries of

The relationship between schizophrenia and surrealism

1879 words - 8 pages unconsciousness. I believe that surrealists are very closely related to the unconscious in a sense that they can no longer distinguish between the real world and their imaginations. Their perception of the world constantly clashes with their unconsciousness. Jean Laplanche, Serge Leclaire, and Patrick Coleman’s article The Unconscious: A Psychoanalytic Study the relationship of Schizophrenia and dreams states, “In Schizophrenia words are subject to the

The Close Relationship Between Hitler and Mussolini

758 words - 3 pages wanted and what was best for them and Hitler believed that he was God.Hitler and Mussolini encouraged cultural exchange. Art exhibits were created in both Italy and Germany showing art from the other country. Youth groups were alsocreated and radios held combined transmission for schools, using the broadcasts to foster personal contacts between the children though pen-pal arrangements. One Italian boy listener was alleged to have written: "I am

Similar Essays

Relationship Between Art And Technology Essay

1867 words - 8 pages . The shift from technological embrace to rejection was signalled by the negative reception received by Tuchman’s exhibition for Art and Technology in 1971 at MoMA. Soundings (figure.2) was Rauschenberg’s first collaborative work with E.A.T and it indicated that, for Rauschenberg at least, the relationship between art and industry was incredibly beneficial for technical development. The piece was produced for the Rauschenberg exhibition at the

The Relationship Between Ethics And Effective Leadership In The Current Business Environment?

930 words - 4 pages wisdom.” (p.19) By having a leader like this you can expect them to keep high standards which could benefit an organization as well as the employees. Leaders can be counted on to do the right things and to demonstrate high standard of ethical and moral conduct. Sometimes being ethical is being effective and sometimes being effective is being ethical. In other words, ethics is effectiveness in some cases. If a leader is effective he is working on

Essay On Relationship Between Art And Life In Death In Venice

1416 words - 6 pages Relationship between Art and Life Explored in Death in Venice      The novella Death in Venice by Thomas Mann examines the nature of the relationship between art and life. The progression of the main character, Gustave Von Aschenbach, illustrates the concept of an Apollinian/Dionysian continuum. Apollo is the Greek god of art, thus something Apollinian places an emphasis on form. Dionysus is the Greek god of wine and chaos, hence something

Aristotle And Friendship, Philosophical Ethics Essay

609 words - 2 pages in a society is to promote goodness between all parties involved in it.As previously mentioned, Aristotle has identified three different types of friendships. The first is friendship based on utility. This is a friendship in which both parties become involved with each other for their own personal benefit. An example would be a working relationship with an individual. These are people who do not spend much time together, possibly because they do